ext-044 day 3 | online mafia game replay

Replay

This is a log of a game of werewolves started on the 28th July 2016 on a 24 hour cycle (12h day, 12h night).
This is a spoiler free version, use the user button (top menu) to see who was alive at the time, and the calendar button or links below the chat to navigate through to different days.
You can play a game of online Mafia by joining the game currently in sign up. New players are welcome, but try to be active!
Day 2
Killed

Yoda was killed during the night
Day 3
Moderator

The sun rises, the village is safe from the werewolves for now. Discuss who you think is a wolf, soon you will get a chance to lynch them
Mace

Active during the last day
Vader

Active during the last day
Lobot

Active during the last day
Maul

Active during the last day
KyloRen

Active during the last day
HanSolo

Active during the last day
Rey

Active during the last day
Palpatine

Active during the last day
Dooku

Active during the last day
Luke

Active during the last day
Obiwan

Active during the last day
Yoda

Active during the last day
Quigon

Active during the last day
Moderator

Voting is now open to lynch the next werewolf
Quigon Sat 10:09

I'm honestly amazed I'm not dead right now
Sat 10:09

Anyone else awake
Lobot Sat 10:10

no
Quigon Sat 10:10

Tnx for the info
Sat 10:10

xD
Sat 10:12

But on a srs note, why yoda?? They barely talked yesterday, definitely didn't seem like a special role or anything. I figured the wolves would go for those of us being more active in the discussion
Maul Sat 10:44

I don't know why you're amazed quigon..?
Quigon Sat 10:45

That I'm alive, or that yoda isn't? xD
Maul Sat 10:45

Why kill you?
Sat 10:45

Or target
Quigon Sat 10:45

I mean honestly I was expecting to die day two again because that's exactly how my luck usually goes
Maul Sat 10:46

I see
Quigon Sat 10:46

Also the talkative ones usually get targeted early on
Sat 10:53

well seems like no one else is on and i need sleep, so I'll tty all later
Moderator

Maul votes to put Rey on trial
Vader Sat 11:20

What's the thinking Maul?
Lobot Sat 11:41

look I have no role, we're 13 peeps, I have no clue who to vote for
Maul Sat 11:50

Not speaking just posting these links all the time, it's not helpful
Sat 11:51

People should speak up more it makes it easier to spot the eventual SS change
Sat 11:59

A wrong kill tonight could leave 4 wolves in 10 tomorrow with SS waiting to go, problem!
Leia Sat 12:04

am i still alive?
Sat 12:04

yeap
Sat 12:04

;D
Sat 12:05

quigon, are you really that surprised?
Moderator

Leia votes to put Quigon on trial
Leia Sat 12:06

i refuse to believe quigon doesn't know how the game goes by now
Sat 12:06

i think i've seen one game where the wolves go for the "talkative" ones first
Sat 12:06

and many where they don't
Sat 12:07

seems like a very moot point to make in any case
Sat 12:08

also, all this talk about not dying?
Sat 12:08

seems fishy.
Sat 12:08

a role would know when to shut up
Maul Sat 12:08

were you inactive yesterday Leia?
Leia Sat 12:08

yes
Maul Sat 12:10

I guess I'll go have a read of what Yoda said yesterday
Leia Sat 12:13

no comment on quigon?
Maul Sat 12:13

Yoda seemed okish on a random lynch, thought it was a waste to just let wolves kill people, mentioned he had connection problems, I'd say an unlikely target based on that little info and leaning towards BH found he had role
Sat 12:14

well I thought the comment about being "honestly amazed" was a bit much, like I mentioned already
Leia Sat 12:17

but yoda's dead?
Sat 12:17

they can only be ss, if anything
Sat 12:18

bh would have needed a way to communicate the target somehow, only possible if they did it outside of the game (which is not allowed)
Sat 12:18

what exactly are you saying?
Maul Sat 12:18

not sure I follow, BH could have found Yoda first night and told them last night?
Leia Sat 12:18

and then yoda ssed out?
Sat 12:19

kind of hasty?
Maul Sat 12:19

no
Leia Sat 12:19

oh i see, sorry, hangover
Maul Sat 12:19

BH checks Yoda night 1, sees he has role. Then night 2 tells wolves and they kill him.
Leia Sat 12:19

you think that yoda might have known something
Sat 12:19

mm, i see, yes.
Sat 12:20

yoda voted you, though ;D
Sat 12:21

oh, i was voted
Sat 12:21

why?
Maul Sat 12:21

to see what would happen
Sat 12:21

answer: nothing!
Obiwan Sat 12:26

Hello!
Maul Sat 12:27

Hi Obiwan
Obiwan Sat 12:27

I think voting to get people to talk is good, but we shouldn't lynch based on just guesses or annoyance.
Maul Sat 12:28

Then it will be no lynch tonight unless role comes forward?
Obiwan Sat 12:28

Rey isn't being very helpful with posting links, but if she's a villager, then it's better to have an unhelpful villager than a dead villager.
Sat 12:28

Yeah, that sounds cool.
Maul Sat 12:29

so no kill tonight then Seer if alive comes forward tomorrow to say who they have checked?
Obiwan Sat 12:29

Yeah, or harlot has some checks.
Sat 12:29

I have to go because I'm struggling with this bad airport wifi. I'll try to check in later!
Maul Sat 12:30

see ya
Rey Sat 12:43

Geez, it's a sorry state when a group has a worse sense of humour than Darth Vader...
Maul Sat 12:44

oh hi Rey, our resident comedian
Sat 12:45

what comedy gold do you have today?
Dooku Sat 12:56

yo yo yo yo yooooo
Sat 12:57

rey's just tryna provide a lil light yknow
Sat 12:57

granted it would've been better if she had sent something else aside from the links but like
Sat 12:57

u gotta live ur life
Sat 12:57

[sunglasses face emojis]
Maul Sat 12:59

innit dook i feel u man
Vader Sat 13:04

What's wrong with Darth Vader's sense of humour? A bit dark for you? ;)
Mace Sat 13:08

Isn't anyone else worried that if seer doesn't step up soon then BH will sniff him out and they kill him and we might end up with a fake seer?
Vader Sat 13:09

That is possible
HanSolo Sat 13:09

hi guys
Vader Sat 13:09

Solo!
HanSolo Sat 13:09

You still got the gravedigger
Vader Sat 13:09

Good to know
HanSolo Sat 13:09

he can confirm who is dead
Sat 13:10

But on the matter of yoda
Sat 13:10

I only see 2 possible scenarios
Sat 13:10

random kill
Sat 13:10

or bh got his role night 1
Vader Sat 13:10

That sounded like a GD claim - dug anyone up yet?
Maul Sat 13:10

Mace - of course worried but it's still odds on Seer will be alive tomorrow so it's worth the risk of keeping stum, unless he found like 2 wolves
HanSolo Sat 13:11

I'm not the GD
Vader Sat 13:11

That would be incredible luck to find 2 wolves
Maul Sat 13:11

uhhuh
Mace Sat 13:11

Confirmed villagers would be nice too
Vader Sat 13:11

Then how do you know we still have GD?
HanSolo Sat 13:12

Although quigons statements about him still beeing alive may sound suspicious ...
Vader Sat 13:12

Please don't avoid my question
HanSolo Sat 13:12

after yesterday he was a good protector or huntsman choice
Sat 13:12

so very risky for wolves
Maul Sat 13:13

like I said yesterday
Sat 13:13

so him being alive is not a surprise...
HanSolo Sat 13:13

Ok I don't know for sure we still got the GD
Maul Sat 13:13

it's more of a surprise that Quigon is so shocked :)
Vader Sat 13:13

Silly thing to say then Solo ;)
HanSolo Sat 13:14

It was a response to the if the seer dies we are fucked and wolf can claim seer
Sat 13:14

Without any information it's just way to much what if
Vader Sat 13:15

You sounded very confident about it though
HanSolo Sat 13:16

Well it was the first thing that popped into my head for a role that could reveal a fake claim
Mace Sat 13:17

I'm not comfortable lynching anyone without real info so I guess I'll just wait for a reveal
Maul Sat 13:18

luke is not playing
Moderator

Maul votes to put Luke on trial
Maul Sat 13:19

said nothing?
HanSolo Sat 13:19

yeah he said nothing but was active
Sat 13:19

both days
Maul Sat 13:19

useless
HanSolo Sat 13:19

I think he is the only one
Sat 13:20

Apart from maybe Rey but with her there is hope :P ;-)
Sat 13:20

Question for you all
Maul Sat 13:21

hit me
HanSolo Sat 13:22

The GD should have checked mara last night. Is there any case where we want him to come out, if mara may is a certain role?
Maul Sat 13:22

I would say no but protector and huntsman should acknowledge your comment
HanSolo Sat 13:22

ok
Vader Sat 13:23

Just want to check, GD can check every night?
Maul Sat 13:23

yes
HanSolo Sat 13:23

yes
Vader Sat 13:23

Or once only?
Maul Sat 13:23

every night
Vader Sat 13:23

Okay good
HanSolo Sat 13:23

every night
Maul Sat 13:23

so they have 1 check so far
HanSolo Sat 13:23

correct
Vader Sat 13:23

Then yes GD should have checked
HanSolo Sat 13:25

I'm off a bit see you all later.
Vader Sat 13:27

O/
Maul Sat 13:31

that's some shitty luck if MaraJade was Seer.... does anyone have any thoughts as to whether a GD should come forward if they found MaraJade was the Seer?
Vader Sat 13:36

If she was seer then worth coming out I think
Mace Sat 13:36

I think yes. Because that means we should really start lynching.
Vader Sat 13:36

Because we would basically have no useful Intel
Sat 13:36

For other days
Sat 13:36

I agree with Mace
Sat 13:39

However I don't think she was seer, because I suspect whoever GD is would have told is already
Sat 13:39

Unless one of the silent group is GD...
Sat 13:39

Or even seer...
Maul Sat 13:41

I'd say GD keeps silent still, if we know Seer is dead I'm not sure how that helps us lynch anyone now? it's odds on GD will still be alive tomorrow and I think we need some luck now if Seer is already dead
Sat 13:42

What about thoughts on Harlot? Come forward if they seen anyone visiting Mara or Yoda?
Sat 13:43

a single person visiting that is
Vader Sat 13:58

That's a decent idea - any info on single visits or Wolfy activity is good
Sat 13:58

I think currently we still have nothing
Sat 13:59

:/
Maul Sat 14:00

everyone should remember that 2 deaths in the morning could mean either: 1. Alphawolf killed two villagers OR 2. Wolf+Huntsman are dead..... 6 people could die over 2 nights :D (lynch, villager killed, villager killed, lynch, wolf dead and huntsman dead)
Rey Sat 14:13

I think if GD found MJ was the seer they should not come out
Vader Sat 14:20

keep the wolves guessing?
KyloRen Sat 14:27

Hey guys, sorry for sporadic activity, should be around a bit more over weekend
Sat 14:29

The chances of MJ being seer are 1/10 or so? but even if it was the case, I'm not sure that it matters much whether to come out or not as GD.
Sat 14:30

If the seer is dead, then we are in a pretty tough spot either way
Sat 14:31

I think GD discovery on Yoda will be interesting, seemed a slightly strange kill, but I guess when information is low then many things can be quite random
Vader Sat 15:01

There are also still many quiet / silent players
Mace Sat 15:06

I think it's dangerous to leave villagers guessing while wolves get intel and have a chance to kill all roles before anyone speaks up
Maul Sat 15:06

want to kill Luke?
Sat 15:07

or who?
Vader Sat 15:08

Luke was apparently active but I don't remember him saying anything
Moderator

Maul votes to put Quigon on trial
Maul Sat 15:54

votes are 2-0 on Quigon now
Vader Sat 16:07

why is Quigon a suspect?
Maul Sat 16:21

his statement about being very surprised about living
Sat 16:21

also, because he is living despite being only one active day 1
Sat 16:21

also, I feel he was a bit too keen on being part of the village team
Sat 16:21

I think he sounds wolfy
Sat 16:22

and I think you do too
Sat 16:22

the way you question Han
Vader Sat 16:27

i thought they were legitimate questions
Sat 16:28

the way he was certain GD is still around
Sat 16:28

made me think he's either GD, or BH
Maul Sat 16:29

it's early, I think it's okay to say it the way he did talking like GD is still around
Vader Sat 16:41

if i seriously thought he was shifty i would have put him on trial
Moderator

I'm pushing an update to the site, if you stop seeing messages please refresh the page.
Luke Sat 17:26

Hello
Vader Sat 17:28

LUKE I AM YOUR FATHER
Luke Sat 17:32

Try not to embarrass me dad
Moderator Sat 17:34

wow, spoilers.
Vader Sat 17:35

one of the most iconic sci-fi films of the last 30 years? a well-known line? not sure if serious
Luke Sat 17:45

You tell em dad
Sat 17:47

You know guys, we may want to consider lynching Kylo Ren before he kills Han.
Sat 17:48

Just kidding don't lynch him
Vader Sat 17:58

i see what you did there
Sat 17:58

realistically though, i don't think Quigon has done anything that means we should lynch him
Rey Sat 18:19

now *that* seems like a spoiler
Dooku Sat 19:37

lmao yeah can we not lynch quigon??
Moderator

Rey votes to put Dooku on trial
Rey Sat 20:08

You gonna balance the vote or not?
Moderator

Vader votes to put HanSolo on trial
Quigon Sat 20:19

Whoa I wake up to two votes on me, good morning
Sat 20:19

Anyone wanna tell me why so I can reassure them I ain't a wolf? xD
Sat 20:19

Reading the chat log brb
Sat 20:24

Okay caught up. Rey, Maul to answer your questions why I was so surprised to be alive today was because yesterday I felt I accidentally implied I was a special role, and figured that would get me targeted immediately
Sat 20:25

And also, Leia
Sat 20:25

This is onyl my second game here xD
Sat 20:26

I'm basing a lot of my guesses on similar games I've played, where the ones who talk a lot and do a lot of info gathering do tend to be killed very fast. I figured it'd be the same here
Moderator

Vader votes to put Dooku on trial
Rey Sat 20:28

hmm, I didn't ask any questions Quigon
Sat 20:28

but nevermind
Quigon Sat 20:28

Oh whoops, meant Leia not rey
Sat 20:28

Sorry bout that
Sat 20:29

I was trying to speed read the chat xD
Vader Sat 20:44

so...at the minute we are tied with Quigon and Dooku
Sat 20:44

i only voted Dooku to balance
Sat 20:45

there really is so little talking in this game i don't think we can really make an informed decision which is really frustrating
Sat 20:46

that was a lot of 'really' but whatever xD
Quigon Sat 20:46

Why is dooku up, btw? Just to balance the vote
Maul Sat 20:46

/ping
Rey Sat 20:46

/pong
Sat 20:46

Quigon, yes
Quigon Sat 20:46

Asking the first person who voted him, not you vadar x/d
Rey Sat 20:46

so that we don't lych you
Quigon Sat 20:46

Well I appreciate that
Sat 20:47

But I wish we had something to go on
Palpatine Sat 21:28

Hey everyone! Okay, just finished reading through all the text. While I agree that we should be careful in revealing special roles, we can't keep waiting and putting it off each night because of the risk that the seer or GD could be killed
Quigon Sat 21:34

Do you have an idea then?
Sat 21:36

We don't have a lot of time before night
Palpatine Sat 21:37

I'm a bit curious about Luke, he hasn't said much in response to the accusations earlier
Maul Sat 21:41

hmm
Quigon Sat 21:41

True, he just popped up for a few comments and left
Moderator

Maul votes to put Luke on trial
Quigon Sat 21:41

Or went silent
Maul Sat 21:42

want to kill Luke?
Quigon Sat 21:42

...I'll give him a minute to defend himself
Maul Sat 21:43

Rey+Vader both have votes on Dooku right now, which means he will die in 15 mins or so
Quigon Sat 21:44

I'll balance if Luke comes back and convinces me not to hit him
Moderator

Rey votes to put Vader on trial
Rey Sat 21:44

Now we don't
Quigon Sat 21:44

I'm keeping an eye on the time
Sat 21:44

or that works xD
Maul Sat 21:44

now it's even
HanSolo Sat 21:45

I'm back
Sat 21:45

What's going on?
Maul Sat 21:45

thinking about who to lynch
Quigon Sat 21:45

We're waiting for luke to say something
HanSolo Sat 21:45

was he online today?
Maul Sat 21:46

yes
Quigon Sat 21:46

For about 3 comments xD
Maul Sat 21:46

what game did you play previously quigon?
Quigon Sat 21:46

But he showed up when he was being suspected before and didn't really say anything about it
Sat 21:46

43
Sat 21:46

Aka the game that lives to give me a headache
Maul Sat 21:47

and that was your only game? ok
Quigon Sat 21:47

Here, yeah. I play town of salem a lot tho but that works differently
Sat 21:47

I'm pretty new here
Maul Sat 21:51

is this your first time as a wolf?
Quigon Sat 21:52

Lol, blunt much.
Sat 21:52

No, I haven't been a wolf yet
Sat 21:53

According to dead chat in 43 it's super stressful so I'm not looking forward to it xD
Rey Sat 21:53

:O
Sat 21:53

spoilers
Quigon Sat 21:53

Awww come on, that's hardly a spoiler xD
Palpatine Sat 21:54

Hm, time is drawing closer, I'm surprise Luke still hasn't spoken up yet
Quigon Sat 21:54

Same
Sat 21:54

he might be legit afk
Sat 21:54

Or waiting til he's actively in danger
Moderator

Quigon votes to put Luke on trial
Quigon Sat 21:54

Maybe he'll respond now?
Vader Sat 21:54

i doubt it
Sat 21:54

if he's not said anything for hours
Sat 21:54

i don't think the last 5 minutes will change anything
Moderator

Rey votes to put Quigon on trial
Vader Sat 21:55

and all i can think is that no one is refuting us putting him up for lynch
Rey Sat 21:55

even votes again now
Vader Sat 21:55

which suggests they either think it'll not carry, or he's a villager
Maul Sat 21:56

letting Luke live then?
HanSolo Sat 21:56

Didn't we already establish not lynching anybody without information is a better way to go?
Vader Sat 21:56

that'sa lot of negatives
Sat 21:57

so you're saying to not lynch?
HanSolo Sat 21:57

tldr not lynching = better
Vader Sat 21:57

okay
Sat 21:57

tbh i had been leaning towards Lobot
Sat 21:57

but i can't really substantiate it
Maul Sat 21:57

why
HanSolo Sat 21:57

why him?
Maul Sat 21:57

gut feeling?
HanSolo Sat 21:57

ok
Vader Sat 21:57

partly yes
Sat 21:58

but in a similar way to other players, he shows up for a bit, then disappears
Maul Sat 21:58

if there is a decent reason then say and maybe Seer will take note
Sat 21:58

ok
Vader Sat 21:58

i've noticed he's there early (dawn) but rarely afterwards
HanSolo Sat 21:58

tz maybe
Maul Sat 21:58

dawn GMT?
Sat 21:58

everyone is different time zones >_<
Vader Sat 21:59

and one of the only things he's said is that he has no role
Sat 21:59

but w/e
Quigon Sat 21:59

Yeah that's true
Vader Sat 21:59

it's night now
Sat 21:59

time up
Quigon Sat 21:59

Uggh we just don't have enough info
Moderator

Vader votes to put Lobot on trial
Quigon Sat 21:59

No lynch today then
Vader Sat 21:59

looks like it
Sat 21:59

see you in 12 hours
Lobot Sat 21:59

???
Quigon Sat 21:59

Yup
Lobot Sat 21:59

why I'm on trail?
Night 3
Moderator

Night falls. As the village sleeps the werewolves begin to stir and decide who to eat tonight...

Your role: Observer

The Village

Graveyard

Spoiler free day archives