Mafia Replay - Lord of the Rings Identities

Replay

This is a log of a game of werewolves started on the 23rd July 2016 on a 24 hour cycle (12h day, 12h night).
This is a spoiler free version, use the user button (top menu) to see who was alive at the time, and the calendar button or links below the chat to navigate through to different days.
You can play a game of online Mafia by joining the game currently in sign up. New players are welcome, but try to be active!
Day 5
Moderator

The sun rises, the village is safe from the werewolves for now. Discuss who you think is a wolf, soon you will get a chance to lynch them
Legolas Fri 10:02

Morning folks
WitchKing Fri 10:02

No death?
Legolas Fri 10:03

I see none
WitchKing Fri 10:03

So Legolas, tell us
Fri 10:03

What did your elf eyes see?
Legolas Fri 10:03

I checked Aragorn, just to be 100% safe on the harlot thing
WitchKing Fri 10:04

Please don't say wolf
Legolas Fri 10:04

no, he's villager
WitchKing Fri 10:04

Please don't say wolf
Fri 10:04

Phew
Legolas Fri 10:04

just wanted to check our only reliable source
WitchKing Fri 10:05

So now let's hear what everyone else has to say
Fri 10:06

I really really really hope Elrond didn't protect me last night
Fri 10:06

Also, Frodo needs to reveal before Aragorn
Legolas Fri 10:06

I hope to hear from aragorn
WitchKing Fri 10:07

Only after Frodo though, so we know if Frodo is telling the truth
Legolas Fri 10:07

true
Fri 10:08

do I got that right, the BH can't vote to kill someone? There was something about Sauron/Eleronds plan
WitchKing Fri 10:08

BH only gets to vote to kill if they're the last wolf alive
Legolas Fri 10:08

the one I was not invited to :P
WitchKing Fri 10:10

Is 44 broken?
Legolas Fri 10:10

so it doesn't matter who we kill first?
Fri 10:10

yep got no day in 44
Fri 10:11

still night
WitchKing Fri 10:11

Guess we need to wait for a mod to wake up 8-)
Legolas Fri 10:11

btw. I have to mail mark after this round, some stuff is super bugged. I had too many icons that night, and some are still here.
Fri 10:12

also wen I went home yesterday my role was wrong until I ctrl-f5'ed the site. I think it's some caching issue or something.
WitchKing Fri 10:14

Hmmmmmnmn
Legolas Fri 10:16

so who you wanna lynch next?
Moderator

Voting is now open to lynch the next werewolf
WitchKing Fri 10:18

Well, I'd still like to lynch you personally... but for now I'm actually happy waiting until the harlots turn up
Legolas Fri 10:18

I retract my question ;)
Fri 10:19

ok I think that sentence was probably a bad move, will give you the wrong vibes :S
WitchKing Fri 10:19

>_> you realise that I was a wolf last time right? ;)
Fri 10:19

XD
Legolas Fri 10:21

I'm not sure if I should enjoy the mindf*k you just went through the last few days in this round or feel sorry for my bad play.
Moderator

Merry votes to put Frodo on trial
Moderator

Legolas votes to put Frodo on trial
WitchKing Fri 10:37

@Legolas why not both?
Legolas Fri 10:39

we were best village buddies for the first 2 days, and since then you restlessly want to lynch me. :((
Fri 10:40

and I'm still not sure why you think I'm a wolf
Fri 10:40

My play has bin consistent, and didn't change at all after my role steal
Fri 10:40

*been
Fri 10:41

so I personaly feel the theory of me being a wolf now is a weak attempt by frodo and Grima.
Fri 10:42

or did you notice any change of play from me?
WitchKing Fri 10:50

I just really want to believe Frodo is innocent
Fri 10:50

D:
Fri 10:51

I invited him round for a party and G&Ts... I don't want a wolf to treat apart my sweet pad
Legolas Fri 10:53

but as you said yesterday the evidence is piling, up, and for some reason the wolves weren't able yet to come up with a coherent storry.
Fri 10:53

probably because they kinda checked themselves in a hole with 2 confirmed villagers who are still alive
Fri 14:51

so no news from aragon or sauron...
Fri 14:51

I think Sauron should arrive in 1 hours, but when was Aragorn last seen?
Aragorn Fri 15:15

yo yo yooooo
Fri 15:15

sorry my activity was spotty yesterday i had a social life for once lmao
Fri 15:16

we gonna wait for frodo to talk
Fri 15:16

in other news i have some info from reading the chat log yesterday
Fri 15:16

lemme grab the quote
Fri 15:17

Moderator WitchKing votes to put WitchKing on trial
Fri 15:17

idk if y'all kno but u can't vote for urself if ur a plain villager ?????
Merry Fri 15:26

When I asked about that yesterday I didn't really understand the reply from witch
Legolas Fri 15:31

Aaragorn got a point O_o
Fri 15:32

I feel scared right now
Fri 15:32

Aaragorn can you give me the timestamp?
Fri 15:33

-a
Fri 15:36

Aragorn where is Witchkings explanation in the logs? I can't find it
Merry Fri 15:39

I asked about 30 mins before nightfall
Fri 15:40

I thought witch meant you can't vote yourself if you are special but can sometimes if you are villager
Fri 15:40

But that's not how I read it
Legolas Fri 15:41

mom, I'm checking
Merry Fri 15:42

Which seer said they checked witch? I think gollum said night 1 witch then night 2 merry
Legolas Fri 15:43

grima
Fri 15:43

wasn't grima you and witch?
Merry Fri 15:43

Actually yea, was grima
Legolas Fri 15:44

I can check Witch tonigh
Fri 15:44

+t
Fri 15:44

Merry I dont find your question
Fri 15:44

in the log
Merry Fri 15:45

It was the only thing I said in the last hour
Fri 15:46

9.44
Legolas Fri 15:46

he said it's a bug
Fri 15:47

Look, due to all my glitches I still have with the interface (multiple buttons I shouldn't have anymore), I tend to believe him
Fri 15:47

I think I will check him
Fri 15:48

just to be sure, but this game is sometimes glitchy. We should go on that notion alone if we suspect him
Fri 15:48

@Aragorn, just fyi checked you tonight, was relieved :)
Fri 15:51

merry were you EVER able to vote for yourself?
Fri 15:51

during this round?
Merry Fri 15:53

Never
Legolas Fri 15:53

we need the result from sauron for more information
Merry Fri 15:53

Sauron said you can vote yourself
Legolas Fri 15:53

he has a role
Moderator

Legolas votes to put Legolas on trial
Moderator

Legolas votes to put Frodo on trial
Sauron Fri 15:54

Hello good news especially for you Legolas
Legolas Fri 15:54

Goth was?
Merry Fri 15:54

Yes he has role so is able, but so was witch able
Sauron Fri 15:54

OH SHIT
Legolas Fri 15:55

mh?
Sauron Fri 15:55

Fk... Should have checked Gothmog I am so stupid but I checked Pippin
Fri 15:55

Pippin showed up as undetermined
Legolas Fri 15:55

shapeshifter
Sauron Fri 15:55

So your theory was right. Gothmog is shapeshifted
Moderator

Sauron votes to put Frodo on trial
Sauron Fri 15:56

Since Gollum is the real seer, Frodo is still a wolf :P
Legolas Fri 15:56

dudes, I will check Witch, just to be sure, but damn I would feel super bad if Witch made some mega play and he gets caught because of a bug :((
Merry Fri 15:56

This sounds dodgy, sauron accidentally checked wrong person?
Sauron Fri 15:56

Not exactly
Fri 15:57

I didn't have the option of checking Gothmog so
Fri 15:57

At around 5pm
Merry Fri 15:57

5pm is in 1 hours time for me
Legolas Fri 15:57

look this stuff could just ruin this game :(
Sauron Fri 15:57

I was excited to see that whether mine Pippin theory is right or not so I was eager to check Pippin
Legolas Fri 15:57

I feel super shitty
Sauron Fri 15:58

??? The wolves are clear everyone
Fri 15:58

Grima and Frodo 2 wolves.
Legolas Fri 15:58

I got no button for Goth or Eowyn either...
Fri 15:58

and yes I still have GR buttons..
Merry Fri 15:59

So we are back to thinking Pippin was SS and went into Goth. Goth said day 2 (first real day) he had ability he couldn't use so he was a prime wolf target, it makes sense.
Legolas Fri 16:00

well if the ss went into Goth, it would explain why he f'ed up the claim
Fri 16:00

he couldn't know which role he had
Sauron Fri 16:01

Yeah, Goth was a harlot, but the harlot role got claimed by Aragorn and followed by Frodo.
Merry Fri 16:01

Possibility is there that Pippin took over someone else I guess. How about Elrond, is that possible? Or did Aragorn clear on day 3?
Legolas Fri 16:01

or das BH happen after SS?
Sauron Fri 16:01

No it is impossible.
Merry Fri 16:01

Elrond was certain Goth was the same person day 2 and 3
Sauron Fri 16:02

Because between Legolas and Gothmog, there has to be a wolf.
Legolas Fri 16:02

so bh couldn't determine Pippin role after he was ss'ed the same night?
Merry Fri 16:03

I don't know how BH works, I.e. at what he gets told role
Sauron Fri 16:03

Fundamentally the wolves are: Legolas / Gothmog (2 GR claims), Grima / Gollum (2 seer claims), + Someone else.
Legolas Fri 16:03

the someone is with 100% for me frodo, since I new gollum was right
Sauron Fri 16:03

Since Gollum is the real seer: Gollum's check on Frodo makes Frodo a wolf.
Merry Fri 16:03

At what point* i meant to say
Sauron Fri 16:04

BH gets told exact role
Merry Fri 16:04

Immediately?
Sauron Fri 16:04

Like seer / harlot / gravedigger and so on
Legolas Fri 16:04

but does he if the player gets SS'ed?
Sauron Fri 16:04

Uh for BH???
Fri 16:04

Idek lol...
Legolas Fri 16:05

yes, does the bh get the result
Fri 16:05

ok next question, Grima claimed I was town during his check, but said I switched probably right?
Merry Fri 16:05

Like at night, can BH check and immediately get told role
Legolas Fri 16:05

I think there is no immediate results
Fri 16:05

all is on dawn
Merry Fri 16:06

Ok
Sauron Fri 16:06

No immediate result, but she know that you stole Gollum's role, thus makes you a wolf at that time
Legolas Fri 16:06

but I'm new, just the expirience I got with GR/Seer so far
Fri 16:06

have you guys seen my question about grima?
Merry Fri 16:06

I keep getting villager only
Fri 16:07

Yea.but I don't know answer
Sauron Fri 16:07

Yes I answered it.
Legolas Fri 16:08

ah saw it
Sauron Fri 16:09

Since Gollum is supposedly Bloodhound :/
Fri 16:09

In Grima's POV
Legolas Fri 16:09

so Grimas story was false?
Fri 16:09

he said he saw me as town
Fri 16:09

right?
Sauron Fri 16:11

No Grima's story was not false at all
Fri 16:11

As in like theoretically speaking
Merry Fri 16:11

Grima must be BH, as per Aragorn
Fri 16:11

No?
Sauron Fri 16:11

Shoot I actually don't know the interaction between them that well yikes... Grima is BH as per Aragorn
Fri 16:12

Frodo is a normal Werewolf.
Merry Fri 16:15

So kill Frodo tonight, then Grima, then if game continues there's a problem
Sauron Fri 16:26

Yeah the game won't continue for 100% sure.
Merry Fri 16:37

So we believe wolves only got 2 kills - Pippin (really Goth) died as BH found his role as Harlot night 1, Eowyn died to imitate a fake SS and cast suspicion.. Why did Goth bother claiming a role?
Legolas Fri 16:41

I know goth wasn't GR, but besides that he's a wildcard for me
Sauron Fri 16:41

Idek what the wolves were planning this game tbh
Fri 16:41

I thought Gothmog is the same guy all along due to timestamp
Legolas Fri 16:42

What do we think about witchkings self vote?
Sauron Fri 16:42

Bug.
Elrond Fri 16:42

Hello!
Sauron Fri 16:42

It is obvious that the three wolves are Frodo Grima and Gothmog
Legolas Fri 16:43

Shall I check him or better someone else?
Fri 16:43

hey Elrond
Elrond Fri 16:43

If for some odd reason the game doesn't end after we lynch Frodo and Grima, we'll have to lynch Witchking. It's probably a bug though.
Sauron Fri 16:43

No need I am so sure I am right that we don't need your seer abilities :P, check WitchKing for fun and it will give you villager
Fri 16:44

O_o that won't happen dw
Legolas Fri 16:44

I was 100% till now on witch, but it's a good spot by Aragorn!
Elrond Fri 16:44

Just to warn you all, I won't be on much as I'm packing for a trip.
Moderator

Elrond votes to put Frodo on trial
Legolas Fri 16:45

should elrond protect me?
Sauron Fri 16:45

Doesn't matter we won :D
Legolas Fri 16:45

on the other hand
Fri 16:45

but we need to know what goth was
Sauron Fri 16:45

Gothmog Frodo Grima 100%
Legolas Fri 16:45

or Frodo, one of those
Sauron Fri 16:46

If Gothmog is a villager I quit this game forever.
Legolas Fri 16:46

I still worry about SS, until we find his body I'm fking scared
Elrond Fri 16:46

Legolas, I'll protect you.
Legolas Fri 16:46

Elrond, you agree that "undetermined" means ss?
Sauron Fri 16:46

Gothmog. Frodo. Grima. Really easy no need to worry Legolas :P
Elrond Fri 16:46

Yes, it should mean SS.
Legolas Fri 16:47

Witchking said unknown but basically same meaning
Sauron Fri 16:47

Yeah Pippin shapeshifted into Gothmog
Legolas Fri 16:47

Elrond, also agree on Witchkings vote being a bug?
Fri 16:47

I think you played some games before right?
Elrond Fri 16:48

This is my fifth game, I think, but yeah, probably a bug.
Moderator

Sauron votes to put Sauron on trial
Legolas Fri 16:48

who would you guys check just to be sure?
Moderator

Sauron votes to put Frodo on trial
Sauron Fri 16:48

No need to worry at all!
Legolas Fri 16:48

we have seer, so I think we should use it
Elrond Fri 16:49

I don't know.
Sauron Fri 16:49

Check me to make sure I am village then
Fri 16:49

It is already crystal clear who the wolves are
Elrond Fri 16:49

That's a waste of a seer check, Sauron.
Legolas Fri 16:49

I just dont want to mess up
Sauron Fri 16:49

Check Grima then
Legolas Fri 16:49

I want to use every tool we have
Sauron Fri 16:49

We don't need to worry about messing up
Fri 16:49

Who else could the wolves be?
Elrond Fri 16:49

Check Grima.
Legolas Fri 16:50

ok Grima's checks were Witch and Merry
Elrond Fri 16:50

Are we assuming no one died last night because I protected the person?
Sauron Fri 16:51

Witch Merry and you, all villager. He came in really late, when we all revealed our roles.
Fri 16:51

Yes no one died last night but I have no idea who you protected.
Legolas Fri 16:51

I think aragorn has still some information, but we wanted to wait on frodo first
Fri 16:52

but Frodo is awfully quiet today
Elrond Fri 16:52

I believe it was stated at some point yesterday, or at least suggested. I protected Aragorn, who was supposed to "meet" with Frodo at WitchKing.
Sauron Fri 16:52

Ha so Frodo really went for Aragorn last night
Elrond Fri 16:53

So, assuming that Aragorn hadn't seen anyone because Frodo's the wolf, that means the wolves tried to off Aragorn before he could expose them.
Legolas Fri 16:53

I think the "last" plan was for you to protect Witch :D
Sauron Fri 16:53

There was no date at WitchKing
Legolas Fri 16:53

which would make aragorn the target
Sauron Fri 16:53

Because we know who Frodo is now right?
Elrond Fri 16:53

Aragorn got stood up.
Fri 16:54

This all but confirms it, but I'm looking forward to seeing Frodo's flimsy defense.
Legolas Fri 16:54

frodo was confirmed by Gollum, so I have doubt in that one
Fri 16:54

*no doubt
Fri 16:54

sry
Sauron Fri 16:54

Yup!
Elrond Fri 16:55

I have to go pack, I'll check in later. By the way, does anyone know if you go to a different timezone if the server will detect it and tell you when night falls in your new timezone?
Sauron Fri 16:55

Gothmog Frodo Grima. Just repeating myself again lol, clear wolf team.
Fri 16:55

Yes I think so O_o
Legolas Fri 16:56

I think yes, I don't live in bst
Elrond Fri 16:56

Okay, nice. I'm too lazy to figure out the timezones.
Legolas Fri 16:56

and it has my local time
Sauron Fri 16:56

There is always the GMT time to refer to
Legolas Fri 16:57

for me it says night fals at 23:00 (GMT 21:00)
Fri 16:57

+l
Elrond Fri 16:59

I believe I'll be in the same timezone as you tomorrow.
Legolas Fri 17:15

I'm from Switzerland.
Elrond Fri 18:24

I'm going to Italy.
Legolas Fri 18:27

yeah same tz :)
Moderator

Grima votes to put Frodo on trial
Grima Fri 19:35

checked frodo, turns out they were wolf, that one did surprise me
Fri 19:38

I think that means goth must have been villager all along? I might actually agree with a wolf here, I will quit if that is the case
Fri 19:39

just so it's clear to everyone, there are now two potential wolf teams for the town to consider
Fri 19:39

1) me, 2) sauron and legolas
Fri 19:39

under the assumption the wolves kill at night, there are two outcomes tomorrow evening
Fri 19:40

you kill me, and if I am wolf, town wins, but if it turns out I was town all along then legolas and sauron win
WitchKing Fri 19:41

How so?
Fri 19:41

oh, you mean if we lynch Frodo tonight
Grima Fri 19:41

correct
Fri 19:42

frodo is the safe vote, both sides want him gone and has been confirmed by practically everyone
Sauron Fri 19:44

Nice try Grima. The wolves are Grima, Frodo and Gothmog.
Grima Fri 19:45

just trying to inform the town, instead of affirming what I want the town to think in order to win
Fri 19:45

as evident by your near hysterical behaviour when merry changed votes last night
Sauron Fri 19:48

MUWAHAHA, It was me, Sauron! Who brainwashed the town with truth!
Fri 19:49

I wish Frodo was here. Sorry for mine rude behaviors :(
Grima Fri 19:51

have you actually been of any real value to the town? you simply supported legolas in his claim to seer when he GR'd into the BH role, then the two of you practically parroted each other
Moderator

WitchKing votes to put Legolas on trial
Grima Fri 19:52

then you said you were the one true gd about a hundred times, and you mess that up by your own admission
Sauron Fri 19:53

:O How did I mess up mine GD claim lol?
Grima Fri 19:53

not the claim, in your checks, my apologies
Sauron Fri 19:53

Hmmm may be... just may be...
Fri 19:54

I didn't mess up any of mine checks! And that Gollum is the real seer! And that Grima is a false one~
Grima Fri 19:55

the only supporting information you have for that is the assumption you and legolas are telling the truth about your roles, after a shaky performance by gollum
Fri 19:56

meanwhile, no one really disputed my claim as seer, I think I was even vouched by aragorn during a seer check?
Fri 19:56

I might need to check that though
Sauron Fri 19:56

Hmmm... That means you are the one and only Bloodhound :O
Fri 19:56

I wonder if Bloodhound can still kill if it is only the Bloodhound left.
Grima Fri 19:57

you say that like it's a novel line of inquiry but that has been the party line for the wolves for a while
Sauron Fri 19:57

If not, Bloodhound should definitely be promoted into a normal werewolf after every other wolves are dead.
Grima Fri 19:57

they can, the BH no longer has BH ability and becomes a normal wolf when they are the last one, I believe
Sauron Fri 19:58

Good then, so you can still kill tonight Grima
Fri 19:58

Who do you want to kill tonight? I wonder...
Grima Fri 19:58

my only kill ability is via vote
Fri 19:58

personally, I want to get rid of probably legolas, he's been too much of a wildcard
Sauron Fri 19:59

Ah but why not me?
Grima Fri 19:59

but frodo might be the more strategic choice
Fri 19:59

I feel like you're the least threatening wolf
Sauron Fri 19:59

Well you are the seer and Frodo is a wolf right?
Fri 19:59

So who are the wolf gangs?
Grima Fri 19:59

legolas would be BH so still has some value, albeit not much
Fri 20:00

correct, but I have identified sauron, legolas and frodo as wolves
Sauron Fri 20:00

According to you: Frodo, me, Legolas, and Gollum are wolves!
Grima Fri 20:01

Yes that is correct
Sauron Fri 20:01

Gothmog is a plain villager who got lynched and he claimed Grave robber for no good reasons
Fri 20:02

Legolas is the real GR who stole Gollum's role
WitchKing Fri 20:02

yes
Fri 20:02

BH becomes a normal wolf
Grima Fri 20:02

I genuinely believe goth got confused between gr/gd, and he got taken advantage of when he messed up his ability checks
Sauron Fri 20:02

Frodo is on the same wolf team as me despite both me and Legolas wanting him gone.
Grima Fri 20:02

so just yolo'd the way to the grave
Sauron Fri 20:03

Oh okay ty WitchKing.
Fri 20:03

Are you going to confess up your sins Grima?
WitchKing Fri 20:03

question
Fri 20:03

if Pippin was SS
Fri 20:03

who did he SS into?
Sauron Fri 20:04

Gothmog
Fri 20:04

Gothmog is originally a Harlot
WitchKing Fri 20:04

I see
Fri 20:04

do you think they knew that?
Sauron Fri 20:04

The 2nd Harlot role was claimed by Pippin's teammate Frodo
Fri 20:05

But everyone already knows that Gothmog has a role other than villager, thus forcing Gothmog to claim Graverobber
Fri 20:05

I am not sure tbh, since I am not on the wolf team and Idk what happened
WitchKing Fri 20:05

Seems an odd play by the wolves
Fri 20:05

why do you think they did that?
Grima Fri 20:05

@sauron not much to confess @witch I think pippin SS'd into sauron, by process of elimination, also I believe frodo even stuck up for sauron earlier by saying they were the same person, as a cover
Sauron Fri 20:05

Because on day 2, I listed out mine top suspicions
Fri 20:06

Which was: Pippin, Gollum, and Frodo
Fri 20:06

Pippin was mine top suspicion and wolves got scared I think, so I forced the Shapeshifter to shapeshift
WitchKing Fri 20:07

hmm
Grima Fri 20:07

why was pippin a top suspect for you again?
Sauron Fri 20:07

Pippin tried to talk like Gothmog but it was very obvious to Legolas that he was shapeshifted into
Fri 20:08

Oh Pippin suggested crazy ideas + random lynch.
Fri 20:08

So based off that I put Pippin as mine top suspect, of course I didn't want to lynch her just because of suspicions, thus tied votes.
Grima Fri 20:09

I'll look into this
Sauron Fri 20:10

Yeah, Pippin would look way less suspicious if she said nothing at all lol
Fri 20:11

Like what you did Grima
Fri 20:11

I really want to know how did you wolves discuss your strategies. Let's talk about that after game :P
WitchKing Fri 20:12

"she"?
Sauron Fri 20:12

Oh isn't Pippin a female character?
Fri 20:12

Idk just looked at the thumbnail lol
WitchKing Fri 20:13

no
Grima Fri 20:13

...
Fri 20:13

busted?
Sauron Fri 20:13

AH I WAS TERRIBLY WRONG LOL
Grima Fri 20:13

clearly
WitchKing Fri 20:13

honestly, I'd have just run with Frodo if Sauron had said Pippin was the harlot
Sauron Fri 20:13

Never watched any of Lord of the ring movies q_q
WitchKing Fri 20:14

but idk
Fri 20:14

it's like I'm watching a play
Fri 20:14

and it's being made so unbelievable that I'm forced to believe it
Fri 20:14

and all my instincts are screaming that Legolas and Sauron are the wolves
Sauron Fri 20:14

I thought Pippin is the harlot but didn't expect them to actually use their shapeshift ability that early
Fri 20:15

Your instincts are wrong lol, it is hard for you right now but if you look at some of Grima's arguments, it is just ridiculously flawed.
Grima Fri 20:15

they're really not, but at least I would have arguments
Sauron Fri 20:15

Legolas and I are not on the same team because: We fought all day on day 3
Fri 20:16

I am never shapeshifted into because... Obvious reasons
WitchKing Fri 20:16

honestly, that's the worst argument ever
Fri 20:16

it implies wolves never fight with each other
Sauron Fri 20:16

That is not. Wolves stick together.
WitchKing Fri 20:16

ha, I've seen so many games were wolves win because they've lynched other wolves
Fri 20:17

where*
Sauron Fri 20:17

I have seen 0, and I have been on the site for a long time.
Fri 20:17

But the arguments between me and Legolas is different, you can clearly tell that me and Legolas doesn't know each other's role.
Grima Fri 20:17

if you have never seen interwolf conflict, you are one of the few lucky ones
Sauron Fri 20:18

Well it will take forever to read those =_=
Fri 20:18

Oh interwolf conflicts? Only been wolves twice so, it went pretty well :)
Grima Fri 20:19

I'd bet that you would have experienced it at least once this game
Sauron Fri 20:19

Nope. Never seen one, is any chance that a man called Potato7 was in the wolf team?
Grima Fri 20:19

the legend lives on!
Sauron Fri 20:20

I was right?
Fri 20:21

Speaking of legend, I miss him a bit, his arguments are pretty funny and brings in a lot of clues at the same time.
Fri 20:22

Seems like others doesn't miss him as much as I do :/
WitchKing Fri 20:25

o__0
Fri 20:25

0__o
Sauron Fri 20:27

What?
WitchKing Fri 20:29

Nothing ^_^
Sauron Fri 20:29

WitchKing, are you by chance THE LEGEND?
Fri 20:30

You certainly don't talk like the legend, so I assume not...
WitchKing Fri 20:35

unfortunately not
Sauron Fri 20:39

Have you had the pleasure of playing with THE LEGEND?
Legolas Fri 20:43

Witchking, are you more scared of me or Sauron, when your inner scream wolf?
Fri 20:44

*inner instincts, sry just woke up :P
Fri 20:45

and whose THE LEGEND?
Sauron Fri 20:45

Potato7
Fri 20:46

Our real identity is always covered by a fictional character.
Fri 20:46

But, everyone knows, who is Potato7.
Fri 20:47

Only Potato7 would relentlessly type 40 lines of theories, accusations, observations, predictions, and get lynched by the village at the same time!
Legolas Fri 20:47

sounds like fun
Sauron Fri 20:48

An artist, who draws pictures without any tools.
Fri 20:49

But his art wasn't so appreciated. Everywhere he goes, people threw vegetable at him and shame him for his rude behaviors.
Fri 20:49

Even the Mod smited him.
Fri 20:50

The Legend never left us, we sinners left him. I believe he is still here, watching us.
Legolas Fri 20:51

This is my second game, in the first one I got killed by the wolves. So quite far to go to become a legend. But at least I get accused of "leading the town", which is more than I expected.
Sauron Fri 20:51

I praise to be Potato7. "Amen Amen Amen Amen Amen Amen Amen. Seven for the wolves"
Fri 20:52

Ah, it will get better! :)
Fri 20:52

The website is becoming more active now so wins doesn't feel like fluke any more :O
Legolas Fri 20:53

I just enjoy the intense interaction, my last was where I got killed there was more activity in grave chat, than in day chat. Was quite sad to watch how the town got eaten alive :)
Sauron Fri 20:55

Yup exactly what I came to werewolv.es for. I expected some explosive gameplay
Fri 20:56

Was disappointing at first but we are getting there. I hope one day I could try claiming big roles as villager :O
Legolas Fri 20:58

I mean it's funny how different ppl. play it, and how me as an outside came in and seemingly didn't play villager like Witchking is used to. I learned my lesson there, but I know it from other such games I played it's important to break the meta from time to time.
Sauron Fri 21:03

Metagaming is always the worst! It is not fun if we just read off our role card
Fri 21:04

Yeah I am especially different than most others when I came here, made me feel really weird
Fri 21:05

Idk how first one went for you Legolas, but mine first one had a lot of inactives and no one revealed their role except me until 3rd day.
Fri 21:06

Everyone is very conservative here, they don't try reveal their roles at all unlike me.
Fri 21:08

I am in a way like Potato7, it is easy to recognize mine real ID because only I would suggest something like Role Call on day 2.
WitchKing Fri 21:09

Sauron, is your nick Potato8?
Sauron Fri 21:09

I think I need to change up mine style a bit. Tbh I am not a smart person, thus I can't tell the stylistic difference between most players here, but I can always tell when Potato7 is here
Fri 21:10

Lol that would be funny but nope. Mine nick completely contradicts how I act in game right now :P
Legolas Fri 21:10

TheSilentOne?
Sauron Fri 21:10

But that is meta so no revealing, many people already know mine name already.
Fri 21:11

Rip I gave away too much, hope I don't get smited for this. But it is really easy to tell who I am in the first place so
Fri 21:11

It is still village win regardless
Fri 21:12

If Merry die, lynch Grima. If Lego die, lynch Grima, if I die, lynch Grima. If Elrond die, lynch Grima, if WitchKing die, lynch Grima, if Aragorn die, lynch Grima. If no one dies, lynch Grima. Grima can't die for 100% sure
WitchKing Fri 21:14

but what if Grima does die?
Legolas Fri 21:14

we should win
Sauron Fri 21:14

I quit this game forever.
Fri 21:15

Grima can't die tonight.
Fri 21:15

Unless she asks Mod to smite him cuz he gave up.
Legolas Fri 21:16

I'm just so scared of some town screwing up, because I've run this xxxx times in my head, and I can't find a possibility of those 3 not being the wolves. One of them had to make some serious mistake to be innocent. And the only one who could make that mistake was probably goth.
Sauron Fri 21:17

Legolas it is impossible. There is no alternatives :P
Fri 21:20

I mean: Grima revealed that Frodo is a wolf and still voted for you xD
Fri 21:20

Gothmog tried to steal your role.
Grima Fri 21:21

still lying? I voted frodo, witch voted legolas
Fri 21:21

killing me in the night would validate everything I have said
Sauron Fri 21:21

Ah cool, I missed that detail
Fri 21:22

Haha you are back as soon as I made a mistake :P
Grima Fri 21:22

and you deliberately left out the part that if I am innocent, and you get town to lynch me tomorrow, you wolves win
Fri 21:22

you don't offer all the possibilities, just those that suit your narrative
Sauron Fri 21:22

Mathematically impossible
Fri 21:23

Assuming me, Frodo, Legolas are the wolves.
Fri 21:23

OH WAIT You are right!
Fri 21:23

But nope you are wrong too
Fri 21:24

We ain't wolves lol
Grima Fri 21:24

I could facepalm my head clean off
Fri 21:24

if town believes you after this, you earned it bud
Legolas Fri 21:26

Is aragorn here?
Fri 21:27

btw. did frodo just quit?
Fri 21:27

I mean no word from him
Grima Fri 21:27

frodo's absence is curious
Fri 21:28

either he isn't talking because he outlived his usefulness, or just making sure not to slip up trying to defend himself
Fri 21:28

which would be par for the course so far
Legolas Fri 21:28

I mean there was this plan about him proving harlot, and he's just gone
Sauron Fri 21:29

I heard that Frodo will be busy too, so that could be the reason
Grima Fri 21:30

uh, where did you hear that
Sauron Fri 21:31

At the werewolv.es lobby for 044, don't worry, we never meta gamed.
Fri 21:31

It is easy to know Frodo's real ID too, we know each other.
Grima Fri 21:31

why would you anyway, unless you were on same team
Sauron Fri 21:32

Yeah so we didn't.
Grima Fri 21:33

it's all these little details that probably make witch suspect you
Fri 21:33

they add up
Sauron Fri 21:33

Haha what?
Legolas Fri 21:35

I think there are mutiple ppl. in here who recognized others
Sauron Fri 21:35

The reason I know what Frodo's real ID is because: Frodo always try to look in small details of how people speak. When Frodo is a wolf, Frodo likes to joke around to deny real discussions until when Frodo claims a role, that is when Frodo gets serious.
Grima Fri 21:35

you kinda dropping hints that you are aware of the identities of people you shouldn't really know, trying to pin guilt on me (twice in a row), then backpedalling (also twice in a row) once I made you realise the town can easily check that you are wrong, etc
Fri 21:36

I'll look for that in future games, it will be nice to know some more tells
Sauron Fri 21:36

Frodo accused me of being "Eowyn the shapeshifter" because I used a lot of "LOL and ROFL" to pretend to be me xD
Fri 21:37

Only Frodo does that :) I played here a bit and I know only Frodo well so.
Grima Fri 21:37

you also used a lot of "LOL and ROFL" as a defence vs my arguments yesterday
Sauron Fri 21:37

But that is of course not why you are guilty Grima
Grima Fri 21:38

oh really, do enlighten me
Sauron Fri 21:38

It is easy as: I am Gravedigger, I checked Gollum and he is seer, so you can't be a real one.
Grima Fri 21:38

wow, a stunning twist in this courtroom drama
Sauron Fri 21:39

Oh btw, there is also a good clue from your speech that makes you a wolf: Just the nail to the coffin. Unfortunately Frodo made the same mistake. Want to know?
Fri 21:39

Welp I am gonna tell everyone anyways.
Grima Fri 21:40

I'm on pins and needles
WitchKing Fri 21:40

*drum roll*
Sauron Fri 21:41

Grima Thu 16:51 wait I thought there was already a shapeshift, why would you worry about another shapeshif
Fri 21:41

Frodo's speech earlier: It's through a meta theory that I know this, but I'm 99% sure Pippin was SS and turned into Gothmog. Reasons idk.
Grima Fri 21:42

well, you completely missed the coffin
WitchKing Fri 21:42

@Sauron I'm confused... isn't that what happened?
Sauron Fri 21:42

At that time I wasn't sure if a shapeshift has happened. Same with every other villagers.
WitchKing Fri 21:43

*sigh* we've got a circular argument now though
Sauron Fri 21:43

But Grima and Frodo were very confident that a shapeshift has happened, only wolves can be that confident
WitchKing Fri 21:43

because it's only your claim that says Pippin was the SS
Fri 21:43

if we take your claim as true, then this argument is sound and therefor your claim must be true
Fri 21:43

but if you're lying, then the whole thing falls apart
Sauron Fri 21:43

Yeah but I never knew that. You can tell from my speech in day 4.
Fri 21:44

I was worried that Gothmog was a shapeshifter who didn't shapeshift yet.
Fri 21:44

But really look at Frodo's speech
Fri 21:45

Frodo is at least guranteed wolf, who I have been trying to lynch all along. Idk how am I still suspected after lynching all those suspects lol
Grima Fri 21:46

wait, what
Fri 21:46

lynch enough suspects and you're bound to hit a wolf? is that it?
Sauron Fri 21:46

Also when I was arguing that Gothmog is a shapeshifter himself, Grima was confused.
Grima Fri 21:47

because gothmog was confusing
Sauron Fri 21:47

Grima: Your list of wolves contains me, Legolas, and Frodo. Am I right?
Grima Fri 21:47

yes that is right
Fri 21:47

is this where you put together your case for the umpteenth time
WitchKing Fri 21:48

why are there people screaming outside?
Sauron Fri 21:48

Oh right, you think Gothmog is a villager.
WitchKing Fri 21:48

did the wolves come to eat my village already? :|
Grima Fri 21:48

... screaming?
Sauron Fri 21:48

Okay actually, what role do you think Gothmog is?
Fri 21:49

@Grima
Fri 21:49

Grima?
Fri 21:49

We have only a few minutes of fun left today :P
Fri 21:50

And umm what is happening @WitchKing *Concerned face
WitchKing Fri 21:51

hm?
Fri 21:51

oh, idk
Fri 21:51

I think it's children
Fri 21:51

maybe they got knocked down by a car or something
Fri 21:51

I wish they'd shut up
Fri 21:51

(*I'm pretty sure no-one actually got knocked down!)
Sauron Fri 21:51

Ah
Fri 21:52

Good I was scared for a sec lol when I saw knocked down part
Fri 21:52

But it seems to me that someone is out of words
Fri 21:53

I will answer your question for you then Grima, Gothmog is a wolf. Gothmog can't be a villager because there is already Eowyn, Merry and WitchKing who claimed villager
Grima Fri 21:53

sorry, started watching stranger things
Sauron Fri 21:53

He can't be a Graverobber because you accused Legolas of robbing Gollum's role
Grima Fri 21:53

I gave my suspicions about gothmog above, need I repeat everything for you
Sauron Fri 21:54

So there are 5 wolves in 1 game?
Fri 21:54

Me, Frodo, Legolas, Gothmog, and Gollum?
Grima Fri 21:54

no? where are you getting that from
Sauron Fri 21:54

Well you said that me Frodo and Legolas are wolves.
Grima Fri 21:54

yeahhhhh?
Sauron Fri 21:55

And you are putting suspicion onto Gothmog, but you don't think he is a wolf at the same time
Grima Fri 21:55

noooooo?
Fri 21:55

I know it's hard, but can you just scroll up a little bit
Sauron Fri 21:55

Gothmog can't be a villager because there are already 3 villagers. Gothmog can't be a Graverobber because that is Legolas
Fri 21:55

Gothmog is 100% wolf.
Fri 21:56

Thus Grima's theory of me, Frodo, Legolas (GR turned BH), and Gollum being the wolves are technically impossible.
Fri 21:57

Because there are way too many wolves.
Fri 21:57

You lost. Grima.
Legolas Fri 21:58

Good night guys, as always a please. See you tomorrow!
Sauron Fri 21:58

There can be only maximum 4 wolves. Not 5. I hope villagers can understand my argument :)
WitchKing Fri 21:58

g'night
Fri 21:58

but
Fri 21:58

I wanna know what Aragorn had to tell us :(
Grima Fri 21:58

gothmog is a question mark due to no information from a trustworthy source, but he's now irrelevant to my suspicions
Sauron Fri 21:58

Oops. He still hasn't came back x_x
Grima Fri 21:58

where is everyone today actually
Sauron Fri 21:59

Wow you are still trying, nice sportsmanship Grima
Fri 21:59

Even when my argument is perfection.
Grima Fri 21:59

alright, sauron, you have a nice night now chum
Fri 21:59

oh my god thank you for that final laugh
WitchKing Fri 21:59

at least Elrond can protect him tonight and he can tell us tomorrow :3
Sauron Fri 21:59

gnight :O
Grima Fri 22:00

true
WitchKing Fri 22:00

I'll probably die though
Fri 22:00

:(
Sauron Fri 22:00

Lynch Grima tomorrow :p
Grima Fri 22:00

I think?
Fri 22:00

ne me lynchez pas
Fri 22:00

svp
Night 5
Moderator

Night falls. As the village sleeps the werewolves begin to stir and decide who to eat tonight...
Lynched

Frodo was lynched by the village

Your role: Observer

The Village

Graveyard

Spoiler free day archives

Mafia Replay - Lord of the Rings Identities