ext-192 Day 9 | Werewolf Mafia Game Online for your Browser

Replay

You are viewing day 9 of a game of werewolv.es started on the 17-Nov-23 Thu on a 24 hour cycle (12h day, 12h night).

This is a spoiler free version, use the user button (top menu) to see who was alive at the time, and the calendar button or links below the chat to navigate through to different days.

You can play a game of online Mafia by joining the game currently in sign up. New players are welcome, but try to be active!
Boone Fri 09:06

Wow. Shit.
MrEko Fri 09:18

maninblack has got sum explaining 2 do
Fri 09:22

boone btw i think uve been lying 2 us
Fri 09:23

u wanna come clean?
Fri 09:23

ur not demon lord at all r u!!
Eloise Fri 09:24

Hmm...
Fri 09:25

Something's not right here...
MrEko Fri 09:25

go on eloise
Fri 09:25

whats not rite?
Eloise Fri 09:26

MiB visited nobody...
MrEko Fri 09:26

r u sure?
Eloise Fri 09:27

Yep...
MrEko Fri 09:27

that doesnt seem possible either hes wolf and should have killed sun or hes protector and should have protected some1
Eloise Fri 09:28

RB'd?
Fri 09:28

If he's prot...
MrEko Fri 09:28

that would mean locke was a wolf bcoz maninblack must be lit but then there must still b 2 wolves left?!
Fri 09:29

we need 2 hear from maninblack
Eloise Fri 09:29

Yes, that's what I'm thinking...
MrEko Fri 09:29

(full disclosure eloise i think ur lying but im not gonna do nething hasty)
Eloise Fri 09:36

Well, if MiB didn't move and he's the protector... How else could he explain this bloodshed?
MrEko Fri 09:38

lets not giv him any ideas lol
Moderator Fri 09:42

Sayid votes to lynch Boone
Sayid Fri 09:42

Asv
Eloise Fri 09:43

Well, rn, he needs to speak up
Fri 09:43

.
Fri 09:44

Problem is, I won't be here to help today... I'll probably not vote today?
Boone Fri 09:45

Yes I lied Eko. I'm not Demonlord.
Fri 09:45

sorry to disappoint you.
Fri 09:46

I wanna hear from mib.
Moderator Fri 09:46

Boone votes to lynch ManInBlack
Eloise Fri 09:47

Hey Boone. Who are your suspects?
Fri 09:48

Aside from MiB, that is...
Sayid Fri 09:49

@mrEko what do you want to do today?
Fri 09:50

Mybe after sun i can trust you
Boone Fri 09:52

Simplest solution would be MiB, Then you and Sayid. I mentioned my suspicions about Sayid yesterday. I'd give him the DW role. Agressive, loud, shady from day 1. Trying to get me to check him, must be frustrating if the plan goes down the drain because the seer gets purged. You because I kinda trust Eko I think. New Day 6 onwards Eko that is. And he said he didn't visit, on the other hand you were right about Charlotte, which is a gamble.
Eloise Fri 09:58

Mmhm. Ok.
Fri 09:59

You must be thinking I'm defending MiB... But so were you, and sun...
Fri 10:00

You even snipe-balanced him...
ManInBlack Fri 10:01

Hello all. I fully expect to be lynched today but I have a technical question.
Fri 10:02

How can a DW still role block if there are only a DW and a BH left? BH reverts last, doesn't it?
Sayid Fri 10:03

Clap clap boone
Fri 10:03

How you are clever
Fri 10:03

:/
Fri 10:03

Wtf is this
ManInBlack Fri 10:03

By the way I was going to say gg for second guessing my second guess, because I didn't try to protect Sun. I tried to protect myself and I hadnt even noticed the role block.
Sayid Fri 10:03

You are bh
Fri 10:04

So mybe lock was dele
ManInBlack Fri 10:04

Sayid I think you are right. But how can DW still have blocked me?
Sayid Fri 10:04

Dw*
Moderator Fri 10:04

ManInBlack votes to lynch Boone
Sayid Fri 10:05

If eko vote for him also maybe we can win tomorrow
Fri 10:05

Couse all of us know that boone is wolf but we cant proof it because he is really good player
ManInBlack Fri 10:05

But how can we have a role block and a kill?
Fri 10:06

I agree about Boone by the way.
Sayid Fri 10:06

Umm
ManInBlack Fri 10:06

Have suspected him since he went ballistic on the revived Desmond.
Fri 10:07

There must be... a different wolf than BH.
Fri 10:07

BH reverts last, so DW should have reverted and didn't.
Sayid Fri 10:08

But we should carful he is good plyer he can lynch me or you or eko and thn he will win the game
Fri 10:08

Bh and dw?
Fri 10:08

I just now that we have 3villgr me and you and eko nothing
Fri 10:09

Else
ManInBlack Fri 10:09

MIB's read of me was correct. I went nowhere even though I was going to point out he lied because I should have been seen selfvisiting. But that was before I noticed roleblock.
Fri 10:10

He can still be DW because he knew I'd go nowhere if he blocked me.
Fri 10:11

But then... Of course!
Fri 10:11

Boone was BH, and got purged into a normal werewolf.
Fri 10:12

So he did the killing, and the drag queen did the blocking.
Fri 10:12
Fri 10:13

Mr Eko, I had half expected a dead wolf this morning because something about your claim has been bugging me.
Sayid Fri 10:13

It can be
Boone Fri 10:13

Wow, you two took a fast turn on me. Interesting Mib.
ManInBlack Fri 10:13

And I'd half expected Eko to be a vampire because the death count on N1 does not seem to add up.
Fri 10:14

Boone, you can hardly claim Sayid took a turn on you.
Fri 10:15

As for me: who else can be a wolf to allow the drag queen to role block me?
Boone Fri 10:15

Boone, I think you vote me because it prevents you from getting lynched :/ You did this yesterday on all people. You jumped the train that was going the fastest
Fri 10:15

eh Mib
ManInBlack Fri 10:16

I know you are going to say it's me, Boone. BUT.
Boone Fri 10:16

So you see Sayid voting me, and you jump on it
Fri 10:16

I didn't. I gave a full assumption.
Fri 10:16

I didn't jump any train.
ManInBlack Fri 10:16

It will all come down to Mr Eko. Boone and I are in your hands.
Boone Fri 10:17

But Sayid votes me because he always does it and you jump on it. because it gives me 2 votes and you 1.
ManInBlack Fri 10:17

Exactly.
Boone Fri 10:17

So you admit being evil?
Sayid Fri 10:17

He want to save his life boone! Like you
ManInBlack Fri 10:17

No.
Fri 10:17

(To Boone)
Eloise Fri 10:18

Well, hmm... Both MiB and Boone attacking me indirectly...
Boone Fri 10:18

Because you don't seem to care much that we lynch evil. You only care that you don't have the most votes.
Fri 10:18

I saved you ffs. and now you vote me.
Fri 10:18

it makes no sense if you're village.
ManInBlack Fri 10:19

I must say I am VERY impressed by your play. The wolf chat must have been deafening that night that you snipe-saved me.
Boone Fri 10:19

I saved you some days ago. And today you see an opportunity to not get lynched and you jump ME
ManInBlack Fri 10:19

Locke having a right go at you. Jin was much less subtle in his defence of you.
Fri 10:19

I'd like to shake hands now and congratulate you.
Boone Fri 10:19

I see no morals in your play MiB.
Fri 10:20

You only play for yourself.
ManInBlack Fri 10:20

But MrEko will be the referee of it all.
Boone Fri 10:20

Not for this village.
ManInBlack Fri 10:20

X
Fri 10:20

Have another ugly gay kiss.
Fri 10:20

You are quite handsome after all.
Boone Fri 10:21

Yesterday it was eloise, today it's me. You vote who has the most votes besides you.
Fri 10:22

You play like an opportunist. And you know who are opportunists? Evils are.
ManInBlack Fri 10:23

Who did MrEko say he shot N1? It may have been our seer...
Boone Fri 10:23

See you make more stuff up.
Fri 10:23

You just make stuff up all the time.
Fri 10:23

You're lying non stop.
Fri 10:24

He said he shot ethan who claimed MESSIAH
Fri 10:24

it has been said 30 times by now.
Eloise Fri 10:24

Hmm... Boone seems to have more class... While MiB is brash...
Sayid Fri 10:24

If you are seer so who is bh!?
Eloise Fri 10:24

That rhymes eh?
Boone Fri 10:24

How should I know?
Fri 10:25

Is there even one?
ManInBlack Fri 10:25

i think you do.
Sayid Fri 10:25

Real seer would never say his role in day one
Boone Fri 10:25

It was day 2. And give 190 a read.
Sayid Fri 10:25

And if he said youll gonna kill him and shapeshift
Boone Fri 10:25

Read 190 and come back.
Sayid Fri 10:25

The seer imean
Boone Fri 10:25

I mean it sayid.
ManInBlack Fri 10:25

Sayid, I disagree about seers not coming out but for the rest I think you're right.
Eloise Fri 10:26

Guys. Let's talk about style...
Sayid Fri 10:26

You mean i am bh?boone ????
Fri 10:26

Hahahaha
Boone Fri 10:26

Tldr: Seer came out Day 1 190, it was a stomp.
ManInBlack Fri 10:26

I have considered this throughout the game and never protected Boone.
Boone Fri 10:26

No I said you're wrong about early seer claims.
Fri 10:27

ext-190 is an example.
ManInBlack Fri 10:27

I find it interesting to see Boone's aggression levels skyrocket when he feels in a tight spot. Like when Desmond got revived.
Boone Fri 10:27

Which shows that Day 1 seer claim is even a thing.
ManInBlack Fri 10:28

She died though.
Fri 10:28

You didn't
Boone Fri 10:28

I got purged. Why kill me.
ManInBlack Fri 10:28

Because you're now a werewolf.
Fri 10:28

Purged BH.
Eloise Fri 10:29

See, this style of play by MiB... Too mobby...
Sayid Fri 10:29

Maybe he wasnt really purge
ManInBlack Fri 10:29

Everybody has been considering the possibility and even Jin acknowledged it.
Sayid Fri 10:29

...
Boone Fri 10:29

MiB you've made up a 100 thoeries by now. 99 were already proven false.
Eloise Fri 10:29

I wanted you lynched since forever... But I resisted coz I thought it was too mobby...
Fri 10:30

Mobby = MiB
Sayid Fri 10:30

I wanna eat brkfst by for now
ManInBlack Fri 10:30

I'd still like to know what Ben was...
Sayid Fri 10:30

Dont use the time when im not here to lynch me :D
Boone Fri 10:30

Sayid, if you vote me because you think day 2 seer claim is dumb and nobody would do that. I can give you tons of examples.
ManInBlack Fri 10:31

You won't be lynched Sayid. This is between Boone and me.
Boone Fri 10:31

You're pandering so hard to sayid. It's a joke.
Fri 10:31

How can sayid not see that -_-
ManInBlack Fri 10:31

Fact is there are two wolves left.
Sayid Fri 10:31

Boone open ur eyes i wrote asv
Boone Fri 10:32

MiB is pandering to every person with their own theory
Sayid Fri 10:32

Bye
Eloise Fri 10:32

Maybe I'll give Boone some leverage...
Moderator Fri 10:32

Eloise votes to lynch ManInBlack
Boone Fri 10:32

To Eko: I protected you N something
Sayid Fri 10:32

Let me to eat my brkfst
Boone Fri 10:32

To Sayid: I protect you from evil Boone
Fri 10:33

This all started yesterday when shit was getting real.
Eloise Fri 10:34

MiB too mobby and too wolfy...
Fri 10:34

Me go to some place me go now for now now
Fri 10:36

I will honor Sun by lynching MiB... I think he's not roleblocked at all... Why? I dunno, just a feeling... Coz it's very cool to use feelings in a game of deduction...
Fri 10:37

Guys, if you simply open your eyes, you will see, MiB is wolf...
Boone Fri 10:38

May I present some facts to everyone! (look this is the difference I'm not pandering. I don't need to, because I have a coherent story backed up by tons of facts):
Fri 10:38

1) I got 2 hits with my first 2 claims, both were confirmed by sun who's dead now
Fri 10:38

2) There was no counter claim by any living person
Fri 10:39

3) The counterclaim by libby in the grave was proven BS by Penelope being Coven, and Libby claimed Penelope is village
Fri 10:39

4) There was no Seer dug up the whole game.
Fri 10:40

5) There were two shamans dug up wich basically confirms my an alchemist in play.
Fri 10:41

6) As wrong as this may sound today, I saved MiB, because I was not sure which Prot was the real one. I got caught by her pandering "I'll protect you if you save me Boone"
Fri 10:43

7) MiB said yesterday that she mostly trusts me because I saved him/her. I assume this was also pandering because today everything is different and "she never trusted me". Why she didn't voice it earlier? She needed my vote.
Fri 10:45

8) She came up with a protect on EKO yesterday, something she didn't mention before, I assume this was to get Eko's vote too. It's a bit odd she wouldn't mention this before. I mean there was no reason not to tell that days ago.
Fri 10:47

9) She made up several theories yesterday to get Locke lynched, switching stories non stop. As soon as stuff was disproved by logic she paddled back to "being tired of the game".
Fri 10:48

10) Referencing to 9) she basically threw Stuff against a wall until it sticks the whole day.
Fri 10:49

11) She pandered to Sayid yesterday by promising him protection from me, while she said on the same day she trusts me.
Fri 10:52

12) Sun is dead, MiB claims protector.
Eloise Fri 10:54

Uggghh. Why did I change my vote???!
Fri 10:54

Yesterday.
Fri 10:54

Cake + Tz = bad decisions
Boone Fri 10:54

you messed up my List
Fri 10:55

13) Thu 20:15 Yes, and if I die, you were right, and the villagers can lynch MiB
Fri 10:55

Maybe the sun shine up upon your grave Sun :(
Fri 10:55

*May
Eloise Fri 10:56

Are you done?
Boone Fri 10:56

Final word of this 13.5 point list: All this stuff can be verified ingame in chat. No theories, no speculation. Just facts. Thanks.
Eloise Fri 10:59

Too bad logic doesn't work against mob mentality...
Boone Fri 11:01

Fuck I forgot a point.
Fri 11:01

It's the most crucial one I think...
Fri 11:05

Here it comes: It's maths crazy stuff: IF Locke was wolf and MiB got roleblocked this would mean there were 3 wolves yesterday, while the vote on locke passed with 5:1 or something. This would mean Wolves lynched their own wolf with 1 lynch/kill to go until parity.
Fri 11:06

Have fun disproving that one MiB.
Sayid Fri 11:27

Eko
Fri 11:27

Wr are you
MrEko Fri 11:41

im here bby dnt u worry
Fri 11:41

i just finished reading bk
Fri 11:42

i said 2 myself this morning that if maninblack claimed roleblock 2day i was gonna vote 4 him and so
Moderator Fri 11:42

MrEko votes to lynch ManInBlack
MrEko Fri 11:43

also i think him saying he tried 2 double bluff the wolves was stupid they would obviously try and kill sun bcoz no matter what result she got from locke it would clear up who is lit n who isnt
Fri 11:44

i still dnt trust eloise bcoz i no i didnt visit boone but rite now hes looking a bit more lit than this morning
Sayid Fri 11:48

Oooo eko do you think mib is a wolf????
Fri 12:15

And what do you think about boone?
ManInBlack Fri 12:38

Well at least it will end tonight - unless there is a vampire left, who will kill Boone or the drag queen, and then Sayid will have to choose between losing to a wolf and losing to the vamp. I will be proved legit. The one thing
Fri 12:39

that I still can't work out
Fri 12:39

is the dead count on N1.
Fri 12:40

Might it have been militia + wolf after all?
Fri 12:41

Then Charlie must have lied about not recruiting.
Fri 12:42

Unless that story was true that Juliet was a vamp he targeted but couldn't touch.
Fri 12:44

What did Juliet ever say?
Sayid Fri 12:44

Maybe eko gonna change hid vote
Fri 12:44

Boon and eloise are in on team mybe
Fri 12:44

His*
Fri 12:45

Eko pls opn your eyes and think about what are you doing if you are villgr we should kill one of the wolfves
Fri 12:45

Wolves
Fri 12:45

Lynch*
Fri 12:46

Its our last chance
Fri 12:46

If we can lynch one of the wolves we’ll win the game
Fri 12:46

Couse we are 3villgt
Fri 12:46

R
Fri 12:46

Me you and mybe mib
Fri 12:46

Im just shur eko and me are villgr
Fri 12:47

Sure*
ManInBlack Fri 12:47

Of course El and Boone are a team, Sayid. It's obvious from the teamwork between MIBloise and Locke, and from the way Jin kept defending Boone on D2/3.
Fri 12:48

But I'm pleased it's almost over - I don't think I can do another day like this.
Fri 12:49

At least I got Locke out even if we failed to heed your words earlier.
Boone Fri 12:50

@Sayid I want to quote myself "IF Locke was wolf and MiB got roleblocked this would mean there were 3 wolves yesterday, while the vote on locke passed with 5:1 or something. This would mean Wolves lynched their own wolf with 1 lynch/kill to go until parity."
ManInBlack Fri 12:50

And I look forwards to congratulating them on VERY clever play, especially Boone. No hard feelings here, in spite of the RP lingo.
Fri 12:51

Signing off now. I hope to see you all at midnight.
MrEko Fri 13:49

boone in ur opinion r there 1 or 2 wolves left
Boone Fri 14:14

I think Locke was a misslynch. So I have to assume 2.
MrEko Fri 14:16

do u think maninblack and eloise could both be wolves?
Boone Fri 14:17

There are 2 scenarios
Fri 14:17

1) Based on the current votes Sayid and MiB, since MiB always gets very upset when I say something about Sayid.
Fri 14:20

2) MiB and Eloise and the Stalk was some kind of try to prove the RB claim. And Eloise ditched her after my listing... Or Eloise will have some revelation later.
MrEko Fri 14:23

so from my pov im kinda certain that eloise is lying bcoz i dnt think i was redirected by a succubus so shes most probs lying about me visiting u and in ur scenarios maninblack is always evil so then i think it must be scenario 2
Boone Fri 14:28

If it's Scenario 2 we need Sayid to vote right.
Fri 14:29

I just can't trust Sayid.
Fri 14:29

He seems 100% undisturbed by any info or facts.
Fri 14:31

I explain how shamans work... "ok" I'm still BH, there are two Shamans dug up, I'm still BH, I explain day 1/2 Seer reveals are quite common. Still BH.
Fri 14:32

If Sayid is innocent MiB is exploiting it very hard.
Fri 14:35

Still here?
MrEko Fri 14:55

yes sry a bit busy 2 day
Boone Fri 14:56

Mee too.
Fri 14:56

Friday always stuff to finish :/
MrEko Fri 14:57

im thinking eloise was 2 easily swayed in2 voting locke yesterday locke and eloise both were very anti-maninblack but then eloise asked who 2 vote 4 and just accepted sun saying locke with no qualms
Fri 14:58

but idk its hard bcoz i believed in maninblack 4 so many days i just cant accept i might have been played
Boone Fri 14:59

I saved MiB, but I found yesterday sketchy, and today is just super obvious.
MrEko Fri 14:59

but u said this morning what i was thinking yesterday that the "save" on me seemed like ??ing and made me more sus of him bcoz i dnt think i was a logical target that night
Boone Fri 15:00

As I said at the start of the day. Mib is very opportunistic the last 2-3 days.
Fri 15:00

Check out yesterday. Theories all over the place.
Fri 15:01

She already voted me the day Desmond showed up.
MrEko Fri 15:01

but then how is maninblack a whichcraft user?
Boone Fri 15:01

This was the day after I saved her.
Fri 15:03

I don't know. I didn't save Eloise that day because I was sure in Locke. But I think she got shadier day for day.
Fri 15:04

SS maybe?
MrEko Fri 15:09

i never noticed a change in typing and her attitude seemed pretty consistent 2
Boone Fri 15:09

No I mean that she's SS
Fri 15:09

not shifted.
ManInBlack Fri 15:10

Just back for a moment to comment on the number of kills early days.
Boone Fri 15:10

MiB you still haven't answered my math question.
MrEko Fri 15:10

u think hed have stayed in that ugly face 4 so long if he was ss?
Boone Fri 15:11

@Eko are there any shift targets around?
ManInBlack Fri 15:11

Which question?
Boone Fri 15:11

I don't think so.
ManInBlack Fri 15:11

Oh, the 5-1?
Boone Fri 15:11

"IF Locke was wolf and MiB got roleblocked this would mean there were 3 wolves yesterday, while the vote on locke passed with 5:1 or something. This would mean Wolves lynched their own wolf with 1 lynch/kill to go until parity."
ManInBlack Fri 15:11

Easy.
MrEko Fri 15:11

boone idk sun mite have been a good shift target
ManInBlack Fri 15:12

Sacrifice one of 3 wolves to incriminate me. I get lynched and there's parity.
Boone Fri 15:12

That's some weird plan if you just need to get to the night.
MrEko Fri 15:12

y not just push a mislynch and get parity last nite???
ManInBlack Fri 15:12

Easier than convincing Sun AND Eko AND Sayid to vote me.
Boone Fri 15:13

You can just last minute balance.
ManInBlack Fri 15:13

.
Fri 15:13

?
Boone Fri 15:13

a balance would have been enough.
ManInBlack Fri 15:13

Who? How?
Boone Fri 15:14

it was 7. If you get to the night, 1 kill = win.
MrEko Fri 15:14

if there were 3 wolves yesterday they would have 2 b locke eloise and sayid i think
ManInBlack Fri 15:15

Boone, that's true.
MrEko Fri 15:16

they couldnt push 2 lynch sun without looking sus and we seem 2 not like lynching boone so that would mean theyd have 2 lynch me or maninblack and that is kinda what locke pushed 4
ManInBlack Fri 15:17

So you think Boone is innocent? And Sayid is DW?
MrEko Fri 15:17

but i dont think sayid could b wolf bcoz the kills dont add up if he isnt militia
Boone Fri 15:17

I'm just baffled where the trust in Sayid comes from. Every time I mention him you go ballistic.
Fri 15:17

Witch kill?
ManInBlack Fri 15:18

I wasn't sure about Boone until I saw the role block. And I could still be wrong.
MrEko Fri 15:18

boone witch kill on walt-now-juliet the shaman???
ManInBlack Fri 15:18

I know for sure Eloise is wolf because of the lies and the support for Locke.
Boone Fri 15:19

True Eko. One of the supposed alphas? 2 Alphas?
MrEko Fri 15:19

idk i never never never ever trusted boone but i cant make a case against him lol
Boone Fri 15:19

you never trust me ever. True
MrEko Fri 15:20

i think if he was a wolf the game would b done already
Boone Fri 15:20

#43
ManInBlack Fri 15:20

The role block is an indication that another wolf (not BH) is in the game.
MrEko Fri 15:21

y not bloodhound?
ManInBlack Fri 15:21

BH reverts after DW?
Fri 15:22

DW hasn't reverted.
MrEko Fri 15:22

no?
Boone Fri 15:22

DW is last.
MrEko Fri 15:22

bloodhound then bloodletter then direwolf
Boone Fri 15:22

its BL -> BH -> DW
Fri 15:22

w8
Fri 15:22

is it BH first?
ManInBlack Fri 15:22

Oh shit...
Boone Fri 15:22

u sure?
Fri 15:23

I thought it was "strength" ordered
MrEko Fri 15:23

If there are no killing wolves left in the Wolfpack, the Bloodletter will become a normal Werewolf; the Bloodletter will revert before a Direwolf would revert, but after a Bloodhound would.
ManInBlack Fri 15:23

You are right, I just checked h2p.
Fri 15:24

We could have predicted what would happen last night...
Fri 15:25

And I did question the safety of not lynching MIBloise.
Fri 15:25

I said to Sun we MUST lynch her.
MrEko Fri 15:25

i asked multiple ppl and every1 said they thought there were only 2 wolves left
ManInBlack Fri 15:25

I said 3.
Fri 15:26

We never found a trace of a wolf outside Jin.
Fri 15:26

Wolf pack should have 4 with this size and setup.
Boone Fri 15:27

I think you slipped. The math just doesn't check out.
Fri 15:27

And you came with a very very clear theory today.
ManInBlack Fri 15:27

You mean the 5-2?
Boone Fri 15:27

yes.
Fri 15:28

You had the plan to claim RB, go for me, exploit Sayid.
Fri 15:28

Because you knew you were in trouble if Sun dies.
Fri 15:28

Sun even told us to lynch you if she dies.
ManInBlack Fri 15:28

I accept that it would look that way.
Fri 15:30

But it's funny how you steered towards a solution of Locke vs MIB when I claimed the drag queen was a DW and needed to die first.
Fri 15:31

And you can't deny that she has been lying to frame MrEko.
Boone Fri 15:31

I don't trust Eko. I can't read him. It's mutual.
ManInBlack Fri 15:32

And you tried to have me believe tha Sayid was wolf. So two distractions from lynching MIBloise.
Boone Fri 15:32

W8, you say me being suspicious of Sayid is a distraction?
Fri 15:32

Have you read his stuff?
ManInBlack Fri 15:33

I have, and it is aggressive.
Boone Fri 15:33

It's fking BS.
ManInBlack Fri 15:33

I'm saying it was a distraction from lynching MIBloise.
Fri 15:33

OK so let's consider Eko.
Fri 15:34

Can he be vamp?
Boone Fri 15:34

But MiB then we're in the same corner again. 3 wolves yesterday. How.
Fri 15:34

He's smart enough. Yes.
ManInBlack Fri 15:34

No wolf carcass was found beside Jin.
MrEko Fri 15:34

i can only b vampire if locke was protector
ManInBlack Fri 15:35

But Eko...
Boone Fri 15:35

Look I think Eko can be anything. But I've accepted that a long time ago.
MrEko Fri 15:35

or if eloise is lying
ManInBlack Fri 15:35

Locke protect you?!
MrEko Fri 15:35

bcoz otherwise boone would b dead rite?
Boone Fri 15:35

maybe I am vamp.
Fri 15:36

ha ha
ManInBlack Fri 15:36

I don't think so.
Boone Fri 15:36

I asked Eko if he's vamp.
Fri 15:36

He kinda declined.
MrEko Fri 15:36

1st demonlord now vampire
Fri 15:36

ur so inconsistent boone
Boone Fri 15:36

Well no masons around to recruit a Demonlord
ManInBlack Fri 15:37

Because, explain 2 deaths N1?
Boone Fri 15:37

But that's a ghost of the past.
MrEko Fri 15:37

triggered
ManInBlack Fri 15:38

So if MIBloise was not lying...
Fri 15:38

I was visited by Jin N2.
Fri 15:39

And I self-protected, so...
Fri 15:39

How were there two deaths?
Fri 15:40

There must have been two vampires.
Fri 15:40

Which fits.
Fri 15:41

But then Locke WAS Protector as well so we had two vamps, two protectors...
Fri 15:41
Boone Fri 15:41

Or you are lying :)
ManInBlack Fri 15:41

Now, if MIBloise is wolf and false claims stalker...
Fri 15:42

He will have used as many facts as possible.
Fri 15:42

So Jin would still have visited me.
Fri 15:42

So we still have 2 vamps.
Boone Fri 15:43

was Jin ever dug up?
ManInBlack Fri 15:43

It is likely he tried to frame Eko because he knew wolves had failed to kill him one night.
Fri 15:44

So if Eko is lit, who could have been the vamp 2?
Fri 15:44

I can only guess Juliet.
Fri 15:44

But Eko could still be vamp.
Boone Fri 15:45

Could sayid be fam, who got me as mark?
ManInBlack Fri 15:45

I can't think why not.
Fri 15:45

Except...
Boone Fri 15:45

I mean he's sooooo presistent
ManInBlack Fri 15:46

If Charlie recruited N1, oh yes.
Boone Fri 15:46

or 2
ManInBlack Fri 15:47

I think Sayid 's aggression started on D2.
Fri 15:47

After your Seer claim.
Fri 15:48

The death count is then explained without a 2nd vamp.
Fri 15:48

But MIBloise is still lying about his stalks.
Fri 15:49

Because without 2 vamps Jin CANT have visited me.
Fri 15:49

And Eko claimed he didn't visit you.
Fri 15:51

So because MIB-El is lying I am assuming he is a wolf.
Fri 15:52

He can't be coven because there hasn't bee n coven activity.
Fri 15:52

And he seems to have used inside info on Jin.
Fri 15:53

So then we still need 2 vamps.
Fri 15:53

I can only think #2 must have been Juliet.
Fri 15:54

As Charlie hinted before we lynched him.
Boone Fri 15:54

If Eko isn't lying, Charlie must have recruited right?
Fri 15:54

Well not must, but 2 kills with a militia kills and wolves around?
ManInBlack Fri 15:55

Yes. OR failed to kill.
Fri 15:55

Because he targeted another vamp.
Fri 15:55

It also explains Richard and Libby's deaths.
Fri 15:56

No alpha kill but wolf + vamp.
Boone Fri 15:56

Or charlie killed and wolves killed and Eko is lying?
ManInBlack Fri 15:56

Yes, possibly.
Fri 15:57

I protected him twice now so I'd feel quite awkward in postgame chat....
Boone Fri 15:58

Meh this is so meta kinda...
Fri 15:58

I got a theory but I'll keep it for myself.
ManInBlack Fri 15:58

Not meta?
Boone Fri 15:58

Too meta.
ManInBlack Fri 15:58

I think we had two vamps.
Fri 15:59

Juliet was #2.
Boone Fri 15:59

Smite juliet?
Fri 15:59

or which one?
ManInBlack Fri 16:00

The one shifted into Walt, yes... oh.
Fri 16:00

Makes little sense.
Fri 16:01

Then the second vamp is still alive or a recruit might be around.
Fri 16:01

And I think only Eko or Sayid can be in that position.
Fri 16:02

Which confirms your idea of Sayid.
Fri 16:04

For me, if you are not wolf it must be Sayid as well; BH angry at his chance of claiming Seer taken away two hrs into D2.
Fri 16:05

But MIBloise is definitely wolf given his lies about his stalks.
Fri 16:06

I have launched quite a few theories that have been proved wrong this game...
Fri 16:06

But I haven't lied about anything I've actually done or omitted.
Fri 16:09

Maybe wolves have more info and know there is a vamp for certain. And that is why they didn't go for parity by balancing ? I don't know... It sounds unlikely.
Fri 16:11

Your maths question is bugging me. But I also think wolves hadn't expected me to hold out for so long, and they hadn't considered that scenario.
Fri 16:12

Anyway, if I'm a wolf, I can only be SS, correct?
Fri 16:13

WC user according to Hurley, who wasn't exactly on my side.
Fri 16:14

So how does that fit?
Fri 16:14

Because I think Ben may have... Ah, no.
Fri 16:15

If there were two vamps Ben could have died a vampire victim.
Fri 16:17

Or puppet, given Charlotte could not be trusted.
Fri 16:18

Anyway, how can I be wolf, WC user and still not shifted?
Fri 16:19

It's not like I have not been in a tight spot for the last 4 days or so.
Fri 16:21
Fri 16:21

Boone, are you still there?
Moderator Fri 16:26

ManInBlack votes to lynch Eloise
ManInBlack Fri 16:28

The only way he is lit is if Eko is a vampire AND we had two protectors this game.
Fri 16:29

Which makes Boone and Sayid wolf team mates. Go figure.
Fri 16:30

Because I did get blocked, so there must be two wolves left.
Fri 16:31

*performs quick sanity check*
Fri 16:33

Role blocked can only mean DW, correct?
Fri 16:34

It was actually confirmed by Eloise.
Fri 16:34

How would that drag queen know?
Fri 16:36

Eloise confirmed I didn't move last night. I didn't kill Sun.
Fri 16:39

Yet his vote is on me.
Fri 16:39

MrEko, what do you make of that?
MrEko Fri 17:14

sry i havent read it yet im still rly busy but i will read it soon i promise
Fri 17:15

maninblack i rly want 2 believe u i rly do but theres so much evidence against u im not sure i can trust nething u say
Fri 17:15

but i will read it neway just in case
Fri 17:19

ok i read and here is what i think ...
Fri 17:22

if maninblack is a wolf he cant b the killing wolf unless eloise is lying bcoz eloise would have seen him visit so then no matter who we believe there r still 2 wolves left unless there is 1 wolf (maninblack) and 1 vampire and maninblack didnt kill last night 2 look lit but then the vamp killed instead but i dnt think vamp would not kill but boone thinks they mite so idk
Fri 17:24

neway if there r 2 wolves left then i think eloise is 1 bcoz she said i visited boone wen i dont think i can have but then were bk 2 boones question about numbs
Fri 17:26

but mb the other wolves cldnt risk poss balancing if the other 4 villagers couldnt b persuaded 2 nt vote locke
Fri 17:27

if thats the case it makes me sus boone even more than i did b4 bcoz he suggested balance n wolves would have won if wed balanced
Fri 17:29

maninblack i rly rly rly dnt like that u didnt even try 2 protect sun
Fri 17:30

its sketchy as f*ck
Fri 17:31

i have bearly registered a word sayid has said but im currently believing hes militia unless he was shifted but i dnt think thats likely
Fri 17:31

eloise i do not trust
Fri 17:32

boone i do not trust but i will not vote 2 lynch him 2day bcoz like our bants
Moderator Fri 17:32

MrEko votes to lynch Eloise
MrEko Fri 17:33

i believe like this sayid gets the deciding vote lol it will b interesting 2 see how he votes
Fri 17:36

rite now i believe there r 2 wolves either maninblack and eloise or boone and eloise i would like it 2 b the former pair but idk
Fri 17:39

i wonder if its poss that both locke and maninblack are wolves that seems rly unlikely 2 me
Fri 17:39

im kinda just thinking out loud now guys lol sry if its annoying
Fri 17:45

there r 2 wolves left whoever we believe so ne1 who suggests balance 2day is super sus we have to lynch and we have 2 lynch rite
Sayid Fri 18:44

Hey eko are you there
Moderator Fri 18:47

Sayid votes to lynch Eloise
Sayid Fri 18:47

I will follow you eko
Fri 18:51

I think boone and eloise are in one team, cuz thy voted for mib, so i know boone is wolf and boone wants to lynch mib so ill vote for eloise
Fri 18:52

If boone is wolfe so eloise is wolf also thy work together
Fri 18:53

Boone if im wrong about you im so sorry
Fri 18:53

But i really think you are wolf
Fri 18:54

Cuz i playd with wolves and you act like then
Fri 18:54

Them*
Moderator Fri 20:59

It will soon be night...
Sayid Fri 21:00

.....
Lynched Fri 21:00

Eloise was lynched by the village
Moderator Sat 09:00

Only a single star remains in the sky...

Your role: Observer

The Village

Graveyard

Spoiler free day archives