-
Replay
You are viewing day 6 of a game of werewolves started on the 17-Jan-16 Mon on a 24 hour cycle (12h day, 12h night).
This is a spoiler free version, use the user button (top menu) to see who was alive at the time, and the calendar button or links below the chat to navigate through to different days.
You can play a game of online Mafia by joining the game currently in sign up. New players are welcome, but try to be active!
-
-
Wickerbottom
Sat 09:00
Werepid does not use witchcraft
-
Sat 09:00
We wasted a day for nothing
-
Deerclops
Sat 09:00
Thanks for the confirmation.
-
Wickerbottom
Sat 09:01
Oh shii no one dies
-
Deerclops
Sat 09:01
We also have no kill, though.
-
Werepig
Sat 09:01
so then yesterday must have been a witch potion?
-
Sat 09:01
no kills o.o
-
Deerclops
Sat 09:01
So this is tricky, but we're on a good path here.
-
Werepig
Sat 09:01
but the game didn't end when we lynched tusk
-
Deerclops
Sat 09:01
Indeed
-
Sat 09:01
There's still evil among us.
-
Wickerbottom
Sat 09:01
(Looking at seal)
-
Werepig
Sat 09:01
could seal have been the witch and we lynched our reviver? D:
-
Sat 09:02
fuck i'm so sorry tusk
-
Wickerbottom
Sat 09:02
Nice wand you have there, Seal
-
Deerclops
Sat 09:02
There are still multiple options
-
Werepig
Sat 09:02
got a theory deer?
-
Deerclops
Sat 09:02
It could also be that our pairing has forced a killing role to not use its ability
-
Werepig
Sat 09:03
good point
-
Deerclops
Sat 09:03
Before going off into theories, I would like to hear from all pairs to confirm each other
-
Werepig
Sat 09:03
we need intel to show up
-
Sat 09:03
i want woodlegs to confirm my guard before i say it
-
Deerclops
Sat 09:03
Because based on what Wicker and I now know, you could still be a killing wolf - but Woodlegs should be able to confirm you can't be
-
Sat 09:03
Yes, please do wait
-
Werepig
Sat 09:03
well woodlegs will clear me when he gets on :)
-
Wickerbottom
Sat 09:04
Here's what we need to do: Lynch Seal. If it doesn't end: Lynch the stalkers as they can be the familiar
-
Sat 09:04
*drops mic*
-
Werepig
Sat 09:04
but who is the vamp then? o.o
-
WX78
Sat 09:05
MORNING FLESH
-
Wickerbottom
Sat 09:05
Could be Wigrid
-
Sat 09:05
*Wigfrid urgh
-
Deerclops
Sat 09:05
@Wicker: if the pairs all add up, I agree that lynching Seal seems the best option.
-
Sat 09:05
I also agree that the stalkers are our first suspects for familiars
-
Wickerbottom
Sat 09:05
@WX78 HELLO WORLD
-
Werepig
Sat 09:06
i really wish we had a gd for this -_-
-
WX78
Sat 09:06
WORLD MEANINGLESS. LIFE MEANINGLESS. FLESH WASTEFUL.
-
Wickerbottom
Sat 09:06
I used to be the GD as Werepig in the last DS theme ;-;
-
Werepig
Sat 09:07
omg coincidence
-
Sat 09:07
i wish i had known there was a ds theme earlier
-
Sat 09:07
i love it so much
-
Wilson
Sat 09:07
I shot the fake seer
-
Sat 09:07
can remember
-
Wickerbottom
Sat 09:07
You're the Hm @Wilson
-
-
Wilson
Sat 09:07
in the last one
-
Werepig
Sat 09:07
oh in the ds game?
-
Sat 09:07
lol sorry,
-
Sat 09:08
tired werepig strikes again
-
Wickerbottom
Sat 09:08
The lovely Catcoon
-
Wilson
Sat 09:08
mr "Trust" seer
-
Wickerbottom
Sat 09:08
it was ext-068 if you wanna reread
-
Werepig
Sat 09:08
i've been playing horror games with friends for the last three hours
-
Sat 09:08
i'm shakey and exhauseted @.@
-
Sat 09:08
thanks wicker!
-
Wickerbottom
Sat 09:09
:D
-
Sat 09:09
But i think ext 068 is broken on the slowatch page
-
Sat 09:09
It never loads
-
Werepig
Sat 09:09
it doesn't have a replay either D:
-
WX78
Sat 09:10
REQUEST: WHO DID WILSON STALK?
-
Wickerbottom
Sat 09:10
You can try this page: http://www.slowatsch.ch/archived_games/reader.html
-
Werepig
Sat 09:10
you, i think?
-
Sat 09:10
thank youuuuu!
-
Wickerbottom
Sat 09:11
You're welcome :D
-
Sat 09:12
What horror games did you play anyway :D
-
WX78
Sat 09:12
REQUEST: WILSON, WHICH FLESHING DID WX78 PROTECT?
-
Werepig
Sat 09:12
lots of dead by daylight
-
Sat 09:12
it's addicting
-
-
Werepig
Sat 09:12
68 wont load D:
-
Wilson
Sat 09:12
In the salt mine?
-
-
Wilson
Sat 09:13
@WX I wanna wait for legs, but I think the plan was "suboptimal"
-
Sat 09:14
We left out seal :S
-
WX78
Sat 09:14
PLAN BETTER THAN NOTHING AT THIS STAGE.
-
Wilson
Sat 09:14
Also I wanted to point out that the Wicker/Deerclops part was ehm...
-
Sat 09:15
But I followed the plan
-
Sat 09:15
laid out by our deer
-
Werepig
Sat 09:16
i hope legs gets on soon
-
Sat 09:16
i wanna sleep
-
Sat 09:17
this game is awful on my sleep schedule
-
Deerclops
Sat 09:18
@Wilson: you were supposed to stalk WX, no? You can already confirm his protect? Or do you want to do it simultaneously with Woodlegs?
-
Woodlegs
Sat 09:18
Sorry. I'm here
-
Deerclops
Sat 09:19
@Wilson: the part where Wicker confirms me again was, in restrospect, indeed suboptimal - but she was the only one who would see my check if I were killed last night.
-
Sat 09:19
OK. Stalkers: you want to go ahead and confirm your targets?
-
Werepig
Sat 09:19
yaaaaaaay
-
Wilson
Sat 09:20
So what is the most optimal order?
-
Deerclops
Sat 09:20
Perhaps both stalkers first say where their target went
-
Woodlegs
Sat 09:20
Can do
-
Deerclops
Sat 09:20
then both protective roles state their (dis)agreement
-
Sat 09:20
Go ahead, I'd say
-
-
Woodlegs
Sat 09:21
Werepig visited me.
-
-
Sat 09:21
i was afraid of being framed by witch @.@
-
WX78
Sat 09:21
SUGGESTION: IF ALL CLAIMS ARE CORRECT. WILSON AND/OR SEAL ARE EVIL FLESH.
-
Deerclops
Sat 09:21
Why specifically Wilson?
-
Sat 09:22
@Wilson: go ahead and say where WX went?
-
Werepig
Sat 09:22
tho now that i think on it, both hm and proc are useless against witch anyway, gdi
-
WX78
Sat 09:22
IF PROTECTION WORKED. WOLF WOULD KNOW WHO WAS PROTECTED.
-
Wilson
Sat 09:22
Woodlegs
-
Sat 09:22
Which was not to plan I think?
-
WX78
Sat 09:22
WILSON IS CORRECT
-
Werepig
Sat 09:22
really? o.o
-
Sat 09:22
wow we think alike
-
Deerclops
Sat 09:23
Haha, Woodlegs had a robot and a evil pig as bodyguards last night
-
Sat 09:23
no wolf in his right mind would go there
-
Werepig
Sat 09:23
lol, no hounds you mean
-
Sat 09:23
by game logic
-
Woodlegs
Sat 09:23
If we have a familiar, I presume they're aware? I couldn't be an unknowing familiar?
-
-
Deerclops
Sat 09:24
I'm unfamiliar with the game, so I wouldn't know Werepig
-
Sat 09:24
@Woodlegs: you'd definitely know
-
Werepig
Sat 09:24
never been a fam, but don't they talk at night?
-
Deerclops
Sat 09:24
they do, right?
-
Werepig
Sat 09:24
deer u should play ds
-
Sat 09:25
so what are the odds seal is a potionless witch rn?
-
Deerclops
Sat 09:25
65,1111111%
-
Sat 09:25
x)
-
Werepig
Sat 09:25
...oddly specific
-
Sat 09:25
xD
-
Deerclops
Sat 09:25
MY ONE EYE SEES THE WORLD IN PURE MATHS
-
Sat 09:26
(sorry, stealing RP from WX now)
-
Sat 09:26
anyway
-
Wilson
Sat 09:26
so what we learn from this
-
-
Wilson
Sat 09:26
: fuck plans -_-
-
Deerclops
Sat 09:26
haha, you and your objection against plans
-
Sat 09:26
at least we didn't get a setback
-
Werepig
Sat 09:26
wilson -_-
-
Deerclops
Sat 09:26
that's some clarity
-
WX78
Sat 09:27
WX78 CALCULATING SCENARIOS. WILSON IS WOLF. PAIRINGS ARE EVIL. SEAL IS EVIL. OR COMBINATION.
-
Wickerbottom
Sat 09:27
OPEN THE DAMN VOTE
-
-
Sat 09:27
I don't get it
-
Wickerbottom
Sat 09:27
Please :3
-
WX78
Sat 09:27
IF WOLF IN PLAY. HIGH CHANCE OF WOODLEGS DECAPITATION TONIGHT.
-
Werepig
Sat 09:27
wait if he stalked you how can he be wolf? o.o do wolves have a stalking role now?
-
Wilson
Sat 09:27
Why am I wolf when I stalked you?
-
Werepig
Sat 09:27
lol jinx
-
Woodlegs
Sat 09:27
How would Evil Wilson know WX visited me?
-
Wilson
Sat 09:28
guessing according to WX?
-
Wickerbottom
Sat 09:28
Plot twist: there is only 1 witch left and all the villagers are overthinking
-
Werepig
Sat 09:28
i'm really hoping that you're right wickers
-
Sat 09:28
cause i'm also starting to be afraid someone is playing us hardcore
-
WX78
Sat 09:29
NOT ACCUSATION. SUGGESTING WOLF ATTACKED SAME TARGET AS WX78 PROTECTED THEN WOLF WOULD KNOW PROTECTION TARGET. UNLIKELY. BUT VALID SCENARIO.
-
Woodlegs
Sat 09:29
I think we have to vote for Seal today
-
Sat 09:29
Wouldn't Werepig have killed them in that scenario?
-
Werepig
Sat 09:29
ohhh okay wx, i get what you're saying
-
-
-
Sat 09:29
yeah duh I'm hm jfc
-
Deerclops
Sat 09:29
I made sure that mod added this to huntsman H2P
-
Werepig
Sat 09:29
god i am too TIRED for this shit
-
Deerclops
Sat 09:29
If protector and huntsman protect same target
-
Sat 09:29
hunstman triggers over protector
-
Sat 09:29
so Wilson attacking Woodlegs is basically excluded
-
Sat 09:29
because they're both still alive
-
Sat 09:30
Let's kill the Seal
-
Werepig
Sat 09:30
are we seriously just overthinking this istg
-
Deerclops
Sat 09:30
Probably
-
Werepig
Sat 09:30
agreed deer
-
Woodlegs
Sat 09:30
Theoretically, Werepig could be a Wolf who tried to kill me but I was protected by WX, but that seems reasonably fringe case.
-
WX78
Sat 09:30
WX78 NOT AWARE. REMOVING WILSON AS WOLF FROM SCENARIO
-
Wilson
Sat 09:30
thx buddy
-
Deerclops
Sat 09:30
@Woodlegs: agreed
-
Werepig
Sat 09:31
woodlegs, didn't you stalk me before too tho? ytou've seen me visit another guard
-
Sat 09:31
i mean i guess i could have been a non killing wolf who got promoted
-
Woodlegs
Sat 09:31
Yes, I think it requires a SS into you as well
-
Sat 09:32
This wasn't an accusation, just a note that it wasn't formally impossible.
-
Werepig
Sat 09:32
well i don't think i'm that hard to play so i can see where you're coming from @.@
-
Sat 09:32
np, i getcha
-
Wilson
Sat 09:32
what I enjoy about this round is the level of activity. ^^
-
Woodlegs
Sat 09:32
I'm big on outlining all possibilities and then deducing from there.
-
WX78
Sat 09:33
SUGGESTION: LYNCH SEAL. TONIGHT ROTATE PAIRING. IF CORRECT STATEMENTS: LYNCH DEERCLOPS AND SCIENCE MACHINE.
-
Wilson
Sat 09:34
I agree on seal for the moment. Still feeling guilty though
-
Deerclops
Sat 09:34
what do you mean with 'correct statements'?
-
Sat 09:34
(@WX)
-
Wilson
Sat 09:34
I thought I'm super smart about not checking him...
-
Werepig
Sat 09:34
yeah, i'm so sorry for lynching tusk instead of seal -_-
-
Deerclops
Sat 09:34
I surely do agree that, if it comes to another night, we should have other pairs.
-
Wilson
Sat 09:34
Well tusk could still be evil
-
Deerclops
Sat 09:34
I should be confirmed by a stalker instead of just Wicker
-
Werepig
Sat 09:34
WX, you mean legs on you and wilson me, or do you want to split up deer and wicker?
-
Deerclops
Sat 09:34
split us up
-
Werepig
Sat 09:34
good idea deer
-
Woodlegs
Sat 09:35
I think WX is correct. Either Werepig and I are Evil together, WX and Wilson are, or Deerclops and Wicker must be.
-
Sat 09:35
These are the only remaining possibilities after Seal.
-
Werepig
Sat 09:35
okay afer i vote seal, i am going to bed. so any plan you guys make i'll read when i get up
-
Wickerbottom
Sat 09:36
D:
-
Werepig
Sat 09:36
good points guys. i do really hope we're just overthinking it and seal is the last one left
-
Wickerbottom
Sat 09:36
I AM YOUR MOTHER WX
-
Sat 09:36
YOU DOUBT YOUR OWN MOTHER
-
Woodlegs
Sat 09:36
Same, Werepig, same
-
WX78
Sat 09:36
IF SEAL NOT EVIL. IMPLIES PAIRING EVIL. STALKER SWITCH TARGETS. CROSS CONFIRM. IF CORRECT STATEMENTS: FURTHER PROOF OF ROLE. DEERCLOPS/SCIENCE MACHINE PAIR LOCKED. ONLY VARIABLE WHICH AGREES WITH PARITY
-
Sat 09:38
STALKERS CONFIRM: CONFIRMS TWO PAIRS. REMAINING PAIR IS EVIL AND COOPERATED
-
Deerclops
Sat 09:38
Exactly
-
Sat 09:38
you could even make it so (if I may suggest another plan): I check Wicker and Wicker checks me, Wilson/Woodlegs check Wicker and me (one on either of us), while the protectors protect the stalkers.
-
Sat 09:39
just from the top of my head, we'd have to see if there are some weak spots in this plan
-
WX78
Sat 09:39
SCIENCE MACHINE IS FLESH. FLESH MUST DIE.
-
Werepig
Sat 09:39
i'll go with whatever plan you guys think of, i'm not good at making them
-
WX78
Sat 09:39
EMPATHY MODULE REMAINS INOPERABLE. NOT APOLOGETIC.
-
Wickerbottom
Sat 09:39
D:
-
Deerclops
Sat 09:40
If we agree that we've pinpointed the evil down to Seal or Wicker/Deerclops, my suggested system should work.
-
Werepig
Sat 09:40
wait deer
-
Deerclops
Sat 09:40
The only thing that is can't really account for/look into is familiars
-
Werepig
Sat 09:40
that plan can't work, we both were on the same person
-
Sat 09:40
the stalkers woudn't both be protected
-
-
Woodlegs
Sat 09:40
Yup, I am almost certainly on my last (wood)legs
-
-
Wilson
Sat 09:40
that pun was great sir Woodlegs
-
-
Sat 09:41
that pun just made me 10x more tired, thankls
-
Sat 09:41
xD
-
-
Wickerbottom
Sat 09:41
I think i'll make some more character to this theme
-
WX78
Sat 09:41
WX78 DOES NOT UNDERSTAND. WOODLEGS HAS WOODEN LEGS. WHY WOULD WOODLEGS NOT BE ON WOODEN LEGS?
-
Wickerbottom
Sat 09:41
any suggestion @Werepig :D
-
-
Sat 09:42
give me my pyro plz
-
Wickerbottom
Sat 09:42
Pyro: noted
-
-
Woodlegs
Sat 09:42
@WX Because the Wolves are going to use them as toothpicks when I have been consumed.
-
Wickerbottom
Sat 09:43
What about the white goat? What will they use it for
-
WX78
Sat 09:43
INEFFICIENT USE OF LEGS. WOODLEGS WOULD BE A GOOD BARBECUE. FUEL IS SUPPLIED.
-
-
Sat 09:44
just gonna put out there for the record i'm pretty sure werepig meat is inedible...
-
Wickerbottom
Sat 09:45
(1 pig skin and 2 meat are too valuable for me)
-
Sat 09:45
(Staring at werepig while holding a spear)
-
WX78
Sat 09:45
ERROR: DEERCLOPS PLAN IS INOPERABLE. WOODLEGS WILL CERTAINLY DIE TONIGHT. WOODLEGS IS OLD AND UNPROTECTED.
-
-
Sat 09:45
wickers
-
Sat 09:45
wickers please
-
Sat 09:45
i've been a good pig D:
-
Woodlegs
Sat 09:46
Get off me pig
-
Wickerbottom
Sat 09:46
I need...a solution.... for my hunger.....
-
WX78
Sat 09:46
THATLL DO WEREPIG. THATLL DO.
-
Werepig
Sat 09:46
........
-
Sat 09:46
okay that made me crack the fuc k up thank you wx
-
Sat 09:47
are robots like onions?
-
Sat 09:47
(i know the orig quote isn't shrek but thats all i can think of when i see it)
-
Woodlegs
Sat 09:47
WX is right to an extant that I will likely not be here to confirm WX's visit
-
Moderator
Sat 09:55
WX78 votes to lynch Seal
-
Werepig
Sat 09:56
oh man i can sleep now
-
Sat 09:57
night guys
-
Moderator
Sat 09:57
Werepig votes to lynch Seal
-
Moderator
Sat 09:57
Wilson votes to lynch Seal
-
Moderator
Sat 09:57
Woodlegs votes to lynch Seal
-
Moderator
Sat 09:58
Wickerbottom votes to lynch Seal
-
Wickerbottom
Sat 09:58
Yay
-
WX78
Sat 09:59
LOADING AUDIO: "I COMPARE YOU TO A KISS FROM A ROSE ON THE GRAY"
-
Sat 10:01
"OOOOH THE MORE I GET OF YOU THE STRANGER IT FEELS YEAH"
-
Sat 10:02
NOW THAT YOUR ROSE IS IN BLOOM. A LIGHT HITS THE GLOOM ON THE GRAY.,
-
Sat 10:04
QUESTION: IS ROSE A MANDRAKE? AUDIO IS BORING AND MAKING WX78 ENTER SLEEP...
-
Moderator
Sat 10:29
Deerclops votes to lynch Seal
-
Deerclops
Sat 10:30
Haha, appropriate, WX78, quoting a Seal-song ::D
-
Seal
Sat 14:33
This is what greets me when i get home from work
-
WX78
Sat 14:37
SEAL MUST PROVIDE CONJECTURE FOR NOT LYNCHING SEAL.
-
Sat 14:38
ONE OF THREE PAIRING IS EVIL AND/OR SEAL IS EVIL.
-
-
Sat 14:39
I'll just was this of the infallible paring you were apart of. Hm wouldn't trigger a kill for vamp.
-
Sat 14:39
Pairing
-
WX78
Sat 14:41
ALTERNATIVE SUGGESTION WHICH FITS SCENARIO: WEREPIG IS WOLF.
-
Seal
Sat 14:41
I've been saying that all along
-
Sat 14:42
But he didn't know who you would protect
-
Wilson
Sat 14:42
That's wrong
-
Sat 14:43
Vamp hitting HM doesn't result in a kill
-
Seal
Sat 14:43
I thought wx didn't
-
Sat 14:43
Exactly
-
Sat 14:43
Im saying there could be a vamp that target wood still
-
WX78
Sat 14:43
WOLF WOULD KNOW BY VIRTUE OF WOLF TARGET BEING PROTECTED.
-
Sat 14:44
LINE OF REASONING IS UNLIKELY HOWEVER
-
Sat 14:44
WEREPIG WAS OKAY WITH DEERCLOPS PLAN. NO DEFENSE.
-
-
Sat 14:44
Its unlikely
-
WX78
Sat 14:44
NO WAY FOR WEREPIG TO KNOW WX78 PROTECTION TARGET. WEREPIG STRATEGY WOULD DEPEND ON SELECTING CORRECT TARGET OR WEREPIG WOULD BE FOUND OUT.
-
Seal
Sat 14:45
But his name is WEREpig
-
WX78
Sat 14:45
FALL BACK TO INITIAL SCENARIO
-
Sat 14:45
SEAL IS EVIL FLESH AND/OR ONE PAIRING IS EVIL
-
Sat 14:46
SEAL MUST BE WITCH IF THIS IS CASE. HOWEVER: NO EVIDENCE OF WITCH DISINTEGRATION OR COVEN ACTIVITIES. ONLY DEFENCE FOR SEAL.
-
Seal
Sat 14:49
My defense is you guys have no proof I'm evil. You keep making these stupid confirmation circles and leavinf me out. Now that i can't revive I'm just a useless vanillager. I gursbtee that there is true evil still lurking.
-
WX78
Sat 14:49
ADDITIONAL DEFENCE FOR SEAL. SCIENCE MACHINES PUSH FOR SEALCLUBBING
-
-
WX78
Sat 14:50
CONJECTURE: DEERCLOPS IS WOLF. SCIENCE MACHINE HAS BEEN SUPERIMPOSED ONTO WOLF FLESH.
-
Seal
Sat 14:51
Tell me, hypothetically, if I'm a witch. Jow did everyone else die? Who was the wolf/ vamp?
-
WX78
Sat 14:51
FITS PARAMETERS OF CURRENT SCENARIO
-
Sat 14:51
NO EVIDENCE OF VAMPIRE
-
Seal
Sat 14:52
Ok. Lets break it down. We lynched tusk, wigfrid, walani, and gobbler.
-
WX78
Sat 14:52
ONE KILL PER NIGHT. EXCEPTION: NIGHT ONE - WX78 PROTECTED SELF. NIGHT FOUR - TWO DEATHS.
-
Seal
Sat 14:53
Warly was killed by wh
-
Sat 14:53
Wendy died twice overnight and max died overnight
-
Sat 14:53
I have one potion
-
Sat 14:53
As a witcg
-
Sat 14:54
So who committed the other 2 murders???
-
Woodlegs
Sat 14:55
We've stalked Werepig three times between me and Wilson. What's he up to if fake?
-
Sat 14:55
Deer claims he killed Maxwell
-
WX78
Sat 14:56
ONE UNACCOUNTED DEATH EACH NIGHT WITH EXCEPTION TO NIGHT ONE AND FIVE.
-
Woodlegs
Sat 14:57
I guess Werepig could be a Wolf, who tried to kill me, knowing I was stalking him. If I died, he claims he visited Wilson, no corroboration possible. However, the question remains what was he up to the other nights when visiting people who didn't die?
-
Seal
Sat 14:58
You guys may be in on it. Or a different pair. Even if i was a witch. The game won't end by lynching me. And I'm not a evil
-
Woodlegs
Sat 14:58
Who are you suggesting is in on it?
-
Seal
Sat 14:59
Okay if were is evil, wilson is prolly in on it
-
WX78
Sat 14:59
ONLY NIGHT WHEN NO FLESH WAS DECAPITATED WAS NIGHT ONE. WX78 PROTECTED WX78. REASONABLE CONCLUSION IS WOLF CREATURES ATTEMPTED TO EAT GEARS.
-
Seal
Sat 14:59
If wicker is evil, clopse is in on it
-
Woodlegs
Sat 14:59
My questions might be coming across harshly here, Seal, which is not my intention
-
Seal
Sat 14:59
Nope. Not harsh
-
Woodlegs
Sat 15:00
I'm trying to solve this game, and I need you to convince me of a scenario that is more likely than you being Evil.
-
WX78
Sat 15:00
SCIENCE MACHINE AND DEERCLOPS: 99% CERTAINTY THAT FLESH ARE ALLIES.
-
Woodlegs
Sat 15:00
For me to believe Wicker is Evil, he HAS to have been SS into, his stuff on the first day with Wendy and Wilson and me was too real.
-
Seal
Sat 15:01
I can't prove I'm not evil thanks to wilson. All i can prove is that there are worse things then a witch to worry about.
-
WX78
Sat 15:01
AGREEMENT WITH WOODLEGS.
-
Woodlegs
Sat 15:01
I might take some time to go through and pull all the claims forward. But I hate doing that stuff :'(
-
WX78
Sat 15:02
FLESH SUPERIMPOSING WOULD OCCUR NIGHT 3+ AS PROTECTION WAS ACTIVATED NIGHT TWO AND ZERO DEATH NIGHT ONE.
-
Seal
Sat 15:03
Lol!!! Me too. These stupid stalker circles are confusing. I don't feel like thinking throught after being at work all night
-
Woodlegs
Sat 15:03
I'M GOING IN
-
WX78
Sat 15:04
SCIENCE MACHINE/DEERCLOPS THEORY WOULD REQUIRE EXPLANATION OF DOUBLE DEATH NIGHT FOUR. SUGGESTION: DEERCLOPS: GREEDY ALPHA WOLF FLESH.
-
Seal
Sat 15:35
Ugh read day 2 took forever. You people talk too much.
-
Woodlegs
Sat 15:53
I'm onto today!
-
Sat 15:53
50 MINUTES?
-
Sat 15:53
sob sob sob
-
Sat 15:57
RIGHT
-
Sat 15:57
On N1 there was no kill and on D2 the following claims were made:
-
Sat 15:57
Woodlegs stalked Werepig who visited Wilson
-
Sat 15:58
Wicker beheld Wendy stalking WX who visited himself
-
Sat 15:58
Wilson stalked WX who visited himself
-
Sat 15:58
WX protected himself
-
Sat 15:58
Werepig protected Wilson
-
Sat 15:59
Deerclops viewed Wilson as not magic user
-
Sat 15:59
Wendy stalked WX who visited himself
-
Sat 15:59
Mactusk claimed reviver
-
Sat 15:59
Warly (claimed on D3) viewed Walani as not magic user
-
Sat 15:59
We lynched Gobbler
-
Sat 16:00
-
Sat 16:00
On N2 Wendy was killed and on D3 the following claims were made:
-
Sat 16:00
Woodlegs stalked Walani who visited Wicker
-
Sat 16:00
Wilson stalked Seal who visited no-one
-
Sat 16:01
Wicker beheld Wilson stalking Seal
-
Sat 16:01
Deer viewed Woodlegs as not magic user
-
Sat 16:01
Walani visited Wicker (only known from Woodlegs's claim)
-
Sat 16:01
Werepig claimed Huntsman and protected WX
-
Sat 16:02
Seal claims reviver
-
Sat 16:02
WX protected Wicker
-
Sat 16:02
Warly claimed witch hunter viewing Deer as magic user
-
Sat 16:02
Wigfrid claimed grave digger and that Gobbler was Djinn
-
Sat 16:03
Maxwell claimed tarot reader
-
Sat 16:03
Wendy stalked Walani who visited Wicker
-
Sat 16:03
We lynched Walani
-
Sat 16:03
-
Sat 16:04
On N3 Maxwell was killed and Wendy was revived and on D4 the following claims were made:
-
Sat 16:04
Woodlegs stalked Wigfrid who visited no-one
-
Sat 16:04
Seal revived Wendy
-
Sat 16:04
Deer viewed Warly as magic user
-
Sat 16:05
Wicker beheld Deer view Warly
-
Sat 16:05
WX protected Wilson
-
Sat 16:05
Wilson stalked Werepig who visited Deerclops
-
Sat 16:05
Werepig protected Deer
-
Sat 16:05
We lynched Wigfrid
-
Sat 16:05
-
Sat 16:06
On N4 Wendy and Warly were killed and on D5 the following claims were made:
-
Sat 16:06
Woodlegs stalked Warly who visited no-one
-
Sat 16:07
Wicker beheld Woodlegs stalk Warly
-
Sat 16:07
Wilson stalked Woodlegs who visited Warly
-
Sat 16:07
Deer killed Warly
-
Sat 16:07
Werepig protected ??? (haven't seen a claim)
-
Sat 16:07
We lynched Mactusk
-
Sat 16:07
-
Sat 16:08
On N5 no one was killed and on D6 the following claims were made:
-
Sat 16:08
Werepig protected Woodlegs
-
Sat 16:08
WX protected Woodlegs
-
Sat 16:08
Wilson stalked WX visiting Woodlegs
-
Sat 16:08
Woodlegs stalked Werepig visiting Woodlegs (lololol)
-
Sat 16:08
Deer viewed Werepig as not magic user
-
Sat 16:09
Wicker beheld Deer viewing Werepig
-
Sat 16:09
-
Sat 16:09
-
Sat 16:09
So that's it all
-
Sat 16:09
Can anyone see any inconsistencies?
-
Sat 16:11
Or build any conspiracies?
-
Sat 16:12
Walani's visit to Wicker on N2 is still unexplained and given we lynched Walani unclaimed, I have to assume they were Evil.
-
Sat 16:13
Deer projected Maxwell's death as SS move
-
Sat 16:14
If Wendy's first death had been a SS into someone and we then revived Wendy, who would Wendy be? The person who was shifted into? Because if so, we can rule out Wendy as ever having been a SS.
-
Sat 16:21
Well. I'm out from 5pm on the lash, so not likely to be around for much coherent discussion later.
-
Moderator
Sat 16:22
WX78 votes to lynch Wickerbottom
-
Woodlegs
Sat 16:22
*Eyebrow*
-
WX78
Sat 16:23
REDIRECTING VOTE. WX78 UNSURE SEALCLUBBING IS CORRECT ACTION.
-
Woodlegs
Sat 16:23
I've noticed I'm missing your action from N4 too WX
-
Sat 16:24
If you think Wicker is Evil, you must assume Deer is too.
-
WX78
Sat 16:24
WX78 PROTECTED WX78. DID NOT MAKE PUBLIC DUE TO UNWANTED TARGETING.
-
Sat 16:25
AT PRESENT MOMENT SUSPICION ON SCIENCE MACHINE AND DEER IS HIGH. SUSPICION ON SEAL IS HIGH.
-
Woodlegs
Sat 16:26
No issue with delayed reveal, just realised I didn't have it.
-
Sat 16:28
I'm still trying to figure out the roleset
-
Sat 16:30
If we have Coven in the game, what do we think we would have had?
-
Sat 16:31
Because I can't see puppets and puppetmaster anywhere. I can't see Succubus anywhere. So we could have Witch/Djinn/Shaman. But there have been too many night deaths for them to exist on their own.
-
Sat 16:32
So we must have either Wolves or a Vamp. Coven more likely in a Vamp based game, just to increase the numbers available
-
Sat 16:36
Theoretically, Walani could have been Alpha and tried to kill Wendy and Wicker, which would make sense since they verified each other on D2.
-
Sat 16:37
No-one has reported action failure, so Direwolf seems unlikely.
-
Sat 16:40
14 to me would need more than 3 Wolves, if just Wolves in game. But if one Alpha and two Shifters, does that power it up enough? If that's the world though, Wigfrid and Walani were almost certainly Evil and we have a Shifter left somewhere? I guess Maxwell could have shifted into Seal under the assumption that Wilson was going to stalk Seal and thus be a cleared vanilla?
-
Sat 16:40
Sorry guys, I'm pretty much going to have to EXTINGUISH (wink wink) my efforts today, as I need to head out and I think this is pretty much it for me.
-
Sat 16:42
Given we know that, if the game doesn't end with Seal's death, that a pairing is Evil, we still have numbers tomorrow, but have to guess right. I would suggest that is Wicker and Deer and would go there.
-
Wickerbottom
Sat 17:00
Ez ez
-
Sat 17:01
i behold Wilson tonight again
-
Sat 17:01
And i will say my result tmr
-
Sat 17:01
If he is legit, maybe there is a familiar or WX could be the Shaman
-
Deerclops
Sat 18:31
I think Coven is pretty unlikely because we've also seen no Djinn-swaps, right? Vamp is unlikely because there are only single kills (apart from me killing Warly). So I think it's a bunch of wolves, and I hope we're nearly there.
-
Sat 18:32
I understand that the pair Deer/Wicker is a bit more suspicious than the other pairs, so I invite you all to plan something (or renegade something, whatever) that would help confirm us. I can help with the thought process but I can also stay out of it
-
WX78
Sat 18:34
IF CONFIDENT OF NO COVEN. WHY LYNCH CONFIRMED REVIVING ROLE. REDUCES VILLAGE NUMBERS.
-
Sat 18:35
IF CONFIDENT OF NO COVEN. KEEP SEAL ALIVE UNTIL INFORMATION CONFIRMS OTHERWISE.
-
Deerclops
Sat 18:35
I think somebody presented a theory that Seal is shifted into
-
WX78
Sat 18:35
THEORY ALSO PRESENT WITH SCIENCE MACHINE
-
Sat 18:35
LITTLE EVIDENCE.
-
Sat 18:36
SUGGESTION: DO NO LYNCH SEAL
-
Deerclops
Sat 18:36
@WX: I'm willing to listen to your no-lynch scenario
-
Sat 18:36
but please do present a good plan about how it moves us forward
-
WX78
Sat 18:37
REASONING: IF SEAL IS COVEN. PARITY EXISTS AGAINST WOLF ROLE. HOWEVER OBSERVATION SUGGESTS SEAL NOT COVEN
-
Sat 18:37
REASONING: WX78 INCLINED TO BELIEVE SPECIFIC PARING IS EVIL.
-
Sat 18:38
CORRECTION: PAIRING
-
Sat 18:39
STATEMENT: ONE PAIRING EVIL SCENARIO MORE LIKELY THAN COVEN SCENARIO.
-
Sat 18:39
EVIDENCE: APART FROM CONFIRMED REVIVE NO OTHER DETECTED COVEN ACTIVITY REPORTED
-
Sat 18:41
CONFLICT OBSERVED: WITCH HUNTER ROLE SUGGESTS COVEN.
-
Sat 18:42
CONCLUSION: BETWEEN COVEN BEING PRESENT AND PAIRING EVIL. LESS ASSUMPTIONS REQUIRED FOR EVIL PAIRING.
-
Deerclops
Sat 18:42
I'm not sure I believe one pairing is more likely than Seal being shifted into. I understand that the ways that Wicker and myself are confirmed are not water-tight right now, but there's quite some checks and checks that we've carried out, also separately
-
WX78
Sat 18:42
LEAST ASSUMPTIONS BETWEEN CONFLICTING HYPOTHESIS SHOULD BE FOCUSED.
-
Deerclops
Sat 18:42
I applaud the attempt to confirm Wicker and/or me, but I don't think that we are necessarily very suspicious
-
Sat 18:43
Less assumptions?
-
Sat 18:43
So were Wicker and I evil from the start?
-
Sat 18:43
how would it work
-
Sat 18:43
Woodlegs created a fine list of actions, please work your way through it
-
WX78
Sat 18:44
WX78 DID NOT STATE SUCH. WX78 SUGGEST ONE OF THE THREE PAIRS ARE MORE LIKELY EVIL THAN SEAL BEING COVEN
-
Deerclops
Sat 18:45
I'm not sure, actually
-
Sat 18:45
So much has happened to see where the possible gaps are lying
-
Sat 18:45
What you'd want to prove would be actually: p(Seal = coven) + p(Seal = wolf) < p(Existence of an evil pair)
-
Sat 18:46
(What I mean to say is that in order for the lynch on Seal to be not the way forward the combined chance of her being Wolf or Coven should be smaller than the existence of an evil pair)
-
WX78
Sat 18:47
CORRECT. HOWEVER EVIDENCE DOES NOT WEIGH MORE AGAINST SEAL COVEN.
-
Sat 18:47
BOTH ARE DISPUTED HYPOTHESES.
-
Sat 18:47
CONJECTURE: SEAL COULD BE SUPERIMPOSED WOLF.
-
Sat 18:48
EVIDENCE: NONE. REASONING: REVIVER SAFE ROLE TO SUPERIMPOSE.
-
Sat 18:48
HOWEVER: SEALS REVIVER CLAIM WAS DISPUTED FROM MOMENT ROLE WAS REVEALED.
-
Sat 18:49
QUESTION: WHY WOULD WOLF FLESH SUPERIMPOSE ON FLESH ALREADY UNDER SUSPICION?
-
Sat 18:49
ALTERNATIVE: SCIENCE MACHINE IS SUPERIMPOSED
-
Sat 18:50
EVIDENCE: NONE. REASONING: CHANGES IN BEHAVIOUR NOTED.
-
Sat 18:50
SCIENCE MACHINE VALID TARGET. HAS BEEN TRUSTED SINCE DAY TWO.
-
Sat 18:50
SAFE TARGET
-
Sat 18:52
UNSUPPORTED CONJECTURE: DEERCLOPS CLAIMED WITCHHUNTER AS SAFE CLAIM DUE AS ROLE REVEAL WAS PROMPT.
-
Sat 18:53
ONLY DAY WHERE DEERCLOPS WAS STALKED WAS DAY WARLY WAS DECAPITATED. THIS DOES NOT PROVE OR SUPPORT DEERCLOPS CLAIM AS WARLY COULD HAVE BEEN DESTROYED BY WOLF CREATURE.
-
Deerclops
Sat 18:54
You have made your case against the two of us. I understand your reasoning.
-
Sat 18:54
Can you give me your thoughts on the other pairs?
-
Sat 18:54
Are they more or less exempt from suspicion right now?
-
WX78
Sat 18:55
UNSUPPORTED CONJECTURE: SCIENCE MACHINE SUPERIMPOSED. WOULD MAKE DEERCLOPS CONSTRAINT VALUABLE TO WOLF ALLIANCE.
-
Sat 18:55
ADDENDUM: SUPERIMPOSED POST DAY 3
-
Deerclops
Sat 18:55
Because if there's only one pair that's under scrutiny, it's pretty easy to check - the four of you on Wicker and me
-
Sat 18:55
Lynching Seal also has the following advantage: we only have the pairs to check
-
Sat 18:56
we can focus on that and there can be no other variables
-
Sat 18:56
assuming that yesterday's pairing made an evil pair, we can always make it so that tonight's pairs are only half-evil
-
WX78
Sat 18:57
WX78 SUSPECTED WEREPIG. HOWEVER TODAYS FINDINGS FROM WOODLEGS PROVIDES SUPPORT FOR WEREPIG.
-
Sat 18:57
LITTLE SUSPICION OF WILSON AS CORRECTLY STATED WX78 PAIRING.
-
Sat 18:58
SUBJECTIVE PERSPECTIVE: STALKER PAIRING HAS STRONGER SUPPORT FOR VILLAGE ROLES THAN SCIENCE MACHINE/DEERCLOPS COMBINATION.
-
Sat 18:59
UNABLE TO PROVIDE OBJECTIVE PERSPECTIVE AT THIS MOMENT IN TME.
-
-
WX78
Sat 18:59
HOWEVER SHOULD NOT BE ELIMINATED FROM ENQUIRY
-
Deerclops
Sat 18:59
So if we lynch Seal, there's 6 of us left. Worst case: 4 village, 2 wolves. If wolves still have a double kill up their sleeves, it's over, but I think it's safe to assume that's gone.
-
Sat 19:00
(if I were wolf, for example, I used it on Warly)
-
Sat 19:00
That means that, if we design the right system of checks for tonight
-
Sat 19:00
there will always be a 3v2 situation for village
-
Sat 19:00
they lynch the right person, and the game will end with 2 villagers standing last
-
WX78
Sat 19:01
CORRECT. HOWEVER REQUIRES CO-OPERATION BETWEEN VILLAGERS.
-
Sat 19:02
SUGGESTION: LYNCH DEERCLOPS. SAME SCENARIO AS LYNCHING SEAL.
-
Sat 19:03
WITCH HUNTER HAS NO VALUE IN VILLAGE AT MOMENT
-
Sat 19:03
ROLE WOULD NOT BE MISSED
-
-
Sat 19:03
you better work on that empathy module
-
Sat 19:04
I see your reasoning, but I do think I at least deserve to not be killed today
-
Sat 19:04
at least in comparison to Seal
-
Sat 19:04
*no offence*
-
WX78
Sat 19:05
P(WOLVES) > P(COVEN)
-
Sat 19:05
IF SEAL OR SCIENCE MACHINE WOLF. SKILL NO LONGER AVAILABLE.
-
Sat 19:06
ANALYSIS LEADING NO WHERE. REDACT PREVIOUS STATEMENT.
-
Deerclops
Sat 19:06
You're overheating your processors! :D
-
Sat 19:07
Well, although only Wicker can see my exact observation at night, a stalker could at least see the person I visited, and confirm that I've not killed that person
-
Sat 19:07
I guess the same would hold for Wicker
-
-
Sat 19:08
SCIENCE MACHINE LYNCH ALSO POSSIBILITY. HOWEVER SCIENCE MACHINE ROLE EASIER TO DISPROVE THAN WITCH HUNTER.
-
Sat 19:09
SUGGESTION: SCIENCE MACHINE BEHOLDS WILSON. PROTECTION ON WILSON. WILSON SELECTS RANDOM TARGET.
-
Deerclops
Sat 19:09
Optimal setting would be: both me and Wicker on the same stalker, the other stalker is protected by both prot and HM, One stalker on me, other stalker on Wicker.
-
WX78
Sat 19:10
REASONING: WOODLEGS CERTAIN TO DIE THIS NIGHT. NO HARLOT PRESENT. ONLY WAY TO FIND WOLF WOULD IS TO STALK KILLING FLESH.
-
Deerclops
Sat 19:10
One person can only die, so one stalker at least can survive, which can either incriminate or redeem either Wicker or me.
-
Sat 19:10
The other must die.
-
Sat 19:10
The setup also allows prot and HM to guard each other the next night
-
Sat 19:10
Since Woodlegs is already exposed, we might as well choose Woodlegs as the target for me and Wicker
-
Sat 19:11
Your idea would also work, although there's a chance Wicker guesses it right of course
-
Sat 19:11
What do you think of my idea? Do you think it would work, or do you see shortcomings?>
-
WX78
Sat 19:11
INCORRECT. STILL ALLOWS AMBIGUITY BETWEEN PAIRING.
-
Sat 19:12
ALLOWS COLLUSION TONIGHT TO COUNTERACT STRATEGY.
-
-
Sat 19:12
I must've made an error in reasoning
-
WX78
Sat 19:14
ALLOW TIME FOR ANALYSIS
-
Deerclops
Sat 19:14
My reasoning: assuming that the evils are Wicker and/or me, one of us would be a killing role tonight. If we target one of the protectors (WX/Werepig), both stalkers are there to verify who visited whom. If we target one of the stalkers, only one stalker is there to verify a suspect. If that suspect visited the person that's dead, you lynch the suspect. If that suspect did not visit the person that's dead, you lynch the other.
-
WX78
Sat 19:17
SAME STRATEGY APPLIES FOR SEAL + ONE OF PAIRING.
-
Sat 19:18
IF DEERCLOPS/SCIENCE MACHINE INSTEAD LYNCHED. STRATAGEM ALSO APPLIES.
-
Deerclops
Sat 19:18
it seems you are bent on keeping seal alive. Can you explain why my plan would not be desirable?
-
WX78
Sat 19:19
I DO NOT CARE FOR SEAL.
-
Deerclops
Sat 19:19
If they are similar, why should we choose one system over the other?
-
WX78
Sat 19:20
IF PAIR COHESION IS REAL. LYNCHING ONE OF THE PAIR CREATES SITUATION WHERE IF PAIR IS IN COLLUSION AND FOUND OUT. ONLY REQUIRES ONE LYNCH TO WIN EVENT.
-
Sat 19:20
IF LYNCH SEAL AND PAIR IS FOUND TO BE IN COLLUSION. REQUIRES TWO DAYS TO LYNCH TARGETS
-
Sat 19:21
IF PAIR IS TOWN ALIGNMENT. REQUIRES ONE DAY TO LYNCH SEAL.
-
Deerclops
Sat 19:21
sounds fair
-
Sat 19:22
Obviously I'm biased here, but I think Wicker has been acting more strangely than I have, so my suggestion would be to lynch her
-
Sat 19:22
her rather than me, at least - I'm still curious to hear from others
-
WX78
Sat 19:22
LYNCH SCIENCE MACHINE THEN. WX78 DOES NOT CARE FOR WHO.
-
Sat 19:22
AGREEMENT WITH DEERCLOPS. REQUIRES INPUT FROM OTHER FLESHLINGS
-
Sat 19:24
CONJECTURE: IF SCIENCE MACHINE AND DEERCLOPS ARE TOWN ALLIGNED. WILL ALLOW SCIENCE MACHINE TO REPAIR EMPATHY MODULE TO APOLOGISE.
-
Deerclops
Sat 19:25
Cheers x)
-
WX78
Sat 19:25
CONJECTURE: IF SCIENCE MACHINE AND DEERCLOPS ARE EVIL ROLES: INSERT LAUGH HERE
-
-
Wilson
Sat 19:25
That was a lot of reading
-
Sat 19:26
Hmm, I guess I'm the person who pointed out some weird bias towards lynching the seal from wickers yesterday.
-
Sat 19:28
WX78 is basically applying my "play it safe" tactics. Avoid one side getting the advantage.
-
Sat 19:28
I often suggest to lynch one of each side to keep the balance
-
Sat 19:28
And I think we can talk of sides when it's seal vs wickers
-
Deerclops
Sat 19:29
FYI: Wicker did get my check right this morning, although Werepig was the most/only logical choice for me tonight
-
Sat 19:29
But other than this reamrk I do agree with what is said
-
Wilson
Sat 19:30
I also see wickers point. The rest of us stalked/beheld/protected each other for days now. And Seal is the "easy" solution, but also probably the easiest target.
-
Sat 19:30
Target I mean; Target to frame
-
WX78
Sat 19:39
ADDENDUM TO STRATAGEM: REMAINING MEMBER OF PAIR VISITS WOODLEGS. IF WOODLEGS SURVIVES. DEFENDANT IS SAFE AND SEAL SHOULD BE LYNCHED. IF REMAINING MEMBER DOES NOT VISIT OR WOODLEGS IS DECAPITATED UPON VISIT. EVIDENCE OF WOLF ACTIVITY.
-
Wilson
Sat 19:40
So you wanna switch WX?
-
Deerclops
Sat 19:40
Sounds good. One stalker on remaining member, other stalker on Seal
-
Wilson
Sat 19:40
eh want us to switch?
-
WX78
Sat 19:42
SUGGESTION: WILSON TARGETS REMAINING MEMBER. WOODLEGS STALKS SEAL. WX78 PROTECTS WILSON. WEREPIG PROTECTS WX. REMAINING MEMBER TARGETS WOODLEGS.
-
Wilson
Sat 19:43
Sounds like a plan. God I hate plans but everything else is leading us nowhere.
-
Moderator
Sat 19:43
Deerclops votes to lynch Wickerbottom
-
Deerclops
Sat 19:43
If I may suggest a target for tonight then...
-
Moderator
Sat 19:44
Wilson votes to lynch Wickerbottom
-
Wilson
Sat 19:44
3:3 is bad..
-
Deerclops
Sat 19:45
definitely. If nobody tips over the balance I'll revert to Seal
-
Sat 19:45
but let's wait a moment
-
Sat 19:45
Werepig is bound to come online soon?
-
WX78
Sat 19:45
REASONING IF WX78/FLESHING IS DESTROYED: WEREPIG/WOODLEGS ARE EVIL. IF WOODLEGS/NO ONE IS DESTROYED: TOWN CAN DEDUCE BETWEEN SEAL/DEERCLOP AND WILSON/WX78 PAIRING.
-
Sat 19:46
STRATAGEM CONFIRMS/DISCREDITS EVERY PARTY. ANY VARIANCE FROM STRATAGUM SHOULD BE TAKEN WITH CONTEMPT.
-
Woodlegs
Sat 19:54
WTF? Get on Seal
-
WX78
Sat 19:55
CONJECTURE: IF TIE - LYNCH SEAL. WILSON/WOODLEGS TARGET UNKNOWN FLESHING. SCIENCE MACHINE: TARGET WILSON. WEREPIG: TARGET WILSON. WX78 PROTECT WEREPIG.
-
Sat 19:59
ADDENDUM: WX78 WILL TARGET WILSON. WILL ENSURE WILSON SURVIVAL TO CONFIRM SCIENCE MACHINE.
-
-
Seal
Sat 20:01
Hooe! Sweet hope!
-
WX78
Sat 20:01
POSSIBLE REDACTMENT OF PREVIOUS STATEMENT. REQUIRES SCENARIO TO CLEAR WOODLEGS/WEREPIG COMBINATION.
-
Moderator
Sat 20:01
Seal votes to lynch Wickerbottom
-
Woodlegs
Sat 20:01
I'm too drink
-
WX78
Sat 20:01
WOODLEGS. IF POSSIBLE PLEASE READ STATEMENT.
-
Woodlegs
Sat 20:02
I've read it and think I understand, but if the Evil pairing is not Wicker/Deer, we're boned
-
Seal
Sat 20:02
Why do you guys think I'm a wolf? I revived someone..... the claim that I'm a witch I understand, but wolf makes no sense
-
Woodlegs
Sat 20:02
This is true
-
WX78
Sat 20:04
CORRECT. HOWEVER: WOODLEGS ANALYSIS AND PREVIOUS NIGHTS RESULTS = PROBABILITY OF DEERCLOPS/SCIENCE MACHINE COMBINATION BEING EVIL HIGHER THAN WOODLEGS/WEREPIG OR WILSON/WX78
-
Sat 20:05
IF SCENARIO WHERE SEAL IS NOT EVIL. STILL REQUIRES STRATEGY TO ELIMINATE THE SUSPECT PAIRING.
-
Woodlegs
Sat 20:06
Yeah, but if we mislynch today and then try and sell Seal as the REAL Evil tomorrow, we lose
-
Werepig
Sat 20:06
whoa what did i miss? o.o
-
WX78
Sat 20:06
SEE ABOVE. LYNCHING SCIENCE MACHINE OR DEERCLOPS ACCOUNTS FOR PROBABLE SCENARIO
-
Werepig
Sat 20:06
better read fast
-
Woodlegs
Sat 20:06
You guys would wait til now :p
-
WX78
Sat 20:08
CORRECT. BASED ON YOUR ANALYSIS OF SITUATION. EITHER WOODLEGS IS EVIL AND GIVING VILLAGE FINAL CHANCE. OR IS VILLAGE AND SUSPECTS WX78/WILSON PAIRING MORE THAN DEERCLOPS/WICKERBOTTOM PAIRING.
-
Sat 20:09
DOES NOT MATTER TO WX78.
-
Woodlegs
Sat 20:09
I think I probably trust Werepig and Wilson more
-
Sat 20:10
But I can't possibly believe that Wicker and Deer were Evil from the start.
-
WX78
Sat 20:10
AGREE WITH SCIENCE MACHINE. DO NOT AGREE WITH DEERCLOPS
-
Sat 20:12
WITCHHUNTER IS EASY TO CLAIM ROLE IN THIS SCENARIO AS LARGE PERCENTAGE OF CLAIMS WERE ANNOUNCED DAY 2. ONLY EVIDENCE TO CONFIRM DEERCLOPS ROLE DOES NOT CONFIRM OR DISCREDIT DEERCLOPS. ONLY CONFIRM DEERCLOPS HAS KILLING POTENTIAL.
-
Woodlegs
Sat 20:12
That's true
-
Sat 20:12
:/
-
Deerclops
Sat 20:13
@WX: you suspect that I might've been evil from the start?
-
WX78
Sat 20:13
TO SUSPECT DEERCLOPS/SCIENCE MACHINE PAIR IS TO IMPLY THIS POINT.
-
Woodlegs
Sat 20:14
How did Deerclops kill Warly then?
-
WX78
Sat 20:14
BY INFERENCE: WX78 DOES SUSPECT DEERCLOPS.
-
Woodlegs
Sat 20:14
And Warly was thus legit?
-
Sat 20:14
Cripes
-
WX78
Sat 20:15
WOODLEGS: BY ASSUMING DEERCLOPS IS WOLF. ONLY CONCLUSION FOR KILL IS ALPHA STRIKE
-
Woodlegs
Sat 20:15
So what was Walani?
-
Sat 20:15
I'm being told off for being antisocial
-
Sat 20:16
:'(
-
Sat 20:16
I'm just going to have to trust you guys.
-
Deerclops
Sat 20:16
@Woodlegs: I think you're asking the right questions
-
Sat 20:16
I think WX is overheating perhaps
-
Woodlegs
Sat 20:16
Hang on, Deer is voting Wicker?
-
Sat 20:17
WTF?
-
WX78
Sat 20:17
CONJECTURE: IF DEERCLOPS/SCIENCE MACHINE ARE VILLAGE ALIGNED. THEN WILL BE ABLE TO CONFIRM TOMORROW.
-
-
Deerclops
Sat 20:17
I'm not sure anymore
-
Sat 20:17
Perhaps Seal is the better way to go
-
Sat 20:17
bah
-
WX78
Sat 20:18
AS MENTIONED. IF SEAL LYNCHED AND DEERCLOPS/SCIENCE MACHINE ARE GOOD. VICTORY.
-
Sat 20:18
IF SEAL IS GOOD: NO PLAN FOR TOMORROW. ONE PAIRING IS DECPETIVE. LIKELY WOLF VICTORY
-
Sat 20:18
CORRECTION:DECEPTIVE.
-
Werepig
Sat 20:19
good lord that was an ightmare to read through
-
WX78
Sat 20:19
REQUIRES TWO DAYS AND CORRECT ASSESSMENT FOR VILLAGE VICTORY
-
Sat 20:19
IF ONE OF PAIRING IS LYNCHED. WILL BE ABLE TO CONFIRM IF SEAL/REMAINING MEMBER IS EVIL.
-
Deerclops
Sat 20:19
How exactly?
-
Sat 20:19
What if we are not the evil pair>
-
Sat 20:20
Then we have Seal to worry about and another pair
-
WX78
Sat 20:20
OR OTHER PAIR.
-
Werepig
Sat 20:20
okay so wx what you're saying is: in case deer and wickers are an evil pair, it's better to lynch one today and plan to either lynch the other or seal tomorrow? o.O
-
WX78
Sat 20:20
WEREPIG: AFFIRMATIVE.
-
Sat 20:21
WX78 ATTEMPTING TO PROVIDE SOLUTION BETWEEN TWO LIKELY SCENARIOS
-
Deerclops
Sat 20:21
Perhaps I must revert to an earlier plan
-
Sat 20:21
We lynch Seal, and the other pairs check us
-
Moderator
Sat 20:21
Deerclops votes to lynch Seal
-
Deerclops
Sat 20:21
So stalkers on Wicker/me, and prots on one of these 4
-
WX78
Sat 20:22
WX78 HIGHLY DOUBTFUL OF COVEN INVOLVEMENT AS NO EVIDENCE TO SUGGEST THIS.
-
Werepig
Sat 20:22
i guess i can see your point? but i don't know if wickers being slightly off is enough to be ss
-
Sat 20:22
i'm gonna try to skim wickers really qucik from the last few of days, just to be sure
-
WX78
Sat 20:22
WHY DOES VILLAGE SUSPECT SEAL? SEAL CONFIRMED TO VILLAGE AS REVIVING ROLE.
-
Deerclops
Sat 20:23
But what about me?
-
Sat 20:23
AM I NOT CONFIRMED AS WITHC HUNTER?
-
Sat 20:23
DOES SEAL REALLY HAVE MOR EVIDENCE SPEAKING FOR HER THAN ME?
-
Sat 20:23
same for Wicker
-
WX78
Sat 20:23
AS MENTIONED BY WOODLEGS AND WX78. UNLIKELY SEAL IS WOLF. BUT EVIDENCE SUGGESTS SEAL IS COVEN.
-
Sat 20:24
DEERCLOPS SHOWS LITTLE EVIDENCE OUTSIDE CONFIRMING KILL ROLE.
-
Sat 20:24
LOADING MANUSCRIPT.
-
Sat 20:24
QUOTING DEERCLOPS: "understand it's for the greater good"
-
Deerclops
Sat 20:24
that statement could be used on Seal as well
-
WX78
Sat 20:25
QUESTION: EVIDENCE OF SEAL BEING COVEN OR WOLF.
-
Sat 20:25
ALLOW FOR: ZERO COVEN ACTIONS NOTIFIED BY VILLAGE
-
Sat 20:26
ALLOW FOR: WHY SEAL MUST BE LYNCHED TONIGHT?
-
Sat 20:26
ALLOW FOR: UNLIKELY TARGET FOR WOLVES DUE TO PERSISTENT THREAT OF LYNCH.
-
Sat 20:27
WX78S CONCLUSION: SEAL UNLIKELY TO BE COVEN. SEAL UNLIKELY TO BE WOLF. ERGO: SEAL IS LIKELY VILLAGER. VILLAGER SHOULD NOT BE LYNCHED
-
Deerclops
Sat 20:29
I don't think your story doesn't make sense, but at least I have some sense of overview if we lynch Seal and the game is continuing
-
WX78
Sat 20:30
LIKEWISE IF WE LYNCH SCIENCE MACHINE OR YOURSELF.
-
Sat 20:30
LIKEWISE IF FLESHINGS LYNCH NO ONE
-
Deerclops
Sat 20:32
@WX: if you think it's all equal, why are we still having this conversation?
-
Sat 20:32
I'm not sure it is equal
-
Sat 20:32
but if you are, then let's leave it as is
-
Sat 20:32
I don't think I'm going to change my vote now
-
Werepig
Sat 20:34
okay wx u have the checks right? i have a question
-
Sat 20:34
did any stalkers stalk wickers on n3 or n4?
-
Sat 20:36
wx?
-
WX78
Sat 20:36
ACCORDING TO WOODLEGS REPORT: NEGATIVE
-
-
Werepig
Sat 20:37
okay i scrolled back to the report and looked myself xD
-
Sat 20:37
it looks like wickers hasn't been stalked since maxwell died
-
Sat 20:37
if, IF we think it might be an ss
-
Sat 20:37
i noticed something a little odd
-
Deerclops
Sat 20:39
What is that?
-
Wilson
Sat 20:39
So we stay on seal?
-
Deerclops
Sat 20:39
Depends...
-
Werepig
Sat 20:39
wickers was to behold deer n3, the night maxwell died. but we already had planned for deer to check warly, so if wickers was ss'ed, it'd be a 50/50 on guessing right, if deer isn't evil, and if deer is evil then they could collude
-
Deerclops
Sat 20:39
Werepig has something to say
-
Wilson
Sat 20:39
Sry I can't keep up with the seep.
-
Sat 20:39
*speed
-
Werepig
Sat 20:39
and then for wickers n4 behold, she TOLD woodlegs who to stalk while she beheld him
-
Sat 20:40
so there's no way to confirm if she actually saw him do anything
-
Deerclops
Sat 20:40
and my behold was also pretty obvious (she also said 'check Werepig, deer' somewhere)
-
Werepig
Sat 20:40
and deer said earlier that wickers guessing his behold was easy
-
Deerclops
Sat 20:40
so that does add up
-
Werepig
Sat 20:40
lol jinx
-
-
Sat 20:40
OK
-
Werepig
Sat 20:40
i haven't read day 5/6 yet tho so there might be some proof for her i missed
-
Sat 20:41
but this is a pattern and i don't like it
-
Deerclops
Sat 20:41
Wicker has been less active as the granny leading the village strategy
-
Sat 20:41
since that time
-
Werepig
Sat 20:41
does anyone have a counter argument incase i missed something?
-
Deerclops
Sat 20:41
Something has changed a bit, indeed
-
Sat 20:41
OK
-
Sat 20:41
I'm with you
-
Werepig
Sat 20:41
ii wanna look at this from all sides
-
Deerclops
Sat 20:41
So also with WX
-
Sat 20:41
So how do we do this
-
-
Moderator
Sat 20:41
Werepig votes to lynch Wickerbottom
-
Deerclops
Sat 20:41
if we lynch Wicker tonight
-
Sat 20:41
what is the system?
-
Sat 20:41
You guys still want to check me?
-
Sat 20:42
How about I use my ability on Seal?
-
Werepig
Sat 20:42
i'm not sure, but we should find a way to prove you
-
Deerclops
Sat 20:42
And somebody stalks me
-
-
Sat 20:42
i think that works?
-
Sat 20:42
stalkers, what do you think?
-
Deerclops
Sat 20:42
Perhaps both should stalk me, so that at least one survivor lives to tell the story
-
Sat 20:42
(I'm just afraid I'm missing something here, so I want to be careful)
-
WX78
Sat 20:43
REVIVER WILL APPEAR AS MAGIC USER.
-
-
Deerclops
Sat 20:43
of course
-
-
Sat 20:43
i think?
-
Wilson
Sat 20:43
he could kill him to prove it... with protection on him?
-
Werepig
Sat 20:43
kill seal?
-
Deerclops
Sat 20:43
What do you mean?
-
Werepig
Sat 20:43
how does that work
-
Wilson
Sat 20:43
It's just a thought
-
Deerclops
Sat 20:43
That would take another day though
-
Wilson
Sat 20:43
yeah forgot that :(
-
Deerclops
Sat 20:43
mod might go for enforced lynch in the meantime :P
-
WX78
Sat 20:43
SUGGESTION: DEERCLOPS TARGETS STALKER FROM PAIR HE SUSPECTS MOST. IF STALKER EVIL. WILL NO LONGER BE A NON MAGIC USER.
-
-
Moderator
Sat 20:44
Deerclops votes to lynch Wickerbottom
-
Deerclops
Sat 20:44
Back to Wicker for now
-
Werepig
Sat 20:44
deer are you okay with that plan?
-
-
Werepig
Sat 20:45
okay, do we want me and wx on anyone specifc, or jusr to choose who to protect/guard?
-
Seal
Sat 20:45
So that leaves unconfirmed and on the chopping block again. Anyone stalking me?
-
WX78
Sat 20:46
SUGGESTION: WOODLEGS STALK DEERCLOPS. WILSON STALK SEAL.
-
Deerclops
Sat 20:46
Woodlegs is exposed tonight, though
-
-
Deerclops
Sat 20:46
I'm trying to make everything fit, so that there are no more loose ends
-
Werepig
Sat 20:46
would that worjk wx?
-
WX78
Sat 20:46
HOWEVER YOU WILL BE ABLE TO CONFIRM YOUR ROLE WHEN I PROTECT SEAL TOMORROW
-
Deerclops
Sat 20:47
OK so I will check Seal tonight
-
Sat 20:47
Seal can't do a thing (if all is well)
-
Sat 20:47
WX will protect somebody from the set {WX, Werepig. Wilson}
-
Werepig
Sat 20:47
okay if we're good i need to feed my cats real quick
-
Sat 20:47
brb
-
-
WX78
Sat 20:47
IF KILL OCCURS TONIGHT. WILSON WILL CONFIRM IF SEAL OR NOT. WX78 WILL PROTECT WILSON. ENSURING SEAL IS EXPLOSED/CONFIRMED.
-
Deerclops
Sat 20:47
EXPLOSED :d
-
WX78
Sat 20:48
CORRECTION: EXPOSED.
-
Sat 20:48
WORST SCENARIO IS NO FLESH IS DECAPITATED. BUT THIS GIVES TIME TO CALCULATE SECOND STRATAGEM
-
Deerclops
Sat 20:48
I would say that Werepig protects Wilson, WX protects self
-
Sat 20:48
Werepig can't 'protect self'
-
Sat 20:49
my version would allow you two to protect each other tomorrow
-
WX78
Sat 20:49
ACCEPTABLE.
-
Deerclops
Sat 20:49
Alright
-
Sat 20:49
So in overview:
-
Sat 20:49
Deer -> check Seal
-
Wilson
Sat 20:49
there's no way we can save woods
-
-
WX78
Sat 20:49
UNLESS NO FLESH IS DESTROYED TONIGHT.
-
Wilson
Sat 20:50
I just say that both protection roles have the same limits
-
Deerclops
Sat 20:50
WX -> protect self. Seal -> stay put. Wilson -> stalk Seal. Deerclops -> check Seal. Werepig -> protect Wilson. Woodlegs -> check Deer
-
-
Sat 20:52
okay i can do that
-
Seal
Sat 20:53
Just saying, this plan does nothing to confirm deer
-
WX78
Sat 20:53
ONLY ALTERNATIVE WOULD BE DEERCLOPS SELECT RANDOM TARGET. WOODLEG CONFIRMS.
-
Seal
Sat 20:53
He knows i use magic, we all saw ot
-
Sat 20:53
Woodlegs is dying tonight...
-
Deerclops
Sat 20:54
if game continues, probably
-
Sat 20:54
so how would people prove me?
-
Sat 20:54
Fact is, even if I were not WH I could fabricate all checks by now
-
Sat 20:54
(based on what people presume to be, anyway)
-
Seal
Sat 20:54
Well will could stalk you but then no one to prove me :/
-
Werepig
Sat 20:54
deer has a point D:
-
Deerclops
Sat 20:55
So I will check Seal
-
Werepig
Sat 20:55
but wait, the only evil role seal could be is wtich, right?
-
-
Werepig
Sat 20:55
since they can definitely revive
-
Deerclops
Sat 20:55
or she could be SS'd into after she was a legit Reviver
-
Werepig
Sat 20:55
is witch kill visible to stalkers?
-
WX78
Sat 20:55
DEER COULD HAVE FABRICATED CHECKS FROM DAY TWO. EARLIER POINT OF WX78.
-
Werepig
Sat 20:55
tru but that would mean we had 2 ss
-
-
Seal
Sat 20:55
Exactly. Totally pointless. Deer check whoever
-
Deerclops
Sat 20:55
So I will check Seal tonight
-
-
Deerclops
Sat 20:55
And if I need to prove myself, I could always kill her, even though she's protected
-
Sat 20:56
perhaps it will come that far
-
Seal
Sat 20:56
Lol. At least that means i wont be lynched tomorrow
-
Werepig
Sat 20:56
so, check seal and then kill her the next night with both me and wx on her?
-
Sat 20:56
that'd take a while
-
Deerclops
Sat 20:56
somethig like that
-
Werepig
Sat 20:56
i guess it's better then nothing
-
Deerclops
Sat 20:56
at least something that excludes me as a non-WH
-
Sat 20:57
seriously: I really hope that Wicker's lynch heralds the end of this game
-
Sat 20:57
this is going over my head by now x)
-
Werepig
Sat 20:57
yeah i don't think there's another role that can visit and not kil, then visit and kill?
-
Sat 20:57
or maybe i'm wrong but this is confusing xDD
-
Deerclops
Sat 20:58
there is none
-
Sat 20:58
the only other event, from the top of my head
-
Sat 20:58
is when a person has reverted from DW/BH to regular werewolf in between the two visits
-
Woodlegs
Sat 20:58
For God's sake, don't kill me you Evil gits, I'm a disabled old man :(
-
Werepig
Sat 20:58
woodlegs i'm sorry we doubled down D:
-
WX78
Sat 20:59
WX78 NOT SORRY. EMPATHY MODULE STILL NOT RESPONDING.
-
-
Lynched
Sat 21:00
Wickerbottom was lynched by the village
-
Killed
Sun 09:00
Woodlegs was killed during the night
-