ext-192 Day 3 | Werewolf Mafia Game Online for your Browser

Replay

You are viewing day 3 of a game of werewolv.es started on the 17-Nov-23 Thu on a 24 hour cycle (12h day, 12h night).

This is a spoiler free version, use the user button (top menu) to see who was alive at the time, and the calendar button or links below the chat to navigate through to different days.

You can play a game of online Mafia by joining the game currently in sign up. New players are welcome, but try to be active!
Kate Sat 09:02

How did Hurley get lynched?
Jin Sat 09:03

That would be only possible with a Harpy
Sat 09:03

So Walt would have been shrouded, meaning that their votes didn't count for the lynch. As a consequence, the second-highest vote count determined the lynch
Kate Sat 09:03

Might have been, do you know the vote numbers by the end of the day?
Jin Sat 09:04

not exactly
Kate Sat 09:04

if 3 of the votes on walt were 2 puppets and a silenced person then it could have gone the other way as well
Sat 09:05

but i guess we know boone is probably seer or a puppet that knows who was shrouded (maybe walt is innocent?) and is trying to look lit
Ben Sat 09:06

Hi
Sat 09:07

Shaken in my faith towards democracy (not exact words)
Moderator Sat 09:07

Ben votes to lynch Sayid
Kate Sat 09:07

alright you were silenced or shrouded then
Ben Sat 09:07

see for urself
Jin Sat 09:07

@Kate: 1 shroud is less to assume than what you're saying, but both are possible, yes
Sat 09:08

Also, shrouding a coven or helping a coven escaping lynch with puppets/harpy stuff is not very strange, so that also corresponds with Boone's coven-find
Sat 09:08

but we'll see
Ben Sat 09:08

so.. am i useless in helping with the vote now? Damn it
Jin Sat 09:08

you are, or you're vote-immune
Sat 09:08

the notification doesnt' differentiate between shroud and silence
Sat 09:08

I would have liked to try to lynch Walt again, even though my money's on would have been a puppet lynch by now
Moderator Sat 09:09

MrEko votes to lynch Boone
MrEko Sat 09:09

asv
Kate Sat 09:09

oh true, if they have djinn he's gone now :( probably the witch or harpy
Desmond Sat 09:09

Ben i believe u were silenced yesterday. Not for today.
Kate Sat 09:09

or pm/djinn tbh...
Jin Sat 09:10

@Desmond: why do you think this?
Ben Sat 09:10

i just say what i c today, yeah why? Pls enlighten me abt that
Desmond Sat 09:10

He got a message this morning?
Ben Sat 09:10

yes sir
Desmond Sat 09:10

Wait lemme copy past h2p
Ben Sat 09:11

'strange dreams... shaken... democracy'
Desmond Sat 09:11

Both abilities may be cast on the same night. Both abilities are available every night. Silence and Shroud targets receive the same cryptic message in the morning.
Sat 09:11

Maybe im mistaken?
Sat 09:12

Now that i consider how u saw it, i cud be wrong
Ben Sat 09:12

yes sir
Sat 09:12

thank you for enlightening me
MrEko Sat 09:13

um
Sayid Sat 09:13

Hi
Sat 09:14

Im militia
MrEko Sat 09:14

if u saw the msg this morn then u r shrouded 2day
Sayid Sat 09:14

And last night i killed walt
Desmond Sat 09:14

Okay my bad.
Sayid Sat 09:14

Because he was coven
Jin Sat 09:14

Sayid taking the matter into own hands, alright
MrEko Sat 09:14

y walt nt boone????
Sayid Sat 09:15

I hope i did a good job
Jin Sat 09:15

Eko
Kate Sat 09:15

oh shit i didnt even realize walt died
Jin Sat 09:15

Please explain why Boone is the better shot
Sayid Sat 09:15

Because im not sure about boon
Jin Sat 09:15

Are you crazy, Eko?
Sayid Sat 09:15

I think boon is a wolf
Jin Sat 09:15

Well, there's plenty of time/opportunity to verify them
MrEko Sat 09:15

bcoz the change tht boone randomly reveals as seer day 2 and exposes the shrouded player r so low!
Sayid Sat 09:15

And if i killed him last night he was shape shiftid to another prsn
Jin Sat 09:16

Somebody who is obviously lying - unfortunately, because their understanding of certain roles failed them - is a better shot
Desmond Sat 09:16

Eko, i was thinking abt that as well.
Jin Sat 09:16

oooh interesting
Sat 09:16

didn't consider that
Sat 09:16

We had Boone the BH as scenario already, but now you're thinking Boone Coven? Puppy maybe?
Desmond Sat 09:16

Two possibilities arose to me
Kate Sat 09:17

thats what i was saying earlier
Sayid Sat 09:17

At all we killed on of the coven and its nice (its my mind)
Sat 09:18

Opnion*
Kate Sat 09:18

most likely...
Desmond Sat 09:18

Sayid, i think killing Walt was a safe bet
MrEko Sat 09:18

did jack speak d2?
Desmond Sat 09:18

I only wonder why Walt didnt djinn himself out.
Sat 09:18

Jack. Didnt speak.
Kate Sat 09:19

thats what im thinking too
Sat 09:19

maybe there is no djinn?
Desmond Sat 09:19

He didnt vote either
Kate Sat 09:19

either that or Sayid is coven (maybe puppet) and lying
Sayid Sat 09:19

I thought djen mybe will change walt and smbody els
Desmond Sat 09:19

I dont think Sayid is lying kate
Jin Sat 09:19

*yeeeerrrr allll puppppeeerrrss*
Kate Sat 09:20

its so easy to make crazy claims as a pup xD
Desmond Sat 09:20

Nah, i think Jin is wolf ;)
Sayid Sat 09:20

I didnt talk yesterday because the if i talk too much maybe the wolves gonna kill me
Jin Sat 09:20

I think Sayid really did the kill ability, although technically this makes it possible for them to be wolf/fam-militia as well
Sayid Sat 09:20

Kate are you evil?
MrEko Sat 09:21

sayid did u vote?
Kate Sat 09:21

I am not
Jin Sat 09:21

Oh, but I am, Sayid
Sayid Sat 09:21

I just wanna to help the villgrs
Kate Sat 09:21

I can see it
Jin Sat 09:21

saw how I lead Walt yesterday into a mistaken claim?
Sat 09:21

=d
Kate Sat 09:21

wolves could do that tooooo
Sayid Sat 09:21

Noooo im militia
Kate Sat 09:22

ya i believe that i think
Sat 09:22

odd how walt didnt djinn shift out though
Boone Sat 09:22

*yawn* Morning everyone
Kate Sat 09:22

Hey there
Boone Sat 09:22

I got good and rly bad news
Kate Sat 09:22

Check?
Sayid Sat 09:23

And last night i dicided to kill walt because he wasting him slf
Boone Sat 09:23

which one you want first?
Jin Sat 09:23

Do the bad news first
Kate Sat 09:23

good news!
Jin Sat 09:23

haha
MrEko Sat 09:23

both in 1 line
Jin Sat 09:23

^^
Boone Sat 09:23

Good: I found the vamp
Sat 09:23

bad: I got purged
Sayid Sat 09:23

I couldn’t say im militia lst night cous of the wolves omg why dont you blive me
Jin Sat 09:23

BAM
Kate Sat 09:24

whos the vaaaamp
Boone Sat 09:24

Charlie
Moderator Sat 09:24

Jin votes to lynch Charlie
Kate Sat 09:24

damn you charlie
Jin Sat 09:24

it must've been the heroin
MrEko Sat 09:24

boone y u check charlie?
Jin Sat 09:24

BECAUSE THEY WERE THE VAMP LOL HINDSIGHT BIAS
MrEko Sat 09:24

wt kind of vamp r they?
Kate Sat 09:24

seer wouldn't know
Jin Sat 09:25

but BH would? =d
Sat 09:25

*sssshh*
Kate Sat 09:25

i think so, not sure actually
Sayid Sat 09:25

Ummm
Sat 09:26

The wolves have nice plan to make people belive them and finde real seer and kill him also
Jin Sat 09:26

A coven and a vamp so far; I think that's good results. Still means Boone could very well be BH, so far it's all targets a BH wants dead as well.
Sat 09:26

I would suggest that we go for the lynch - unless Charlie has a very strong counter-claim - and we need GD info to sort all this out quickly
Kate Sat 09:27

btw Boone what were you purged into
Boone Sat 09:27

Vanilla -_-
MrEko Sat 09:27

jin a coven that led 2 some1 else being lynched & a conveninent purge claim
Boone Sat 09:27

Wait a moment eko
Kate Sat 09:27

lol it would be fun to just claim that after not being purged so you wouldnt be targeted by evils ;)
Boone Sat 09:27

You want to say I'm what? Puppet? Coven? Wolf?
MrEko Sat 09:28

idk
Jin Sat 09:28

ALL OF THE ABOVEEE ;,,;
Boone Sat 09:28

great
MrEko Sat 09:28

coven or mb puppet
Kate Sat 09:28

@Boone
Boone Sat 09:29

mh?
MrEko Sat 09:29

coven bcoz chance of u finding the shrouded player in 22 looooooooow
Locke Sat 09:29

I was busy this morning with meta stuff, can someone give me a summary and I will read all later
Desmond Sat 09:29

Whos the vamp Boone?
Locke Sat 09:29

Also... this many dead people?
Boone Sat 09:29

I said already, it's charlie
Jin Sat 09:29

CHARLIE IS VAMP @DES @LOCKE
Sat 09:29

according to Boone
Moderator Sat 09:29

Kate votes to lynch Charlie
Kate Sat 09:29

i guess ill just vote for now
Desmond Sat 09:29

Kate dont be so hasty
Jin Sat 09:30

@Des: please do explain what else you want to do with a Vamp find?
Kate Sat 09:30

i mean its not like im gonna vote and disappear for the whole day
Locke Sat 09:30

Oh... and I guess Boone was well protected last night ;)
Desmond Sat 09:30

Ur choice, in the end, go ahead.
Kate Sat 09:30

ill be around to change it should something come up
MrEko Sat 09:30

locke he was purged
Sat 09:30

apparently
Jin Sat 09:30

prots don't help against purges, unfortunately
MrEko Sat 09:31

every1 conveniently thought of harpy but no1 thought of alchemist
Boone Sat 09:31

only a harlot would
Sat 09:31

he could tell us who visited me
Jin Sat 09:31

Eko: what could we have done about the Alchemist then?
Kate Sat 09:31

hopefully one did
Jin Sat 09:31

I don't like your tone
Kate Sat 09:31

it definitely makes sense to purge the seer
MrEko Sat 09:31

jin he cld not have revealed so early!
Jin Sat 09:32

Who could not?
MrEko Sat 09:32

boone
Jin Sat 09:32

Well, he did - so he could have
Sat 09:32

You deem it unwise?
Kate Sat 09:32

i think we rather get info right away if he has any
Jin Sat 09:32

That's a different thing
Sayid Sat 09:32

Its just a theory ! Maybe boon is coven and yesterday he said he finde walt as coven to make ppl belive him pleas open your eyes
MrEko Sat 09:32

1 coven 4 1 seer is nt a good trade
Jin Sat 09:32

Plus, look at what it has brought us!
Sayid Sat 09:32

And he knew that walt wouldn’t die
Kate Sat 09:33

we all considered it
Jin Sat 09:33

So what was Hurley, then?
Kate Sat 09:33

could have been anything
MrEko Sat 09:33

boone y charlie??
Jin Sat 09:33

I don't buy Hurley being some innocent bystander - so that must've been a pupper sacrifice?
Sayid Sat 09:33

So!?
Jin Sat 09:33

(in that scenario)
MrEko Sat 09:34

jin y wud coven sacrifice a puppet like that??
Boone Sat 09:34

"Charlie Fri 12:55 Trying to think of ways Coven could find vamp, but is there only witch potion? Doesn't seem likely one would use that so earl"
Desmond Sat 09:35

(Im uncomfortable again, ill return to my shadows)
MrEko Sat 09:36

boone thats ur reason?
Desmond Sat 09:36

(Village missing what’s right in front of them)
Boone Sat 09:36

he mentioned vamp multiple times. Yes.
MrEko Sat 09:36

um
Sat 09:36

bcoz walt said jack was vamp
Moderator Sat 09:36

Sayid votes to lynch Boone
MrEko Sat 09:36

y is that strange?
Moderator Sat 09:37

Sayid votes to lynch Charlie
Boone Sat 09:37

yes but we knew minutes after walt that that Walt was full of s. But he kinda kept going at it.
Sat 09:37

*after walt's claim
Sat 09:37

Walt got so many things wrong, the topic was kinda over for me.
MrEko Sat 09:41

boone idk if u just picked a bad example bt ur reason seems crap 2 me
Sat 09:41

<Charlie> [Fri 12:13] Rethink them with what new information ? <Walt> [Fri 12:22] I put my vote on jack he's a vampire and I cannot share the information how i know that cause that will make me target at night unlike someone i should be afraid of others knowing my position <Charlie> [Fri 12:55] Trying to think of ways Coven could find vamp, but is there only witch potion? Doesn't seem likely one would use that so early [Fri 12:55] My vote remains <Walt> [Fri 14:19] Fine im insomniac
Sat 09:42

charlie didnt seem 2 sus 2 me
Desmond Sat 09:44

(I see so much sense in Eko’s sense)
MrEko Sat 09:44

desmond u were my fav char in the show :3 :3
Desmond Sat 09:44

he had an awesome accent
Sat 09:45

But im not rp ... (i like to stay in my quiet place here)
Kate Sat 09:46

did we find the fam though (looking at eko)
Boone Sat 09:46

why are so many people defending charlie, before he said a word or claimed anything today? In my eyes he was off, I checked him and I'm pretty fking sure I brought us much much closer to victory. I'm a bit sad now, because I extra checked the phone in bed and when I saw Vamp I jumped up and ran to the pc. The lack of enthusiasm after this big find is kinda demotivating me :/
Sat 09:46

I'll go and sleep again. Cya later
MrEko Sat 09:47

im not trying 2 defend charlie im trying 2 attack u!
Sat 09:47

its different
Sayid Sat 09:47

*(Good player)*
Moderator Sat 09:47

Locke votes to lynch Charlie
Desmond Sat 09:47

(Eko beings sensible again)
Jin Sat 09:47

Boone, thanks for your effort, sleep well
Desmond Sat 09:48

(Charlie could be coven. Very true, but Boone doesnt sound lit to me)
Jin Sat 09:48

Guys, I understand how Boone can be evil in many different ways
Desmond Sat 09:48

(Eko they will kill u tonight, Hurley stood up to them yatrday, and u saw how they lined him to second lynch)
Jin Sat 09:48

but bring some concrete evidence against Boone, or roll with the vamp find? It's a pretty big thing though
Desmond Sat 09:48

(Goodbye Eko)
Sat 09:48

(Sayid ur next)
Sat 09:48

(Or maybe ill die first)
Boone Sat 09:48

meh I can't let go
Sat 09:49

ok so I said don't vote on hurley
Desmond Sat 09:49

Boooniee!!
Boone Sat 09:49

and now I'm also responsible for hurley???
Desmond Sat 09:49

Booonee. Dont sleeep
Sat 09:49

(No.. no, go sleeeep. Im sorry)
Sat 09:49

*shhhhhhhhh*
Sat 09:49

*sssshhhh*
Kate Sat 09:50

there's so many evils in this game :(
Sayid Sat 09:50

No they shouldn’t kill me now im just a villager:(
Boone Sat 09:50

I see I can only do wrong. Bet if hurley turns out to be a puppet it's the other way around "boone didn't want to lynch hurley"
Desmond Sat 09:51

(Hurley could easily be coven, but we didnt have enough prove to put him on second lynch so brutally)
Sat 09:51

(Proof*)
Sayid Sat 09:52

Wrs our gd:|
Boone Sat 09:52

Also it's fking absurd to say I'm a puppet, who lead a vote on a coven, to get someone else lynched because the harpy shrouded walt. That's like the most wasteful plan ever. Which also apparently includes a death of Walt. Great plan, 10/10.
Desmond Sat 09:52

(He only seemed logical, and MiB and Sun pushed the idea that he is good second lynch)
Sat 09:52

Booone! Ur right!
Sat 09:53

I realised the same thIng this morning!
Kate Sat 09:53

@Boone i mean i think it would be a good plan
Jin Sat 09:53

He 'seemed logical, but we didn't have enough prove (PROOF) to put him on second lynch'
Sat 09:53

Desmond, your words, about Hurley
Desmond Sat 09:53

(Which is why i came up with second possibility after it)
Jin Sat 09:53

Now look at you talking about Boone:
Sat 09:53

you don't have enough proof to put him on the stand like you do
Desmond Sat 09:53

JIN STOP TALKING
Sat 09:53

YESTERDAY U WERE SO MEAN
Sat 09:54

(He attacked everyone)
Sayid Sat 09:54

Walt shrouded himslf
Desmond Sat 09:54

(He attacks everyone today)
Boone Sat 09:54

not possible
Jin Sat 09:54

lol
Boone Sat 09:54

you can't shroud yourself.
Desmond Sat 09:54

Im sorry Jin
Jin Sat 09:54

I'm actually on the defence here I feel, for Boone
Desmond Sat 09:54

I didnt mean to shout
Sat 09:54

But i dont like you
Sun Sat 09:54

Hello everyone (Hi Jin)
Jin Sat 09:54

nicely ganging up with an enemy of the state, I'm at least invincible during the night now ;)
Sat 09:55

My great fiery ball, bestowing life on us all!
Sat 09:55

I should write love poems def
Charlie Sat 09:55

Yeah Boone went nowhere last night, yesterday was a complete sham. I'm a Stalker, my night 1 was a self visiting player so I wont say incase they are prot. Back sooon
Moderator Sat 09:55

Charlie votes to lynch Boone
Sayid Sat 09:55

But i heard they can shroud them selfs:|
Jin Sat 09:55

Hi Charlie
Sat 09:56

Nice of you to be here, now we can get this thing started
Kate Sat 09:56

oh god i definitely believed that line a lot more before i read who said it
Sat 09:56

(with charlie)
Jin Sat 09:56

Why did you choose Boone as a stalk target?
Boone Sat 09:57

He was on my side the whole day yesterday. Odd stalk.
Sat 09:57

^^
Desmond Sat 09:57

Isnt stalking a good way to verify someone?
Sat 09:57

(Boone needs verification, BADLY)
Sat 09:58

(Doesnt tell us if he’s seer or BH tho)
Kate Sat 09:58

ya but im not about to trust the person he just said was vamp
Boone Sat 09:58

lynch the fking vamp, and we got some.
Desmond Sat 09:58

:(
Sayid Sat 09:58

(He was on ur side couse he think ur seer mybe)
Desmond Sat 09:58

(I dont trust Charlie, but i will listen to him)
Boone Sat 09:58

then why stalk me? And not Walt for example?
Moderator Sat 09:58

Eloise votes to lynch Charlie
Jin Sat 09:59

I understand that Boone needs verification and it's not a terrible stalk, it's not one I would make though. And what's more: it's convenient the one being Vamp-Seen has counter-intel on the Seer
Kate Sat 09:59

i think walt would be a bad stalk
Desmond Sat 09:59

Why not walt? Good question..
Sayid Sat 09:59

(you can convince ppl:)
Sat 09:59

Wll
Desmond Sat 09:59

(Sayid u like ( ) too)
Sat 10:00

(Keeps you safe right)
Boone Sat 10:00

(fml)
Sun Sat 10:00

I'm worried that our Militia is gone, or why is Walt still alive?
Desmond Sat 10:00

(Boone joins the party )
Boone Sat 10:00

Walt is dead
Desmond Sat 10:00

Hehehheheheheh suuuun
Sayid Sat 10:00

I am nothing im just a villgr righn know :)
Moderator Sat 10:02

OK, I think I've cleared up the weirdness from the day starting twice, if you have any problems send me a direct message on Discord to @StormPooper and I'll take a look.
Boone Sat 10:02

wth
Sat 10:02

ok so less deaths?
Sayid Sat 10:02

Sun ur brave militia killd walt last night:) :D
Boone Sat 10:02

Walt was dead on my screen
Sat 10:03

was he dead for someone else?
Kate Sat 10:03

ya he was dead for me too
Eloise Sat 10:03

I think he has been swapped.
Richard Sat 10:03

Hi all
Sat 10:03

What an active morning
Sayid Sat 10:03

Yes he was dead
MrEko Sat 10:03

<Boone> [Sat 09:54] you can't shroud yourself.
Boone Sat 10:03

wtf
MrEko Sat 10:03

ur right BUT
Eloise Sat 10:04

My first day start said he was killed. My second day start said someone else was killed.
Boone Sat 10:04

who is someone else?
MrEko Sat 10:04

what if they have a succu and succu redirected harpy 2 themself?
Eloise Sat 10:04

Juliet.
Boone Sat 10:04

I didn't check, my morning was all mesed up due to purge .
Jin Sat 10:04

I got the same weirdness in the morning
Sat 10:05

Okay now mod's fixed it we can discuss
Boone Sat 10:05

I got like 2 messages about my new role, etc.
Richard Sat 10:05

Hey what's the weirdness guys
Eloise Sat 10:05

Juliet is now Walt. The question is...
Boone Sat 10:05

nah she's dead. Hmm. Not sure if we can break it down like this
Sun Sat 10:05

Ok, yeah, I see Walt as having died now. That was weird.
Richard Sat 10:05

Except from Walt not being lynched yesterday :o
Boone Sat 10:05

but sayid claimed he shot walt.
Eloise Sat 10:05

Did Sayid really shoot Walt or was it someone else?
Sun Sat 10:06

Okay everyone - I am a GD. I checked Hurley.
Sayid Sat 10:06

If juliet is now walt, so who did i killd last night?:/ im gonna confusee
Sun Sat 10:06

Hurley was a Witch Hunter.
Boone Sat 10:06

fuck
Sat 10:06

FUCK
Jin Sat 10:06

Huh?
Sun Sat 10:06

^]
Sayid Sat 10:06

I choosed walt to kill
Kate Sat 10:06

did he even claim? :/
Boone Sat 10:06

FUFUUFFUFUFUFUFUFUFFUUCKCKCKCKCK
Eloise Sat 10:06

No.
Desmond Sat 10:06

AAAAAAAAAAAAAAA!!!!!!!!
Eloise Sat 10:06

I'm baffled at his play.
Charlie Sat 10:07

Boone, I was on your side thinking Harpy would be ridiculous, and then it happened. You set the entire thing up
Jin Sat 10:07

Okay, it's unfortunate, but Hurley's play was bad, too
Desmond Sat 10:07

No! HURLEY WAS GOOOD
Sat 10:07

SUN r u lying!???
Boone Sat 10:07

why did he defend Hurley so much?
Sat 10:07

eh walt
Desmond Sat 10:07

(We KILLED AN INNOCENT)
Eloise Sat 10:07

It was suicidal to defend Walt.
MrEko Sat 10:07

um guys i have a question
Desmond Sat 10:07

HE DID DEFEND HIMSELF
Boone Sat 10:07

I said don't vote him :/
MrEko Sat 10:08

neither jack or juliet spoke or voted yesterday??
Desmond Sat 10:08

Yes...
Richard Sat 10:08

I have a feeling MiB is not a good guy
Sat 10:08

He's the first to suggest that Walt might be shrouded
MrEko Sat 10:08

cld they both b puppets?
Desmond Sat 10:08

MiB suggested harpy
Charlie Sat 10:08

Well you can dig me but by then Boone prob be switched out. Look at yesterday's voters for who mentioned Harpy more than naturally (because as a villager I didn't expect it tbh) also dig Walt incase it was a witch swap , if not you get to know what is down
Desmond Sat 10:09

MiB also wanted hurley as second lynch
Sat 10:09

MiB was meeeeeaaaaan
Sat 10:09

MiB is wolf
Richard Sat 10:09

Or coven
Desmond Sat 10:09

(Or some other evil)
Sat 10:09

YessssSSSSssS
Eloise Sat 10:09

Charlie - what other roles self-visit?
MrEko Sat 10:10

alchemist, ss, prot, shaman, tr i think
Desmond Sat 10:10

Booone - why u not say Sun is LYING and u just say Fuck like uve ben found out
Sat 10:10

why Booone!
MrEko Sat 10:10

+++ n1 redirected 2 themself by succubus
Desmond Sat 10:10

What are you getting at???!
MrEko Sat 10:10

ne1*
Boone Sat 10:10

???
Sayid Sat 10:11

:||||||
Richard Sat 10:11

Also, messiah visited himself too
MrEko Sat 10:11

ur right
Eloise Sat 10:11

but that person would then be dead.
Jin Sat 10:11

Des: Boone can't know if Sun was lying. Nobody knows except for GDs or people who knew what Hurley was. Maybe saying 'FUCK' is appropriate if you think it's bad we may have lost a WH.
Moderator Sat 10:11

Richard votes to lynch Charlie
Richard Sat 10:12

As far as we know, Boone is not coven aligned?
Jin Sat 10:12

Charlie would suggest so, but he's in a tight spot
Desmond Sat 10:12

He could be?
Sat 10:12

(Right?)
Jin Sat 10:12

and some people against Boone also would argue that
Eloise Sat 10:12

How would it work?
Charlie Sat 10:12

He claimed purged so only digging me can catch him now tbh
Jin Sat 10:12

My suggestion is: we keep Sun alive at all costs tonight
Sat 10:13

(or any GD for that matter, but one is out now)
Charlie Sat 10:13

Or digging him
Jin Sat 10:13

If Charlie is indeed Vamp, we can exclude Boone being coven
Charlie Sat 10:13

Boone is a puppet
Eloise Sat 10:14

How can you be so sure?
Charlie Sat 10:14

Anyone humoring Boone after the Walt thing should be watched
Sat 10:14

He doesn't go anywhere and I doubt a Djinn , or anything else would claim Seer
MrEko Sat 10:15

doesnt ne1 else think its weird both jack and juliet died??
Charlie Sat 10:15

Ahhh if I could survive one more night I could see if my prot suspect goes to Sun :P too bad
Richard Sat 10:15

Interesting how Jack and Juliet were killed despite being inactive af
Charlie Sat 10:15

If they look Shamany today I'll tell you before nightfall , maybe
Jin Sat 10:15

@Eko: it's a good point to discuss the amount of kills last night too
Desmond Sat 10:15

(I also wanna understand the three kills :( )
Jin Sat 10:16

Let's discuss that
Desmond Sat 10:16

HM?
MrEko Sat 10:16

jack didnt speak d2 juliet didnt speak d2 both died n2
Jin Sat 10:16

Puppers?
Sat 10:16

We have to take into account Sawyer's 'I shot Walt' claim, though
Desmond Sat 10:16

Sayid
Sat 10:16

Not sawyer
Jin Sat 10:16

Sorry
Sat 10:17

Sawyer is in the GY, messed up there x)
Boone Sat 10:17

What I don't get is sayid saying he shot walt, then continued to not trust me :/
Sayid Sat 10:17

:||
Boone Sat 10:18

why did you shoot if you think I'm lying?
Desmond Sat 10:18

(I think like sayid)
Sayid Sat 10:18

Because i was not sure about you but im sure about walt
Boone Sat 10:18

hmm ok
Desmond Sat 10:19

(Walt semmed like a liar)
Sat 10:19

(U could be telling the truth abt Walt, but u cud also be my enemy)
Eloise Sat 10:20

So if we accept Sayid's story, let's look at Jack and Sawyer again.
Sat 10:20

Sawyer spoke and didn't act like a puppet.
Sat 10:20

Juliet could be a puppet who is now looking like Walt.
Jin Sat 10:21

The now-Walt speaking up could help us so much =o
Desmond Sat 10:21

U make no sense Eloise..
Sat 10:22

(My sense sees no sense in Eloise’s sense)
Eloise Sat 10:22

Desmond, I am only not voting to lynch you because I think Charlie is lying, and therefore is a vampire.
Charlie Sat 10:22

They swapped Walt and Walt died as one of those 3 dead is what she means
Desmond Sat 10:22

Hehhehehehehehehehehhe
Eloise Sat 10:22

It is 100% clear to me that Desmond is coven or wolf.
Desmond Sat 10:22

There is reason within my madnes
Sat 10:22

s
Charlie Sat 10:22

Eloise is probably coven
Desmond Sat 10:23

Think and u shall find urself the wiser
Sat 10:23

(Or dont, up to u)
Charlie Sat 10:23

If anyone has evidence to save me/bring down Boone I'd appreciate it
Eloise Sat 10:23

Charlie, tell me again what roles self-visit?
Jin Sat 10:24

Sat 10:23 If anyone has evidence to save me/bring down Boone I'd appreciate it
Naomi Sat 10:24

We really need a way to cut through all the bullshit, how abouts a nice day 3 full role claim
Jin Sat 10:24

Look people, this is when the male Vampire calls out to their Familiar
Naomi Sat 10:24

With all these evils it will definely be amusing
Charlie Sat 10:24

Ones that don't die, or bring us a TR read the next day and self visit particularly on n1: Prot and Shaman -_-
Eloise Sat 10:24

Please no role claim.
Sat 10:24

Without the possibility of a succubus ruled out, that would be suicidal.
Charlie Sat 10:25

Ah yes, my familiar, pls save me ! oh wait.
Naomi Sat 10:25

Assumming people don't lie
Jin Sat 10:26

Sat 10:25 Assumming people don't lie
Sat 10:26

YEAH, LET'S ASSUME SO
Sat 10:26

=)
Eloise Sat 10:26

^
Naomi Sat 10:26

Yay
Charlie Sat 10:27

Hope people think for themselves before jumping on coven bandwagons
Jin Sat 10:27

Naomi, please pick up your sarcasm-meter and hold it over my statement. The sarcasm levels you're measuring should be off the charts
Naomi Sat 10:28

It exploded
Jin Sat 10:28

*oops*
Desmond Sat 10:28

(Booom!)
Naomi Sat 10:30

Desmond what is with the (((()))) your expression does not need them, it is a querky thing that usually shouts puppet puppet puppet
Eloise Sat 10:30

^
Desmond Sat 10:30

(Does she rlly wanna know?)
Sat 10:30

(Should i tell her?)
Eloise Sat 10:31

And it helps if you plan to be swapped or shift. Because then you drop them and hey, you're a totally new character with a totally different style!
Desmond Sat 10:31

My last game i talked allot. Allot of speculation.
Sat 10:31

It got me killed so fast.
Moderator Sat 10:31

Eloise votes to lynch Desmond
Desmond Sat 10:31

(I think () are so safe)
Eloise Sat 10:32

I'm ever so sorry about my cynical tone just now.
Desmond Sat 10:32

So ( ) puts you on trial anyways?
Sat 10:32

They are not safe..
Sat 10:32

I’ll cry now
Sat 10:33

I dont mind quitting them.. but think abt it
Eloise Sat 10:33

Let's think about what Boone would achieve if he was coven.
Desmond Sat 10:33

If im village, im sus enough to keep the evils off my back coz im a good distraction for the villagers
Eloise Sat 10:34

Be quiet for a moment please.
Jin Sat 10:34

Eloise, you have a good point on Desmond's style
Desmond Sat 10:34

In this case i figured villagers wudnt lynch jst coz of ()
Jin Sat 10:34

And please talk about Boone as coven
Sayid Sat 10:34

rp*desmond are you scared of sth? Look at your face*:D
Eloise Sat 10:34

If he was Puppet...
Sat 10:34

He could have shrouded somebody to prove his seer claim and then accuse them of being coven.
Desmond Sat 10:35

So u dont think jack and juliet were puppets?
Eloise Sat 10:35

I mean, his coven colleagues could have shrouded somebody.
Desmond Sat 10:35

Oh u meant boone
Eloise Sat 10:35

But - oh do shut up Desmond!
Sat 10:35

If they shrouded one of their own, the coven hunt would be on themselves.
Sat 10:36

So Boone being coven could only work if he shrouded somebody random, and then accused them of being coven.
Sat 10:36

The shroud would "prove" the coven claim, you see.
Sat 10:36

But Walt wasn't innocent. He lied through his teeth.
Sat 10:37

So if Boone had been coven planning all this... He must have been incredibly lucky to happen on an evil who was also such a poor liar.
Sat 10:37

I think the chances of this are less than 25%.
Moderator Sat 10:38

Sayid votes to lynch Boone
Desmond Sat 10:38

*applause* *standing ovation*
Eloise Sat 10:38

I am saying 25% because with a coven of 4, that is the chance of Walt being shrouded the night before.
Desmond Sat 10:39

Eloise could Boone be wolf?
Eloise Sat 10:39

Sun, if you are really a GD, please dig Juliet tonight. They won't have had a chance yet to swap her (Walt in reality) with someone else again.
Jin Sat 10:40

A piece of text from you is such a relief, Eloise. You're getting to the point, you're showing basic reasoning skills. Beautiful! =)
Desmond Sat 10:40

Now that we know he can be coven, will it be interesting to see of he could be wolf?
Eloise Sat 10:40

Boone could be BH, yes.
Sat 10:40

Which still can find us a vampire
Jin Sat 10:40

But that does mean that Charlie is lying, since he claims Boone is a non-visitor.
Desmond Sat 10:41

And the BH foudn a harpy! And thats why they were worried abt shoruds???
Sat 10:41

Was Walt the harpy? Then we can remember what Eko said?
Moderator Sat 10:42

Sun votes to lynch Charlie
MrEko Sat 10:43

harpy cant shroud themself
Sun Sat 10:43

I can check Juliet, sure.
Desmond Sat 10:43

U mentioned a redirect, works or not?
MrEko Sat 10:44

idk probs but mb ask mod
Eloise Sat 10:44

MrEko Sat 10:10 +++ n1 redirected 2 themself by succubus
Sat 10:44

What does that mean?
MrEko Sat 10:45

u asked who else self visits
Sat 10:45

ne1 redirected 2 themself
Sat 10:45

even nonvisiting roles like villager
Boone Sat 10:46

why would you redirect your own coven n1?
Eloise Sat 10:46

To make them shroud themselves.
Boone Sat 10:47

that's a loooot of effort for?
Eloise Sat 10:47

I know...
Sat 10:47

We must know what "Juliet" was.
Boone Sat 10:47

and sawyer
Eloise Sat 10:48

But that gives the evils as much information as it does us.
Boone Sat 10:48

if Sayid is right, Walt is probably a puppet by now
Eloise Sat 10:49

What are the chances of Jack having died a puppet because of a random N1 PM kill?
MrEko Sat 10:49

yes
Desmond Sat 10:50

So ethan or jacob was a pm?
Sat 10:50

Probably?
Eloise Sat 10:50

Otherwise I think a wolf might have got Jack to see if there was any truth in Walt's vamp claim.
MrEko Sat 10:50

eloise do u rly want the actual chance or what
Sat 10:50

bcoz its about 2 in 25
Eloise Sat 10:50

It was rather a rhetorical question, admittedly.
Jin Sat 10:51

MrEko, now I do want you to give us an exact number.
Desmond Sat 10:51

Jack - Wolf / Juliet - Sayid’s Walt shoot / Sawyer?
MrEko Sat 10:52

well look vamp cant die @ nite so 2 in 24 mb u can argue that a wolf has a smaller chance of dying than ne1 else so then that mb changes it more??
Sat 10:53

+++ mb theres more than 1 vamp
Jin Sat 10:53

(I think the calculation works slightly different - taking into account the amount of non-wolf targets the wolfpack has, plus the amount of non-vamp targets the vamps have (or vamp has))
Sat 10:54

((let's not dive into it))
MrEko Sat 10:54

so then its rly 2 in (25 - num vamps)
Jin Sat 10:54

Nope. But never mind.
Sat 10:54

I think, especially after Eloise's argument, we can safely go for Charlie today.
Sat 10:54

Eloise, you want to join in on the vote as well?
Naomi Sat 10:55

(Mr Eko, why do you use txt spk lyk that? It feels harder thn predictive text?)
Sat 10:55

(makes it harder reading back)
Eloise Sat 10:56

I want to stay on Desmond as a reminder that he is to be lynched as soon as possible. I expect to die soon for having accused so many people, so see it as a legacy...
MrEko Sat 10:56

(naomi its complicated do u rly wanna no??)
Eloise Sat 10:56

I will change it towards nightfall if there seems to be a chance of us missing the lynch.
MrEko Sat 10:57

(complic8ed????)
Libby Sat 10:59

ok caught up I think
Sat 11:00

I still think Boone is BH over seer, but looks like Charlie is likely vamp. wolves want vamps dead too, so makes sense to out him anyway.
Sayid Sat 11:00

Aaaaaaaa it means walt was juliet?
Libby Sat 11:00

Eloise, what was the suspicion on Desmond, was it puppet?
Desmond Sat 11:00

Sheesh i can stop
Moderator Sat 11:00

Sayid votes to lynch Charlie
Libby Sat 11:01

I checked this morning and Walt was dead, can someone break that down with the switch?
Desmond Sat 11:01

Will that stop everyone from killing me?
Sat 11:01

I DO want the village to win fyi
Sat 11:01

Im NOT evil
Moderator Sat 11:01

Libby votes to lynch Charlie
Desmond Sat 11:01

I DID claim village. and will claim again
Libby Sat 11:01

either way Charlie dying is good for the village
Jin Sat 11:02

@Libby: we're not sure, but it was a mistake server-side, so it's hard to say what it is
Libby Sat 11:02

ah ok, so if Walt was coven and switched with Juliet, he's dead anyway right?
Jin Sat 11:02

yes
Libby Sat 11:02

great!
Desmond Sat 11:02

So i should vote for him? R we sure we want to let boone get away for now?
Jin Sat 11:03

Do whatever you want, Des.
Sat 11:03

I'm done with you for now
Libby Sat 11:03

I think Charlie is evil either way. I also think Boone is, but he can wait as the majority aren't sure, no point wasting a vote again when there are puppets in play
Desmond Sat 11:04

Prob is we dont even know wether is boone lying wit either ?
Jin Sat 11:04

I think we can reduce the possible roles for Boone to Seer and BH
Desmond Sat 11:04

..Lying either do we?
Jin Sat 11:04

Point is, if he never finds wolves, we'll be more and more sure he's BH.
Sat 11:04

and if he finds a wolf, there will definitely be a conflict, and other intel roles (like GD) will tell us which one is lying
Eloise Sat 11:04

He won't find wolves now.
Libby Sat 11:04

I thought he'd been 'purged'
Jin Sat 11:05

oh never mind
Libby Sat 11:05

as in, he's claimed purged as an excuse for no longer being helpful to us
Jin Sat 11:05

yeah, the purge - it makes total sense to be purged as Seer, at the same time it's pretty fking convenient x)
Sat 11:05

with you, Lib
Libby Sat 11:05

yep
Charlie Sat 11:10

Lynch the puppet, dig the puppet, apologise for being idiots tomorrow and I'll find you a wolf
Sat 11:12

...and then vamp probably recruits me anyway for Stalker Familiar RIP
Jin Sat 11:12

*please give me another chance at finding a fammy, please please let me live a little longer* =D
Charlie Sat 11:13

I didn't think Jin was coven yesterday but I guess there we go
Libby Sat 11:13

how can you find a wolf? I thought you claimed stalker. you're clutching at straws now... also, how would you know who is a puppet???
Charlie Sat 11:14

Yeah I'm more likely to find a wolf than a pup-uh, purged Seer
Sat 11:14

Libby, do you even read the game? 99% sure Boone is puppet
Sat 11:15

Because I'm not vamp, whether you think I'm still evil or not is up to you
Sat 11:15

The strongest Boone supporters will also be coven, so bring em down
Jin Sat 11:16

Can somebody also suspect me of being Vamp? Then I got my 'evil faction card' full. Already got Coven and Wolf! :D
Sat 11:16

(you can collect a cool sticker at the end of the game if you hand in the card to mod)
Charlie Sat 11:18

I thought I was vamp?
Eloise Sat 11:18

No, you're stalker... aren't you?
MrEko Sat 11:19

[Jin> Sat 11:16 Can somebody also suspect me of being Vamp?
Sat 11:19

ugh fail
Sat 11:19

<Jin> [Sat 11:16] Can somebody also suspect me of being Vamp?
Sat 11:19

hes replying 2 that
Jin Sat 11:19

there can be more vamps in this game. sorted
Eloise Sat 11:20

Let's have ourselves a battle of vampires!
Sat 11:20

But for Charlie's claim to be more credible, it would really help if he revealed his N1 check.
Sat 11:21

If he saw the protector, they can protect themselves again tonight. But all the other roles except TR are evil.
Sat 11:21

And if the TR didn't come out with their check after N1, then...
Jin Sat 11:24

I wouldn't normally go with outing a N1 self-visitor, but since I don't believe Charlie's claim, it's interesting to see what falls out
Sat 11:24

so I agree the claim may be welcome
Charlie Sat 11:27

Oh yea could be more vamps if there were recruits n1 and n2
Sat 11:27

But deaths have been 2 and then 3
Sat 11:32

If there are 3 deaths again tonight it could be 2 vamps
Sat 11:33

Oh yeah I fully plan to out them towards the end of today
Sat 11:34

But say you find a more concrete intel to follow, and I end up outting the prot already
Moderator Sat 12:49

ManInBlack votes to lynch Charlie
ManInBlack Sat 12:51

Hey guys. So vamp huh? Ordinary vamp?
Charlie Sat 12:57

So my prot suspect is now dead :P see why I wanted to hide it now?
MrEko Sat 13:08

who??
Charlie Sat 13:20

Find it yourself lol. There are probably 2 vamps cause our n1 kill didn't go through yet 2 other deaths occurred. I wish mod just gave us more team mates than split it all up like this, how the fk do we fight 20 other players? it's just impossible. Boone played y'all yesterday, and I'm not a Vamp, but since he's prob a puppet you can look at his supporters to find the covens
MrEko Sat 13:20

did i miss smth???
Sat 13:21

r u sayin ur a wolf??
Moderator Sat 13:21

MrEko votes to lynch Charlie
Charlie Sat 13:21

No I'm LemonDord , dig me to find out which one
Moderator Sat 13:23

MrEko votes to lynch Boone
MrEko Sat 13:24

im worried were being led again
Charlie Sat 13:26

Boone is probably shrouded, he got lucky to accidentally guess an evil cus I could have been super lit with nice evidence for all he knew
MrEko Sat 13:27

who did u try and kill n1?
Charlie Sat 13:28

a) Jack b) Saywer or c) Juliet
MrEko Sat 13:28

i choose b
Charlie Sat 13:32

Umm actually it was all a lie, I'm a vamp after all, I forgot
Sat 13:33

Boone is super lit, I'm confirming Boone
Moderator Sat 13:33

Charlie votes to lynch Desmond
MrEko Sat 13:34

i think we shud make sure we dnt lynch some1 random if charlie is shouded ...
Charlie Sat 13:35

Why would they shroud a wolf
Sat 13:35

VAMPIRE**
MrEko Sat 13:36

ur defence is bad like walts we dnt no ur wolf or vampire??
Charlie Sat 13:39

I just really hate covens
MrEko Sat 13:41

i think we need 2 get equal votes on 6 other players 2 b safe f*ck
Sat 13:42

or mb only 5 other
Sat 13:42

worst case is puppet + puppet + silence + shoud + balance + balance ...
Moderator Sat 14:20

Walt votes to lynch Charlie
MrEko Sat 14:20

... walt
Sat 14:22

ur not even gonna comment on yesterday??
Walt Sat 14:43

Haven't read back yet sorry
MrEko Sat 15:17

u dnt need 2 read bk 2 no u didnt get lynched yesterday!
Mikhail Sat 15:26

Hold on, if Sayid is militia and killed Walt, why is Walt alive? Did no one else pick up on Sayid lying?
Sat 15:27

Also, all three deaths last night were silent or very quiet, weird targets don't you think?
Sat 15:28

Also puppets are likely Desmond & Eko, due to overt use of individual language (Desmond and parenthesis, Eko and text speak)
Sat 15:29

Kate supported Boone v quick, so if Boone is BH I put my money on Kate as a nother wolf
Sat 15:29

But seriously, why has no one asked Sayid why Walt is alive if he shot him?
Moderator Sat 15:31

Mikhail votes to lynch Charlie
Eloise Sat 15:32

Mikhail, please read the start of today, especially from Moderator's comment about reloading after the double day opening. Sayid's claim is explained in those comments.
Charlotte Sat 15:32

Militia shoots Walt, Djinn swaps Walt and Juliet = Militia shoots Juliet
Mikhail Sat 15:33

Ah ok
Charlotte Sat 15:34

Would seer/bloodhound know the diff between vamp and fam?
Eloise Sat 15:34

Yes.
Sat 15:35

Do you suspect Charlie might be familiar?
Charlotte Sat 15:35

Oh wait, but there have been no recruits yet right, due to number of kills each night?
Sat 15:35

So if we take him out vamps have gone for good?
Eloise Sat 15:35

What makes you think the vampire hasn't recruited anyone?
Charlotte Sat 15:36

Two kills night one (one vamp one wolf) three kills night two (one vamp, one wolf, one militia)
Eloise Sat 15:36

The first night could be alpha wolf.
MrEko Sat 15:37

or militia
Charlotte Sat 15:37

If it was militia surely they would have said so, and why would militia kill night one?
Sat 15:37

I hadn't considered AW
MrEko Sat 15:37

or messiah
Sat 15:37

or witch
Sat 15:37

or huntsman
Eloise Sat 15:37

Also unlikely for N1.
Charlotte Sat 15:37

Still, night one?
Sun Sat 15:38

AW, probably.
Charlotte Sat 15:38

Possible, but unlikely. I'm going to be optimistic and hope Charlie is the only vamp
MrEko Sat 15:38

mb militia realised it was a mistake and didnt want to admit to it??
Charlotte Sat 15:38

Then they would be disadvantaging the village by not coming forward
Moderator Sat 15:38

Charlotte votes to lynch Charlie
Mikhail Sat 15:41

Eko why would militia shoot n1 and not admit it? Your attempt at confusing the situation unnecessarily supports my thoughts you are a puppet
MrEko Sat 15:42

y u think im a puppet??
Mikhail Sat 15:43

Using text speak - feels like a forced attempt to create an alternative persona when speaking
Sat 15:43

As is Desmond's use of parenthesis
MrEko Sat 15:43

um but y does that make me a puppet??
Eloise Sat 15:43

^
Sat 15:43

I second Mikhail's points.
Mikhail Sat 15:43

It's a trait of puppets - to make them feel like individuals, not an extension of someone else
Sat 15:43

A unique identity
Eloise Sat 15:44

Without a real mind of their own.
MrEko Sat 15:44

y cant i just be a regular person trying on a new personality????
Mikhail Sat 15:44

It was picked up on previously, I'm not sure who, but it made sense
Charlotte Sat 15:45

I clocked the text speak too, although it wasn't me who mentioned it first
Mikhail Sat 15:45

That being said, it doesn't help us locate the PM
MrEko Sat 15:46

so u dont think pm is dead already then?
Mikhail Sat 15:46

No
MrEko Sat 15:46

just coincidence that jack and juliet both didnt speak d2 and died this morning then?
Mikhail Sat 15:47

Yes
MrEko Sat 15:48

ok
Sat 15:48

might b but 2 many coincidences so far for me
Mikhail Sat 15:49

What are the other coincidences?
Sat 15:49

Does anyone else feel weird talking to suspected puppets?
MrEko Sat 15:49

seer finding shrouded player n1?
Mikhail Sat 15:50

There is plenty of suspicion on Boone also, but I don't think anyone is denying Walt was evil, are you?
MrEko Sat 15:51

no?
Sat 15:52

but charlies "confession" reminds me a lot of walts
Mikhail Sat 15:52

So what's your point? That Boone is sus? Because we know that
MrEko Sat 15:52

my point was that im not a puppet
Mikhail Sat 15:52

That's what a puppet would say...
MrEko Sat 15:53

what do u think of my plan 2 balance 5 ways around charlie??
Mikhail Sat 15:54

Why do you want to balance around Charlie?
MrEko Sat 15:55

bcoz we apparently lynched the witchhunter yesterday
Sat 15:55

i dont wanna do the same thing today
Sat 15:55

so we either lynch charlie (if hes not shrouded) or no1 (if he is shrouded)
Mikhail Sat 15:56

If Charlie's lynch doesn't go through it falls on Desmond. Right now, I'm ok with that.
MrEko Sat 15:57

y?
Mikhail Sat 15:57

Because I think he's a puppet aswell
Charlotte Sat 16:02

FYI, I don't like talking to puppets either ;)
MrEko Sat 16:02

gud bcoz im not a puppet :3
Mikhail Sat 16:03

She wasn't speaking to you...
Charlie Sat 17:08

Revive Hurley !!!!!
Sat 17:08

Covens must die
Moderator Sat 17:25

Sayid votes to lynch Boone
Moderator Sat 17:26

Sayid votes to lynch Charlie
Charlie Sat 17:27

SW
Sayid Sat 17:31

I killed night one because I thought maybe wolves kill me
Sat 17:35

And if last night wolves killd me and I didn’t do anything for villagers i hated my self I wasn’t useful for ppl
Sat 17:37

.........
Sat 17:38

And i was sure about walt he was evil and 90% coven
Sat 17:42

If i didnt kill him how you guys could finde real walt
Sat 17:43

I hoped I could do sth good for village
Sat 17:44

Btw one of the evils dead and its not bad
Moderator Sat 18:58

Mikhail votes to lynch Libby
Moderator Sat 18:58

Mikhail votes to lynch Charlie
Mikhail Sat 18:59

Wait. If you killed n1, how did you shoot Walt n2?
MrEko Sat 19:26

he probs meant n2 rather than n2 since most ppl dnt care about d1 & n1
Sat 19:31

rather than n1 ...
Naomi Sat 19:55

Hurley voters(alive) : Ben, Desmond, Jin and Sun
Sat 19:56

Likely a few coven in there
Moderator Sat 19:57

Naomi votes to lynch Desmond
MrEko Sat 19:59

y desmond naomi?
Eloise Sat 20:11

Naomi, I am fairly sure that Ben's vote was on Boone last night. As was Libby's.
Sat 20:12

Mine, however, was on Hurley. And I stand by my reasoning for it, even though I'm appalled at the possibility of having lynched the WH.
Sat 20:13

It absolutely baffles me to think that a witch hunter should have acted in the way he did. He just refused to see that Walt was lying.
Sat 20:15

Maybe he was under the influence of something or other, or thought that by being "edgy" he would survive longer. But his behaviour just went against any normal village attitude.
Sat 20:16

It is such a discrepancy that I would urge any living stalkers to go after Sun because I struggle to believe Hurley could have been a witch hunter.
Sun Sat 20:23

Do you know if there's any way it could have been faked?
Sat 20:24

Djin swaps and the like happen after...
Sat 20:24

I am pretty confused by the result. But he's definetly WH if there's no way to change it.
Eloise Sat 20:25

I know about the djin swaps happening after. This is why I would like a stalker on you because that dig is so unexpected it makes me wonder your legitimacy. Ever so slightly.
Sun Sat 20:25

It makes me wonder my own sanity. But it definetly says WH.
Sat 20:25

He was acting so oddly though.
Sat 20:26

Ugh
Sat 20:26

Why didn't he reveal?
Eloise Sat 20:26

He was not acting like any witch hunter that understood his role properly.
Sun Sat 20:27

Maybe he thought he actually was coven? XD
Sat 20:27

What with the 'witch' in his name.
Eloise Sat 20:33

That or intoxication seems to be the only likely explanation.
Kate Sat 20:47

So what roles have been claimed so far? Militia, Seer, and GD?
Eloise Sat 20:52

Yes, and Witch Hunter - deceased.
Sat 20:52

None of the roles have been 100% confirmed either.
Sat 20:54

But we can deduce with 100% certainty that Juliet (inside Walt) is a puppet unless she is even more off the ball than Hurley was.
MrEko Sat 20:54

so eloise kate & sun
Kate Sat 20:54

?
MrEko Sat 20:55

r u ok with lynching desmond if charlie is shrouded today??
Kate Sat 20:55

im indifferent. I could see him being good or evil tbh
Sat 20:55

i doubt charlie is shrouded today though
Sat 20:55

if he is im inclined to think boone is actually coven
Eloise Sat 20:57

I think MrEko is coven because he is still trying to make us believe that Jack and Juliet both died as puppets, and to create the impression Charlie could be shrouded. Which would be utter nonsense.
MrEko Sat 20:57

im not "trying 2 create the impression" im simply asking r u ok if he is
Eloise Sat 20:58

So, Protector and Stalker on Sun tonight. Sun digs Juliet to find out what Walt was. And I hope I see the light of day.
Sat 20:59

The number of people I've accused!
Moderator Sat 20:59

It will soon be night...
Eloise Sat 20:59

Ben, Desmond, MrEko, Libby...
Sat 20:59

Juliet inside Walt...
Lynched Sat 21:00

Charlie was lynched by the village
Moderator Sun 09:00

The cockerel stirs...
Killed Sun 09:00

Richard was killed during the night
Killed Sun 09:00

Libby was killed during the night

Your role: Observer

The Village

Graveyard

Spoiler free day archives