ext-128 Day 8 | Forum Werewolf Game

Replay

You are viewing day 8 of a game of werewolves started on the 17-Apr-01 Sat on a 24 hour cycle (12h day, 12h night).

This is a spoiler free version, use the user button (top menu) to see who was alive at the time, and the calendar button or links below the chat to navigate through to different days.

You can play a game of online Mafia by joining the game currently in sign up. New players are welcome, but try to be active!
Fluttershy Sat 09:01

Why him
Sat 09:06

This is hard
Derpy Sat 09:12

I still trust BigMac, since I think we're kinda forced to
Sat 09:12

the fact the game isn't over is a good thing
Moderator Sat 09:12

Derpy votes to lynch TwilightSparkle
Fluttershy Sat 09:13

You distrust Sparkle?
Derpy Sat 09:13

she was second on BigMac's list, after Discord
Fluttershy Sat 09:14

I know, but I don't think we should just blindly follow BigMac
Derpy Sat 09:14

he was all but confirmed legit
Fluttershy Sat 09:14

We should at least think who we distrust the most ourselves
Sat 09:14

I know
Derpy Sat 09:14

in a situation where others can lead us (small groups with close to half wolves), I feel it's best to not go off your own interests, really
Sat 09:15

interests is the wrong word, I'm hungover
Fluttershy Sat 09:15

That feel so unlike you. But right
Derpy Sat 09:15

I know
Sat 09:15

I don't see end-game often, so this part of me doesn't often come out
Sat 09:15

but in a normal situation, we'd all present our thoughts
Sat 09:16

your thoughts might change mine - which would be fair enough when you're one person out of 20
Sat 09:16

but when you're one person out of 5, 2 of whom are wolves, I don't want ANY of you to influence me
Sat 09:16

the best way to do that, IMO, is to follow the directions of a legit villager - even if they are dead
Fluttershy Sat 09:16

Why not me? I'm only pretty much conformed
Sat 09:17

Confirmed*
Derpy Sat 09:17

because I already said I was gonna go by BigMac
Fluttershy Sat 09:17

Hmm okay
Derpy Sat 09:17

also I just want the game to be over without much more thought required, sad but true
Fluttershy Sat 09:18

Right
Sat 09:18

But don't you think MM is a weird kill?
Derpy Sat 09:20

a little, I guess
Sat 09:20

but also no
Sat 09:20

as I've said, BigMac was pretty much confirmed by now
Sat 09:21

killing his "confirmed villagers" makes sense
Sat 09:21

I wasn't checked by him - you don't have any info on my role, "confirmed" or not
Sat 09:21

hence why I'm still here
Fluttershy Sat 09:22

But why not kill me
Derpy Sat 09:22

I guess it just doesn't make any difference
Sat 09:22

you, MM, whoever
Sat 09:22

perhaps you're next
Fluttershy Sat 09:22

I'm Prot, so I don't see why he didn't go for me first
Sat 09:22

Or they I don't know how many are left
Derpy Sat 09:23

oh I forgot about that
Sat 09:23

maybe they're concerned about a secret harlot or something
Sat 09:23

if we had one, it would be on you, for sure
Fluttershy Sat 09:24

That would be great. But I'm pretty sure we don't have one
Derpy Sat 09:25

could be me
Sat 09:25

unless they have a BH, they don't know
Fluttershy Sat 11:14

Where are the others?
Sat 11:15

Honestly I find everyone sus lol
Derpy Sat 11:20

yeah I know
TwilightSparkle Sat 11:34

Afternoon
Fluttershy Sat 11:34

hi
Moderator Sat 11:34

TwilightSparkle votes to lynch SweetieBelle
TwilightSparkle Sat 11:35

I'm still not convinced by Sweetie's behaviour, and she seems high on everyone's suspicions list
Fluttershy Sat 11:35

What do you think of Viny?
TwilightSparkle Sat 11:37

I like the theory behind Derpy's reasoning for going with BigMac, but it seems to me that that's only a good strategy if we have reasons to believe his instincts are good
Sat 11:38

Flutter, Vinyl is interesting... I'd like to know why he put Derpy and myself lower down his suspicion list than you or Mayor
Fluttershy Sat 11:39

Same here.
Sat 11:39

I personally trust you the most out of everyone atm
Sat 11:39

But I could be horribly wrong
TwilightSparkle Sat 11:43

The problem with blind games is that we have no idea what we're up against; we don't even know how many wolves are left ... if we assume two then we have to lynch (correctly) or the game ends — but actually there might only be one left and in that case lynching is actually detrimental to our cause
Fluttershy Sat 11:45

So how many wolves do you think there are left?
TwilightSparkle Sat 11:47

hmm - well let's start with facts: there can't be three wolves still alive (... unless there's a coven lurking, but let's ignore that possibility for now)
Sat 11:50

so then, we lynched two confirmed (presumably?) wolves already - Pumpkin and Princess - so it partly depends how many we started with
Sat 11:51

It's possible that Discord was also a wolf, but we've also had a couple of smites who also could have been wolves and that complicates things
Sat 11:52

although I think Mac cleared Zecora
Sat 11:53

so, moving into speculation - I'd say we started with five wolves, three must definitely be dead, so imho we have two left
Sat 11:54

but maybe we got lucky and one was smited
Sat 11:55

and three were lynched
Fluttershy Sat 12:02

So coming to my question, how many do you think are still left?
Derpy Sat 12:03

huh?
Sat 12:03

2 confirmed dead, as you said
Sat 12:03

but possibly Discord
Sat 12:03

how does that equal "three must definitely be dead"?
Fluttershy Sat 12:04

Nevermind I misread. 2 left you think. Okay
Sat 12:05

Derpy, what do you think? How many are left and who dod you think are the wolves
Derpy Sat 12:06

It's hard to say
Sat 12:07

I'd kinda love for me to be the last villager, and there be 2 coven and 2 wolves
Sat 12:07

but I doubt that, unless the Seer was EXTREMELY unlucky
Fluttershy Sat 12:07

How would that be possible?
Derpy Sat 12:07

nah, it wouldn't, if BigMac was legit
Sat 12:07

ignore me, I'm all over the place
Sat 12:08

but if it was just wolves vs village, starting with 5 makes sense
Sat 12:08

I suppose there can't be 3 left, or mod would end the game?
Sat 12:08

so it must be 2
Fluttershy Sat 12:08

Not its 2 or 1
Sat 12:08

noep*
Sat 12:08

NOPE=*
Derpy Sat 12:09

so in that case, ignore my questioning of Twilight above. I see now she was speculating
Fluttershy Sat 12:09

Derpy you are all over the place
Derpy Sat 12:09

I know
Sat 12:09

hungover, unmotivated
Fluttershy Sat 12:10

Yeah but like the whole game
Sat 12:10

It's day 8
Derpy Sat 12:10

oh, just unmotivated for the whole game
Fluttershy Sat 12:10

Again?
Derpy Sat 12:10

not 100% sure why
Fluttershy Sat 12:10

right
Derpy Sat 12:10

early game was a drain on me
Sat 12:10

I got pissed off again
Fluttershy Sat 12:11

Okay, so coming to my question who do you think are the last 2 wolves
Derpy Sat 12:16

internet died, sorry
Sat 12:16

that's the big question, isn't it?
Fluttershy Sat 12:16

It is, that's why i'm asking
Derpy Sat 12:17

sorry, my net seems to be dropping in and out now
Sat 12:17

not all messages appearing
Sat 12:17

for the third time... vinyl has been rather quiet, as far as I remembere
Sat 12:18

so my 2 are Twilight and Vinyl/Sweetie
Sat 12:18

but I'm really not sure between the last two
Sat 12:18

maybe today's voting will help me work it out
SweetieBelle Sat 15:24

@twilight Nah m8, Im only high on both discord and your list. the rest was bottom for me. so here I am. Either, we still trust BM through and through or like some of you mentioned Vinyl
Sat 15:25

I have to agree on feeling unmotivated.. Fun fact: when you get vanillager, at times I could go braindead on trying to reach a logical rational sounding decision or theory
Sat 15:27

Expect the worse, prolly 2 wolves left

Your role: Observer

The Village

Graveyard

Spoiler free day archives