Mafia Replay - Lord of the Rings Identities

Replay

This is a log of a game of werewolves started on the 23rd July 2016 on a 24 hour cycle (12h day, 12h night).
This is a spoiler free version, use the user button (top menu) to see who was alive at the time, and the calendar button or links below the chat to navigate through to different days.
You can play a game of online Mafia by joining the game currently in sign up. New players are welcome, but try to be active!
Killed

Aragorn was killed during the night
Day 6
Moderator

The sun rises, the village is safe from the werewolves for now. Discuss who you think is a wolf, soon you will get a chance to lynch them
Legolas

Active during the last day
WitchKing

Active during the last day
Merry

Active during the last day
Frodo

Active during the last day
Aragorn

Active during the last day
Sauron

Active during the last day
Elrond

Active during the last day
Grima

Active during the last day
Moderator

Voting is now open to lynch the next werewolf
Moderator

WitchKing votes to put Legolas on trial
WitchKing Sat 10:03

I'll be gone for most of the day
Moderator

Grima votes to put Legolas on trial
WitchKing Sat 10:03

Have fun guys
Legolas Sat 10:03

W8
Sat 10:03
Grima Sat 10:03

hope to see you around
Legolas Sat 10:04

We said grima next
Sat 10:04

Btw. Sauron is villager
Grima Sat 10:04

you and sauron said grima next
Moderator

Legolas votes to put Grima on trial
Legolas Sat 10:19

anyway, I'm positive on Merry, Elrond and Sauron sticking to the plan.
Moderator

Merry votes to put Grima on trial
Legolas Sat 11:36

btw. I checked Sauron because I found his 100% optimism and "don't worry we will win" a bit too optimistic. Sry Sauron, just wanted to be sure :)
Sat 11:37

and he has one of our most important roles
Sat 11:40

and just as a hint for Witchking, the person I confirmed town last day was killed tonight ;)
Merry Sat 12:07

why is witch voting you?
WitchKing Sat 12:09

Whoa whoa whoa
Sat 12:09

What do you mean "one of our most important roles??"
Sat 12:10

If you're seer as you claim, you don't know what role he has
Merry Sat 12:11

good point
WitchKing Sat 12:13

Merry, just kill Legolas tonight... village can still win if Grima is the wolf
Sat 12:13

We kill Lego then Grima then Sauron
Sat 12:13

V
Sat 12:14

But if Lego and Sauron are wolves and we kill Grima tonight then they'll win
Sat 12:14

The only way that plan fails is if you're a wolf, Merry... and if you are then you bloody deserve to win
Moderator

Elrond votes to put Grima on trial
Elrond Sat 12:17

Let's stick to the plan.
WitchKing Sat 12:17

Elrond...
Sat 12:18

Why go with a plan that has a 50% chance of making us lose?
Sat 12:18

Why not go for the 100% chance at victory?
Sat 12:19

Well, 90%
Sat 12:20

There's still the chance that Merry is a wolf, but I'm ignoring that
Merry Sat 12:22

Could witch be a wolf?
Sat 12:22

Witch and Grima
Sat 12:23

if so killing Lego means village loses tonight as it would likely be 4 people left tomorrow
Sat 12:23

Grima, Witch and 2 from Merry, Sauron, Elrond
Elrond Sat 12:23

… It doesn't have a 50% chance of making us lose. Have a little faith.
Merry Sat 12:24

who did you protect the night before last Elrond
WitchKing Sat 12:33

Aragorn
Sat 12:34

And now Aragorn is dead before he could tell us what he saw
Sat 12:36

Well, sod it, let's lynch Grima
Sat 12:36

But if we lose then I'm going to be very upset with y'all :p
Moderator

WitchKing votes to put Grima on trial
Merry Sat 12:38

why do you want to kill Lego? combination of reasons or anything in particular?
WitchKing Sat 12:45

He sounds like a wolf... I still believe that Frodo was a harlot, which makes Gollum a wolf, which makes Sauron and Legolas a pair of wolves
Sat 12:45

They all keep making little slip ups that are passed off as "misunderstandings"
Sat 12:46

Sauron called Pippin a she, despite people using "he" on multiple days; Lego said Sauron has an important role but he can't know that for certain unless he's the Bloodhound
Sat 12:48

The entire Pippin was SS and shifted into Gothmog was just... idk, too convenient for me? I can't believe that a SS would use their power on the first day
Merry Sat 12:48

Lego checked Sauron, check says he's a villager, Sauron says he's GD so I guess that's how he knows
WitchKing Sat 12:49

But then you'd say "I checked Sauron and he's definitely a villager"
Merry Sat 12:50

it is a bit unusual the way he said it I agree.. but I think it's ok
WitchKing Sat 12:51

Guess we'll find out tomorrow :/
Merry Sat 12:51

I called out Pippin as SS before anyone so I feel that works
Sat 12:52

Goth just didn't seem like same person, his typing style was different and his attitude seemed different
Sat 12:53

I always voted Goth over Gollum so it's hard to convince me on that one..... I felt Goth was prime wolf target as he was a 'safe' villager at the time
Sat 12:53

he was 'safe' because he came forward to say he had a role but didn't know how to use it
Sat 12:55

I think Elrond being alive all the way to end if a bit odd, the last time I played with a protector who came out early and then was still living near end it was when they were SS into and nobody picked up on it
Legolas Sat 12:55

w8 guys
Sat 12:55

u got my point totally wrong O_o
Merry Sat 12:55

this game is unusual though with everyone active and all roles coming forward
Sat 12:56

coming forward on day 2 or 3
Legolas Sat 12:56

My point was with "our most important role" is that, if he wasn't the GD and a wolf, we would be fked because he's the only one who can "confirm" our lynches
Sat 12:57

I can't check his role ofc, but I was most scared of one of the few roles we have left being a wolf maybe ss'ed
Sat 12:58

Sauron "confirmed" Pippin being the SS, I wanted to be sure that this stuff is right
Sat 12:59

do you get my point guys?
Sat 12:59

Sorry english is not my native language, and sometimes I shortcut my sentences because I'm not sure how to word them :(
Sat 13:00

my thought process was "which error of judgement could cost us the most"
Sat 13:01

and my conclusion was that Sauron piggybacking on me and telling us false confirms on dead ppl. is the most risky one. So I checked him
Sat 13:02

and since I found his reaction yesterday a bit too confident
Sat 13:02

because he basically called the win, and said nothing could go wrong now.
Merry Sat 13:03

I feel like if Lego was wolf why would he even bother typing all that
Sat 13:04

it's Grima 4 votes, Lego 1
Sat 13:04

only Sauron hasn't voted and there's no doubt where his vote will go
Legolas Sat 13:06

does the round end after the last wolf gets lynched or in the morning?
Sat 13:07

@merry I hope the above explained my reasoning, and yes I worded it poorly at first :(
Merry Sat 13:07

ends immediately if wolves are all dead
Sat 13:08

so will end tonight hopefully
Legolas Sat 13:08

I'm so scared of 23:00, and the wait for it to end. I put way to many emotions in this round. Damn I even dreamed of it :P
Sat 13:09

I woke up at 8am today and wanted to check the game on my phone, then realized it's not even 11, woke up at 11:05 or something
Sat 13:11

I HOPE sauron checked gothmog, because I'm 100% on frodo due to Gollum being the seer, and 100% on Grima because he claims the role I dug out. But I'm only 95% on gothmog, because the original player seemed new and experienced. :(
Sat 13:11

*unexpirienced
Merry Sat 13:15

lol Lego
Sat 13:16

you deserve a win this game
Sat 13:16

wolf or villager :)
Sat 13:16

btw it's inexperienced
Legolas Sat 13:26

damn it! :P
Merry Sat 13:30

are you in game 44 lego?
Sat 13:30

don't say who if you are of course
Sat 13:30

I think Aragorn is in 44, at least someone that sounds just like him lol
Legolas Sat 13:38

yes I am
Sat 13:39

but not that talky like here ;)
Merry Sat 13:40

ah okay
Legolas Sat 13:41

my chatty attitude got me in trouble in this game and the last I played^^
Grima Sat 13:55

I'm going to be heading out for a while so I figure I'll give the town something to reconsider while I'm away
Sat 13:55

if I get lynched and lego and saur are wolves, they will kill another villager in the night, leaving 2 wolves and 2 villagers
Sat 13:55

Not a winning outcome
Sat 13:57

also witchking picked up on the same little slip ups as I did, which are easily swept away with "I got confused" or something similar, if you believe them
Sat 13:58

they have been also acting thick as thieves, if you ever noticed them talking between themselves when no one else is around, patting each other on the back for 'finally solving' the game
Sat 13:58

almost like they're on the same close knit team
Sat 13:59

witch had the right idea earlier, much safer to lynch legolas first, gives the town more time to comb over the facts
Sat 14:00

it would guarantee at the very least that only one wolf remains
Sat 14:00

also if I don't return in time, my last words are to check out stranger things if you haven't already, it is really good
Moderator

Sauron votes to put Grima on trial
Sauron Sat 16:15

@Legolas WHAT!? How was I too optimistic? It was clear since day 4 that the wolves are Frodo, Grima and Gothmog.
Sat 16:16

Checked Gothmog and it said "Werewolf", tho didn't need to check cuz already known.
Sat 16:16

Not gonna be online for much at all but Good game everyone. We won.
Sat 16:19

Also if Grima ever fight back in anyways, just remember that he claimed that me, Legolas, Frodo, and Gollum are wolves when Gothmog is fundamentally a wolf according to Grima's logic (Gothmog can't be villager and that Legolas is the real GR who turned wolf)
Sat 16:22

Seer: Gollum - GraveDigger: Sauron - GraveRobber: Legolas - Harlots: Original Gothmog and Aragorn - Villagers: Merry WitchKing and Eowyn - Protector: Elrond - Shapeshifter: Pippin - Normal WW: Frodo - Bloodhound: Grima
Sat 16:22

Bye bye! :O
Moderator

I'm pushing an update to the site, if you stop seeing messages please refresh the page.
Merry Sat 17:27

Roger
Night 6
Moderator

Night falls. As the village sleeps the werewolves begin to stir and decide who to eat tonight...
Lynched

Grima was lynched by the village

Your role: Observer

The Village

Graveyard

Spoiler free day archives

Mafia Replay - Lord of the Rings Identities