ext-044 day 8 | online mafia game replay

Replay

This is a log of a game of werewolves started on the 28th July 2016 on a 24 hour cycle (12h day, 12h night).
This is a spoiler free version, use the user button (top menu) to see who was alive at the time, and the calendar button or links below the chat to navigate through to different days.
You can play a game of online Mafia by joining the game currently in sign up. New players are welcome, but try to be active!
Killed

Maul was killed during the night
Day 8
Moderator

The sun rises, the village is safe from the werewolves for now. Discuss who you think is a wolf, soon you will get a chance to lynch them
Lobot

Active during the last day
Mace

Active during the last day
Maul

Active during the last day
KyloRen

Active during the last day
Rey

Active during the last day
Moderator

Voting is now open to lynch the next werewolf
Lobot Thu 10:07

F M L
Thu 10:10

Mace, who should I vote for?
Moderator

Lobot votes to put KyloRen on trial
Lobot Thu 10:13

Maul Wed 22:52 I'm going with Lobot and Mace being the same people...
Moderator

Mace votes to put KyloRen on trial
Mace Thu 10:22

Easy
Lobot Thu 10:31

Mace do you think there were two left or was Rey a misslynch?
Mace Thu 10:58

Two left
Thu 11:00

I was pretty sure yesterday we would end up like this. Me, you and Kylo
Thu 11:01

I don't understand the votes against me. Did I look shifty?
Lobot Thu 11:02

I think you would have been the better pick
Mace Thu 11:02

?
Thu 11:02

For a lynch?
Lobot Thu 11:03

for an SS
Thu 11:05

btw. from which movie is KyloRen?
Mace Thu 11:06

I've only seen the first movie, I have no idea
Lobot Thu 11:07

the first?
Mace Thu 11:08

Later named IV
Lobot Thu 11:08

ah k ^^
Thu 11:09

I've seen 1-VI
KyloRen Thu 12:57

Argh
Thu 12:58

I hoped game was over, but I thought this may happen too
Thu 12:59

Lobot/mace do you really think I was SS?
Thu 13:00

I mean I just think I am last choice for SS and my grammar is quite easy to spot especially when I am on iPhone
Thu 13:01

I'm definitely not SS!!
Thu 13:07

One of you is making a mistake!
Thu 13:07

we will lose last night :/
Thu 13:08

Think about it please!! IF I am not SS, which I think if you look back you will see I am not SS
Thu 13:10

Either Han/Palp/Rey were the wolves or Han/Palp/Leah, and i VOTED for Palp on Day 4 (please check the log) and I was first to vote Han on day 5 and have been trying to help the village since the start??
Thu 13:11

Even yesterday I would have accepted Maul's suggestion on who to vote
Thu 13:11

Please think about it!
Thu 13:14

anyway, I will look for further clues of SS later too, but please both look if u can for me and for each other
Mace Thu 13:26

I think you're regular ww, Kylo
Lobot Thu 13:26

Same here
Thu 13:27

My problem is: Mace was cleared by the Seer, and I can't find any hints of mace being SS'ed. Also Maul came to the conclusion that there was no SS into Mace, and Maul died tonight
Thu 13:28

WW's can't kill themself so Maul was 100% legit
KyloRen Thu 16:45

So there is chance of me being regular Werewolf vs chance of Mace being SS vs chance of Lobot being SS
Thu 16:46

And Lobot, you are saying that you think chance of me being regular ww is higher than mace being SS, but I don't think this is true
Thu 16:49

There may not be much difference between Mace's chat, but if you look Mace did not say much before SS happened. I don't think he would be that hard to impersonate. Who knows, it is hard to judge....
Thu 16:50

I think Maul was likely to die, so I don't think Maul was chosen just because he said Mace was clear? And I don't think Maul was completely sure, as he had his vote on Mace for half the day no?
Thu 16:50

Also I think Maul found something that was good evidence for Obi turning into Mace: Both Obi and Mace used the word "Vacation", that is unusual, most people say holiday, from my experience
Thu 16:51

I agree this is all inconclusive, but I have quite hard facts on my side of NOT being a WW....
Thu 16:51

This for both of you, Lobot/Mace, PLEASE explain, Why did I vote for PALP on day4 ? AND WHY did I vote for Hansolo on day 5?!
Thu 16:53

I just don't see how from Lobot's point of view, it is more likely that I am a wolf....
Thu 16:59

Look at this from day 6 too:
Thu 16:59

"Mace Tue 14:54 My theory is, Luke and Vader were telling the truth. That means we have 2-3 wolves out of Kylo, Rey, Han and Obi. Looking back at how they voted and what they have contributed I'd say Rey is a good bet. She didn't vote for Leia but voted for Palpadine and I'm not sure Palpadine was a good lynch because everybody was happy with it. Moderator Mace votes to put Rey on trial"
Thu 17:00

Lobot, please look at that! That was from day 6, when I had already voted for Hansolo because I thought it was clear he was wolf, THEN Mace goes for Rey, THEN HANsolo goes for REY, Then Palp goes for Rey
Thu 17:00

I think Rey was villager all along, and that Leah was Wolf now. That makes sense why Mace was happy to vote rey all along
Thu 17:01

Also, i found this, if you think Rey was SS? which must be the case for me to be WW, (which I also find weird that Obi would have chosen Rey for SS)
Thu 17:04

---------------
Thu 17:04

This is the day 7 bit about the vacation grammar, that Maul found and then decided to ignore?
Thu 17:04

Mace Wed 14:41 True. But I've been online way too much today for a family vacation Maul Wed 14:43 The fact you call it family vacation does more for your favour than being active IMO, obi could simply be lying all along as a convenient reason to stay quiet and innocuous Wed 14:43 Did obi ever call it a family vacation..? I thought he said holiday Mace Wed 14:44 With family Maul Wed 14:45 Actually he said vacation Mace Wed 14:46 Oh, you were looking for text patterns Lobot Wed 14:46 I like Maul's play this game Maul Wed 14:46 Yes, a difference, but you both say vacation
Thu 17:07

1) He was fairly quiet, I don't think his style is that hard to imitate
Thu 17:08

2) the word vacation is definitely strange, and I think on day 6 Mace was overusing that as an excuse to clear himself, it is easily possible that Obiwan was just using the holiday thing as an excuse no?
Thu 17:09

3) I don't think Maul was that certain himself, why did Maul have his vote on Mace for a lot of the day?
Thu 17:13

those are the reasons I think Mace is suspicious, and combine this with an explanation for why I vote palp on day 4 and Han first on day 6
Thu 17:15

Sorry for repetition and wall of text, just trying to get it all down
Moderator

Lobot votes to put Mace on trial
Mace Thu 17:44

About that "vacation" - I'm not a native speaker. I think I used that word because Obi used it. I didn't even know it's that strange
Lobot Thu 17:45

Mace I just want to hear more from you
Mace Thu 17:46

Voting for wolves as a wolf is actually quite common
Thu 17:47

Lobot, if you think I'm not ss then you have to admit I'm a villager because I was cleared by seer. The only logical choice is Kylo
Thu 17:48

I'm not gonna be on today much longer. Pub quiz coming up
Lobot Thu 17:48

the sample data for you the last few days I pretty small tbqh
Mace Thu 17:51

Remember - Maul's last instinct was that you and I are not ss
Thu 17:51

Don't let Kylo fool you
Thu 17:51

I'm out.
Lobot Thu 17:53

oh well
Thu 17:53

¨thanks I guess
Moderator

Lobot votes to put KyloRen on trial
KyloRen Thu 18:55

Well, I don't see how the only logical choice is me, I think both choices are logical, and it's just about which is more likely
Lobot Thu 18:56

is there a logical choice?
KyloRen Thu 18:57

Well I think it is Mace and clearly mace thinks it is me, but I think it is about the most evidence
Thu 18:57

I guess it comes down to chance of Mace being SSed into convincingly vs chance of me voting against wolves in the way i did
Thu 18:58

I would ask you to re-read end of day4, and whole of day 6 and 7 if you have time
Thu 18:58

Also read about Maul's opinion on Mace for day 7, I think even though he says he thinks Mace/Lobot are same persons, he was not 100% by a long way
Lobot Thu 18:59

I was rdy to lynch you until Mace made a 3 line statement and left
Thu 18:59

I'm just WTF right now
KyloRen Thu 18:59

I think Mace has also been keen to vote for me or Rey on day 7, whichever was looking like most likely
Thu 19:00

And i think Rey was prob villager and Leah was wolf now, which makes that make more sense
Thu 19:03

Another angle too is
Thu 19:04

If Mace is villager, then Rey had to be SS, so you could look for inconsistencies there? But I find that hard myself
Thu 19:04

I also find it weird that they would choose Rey as SS, I know it's possible, but I just don't think it is likely
Lobot Thu 19:05

I wanted rey because he wasn't really helpful
KyloRen Thu 19:05

I have had the misfortune of never being cleared by Vader, but what can i do about that
Thu 19:05

And to be honest, you guys shouldnt be any clearer than me, with an SS, all SS has to do is a competant job and you guys are as unclear as me
Thu 19:06

I only believe you, because Mace is being more shady now the heat is on him, and I trusted maul most and he trusted you
Thu 19:06

What do you mean you wanted Rey?
Lobot Thu 19:06

to be lynched
KyloRen Thu 19:07

Well, to me I didn't mind either Rey or Mace, but i guess that doesnt necessarily help my cause
Thu 19:08

I did think that Rey might have been SS, as he was quite quiet, and I was hoping game would end when Rey was lynched, but it didnt, so then I knew it had to be one of you two and I knew today would be stressful, that's why I was trying to prevent this distrust
Lobot Thu 19:08

Look my problem is: I'm pretty sure you were not SS'ed. And if you were not SS'ed then where did the SS go
KyloRen Thu 19:08

by asking Maul to choose my vote
Thu 19:09

Well, either you or mace....
Thu 19:10

And throught yesterday and today, I have become certain it is Mace
Thu 19:10

well, not certain, but highly more chance than you
Thu 19:10

Do we agree, it is chance of me being WW vs chance of him being SS?
Thu 19:11

So please re-read end of day 4 and see how me/maul/vader/han all reacted at the end of Day 4, Hansolo went against my vote
Thu 19:12

Then read start of day 6 for my vote on Han
Thu 19:12

And then Day 7 to just see how mace talks, how I talk, and how Rey talks
Thu 19:12

And day 7 also to see what Maul thinks of Mace throughout day
Thu 19:12

If u have time obviously
Lobot Thu 19:12

look
KyloRen Thu 19:13

If after all that you still are leaning towards me, then I guess thats gg
Lobot Thu 19:13

I'm now comaring times and sentences since an hour
Thu 19:13

and the frustration comes for the LACK of talking
KyloRen Thu 19:13

between who?
Lobot Thu 19:14

Quigon/Mace
KyloRen Thu 19:14

Well thats what made Mace a clear choice for SS no?
Thu 19:15

I know it might have been the clearest choice, but that is still what happens
Thu 19:15

I think end of Day 4 is clearest, that me and Hansolo didnt have any ties.... if you can re-read that please, then you will see, that I had no idea at that point than Hansolo was a wolf
Lobot Thu 19:15

look I'm super pissed at mace right now (sry if you read this later), but I think for a good town you have to give the person "deciding" some fking info. I put him on trail before because I wanted SOME stuff from him
KyloRen Thu 19:15

I even Say I suspected him the least at like 8pm
Lobot Thu 19:16

And all I get is like 3 lines with a "oh I'm out, trust maul cya"
Thu 19:17

and and he sets a dot at the end of it.
Thu 19:17

The dot totally tilts me
KyloRen Thu 19:17

Im annoyed that he never explained why he thought I would vote for Palp or Han and just says im WW and thats it
Thu 19:17

no really explanation
Lobot Thu 19:17

Obiwan endes all multisentence stuff with a .
KyloRen Thu 19:17

Anyway, I'm going round in circles and not helping
Lobot Thu 19:17

-er
KyloRen Thu 19:17

Sorry to leave you for like an hour or so
Thu 19:18

If i may ask you the favour, if you have time, please read end of day4, day 6 and day 7 then choose
Moderator

Lobot votes to put Mace on trial
KyloRen Thu 19:18

The vacation thing is also odd no?
Thu 19:19

Maul was saying that as eveidence for Obi and Mace being the same person no?
Thu 19:19

I don't think I was imagining that
Moderator

Lobot votes to put KyloRen on trial
Lobot Thu 20:09

Ok guys, this is my decision, I will probably look stupid after the game. I voted for Kylo for the following reasons: -If you have no information I guess going for the easiest solution is the best. I created excel sheets with activity times and compared English sentences as best as I could, and this is hard for me as a non native speaker. I just could find no evidence of any kind of shapeshift on Mace. So in dubio pro reo... -Mace made those short but specific statements the whole game, and so did he today when he wrote "easy" and went for the vote. -Maul lead this game and he went for kylo. -I overthink this game way too much from time to time, and I have to put a stop before I "waste" the whole evening thinking about it non stop like I did for the last two hours. I think I failed as Villager, probably because I was way to exhausted from 43 and I didn't push hard enough in this game. Didn't ask enough questions and so on. If we lose this I will take the responsibility for it and apologize in advance. I just want you Gravechatters to know that I tried, and spent a lot of time thinking about this. I will now close this window and try to "enjoy" the two reaming hours until the lynch happens. GG Well played to everyone!
Moderator

KyloRen votes to put KyloRen on trial
KyloRen Thu 21:21

:(
Thu 21:21

Gg all
Night 8
Moderator

Night falls. As the village sleeps the werewolves begin to stir and decide who to eat tonight...
Lynched

KyloRen was lynched by the village

Your role: Observer

The Village

Graveyard

Spoiler free day archives