ext-192 Day 2 | Werewolf Mafia Game Online for your Browser

Replay

You are viewing day 2 of a game of werewolv.es started on the 17-Nov-23 Thu on a 24 hour cycle (12h day, 12h night).

This is a spoiler free version, use the user button (top menu) to see who was alive at the time, and the calendar button or links below the chat to navigate through to different days.

You can play a game of online Mafia by joining the game currently in sign up. New players are welcome, but try to be active!
Boone Fri 09:10

Good Morning
Charlie Fri 09:16

Good morning
ManInBlack Fri 09:16

Forgot to bring my memory eraser flashy thingy
Fri 09:16

Good morning
Hurley Fri 09:19

Boone, Charlie and ManInBlack are confirmed Bloodhounds
Jin Fri 09:19

Can I join the Bloodhound Gang?
Fri 09:19

Good morning
Fri 09:19

https://media.giphy.com/media/e0dU1Hy8pbGO4/giphy.gif
Moderator Fri 09:20

Hurley votes to lynch Jin
Jin Fri 09:20

sorry, it was too good an opportunity to pass up =)
Hurley Fri 09:20

You scared me
ManInBlack Fri 09:22

I was seriously looking for a "like" button... XD
Moderator Fri 09:22

Ben votes to lynch Desmond
Ben Fri 09:22

asv
Moderator Fri 09:23

ManInBlack votes to lynch Charlie
ManInBlack Fri 09:23

Is that Charlie puth?
Fri 09:25

So, 2 deaths for 2 GD's...
Locke Fri 09:29

Morning people! I missed day one, sadly...
Fri 09:29

Wow... why does my avatar look like a psycho killer
Fri 09:29

2 deaths huh?
Fri 09:30

Well, we all know what are the possibilities, no point in listing them all again
ManInBlack Fri 09:51

Well, there are weird possibilities. Weird and unlikely possibilities.
Locke Fri 09:54

Yes, but sometimes, even the unlikeliest of possibilities prove to be true
Moderator Fri 09:58

Sayid votes to lynch Naomi
Sayid Fri 09:58

Asv
Boone Fri 10:21

OK let's keep this thing going. No time for asv, fking 4 way game.
Fri 10:21

hmm
Fri 10:21

I'll ask like this, has anyone found a wolf or vampire, speak up. If you saw anything suspicious.
Fri 10:22

I'll check back at 11 and move stuff forward if nobody speaks up.
Jin Fri 10:33

Let's kill Ben
Moderator Fri 10:33

Jin votes to lynch Ben
Boone Fri 10:33

Reasons?
Jin Fri 10:33

Ben Fri 09:22 asv
Fri 10:33

Let's go for it
Moderator Fri 10:37

Charlie votes to lynch Ben
Charlie Fri 10:37

Down with the ASVs!!!!
Fri 10:38

asv isn't even needed day 2, he's clearly just being smug
Fri 10:41

Where the hell did my other message go?
Fri 10:41

*ASV isn't even needed on day 2, he's clearly just being smug
Moderator Fri 10:42

Sun votes to lynch ManInBlack
Sun Fri 10:42

Definitely not asv.
Jin Fri 10:43

Way to go, we're now going to evolve the meta by having people say 'not ASV' when they cast an 'ASV vote' xD
Sun Fri 10:43

It's a proper, honest vote.
Fri 10:43

I can tell.
Fri 10:43

Somehow.
Boone Fri 10:44

Can we stop fighting the meta by using more meta to change the meta?
Sun Fri 10:44

Can we?
Jin Fri 10:44

I lost you there, Boone
Fri 10:44

but okay, lets just act and not reflect on the meta too much
Moderator Fri 10:44

MrEko votes to lynch Jack
MrEko Fri 10:45

asv
Boone Fri 10:45

Ok I'll skip 15 minutes
Fri 10:45

NO EKO you DONT
Sun Fri 10:45

Without any info roles coming out though, there's not much to do other than asv.
Boone Fri 10:45

you're a good boy now and vote walt OK?
Fri 10:46

He's coven. I wanted to wait a bit in case anyone found something more lynch worthy like a Wolf or Vamp.
Moderator Fri 10:46

Boone votes to lynch Walt
Jin Fri 10:47

stuff is escalating
Fri 10:47

Boone, this might be obvious but I take it you're claiming Seer?
Boone Fri 10:48

yes.
Sun Fri 10:48

Hmm
Fri 10:48

I don't know whether to trust you or not...
Jin Fri 10:48

Well, there is an info role coming out now, Sun
Moderator Fri 10:49

Jin votes to lynch Walt
Jin Fri 10:49

I'll roll with it for now and see who contests it =)
Fri 10:49

(Sun, as my wife you should totally follow my lead and vote Walt #feminism)
Sun Fri 10:49

I'll wait to see, bandwagoning kills.
Boone Fri 10:50

Want to ask me for my other checks? XD
Sun Fri 10:51

(Jin, as my husband, you should do what I say. #matriarchy)
Fri 10:51

But...you won't have any other checks yet.
Boone Fri 10:51

that's why there's a "XD" afterwards..
Sun Fri 10:51

What are your other checks Boone!!! Tell me now!
Fri 10:52

Not fast enough - evil confirmed.
Boone Fri 10:52

Night 0 I checked Mod, he's a troll.
Sun Fri 10:52

Oooh
Fri 10:52

Interesting...
Boone Fri 10:52

not in the h2p yet.
Sun Fri 10:52

Sun votes to put Moderator on trial
Jin Fri 10:52

Sun = Nietzsche
Sawyer Fri 10:59

I agree about not asving in a 4 ways game
Boone Fri 11:00

Eko didn't change his vote...
Fri 11:00

*annoyed*
Moderator Fri 11:00

Sawyer votes to lynch MrEko
Sawyer Fri 11:01

do we want to pressure Walt? I can vote him
Boone Fri 11:01

I don't wanna pressure him. I actually wanna lynch him. May sound cruel but...
Fri 11:02

There's no role in the game that can falsely give you a coven check.
Sun Fri 11:03

You've convinced me, Boone.
Moderator Fri 11:03

Sun votes to lynch Walt
Moderator Fri 11:07

ManInBlack votes to lynch Walt
ManInBlack Fri 11:07

Let's make it harpy-proof then. :)
Fri 11:08

Oh wait... :/
Hurley Fri 11:10

So what are you Boone? BH or puppet?
Fri 11:10

Or are you an SS?
Boone Fri 11:11

Odd way to start a conversation.
Fri 11:11

Your way of asking indicates that you're not agreeing with Walt being coven?
Hurley Fri 11:12

Hmm, no, it doesn't
Boone Fri 11:12

If so, can you please elaborate your role and why you're disagreeing?
Libby Fri 11:12

checking in to asv
Boone Fri 11:12

nope libby
Fri 11:12

NOPE NOPE NOPE
Moderator Fri 11:12

Libby votes to lynch Richard
Boone Fri 11:12

You didn't got the memo?
Libby Fri 11:13

back later to catch up properly
Hurley Fri 11:13

ok :)
Boone Fri 11:13

this is frustrating already and we've just started this round.
Fri 11:13

Hurley? Still waiting for your input.
Hurley Fri 11:14

Why I disagree? A feeling
Fri 11:14

Maybe it's nothing, let's see what happens when Walt shows
Fri 11:14

up
ManInBlack Fri 11:14

There should be another seer (or real seer) roaming around with a check... We should make that our vice-lynch, (in case of shroud).
Boone Fri 11:15

Should there Mib? WHY?
Hurley Fri 11:15

If there's another seer, they should speak up today
Fri 11:16

MiB is very focused on the Harpy imho
ManInBlack Fri 11:16

Right now, idc whether Boone is BH or seer... But a coven check is consistent with both... And protection has no choice but to believe Boone (for now)
Jin Fri 11:16

Hurley, I don't understand you at all. Your first point made against Boone is that you're suspecting them of being BH. Now Boone is coming out as Seer, which still fits the story. You make a statement about how Boone is probably all some sort of wolf (you also mention Puppet), and defending Walt based on some feeling. The thing is, you pose no real counter-argument to Boone's check.
Boone Fri 11:16

maybe a trauma.
Jin Fri 11:16

Boone is Seer --> finds Coven --> lynch Coven
Fri 11:17

Boone is BH --> finds Coven --> lynch Coven
Fri 11:17

we'll sort out Boone in time
Boone Fri 11:17

I waited 2 hours in case any wolf/vampire lynch opportunity shows up.
ManInBlack Fri 11:17

^
Hurley Fri 11:17

Well, if he's BH, I'd prefer lynching Boone today .....
Boone Fri 11:17

wtf
Fri 11:18

your mentality triggers me slightly.
Fri 11:18

just slightly..
Sun Fri 11:18

But how could we tell if he's BH rn anyway?
Jin Fri 11:18

^^^^
Fri 11:18

Riddle us that
ManInBlack Fri 11:18

Hurley is 77% coven imo.
Boone Fri 11:18

77%? You serious? *facepalm*
Fri 11:19

why 77% ... don't answer.
ManInBlack Fri 11:19

Probably puppet, with this aggressiveness.
Boone Fri 11:19

I want to know if there's some odd claim behind Hurley's "feelings"
Jin Fri 11:19

99.9999999992138192% coven for me, and that's just because I only have a limited amount of decimal places accuracy
Sun Fri 11:19

If a gd digs walt as non-coven, we can lynch boone.
Fri 11:19

But I'm gonna trust him for now.
Boone Fri 11:20

On the other hand he listed like ALL evil options. Which makes me think he has no actual info.
Hurley Fri 11:20

Sorry, I'm derailing you, go ahead, I'll be back when Walt shows up
ManInBlack Fri 11:20

We won't dig Walt if shroud happens... I suggest Hurley as the vice-lynch... Who's with me?
Hurley Fri 11:20

ManInBlack, why are you sofocused on the Harpy?
Boone Fri 11:21

If Walt doesn't get lynched we can send some Militia after him.
Hurley Fri 11:21

We don't know whether it's in the game and how could coven have predicted that walt will be found?
Boone Fri 11:21

@Hurley I agree with MiB's odd obsession.
Hurley Fri 11:21

Shrouding without a reason has the disadvantage that you can't shroud the next night
Boone Fri 11:21

MiB where did the harpy touch yoU?
ManInBlack Fri 11:22

:'(
Fri 11:22

Can I use a doll place?
Fri 11:22

*please
Jin Fri 11:22

I think having secondary lynches is a safe precaution in a game with coven
Fri 11:23

we have plenty of voters to create 2 big piles of votes
Boone Fri 11:23

we can also keep it at 1 for all
Fri 11:23

should also work
Fri 11:23

would be a no lynch
Fri 11:24

or we use one of our dear "Asv"'s
Fri 11:24

right MrEko?
Hurley Fri 11:24

that'd be at least consistent
Boone Fri 11:25

I agree in general with the notion of taking precautions for a harpy, but damn MiB *hands MiB a puppet*
Charlotte Fri 11:46

Is Boone the only one providing info right now?
Hurley Fri 11:46

Yes
Jin Fri 11:47

Well, plenty of people providing info, one way or another x)
Fri 11:47

But there's only one explicit claim so far, yes
Charlotte Fri 11:48

So from what I see, Boone claims Seer, could also be BH, or maybe even puppet, but either way, Walt is looking good as a lynch unless he comes to defend himself?
Moderator Fri 11:49

Charlie votes to lynch Walt
Moderator Fri 11:49

Charlotte votes to lynch Walt
Hurley Fri 11:50

There are definitly Puppets in the game
Charlie Fri 11:50

Shroud would pretty much confirm Boone's intel whether seer or BH, so wouldn't be too bad other than if multiple militias go for him
Charlotte Fri 11:50

Something to consider, but if we lynch Walt, someone can dig and confirm right
Charlie Fri 11:51

Yup
Charlotte Fri 11:51

I don't see anything else to go on right now, I'm happy to make a start with Walt
Moderator Fri 12:02

Locke votes to lynch Walt
Sayid Fri 12:04

Hey guys! Don’t judge soon, maybe the wolves had nice ideas to lynch innocent prson
Fri 12:06

They are more celever and mysterious than what we think
Hurley Fri 12:07

I agree, we shouldn't decide too early on a lynch
Walt Fri 12:08

Ummmm helllllooooooo
Sun Fri 12:08

Hello Walt
Fri 12:09

*sharpens axe*
Walt Fri 12:09

Guys how can you just judge one person by one guy that comes the beginning of the game and tells you a list of people you cannot trust?
Sun Fri 12:10

Well, a claimed Seer found you as Coven...
Charlie Fri 12:10

Could be a good moment to state your defense with no hesitation or distraction
Walt Fri 12:10

He is claiming to be seer that im not sure of
Sun Fri 12:10

He might be a BH, but that wouldn't help your case.
Fri 12:11

If he's a coven himself, then we'll dig you and, find that out.
Walt Fri 12:12

Yeah exactly u can find out about me by grave digger but choosing him as leader for now is a mistake
Fri 12:13

I have to go again ill be back in an hour please re think your judgements
Charlie Fri 12:13

Rethink them with what new information ?
Walt Fri 12:22

And who announces themself the first day that he's seer?!
Fri 12:22

That would make him a target unless he's not afraid of being the viktom
Fri 12:32

I put my vote on jack he's a vampire and I cannot share the information how i know that cause that will make me target at night unlike someone i should be afraid of others knowing my position
Moderator Fri 12:32

Walt votes to lynch Jack
Hurley Fri 12:32

Please fill in the form: My name is ___________ . My alignment is ____________ My role is _____________
MrEko Fri 12:38

y?
Hurley Fri 12:41

Why what?
Boone Fri 12:41

Ok, that's one of the more bizarre defenses I've read so far.
Fri 12:42

@Hurley you forgot Sex _______ on that form. What you make of Walt's defense?
Hurley Fri 12:46

Feels like a puppet to me
Fri 12:47

I tend to think that he's evil, because he attacked the whole village instead of attacking you
Boone Fri 12:48

Puppets show as puppets for seer.
Locke Fri 12:48

My name is: Locke. My alignment is: Good. My role is: Troll. My sex is: really hardcore!
Fri 12:50

Also... Boone, no matter if you are a lit seer or BH, finding coven is still good imo... so, lynching walt is good imo
Fri 12:51

GDs should of course check the littnes of your intel tonight... and if there is another seer, he can confirm you.
Fri 12:51

Also, Protection will be on you tonight, so that we do not lose you if you are a seer
Sayid Fri 12:55

Maybe boone said iam seer to finde real seer
Charlie Fri 12:55

Trying to think of ways Coven could find vamp, but is there only witch potion? Doesn't seem likely one would use that so early
Fri 12:55

My vote remains
Boone Fri 12:56

Vamp would be the "find" which takes priority over a coven lynch by far. But it seems a rather lazy attempt.
Charlie Fri 12:56

May be a puppet he's hoping plays along to save him
Boone Fri 12:57

@Sayid aha? eh what? why?
Fri 13:03

Still puppets don't show up as coven.
Fri 13:03

I wouldn't reveal for a puppet -_-
Jin Fri 13:03

I've read Walt's defence and I'm totally convinced
Moderator Fri 13:03

Jin votes to lynch Jack
Walt Fri 13:06

I think vampires are more dangerous in this game than covens cause they can familiar people and make there way up
Hurley Fri 13:07

Hi Walt
Boone Fri 13:07

That is all true, but for this we need to find the vampire. And you haven't told us now how you know who the vampire is. Obviously I know you're lying but I try to see it from a more neutral vanilla standpoint.
Walt Fri 13:07

And boone you seem too sure of what your saying al the time for the first day and that makes mostly on the side that has allies at night
Fri 13:08

Hi hurley :))
Fri 13:11

Sorry if i say who i am you'll kill me tonight
Penelope Fri 13:11

Hi, I will asv temporarily now and will come back after around an hour if I can finish what I am doing now
Moderator Fri 13:11

Penelope votes to lynch Sun
Moderator Fri 13:12

Penelope votes to lynch Libby
Moderator Fri 13:12

Penelope votes to lynch Sun
Penelope Fri 13:12

and catch up with the reading
Hurley Fri 13:12

@Walt I think it's very likely that we have either a Protector or a Huntsman
Fri 13:13

so dw too much about getting killed at night if you are an important role
Fri 13:13

if you're even going to see the night ...:/
Moderator Fri 13:15

Hurley votes to lynch Jack
Boone Fri 13:15

eh?
Fri 13:16

like... don't tell me he convinced you with this?
Richard Fri 13:21

Hello sunshine!
Fri 13:23

I think Boone's reaction tends to be seer who is helping more than a puppet, puppets will usually be indifferent
Fri 13:25

Could be BH, but BH give out more important target than a coven to gain trust
Fri 13:26

So technically, 90% believing Boone
Moderator Fri 13:26

Richard votes to lynch Walt
Richard Fri 13:39

But, a BH still can catch a coven offguard to gain trust so...
Fri 13:40

Believing rate drops down to 80%
Fri 13:40

Maybe I'm just paranoid @.@
Boone Fri 13:43

Which is good in ww.es
Locke Fri 13:44

Okay... so we have these 2 arguments:
Fri 13:45

Boone claiming seer and saying Walt is coven
Fri 13:45

And Walt claiming he knows that Jack is a vamp
Fri 13:46

But, he doesn't provide any argument or claim as for how he knows who the vampire is
Boone Fri 13:46

I wouldn't consider Walt's gibberish an actual argument. There's no role, there's no reason, there's no logic.
Locke Fri 13:46

So, my trust goes to Boone
Fri 13:47

If he was a ML and tried to recruit a vamp, he would not be speaking now, he would be dead instead...
Charlie Fri 13:47

I agree with Boone, I hope those guys are joking
Boone Fri 13:47

"those guys"?
Locke Fri 13:48

If he was a stalker and stalked Jack, maybe he saw him visit one of the dead targets...
Fri 13:48

Or beholder... harlot
Fri 13:48

But the problem with his statement is... no role claimed...
Fri 13:49

@Walt, you DO NOT ask people to trust you and follow your statement on your word alone with no role claim and no intel or evidence to back it up
Fri 13:52

One small meta question... when a beholder follows a person, what kind of message does he get? Is it something like "you followed X. X tried to recruit Y."
Fri 13:52

Or is it something else entirely?
Boone Fri 13:52

it's the check
Fri 13:53

as the role would see it
Locke Fri 13:55

So basically if beholder was to check a vamp, he would get the same message that vamp got... something like "Tonight you will recruit X" and "X could not be recruited so you kill your target instead"?
Boone Fri 13:55

no
Fri 13:55

You don't get every message
Fri 13:55

only intel messages
Fri 13:56

you see nothing on most evils besides BH/Fam-Stalker-Fam gd.
Fri 13:56

"Your target saw nothing last night" or so is the message if you behold a non intel role
Sun Fri 13:56

I don't think walt is a beholder...
Locke Fri 13:58

Okay, thank you for explaining it to me
Boone Fri 13:59

No problem.
Locke Fri 13:59

So, without a solid roleclaim from Walt, I am not moving my vote from him
Walt Fri 14:19

Fine im insomniac
Fri 14:19

And im not sure what boone is but im curtain he's not seer and im certain about jack
Hurley Fri 14:20

:O \o/
Fri 14:20

So .... what did you see last night?
Walt Fri 14:22

I saw jack hidding in the darknes and his face was very strange i thought he was my friend untill i saw him rolling in the blood of an innocent
Boone Fri 14:23

That's not how insomniac works
Fri 14:23

if you claim he's vampire, you would be dead.
Walt Fri 14:24

Not if someone protected me
Boone Fri 14:24

then you should have seen me visiting
Walt Fri 14:24

I didn't thats why im curtain your not seer
Boone Fri 14:24

so who else did visit? :)
Fri 14:25

Besides... Jack?
Walt Fri 14:25

Certain *
Jin Fri 14:25

Walt, what roles were mentioned as visiting you? It's very important to know
Walt Fri 14:25

Vampire master :(
Jin Fri 14:25

In your Insomniac report, did it say Seer or BH? Or no Seer-type role at all?
Boone Fri 14:25

he's lying obviously. If he's insomniac and claims that Jack wanted to kill him he'd see two persons
Fri 14:25

Insomniac doesn't report any roles
Fri 14:26

I feel bad for him because he doesn't know how stuff works :(
Jin Fri 14:26

*oops*
Fri 14:26

Yeah, sorry Walt
Boone Fri 14:26

For the slightest truth in his claim, he'd need to see 2 people visiting at least. But then he wouldn't know which one is the vamp.
Fri 14:26

but he only mentioned Jack
Fri 14:27

so he's obviously lying.
Jin Fri 14:27

Let's also appreciate the people voting along with Walt, and the info it gives us ;)
Moderator Fri 14:27

Jin votes to lynch Walt
Boone Fri 14:27

Just for clarification, as Insomniac you only see who visited you, no roles
Jin Fri 14:27

(Along with Walt, on Jack, I mean)
Boone Fri 14:28

if he got protected and Jack visited him it would be 2
Walt Fri 14:28

seriously
Hurley Fri 14:28

Jin, you're an evil person
Jin Fri 14:28

Yep, evil confirmed =)
Walt Fri 14:28

Yeah exactly and i didnt get seer and tour claiming your seer
Boone Fri 14:29

*sigh*
Walt Fri 14:30

Guys im not lying about insomniac im sad that boone is getting away with being seer
Fri 14:31

Its a good time for the real seer to show up
Boone Fri 14:34

Ok, I know you're coven, but let's go through your claim again, so everyone gets the same logic.
Fri 14:34

So who did visit you last night? Please list all persons
Walt Fri 14:36

I've been protected once so I can't be again thats why im not completely open the risk of being killed on me is too much
Fri 14:37

Im not gonna list them for you to make your work easier
Boone Fri 14:37

But you said Jack is vamp.
Walt Fri 14:39

Yes he is and im not sure what you are but im sure your not who you say you are
Jin Fri 14:40

Walt, can you zoom in on how you found out which visit was a Protector? And which was the killing role?
Fri 14:40

That's not clear to me yet...
Boone Fri 14:40

Obviously not
Fri 14:41

that's the whole defense falls flat on it's face.
Locke Fri 14:44

Walt... let me help you with your lies... If you were protected as you say, that means that you can't be protected this night again, so it doesn't matter who the other person who visited you was...
Fri 14:44

And even if you call out that other person, he could be saved if he is a protecting role
Moderator Fri 14:44

Hurley votes to lynch Locke
Hurley Fri 14:45

I wish I could vote for Jin too
Locke Fri 14:45

But... the fact that you do not want to state who else visited you
Fri 14:46

So... once again... Walt... try harder...
Charlie Fri 14:46

They seem new, it's great they tried feigning a role, but the choice was unfortunate. Maybe a little tweaking is needed for the wording on HTP to make it clear Insomniac only see the names, not roles?
Locke Fri 14:46

Hurley? Why a vote on me? I was only being sarcastic towards Walt when I said "let me help you with your lies"
Hurley Fri 14:48

Because you're beating a dead horse here
Boone Fri 14:48

Hurley you seem to beat everyone besides the horse.
Hurley Fri 14:49

Because the horse is dead ....
Charlie Fri 14:49

Hurley's voting has been worrying even before that
Boone Fri 14:50

So you told us the whole morning the horse is alive, and then you get mad when people beat the dead horse which should be well and ticking in your eyes.
Fri 14:50

I find your play today very very odd.
Walt Fri 14:51

Isn't it cryptic to say your seer in the first day am i the onlyone noticing it?!
Hurley Fri 14:52

Boone, I don't think that you are trying to understand me
Boone Fri 14:52

I do. As I tried to explain Walt why his claim makes not much sense.
Hurley Fri 14:53

Yes, your explanation was fine, Locke was overdoing it
Boone Fri 14:53

He seems like he isn't a regular himself.
Fri 14:53

or well, let's say not that experienced with all the mechanics.
Fri 14:54

So if you give Hurley the benefit of the doubt to some point. Please consider this also for others.
Locke Fri 14:54

I am, I only did not understand the beholder part..
Boone Fri 14:54

ok cool.
Locke Fri 14:55

And @Hurley... how was I "beating a dead horse"?
Boone Fri 14:55

Sorry didn't want to insult anyone. :))
Locke Fri 14:55

No, it's all okay
Fri 14:55

Not offended at all
Moderator Fri 15:05

Sayid votes to lynch Walt
Walt Fri 15:08

Guys ok put your votes on me but use the grave digger so you'll know boones accusation on me is wrong
Locke Fri 15:17

Oh, no worries Walt, we will do it
Richard Fri 15:18

*loading guns*
Fri 15:18

It'll be a peaceful death I tell ya
Fri 15:21

Can't believe we're lynching the only child in town
Fri 15:23

Evil, me gusta
Sun Fri 15:25

Is it just me, or does Hurley seem very suspicous?
Richard Fri 15:26

Both
Fri 15:28

Maybe Seer should check Hurley tonight?
Walt Fri 15:32

Rp:im only 9 people niiiiiiine
Richard Fri 15:35

*evil laugh*
Fri 15:35

You will forever be nine muahahaha
Kate Fri 15:45

Hi everyone
Fri 15:45

My gut trusts Boone
Moderator Fri 15:46

Kate votes to lynch Walt
Moderator Fri 15:58

Walt votes to lynch Boone
Walt Fri 16:01

Ethan jacob im coming my brothers im coming to the beyond
Eloise Fri 16:22

Good afternoon everyone.
Boone Fri 16:23

heya Eloise
Eloise Fri 16:23

I think Walt is a good lynch but also agree with ManInBlack about the possibility of a harpy.
Fri 16:24

Especially given that Walt is likely coven. Only coven will be shrouded at this stage, I think.
Fri 16:25

And since Hurley seems all too keen to pull votes towards him by being overly suspicious, I suspect he is a puppet.
Fri 16:27

So who would be a good second choice?
Boone Fri 16:28

if we think he's a puppet we could take him
Sun Fri 16:28

Well, Hurley is probably still the best second choice.
Moderator Fri 16:29

Eloise votes to lynch Hurley
Boone Fri 16:29

it's not the best second lynch but wont hurt. But honestly before we do this I want to give him a chance to claim. I don't want to second snipe him of.f
Charlie Fri 16:29

Why do we need a second choice?
Boone Fri 16:29

Harpy
Charlie Fri 16:29

If anyone is shrouded it'd be Harley, otherwise no point defending Walt
Fri 16:29

if Walt was shrouded, no point defending him, I mean. Eloise is a similar level to Hurley right now for me
Sun Fri 16:30

Yeah, so we're most likley going to succeeed in lynching walt.
Eloise Fri 16:30

Charlie, you have a good point.
Boone Fri 16:30

Yeah, also true what Charlie says,
Eloise Fri 16:30

I didn't see that earlier.
Sun Fri 16:30

But, he didn't know game mechanics very well, it seemed, so they might be unusure about harpy.
Fri 16:31

Can't be certain that Walt isn't shrouded.
Charlie Fri 16:31

Unless the entire thing is a coven inside plan with Walt shrouded, Boone pup, and a djinn ready to mix it all up tomorrow lol
Fri 16:31

That would be ...silly though
Eloise Fri 16:32

The harpy is so new that I find it difficult to see all the implications.
Fri 16:34

Can we maybe stack votes and see what happens? Hurley and MrEko do make good alternatives in my opinion.
Fri 16:35

As long as we lynch someone. I prefer not to risk a non-lynch.
Boone Fri 16:38

did any of the ASV's ever change their vote ?
Fri 16:39

like Sayid, Ben etc=?
Sawyer Fri 16:42

We want to make Hurley the second alternative in case of harpy, right?
Fri 16:42

I'm fine with that
Moderator Fri 16:43

Sawyer votes to lynch Hurley
Desmond Fri 16:46

*i lurk*
Fri 16:46

*shhhhhh*
Moderator Fri 17:04

Ben votes to lynch Hurley
Desmond Fri 17:15

(ill help with possible second target lynch.. in case hurley has two puppet votes)
Moderator Fri 17:15

Desmond votes to lynch Hurley
Desmond Fri 17:16

(Anybody checked before game-start count? Anybody certain abt presence of PM?)
Fri 17:18

(What if Hurley actually dies.. worth it?)
Fri 17:18

(YessSsssSSs, maybe it is..)
Hurley Fri 17:19

No, not worth it
Desmond Fri 17:19

(NoOoOO, maybe not)
Hurley Fri 17:20

I thought we wanted to go after the asvs? Well, seems like I am more suspicious :(
Desmond Fri 17:20

(R u scared hurley? If u r, u might be coven)
Fri 17:20

(Or a very cautious wolf)
Fri 17:21

(Or a vamp that didnt lay low)
Fri 17:21

(Or a villager)
Fri 17:22

(Me too, i could be any of that)
Fri 17:22

(But let records show i claim villager)
Hurley Fri 17:24

I am scared ..... :/
Ben Fri 17:28

shit... what if both walt and hurley are innocent? Then the harpy trick would work on us...
Desmond Fri 17:30

(Ben are YouUuUU scared?)
Ben Fri 17:31

_|_
Hurley Fri 17:50

Hmm, something I noticed: Penelope never returned from "reading"
Fri 17:52

Jack didn't speak up
Fri 17:52

MiB disappeared, but that could be a tz reason
Ben Fri 17:53

tz?
Hurley Fri 17:53

timezone
Charlie Fri 17:57

Oh. I finally realised what the second target thing means, derp. I kept thinking Harpy just protects the lynch rather than moves it to #2
Fri 17:57

This seems good
Hurley Fri 17:57

Naomi was silent so far, Libby didn't show up again after the asv, Mikhail wasn't here, Juliet wasn't either
Charlie Fri 17:58

And Jack!
Fri 17:58

Famous Jack
Hurley Fri 17:58

@Charlie, the shrouded player is handled as if he had 0 votes
Fri 17:58

Famous Jack?
Ben Fri 17:58

i c.. @tz, thanks
Charlie Fri 17:59

Coven seem to think he's vamp
Hurley Fri 18:01

Well, unless they tried to poison him, their hints are very weak
Charlie Fri 18:03

How come he wasn't on your list? He's not been on
Moderator Fri 18:03

Libby votes to lynch Mikhail
Hurley Fri 18:03

He was on my list :P
Fri 18:03

17:52
Fri 18:03

Hi Libby, thoughts?
Charlie Fri 18:04

Oh oops, didn't see the first section
Hurley Fri 18:05

Are you really sure that I'm the best alternative?
Fri 18:05

Btw, Harpy does move the lynch to #2
Moderator Fri 18:05

Mikhail votes to lynch Libby
Hurley Fri 18:06

Mikhail, thoughts?
Libby Fri 18:07

sorry, I was catching up
Hurley Fri 18:07

Oh, that's fine, don't worry
Libby Fri 18:08

didn't actually mean to switch to Mikhail, I'm suspicious of Walt sure, but something makes me think Boone is more likely BH than Seer
Eloise Fri 18:09

Then you should vote for Boone, dear.
Libby Fri 18:09

day 1 reveal is risky
Fri 18:09

unless you know the wolves won't target you
Eloise Fri 18:09

Your current vote makes as little sense as an ASV.
Fri 18:10

What we do know is that Walt lies, and that he does it badly.
Libby Fri 18:10

I was tallying votes and clicked Mikhail while scrolling, I'll switch when I make a full decision
Fri 18:10

that may be true! but if we're also looking for a second option, I'm voting Boone over Hurley
Moderator Fri 18:11

Libby votes to lynch Boone
Desmond Fri 18:14

(Im not ready to lynch Hurley, so ill change vote, so if Walt is shrouded - unlikely - and hurley doesny get lynched, we will catch puppets)
Hurley Fri 18:14

I just don't want to get into the range where puppets / silenced players on Walt could lynch me
Moderator Fri 18:14

Desmond votes to lynch Sayid
Ben Fri 18:15

what if the shrouding is just to derail us even more?
Fri 18:15

Boone definitely has an early claim..
Fri 18:15

@hurley, why locke?
Moderator Fri 18:16

Ben votes to lynch Boone
Desmond Fri 18:16

(Ben u dont want puppets caught?)
Hurley Fri 18:16

That's an old vote, I didn't like his behaviour
Fri 18:18

Mikhail didn't even bother saying anything ....
Ben Fri 18:18

lemme think abt it des
Fri 18:18

I hate ppl who pin point each other
Fri 18:19

based on sth villagers like us can't prove..
Sun Fri 18:19

Wait, why is Boone the 2nd lynch? If Walt is shrouded, we may end up killing our seer...
Fri 18:20

I seriously suspect Hurley here.
Eloise Fri 18:22

Sun, is your vote on Walt currently? If so, would you change it to Hurley?
Jin Fri 18:22

Libby, there are vamps. Claiming Seer is risky as Seer and as BH. Your argument is invalid.
Fri 18:22

Boone won't live long either way ;)
Moderator Fri 18:23

Jin votes to lynch Hurley
Moderator Fri 18:23

Sun votes to lynch Hurley
Jin Fri 18:23

Ill try to make hurley second lynch again
Sun Fri 18:24

We shall cleanse this village of evil together, my husband.
Ben Fri 18:24

damn, that roleplay is legendary
Jin Fri 18:26

<3 Sun
Ben Fri 18:26

that return is extraodinary
Hurley Fri 18:27

ok, this is getting too close my friends,
Fri 18:27

Can we just lynch some inactive?
Moderator Fri 18:27

Hurley votes to lynch Walt
Sun Fri 18:27

Suspicious>Inactive
Hurley Fri 18:33

/o\
Naomi Fri 19:15

Lack of walt claim, after accusation
Moderator Fri 19:16

Naomi votes to lynch Walt
Hurley Fri 19:17

Walt did claim, just later
Locke Fri 19:49

Just reminding you guys that there are protective roles in this game... well, at least there should be...
Fri 19:49

And Boone coming out early is not bad imo
Fri 19:49

Even if he is a BH, pointing us towards coven is super useful
Fri 19:50

But, I believe that he is a seer
Fri 19:50

Because every seer should alarm the village as soon as they find evil...
Fri 19:50

In this case Boone was lucky to hit coven n1 so there it is
Fri 19:51

I agree that hiting a vamp would be more desirable but oh well
Fri 19:52

And I think that both coven and wolves would have use of a seer this early in the game so they won't target him
Fri 19:53

But a vamp might
Hurley Fri 19:53

I think all evil factions want the seer dead
Fri 19:55

I wonder whether you're trying to coordinate? *shrugs*
Eloise Fri 20:10

Well, speaking of coordination... the Militia can have themselves a right party tonight if they want with so many evils being obvious already. The question is who to shoot lest they take out a puppet... Or will that be not so bad? Shall we make a plan?
Hurley Fri 20:11

I wonder before whether this was a hint for Walt - (Locke) "@Walt, you DO NOT ask people to trust you and follow your statement on your word alone with no role claim and no intel or evidence to back it up"
Eloise Fri 20:12

^Evil suspect number 1, after Walt
Hurley Fri 20:12

Hmm, Militias do greatly benefit fromshooting before a role claim
Fri 20:12

But shooting a villager might even be gamelosing
Eloise Fri 20:13

I would discourage any Militia to come out by the way, as long as we have coven who may well be able to thwart them.
Fri 20:13

*from coming out
Fri 20:18

So I'm not sure whether just to state my preferences or to wait until somebody more villager-like turns up.
Hurley Fri 20:20

Hey, I'm not confirmed evil yet, please don't treat me as such (yet) ok? thanks.
Eloise Fri 20:23

Hurley, I think you are much too eloquent not to see the gaping holes in Walt's claim. So the fact that you are defending him makes you confirmed evil in my view. If you want me to treat you in any other way, you could start by offering an explanation for your strange voting behaviour throughout the day.
Charlie Fri 20:23

Who on earth is on Boone?!
Eloise Fri 20:23

Ben, Hurley and Libby.
Fri 20:24

The other coven are probably MrEko and Desmond, with Penelope as a possible.
Fri 20:25

So the question is for any militia: who to shoot? Because it would be worth taking out more than just one.
Fri 20:25

Unless they take out a puppet who will die soon anyway.
Locke Fri 20:26

Hurley is deff evil in my opinion too...
Eloise Fri 20:26

What do you think, Charlie?
Fri 20:26

Ah, Locke, you're here too.
Locke Fri 20:27

And that thing I said which you quoted was no hint...
Hurley Fri 20:27

I feel flattered, Eloise
Eloise Fri 20:27

You're welcome.
Hurley Fri 20:27

Uhm no, I am not on Boone
Eloise Fri 20:28

Ah, no, changed to Walt I think.
Hurley Fri 20:28

I am on Walt, for self-preservational reasons, obviously
Locke Fri 20:28

I only said it with caps lock on, because his attempt on defense was so lame...
Fri 20:28

And I only stated why I don't believe him
Fri 20:30

Because if someone want's to try his luck at lying, one should at least try as hard as possible to sound lit... so, that requires a role claim and some intel/evidence to back it up...
Fri 20:30

Even if he knows he is faking it, he should try hard to make it believable
Eloise Fri 20:30

Anyway...
Locke Fri 20:30

Yes?
Eloise Fri 20:30

We all know Walt is lying and will be lynched if not shrouded.
Fri 20:31

Shall we make a plan to take out a few other evils quickly?
Locke Fri 20:31

Indeed...
Fri 20:32

I also have something to point out since nobody seams to understand a harpie I guess...
Eloise Fri 20:32

My understanding is...
Fri 20:32

the person with the largest number of votes AFTER the shrouded person gets lynched.
Fri 20:32

Correct?
Locke Fri 20:32

I hope you realise that harpie (as all other roles) decide who to shroud/silence during the night, and that person is under that effect the next day?
Eloise Fri 20:33

Yes.
Locke Fri 20:33

Yes, that is the case, but not my point
Eloise Fri 20:33

But it is like an internal protector, correct?
Fri 20:33

So they would randomly have chosen a coven member last night.
Locke Fri 20:34

My point is... what are the odds that coven knew that Walt would be busted right away and shrouded him last night?
Hurley Fri 20:34

Yes
Eloise Fri 20:34

Walt was the only one of the apparent coven today who spoke last night.
Hurley Fri 20:34

@Locke, I pointed that one out before, maybe Walt was shrouded because he's important
Locke Fri 20:34

They could not know... so, I think that Walt is not shrouded... In fact, if I was coven, I would not shroud n1 at all
Eloise Fri 20:34

And they will only have had a team of 4+2, probably.
Locke Fri 20:35

Since maybe I'd need to shroud that person n2 and I won't be able if I shrouded n1
Eloise Fri 20:35

In that case Hurley does not have to be as nervous as he is coming across.
Hurley Fri 20:35

BUT then again, he can't be shrouded the next time night
Eloise Fri 20:37

Locke, can we please go back to the question how to make the most of our head start? I feel this question about the harpy is of secondary relevance at the moment.
Hurley Fri 20:37

Eloise, I'm more concerned about puppets & silenced players
Locke Fri 20:37

That is why I just said all this... Why use the ability at random n1, and then not be able to actually use that ability on that person n2 when/if needed...
Hurley Fri 20:37

I am concerned when a player suggest having the militia shooting me
Locke Fri 20:38

Well, if Militia is here, Hurley is a way to go imo
Hurley Fri 20:38

Don't say stuff like that Locke, Hurley could be a militia :P
Fri 20:38

Or a Witch? Whoooo knows
MrEko Fri 20:39

hi
Hurley Fri 20:39

Hi o/
MrEko Fri 20:39

y walt?
Moderator Fri 20:40

MrEko votes to lynch Walt
Locke Fri 20:40

Well, if you are a Militia, then I suppose I won't be alive tomorrow, eh? Hurley?
Hurley Fri 20:41

Hmmmmm why?
Locke Fri 20:41

But... my guts say that you are evil, probably coven like Walt...
Fri 20:42

Oh, maybe because we show mutual suspicion towards each other
Fri 20:43

And what's stoping a Militia from shooting a person they do not trust
Hurley Fri 20:45

No, I'd not risk killing a fellow villager, if there's no immediate possibility of losing
Locke Fri 20:45

So, if anyone want's to follow my suggestion, it's this lynch Walt (we are already doing it I guess), and tonight, protector on Boone, and Militia goes band with Hurley
Fri 20:46

Bang *
Fri 20:48

Oh... and GD on Walt
Hurley Fri 20:48

Are you sure about that?
Locke Fri 20:48

Yeah, I'm sure... and if I'm wrong, well... sorry I guess
Hurley Fri 20:49

Sure about the GD
Eloise Fri 20:49

I agree with GD on Walt and Prot on Boone.
Fri 20:49

I am less sure about Hurley as a target because he might be a puppet.
Locke Fri 20:50

Okay then, who do you suggest then Eloise?
Hurley Fri 20:50

it's not like the Militia has to shoot tonight?!
Eloise Fri 20:51

We will have an advantage if we take out evils early. Dealing with wolves and vamps is bad enough as it is.
Locke Fri 20:51

Well, they certainly don't have to
Hurley Fri 20:52

I think the GD should not dig Walt ....
Eloise Fri 20:52

Now what could be the reason for THAT?
Locke Fri 20:52

Why? You wanna hide your buddy?
Hurley Fri 20:53

How valuable is it to know his role?
Locke Fri 20:53

Well, his exact role that is
Hurley Fri 20:54

hmm, ok it might be worth it, knowing that there's a harpy less etc ...
Fri 20:54

so yeah, maybe dig him
Locke Fri 20:54

Oh... Djin swaps? Are they before or after intel checks
Eloise Fri 20:54

After.
Hurley Fri 20:54

THe GD still sees the old role with the new name
Locke Fri 20:54

Okay, then it's worth checking him
Hurley Fri 20:55

But there will be a coven claiming GD tomorrow ... let's see how it goes
Locke Fri 20:55

If it was before checks, there would be no point since djin could swap him to hide his role
Fri 20:56

Anyways, I don't see any reason to stay here any longer today, I am off for tz reasons, see you guys tomorrow...
Fri 20:57

If I live that is
Hurley Fri 20:57

Bye
Fri 20:57

Not waiting to watch me die?
Eloise Fri 20:58

Militias, I would consider Ben as an alternative to Hurley...
Hurley Fri 20:58

Well, please remember who was voting for me when the Harpy hits
Locke Fri 20:58

You won't die... as I said, I doubt that harpie did her thing n1
Libby Fri 20:58

what are you basing all this on Eloise?
Hurley Fri 20:58

I got a bad feeling .... Walts defense was too bad to be true
Fri 20:59

I think we were baited, but oh well, good night
Moderator Fri 20:59

Creatures of the night begin to stir...
Lynched Fri 21:00

Hurley was lynched by the village
Moderator Sat 09:00

Only a single star remains in the sky...
Killed Sat 09:00

Jack was killed during the night
Killed Sat 09:00

Sawyer was killed during the night
Killed Sat 09:01

Juliet was killed during the night

Your role: Observer

The Village

Graveyard

Spoiler free day archives