ext-128 Day 4 | Forum Werewolf Game

Replay

You are viewing day 4 of a game of werewolves started on the 17-Apr-01 Sat on a 24 hour cycle (12h day, 12h night).

This is a spoiler free version, use the user button (top menu) to see who was alive at the time, and the calendar button or links below the chat to navigate through to different days.

You can play a game of online Mafia by joining the game currently in sign up. New players are welcome, but try to be active!
Derpy Tue 08:34

Lots of smite risk from yesterday
PrincessCelestia Tue 08:34

Why did the night take so long?
Tue 08:35

Whatever
Tue 08:36

I think it's time for the GD to come out
Fluttershy Tue 08:38

Might be useful
PrincessCelestia Tue 08:41

Actually, lets hear from MM first
Derpy Tue 08:43

these are known roles?
Fluttershy Tue 08:58

Are we doing a role reveal?
Zecora Tue 09:02

Hmm
Tue 09:02

So we actually lynched King
Fluttershy Tue 09:03

Yes and you were a part of it
Derpy Tue 09:21

duhh, I was reading MM as ML (Mason Leader) so that was confusing me
Fluttershy Tue 09:52

Should we do a full reveal?
Derpy Tue 09:52

seems as valid to me as anything at this point
Fluttershy Tue 09:53

We got like no info, so we need to create into
Tue 09:53

Info
Tue 09:53

So I'm down
Tue 09:53

*waiting for someone to tell me I'm high*
Tue 10:06

Is someone here to discuss things?
Tue 10:06

I'm bored
Derpy Tue 10:06

sure
Tue 10:11

or not, whatever :D
Fluttershy Tue 10:11

:D
Tue 10:11

Soo any suspicious so far?
Tue 10:12

Did you read the MM and KS thing?
Tue 10:12

I want MM to speak up ASAP
Derpy Tue 10:12

I did
Fluttershy Tue 10:13

And what did you think?
Derpy Tue 10:13

I agree with Pinky that Rarity was defending King quite heavily
Tue 10:13

I think we need more info
Fluttershy Tue 10:13

We indeed do need more info
Derpy Tue 10:14

more info from them, that is
Fluttershy Tue 10:14

Which is why I would be down for a full reveal
Derpy Tue 10:14

not just generally
Tue 10:14

King needs to either tell us what Mayor is talking about
Fluttershy Tue 10:14

Yes especially from MM
Derpy Tue 10:14

or Mayor needs to expand
Fluttershy Tue 10:14

Err, King is dead..
Derpy Tue 10:15

King is dead
Tue 10:15

I just realised that
Fluttershy Tue 10:15

:/
Tue 10:15

So we will only have info from MM
Derpy Tue 10:15

as I looked up to see who was going to be smited today
Fluttershy Tue 10:15

Which is something I don't like
Derpy Tue 10:15

yes, we need that info from Mayor
Fluttershy Tue 10:15

MM where are yaaaa
Moderator Tue 10:38

Fluttershy votes to lynch MayorMare
SweetieBelle Tue 10:41

What's the story morning glory ponies
Discord Tue 10:43

I didn't expect King was lynch with just an vague sentence like that :(
TwilightSparkle Tue 10:44

Hello my equine friends
Discord Tue 10:44

Hello
TwilightSparkle Tue 10:44

Discord, I would not have expected it either, but I do not believe he turned up to defend himself?
Tue 10:45

I have yet to catch up on the end of the day though, so I might be mistaken
Discord Tue 10:45

Yup
Tue 10:46

King didn't show up
TwilightSparkle Tue 10:47

I think at the very least, we should hear from the accuser (was it Mare?) to provide their full information
Discord Tue 10:47

It's Mayor
Tue 10:47

Right
TwilightSparkle Tue 10:47

MayorMare, how punny
Derpy Tue 10:48

in certain accents, yes
TwilightSparkle Tue 10:48

I suggested a role reveal yesterday, I stand by that today if others agree
Discord Tue 10:48

Seem like everyone want that too
TwilightSparkle Tue 11:02

great ^_^
Zecora Tue 11:07

I will start. Im vanilla :(
Tue 11:08

Like super vanilla
Tue 11:08

Im a zebra too
Fluttershy Tue 11:21

If we do this I like EVERYONE to claim
PrincessCelestia Tue 11:37

That leaves the powerful as targets ...
Tue 11:37

I think it is better for the Intel roles to come out once they find something
TwilightSparkle Tue 11:43

I am also vanilla
Tue 11:43

hmm
Tue 11:45

Princess, I think they should come out anyway, we've seen in the past that early role reveals leave the evils off balance and vulnerable
Tue 11:45

also they generally don't claim it claim late, so that gives any power roles better targets
Derpy Tue 12:02

I'm also vanilla
Tue 12:02

let's just get this out there
AppleBloom Tue 12:06

Well may as well drops some info down, before it becomes another empty day.
Tue 12:06

Trixie and sombra were villagers
Derpy Tue 12:08

that's their faction?
AppleBloom Tue 12:08

And role
Derpy Tue 12:08

so vanilla?
AppleBloom Tue 12:08

Aye
Derpy Tue 12:08

ok
Tue 12:09

but you are claiming GD
Tue 12:09

so at least we're not all vanilla
Tue 12:09

I could have seen mods doing that for a joke
AppleBloom Tue 12:10

So there is no way sombra could have visited, right?
Derpy Tue 12:11

ahh
Tue 12:11

unless they were a sleepwalker
Tue 12:11

was that implemented yet?
Tue 12:11

/guides/roles/Sleepwalker yes it was
AppleBloom Tue 12:11

Does that not come up? On gd check?
Derpy Tue 12:11

I don't think so
AppleBloom Tue 12:11

Lycan did right?
Fluttershy Tue 12:15

So who claimed vanilla so far?
Tue 12:15

Let's get a summary going
Moderator Tue 12:20

AppleBloom votes to lynch MayorMare
SweetieBelle Tue 12:24

Me. Im a vanillager
Tue 12:24

Just read
AppleBloom Tue 12:24

I see a trend coming on...
TwilightSparkle Tue 12:29

You'd see Sleepwalker
Discord Tue 12:29

count me in vanilla group
TwilightSparkle Tue 12:29

You find out their exact role, plus pretty sure a GD had confirmed a sleepwalker in the past
Moderator Tue 12:29

TwilightSparkle votes to lynch MayorMare
Discord Tue 12:30

uh oh
Tue 12:31

this feel familiar
Tue 12:31

Mayor, pls don't be the second KingSombra
AppleBloom Tue 12:59

At this point wolves will just all claim villager, and we'll just end up outing the specials -_-
Fluttershy Tue 13:04

I agree with AppleBloom
PinkiePie Tue 13:23

yo yo yooooooooooo
Tue 13:23

I third that
Moderator Tue 13:23

PinkiePie votes to lynch MayorMare
PinkiePie Tue 13:23

also, wtf mayor
Derpy Tue 13:43

hold on now
Tue 13:43

this is mayor vs apple
Tue 13:43

let's not just play "trust the newest info"
MayorMare Tue 13:52

HI all, so yesterday was interesting. I was trying to spark some discussion, it was really just an ASV, wasn't expecting that to turn into a lynch. But well, if he wasn't active enough to defend himself then seems like a fair lynch to me.
Derpy Tue 13:53

so you didn't actually see anything?
MayorMare Tue 13:56

I did not - I picked him because of the title (I'm Mayor, he is King. Mayor > King) - Was expecting more than just bandwagon voting and no defense.
Derpy Tue 13:57

pfff
Tue 13:58

I mean, doing that and then not coming back... that's the bit that's gonna hurt you
Moderator Tue 13:58

Derpy votes to lynch MayorMare
Derpy Tue 13:58

because we really needed to know that yesterday
MayorMare Tue 13:59

I intended to come back, but things got in the way. Lynching me will just remove another vanilla, so other than changing the ratio of evil:villagers, no loss.
Derpy Tue 14:01

that might be true
Tue 14:01

but the chance of you being anti-town is higher than it was previously, IMO
MayorMare Tue 14:04

Understandable.
Derpy Tue 14:04

if you'd come back and said this yesterday, it's something
MayorMare Tue 14:04

We should still try and use the rest of teh day to get some useful info from people rather than just another day focussed on lynchign a single person (which was not my intention yesterday)
Fluttershy Tue 14:07

That was a really silly move MM
Tue 14:08

I mean the bait was okay I guess. But not coming back is the bad part
MayorMare Tue 14:10

Well, had to try something. Yesterday was pretty dead, conversation wise.
Derpy Tue 14:11

so if you are a villager, it's even worse
Tue 14:11

since today's now the same
Tue 14:11

AND we're lynching you as a result
MayorMare Tue 14:15

Could always not lynch me and do something useful...
Derpy Tue 14:15

yep
Tue 14:15

could
Tue 14:16

gonna be tough to make that happen now though
Fluttershy Tue 14:16

It would all have been solved if you came back yesterday
Tue 14:16

;-;
MayorMare Tue 14:22

I realise I hurt my play a bit with that, it was unintended. And fine, if people are still going to lynch me today then I guess that's my fault - but at the very least there should be some other discussion, at least make the day useful.
Moderator Tue 14:22

MayorMare votes to lynch VinylScratch
MayorMare Tue 14:22

ASV on the off-chance I don't die. Hasn't spoken today yet.
Discord Tue 14:23

yo
Tue 14:24

worse scenario: 5 villager in gy tonight -_-'
Tue 14:25

*worst
Tue 14:25

I guess we have conven in this setting
MayorMare Tue 14:26

Have we seen any evidence of Coven? Anyone been redirected/swappped?
Discord Tue 14:26

nah, haven't heard anything
Derpy Tue 14:27

not many roles claimed, that could be redirected so far
Discord Tue 14:27

dozen of vanilla though
Derpy Tue 14:27

claimed vanilla
Tue 14:28

wouldn't surprise me if we had coven in that mix
Discord Tue 14:28

or, maybe there are lycans and sleepwalkers
MayorMare Tue 14:36

Started on April Fools, so probably a bunch of sleepwalkers/lycans
Discord Tue 14:39

if it's so, we might have a seer
Tue 14:40

or stalker
Tue 14:40

harlot
Tue 14:41

but no one has spoken anything
Tue 14:41

yet
Tue 14:47

so let's lean on the theory that we have fake claim here
BigMac Tue 15:06

Hey guys, BigMac's here
Tue 15:06

hmm, why do we lynch MayorMare
Tue 15:07

I think it was a good move yesterday to make Sombra talk and generate some info out of thin air
Discord Tue 15:07

that's right
Tue 15:07

but
Tue 15:08

she didn't come back after that
BigMac Tue 15:08

The way he didn't come up is bit sus, but so did Sombra
Discord Tue 15:08

bad move
BigMac Tue 15:09

I don't know, MM feels vanilla who tried to do something for a boring town to me
Tue 15:09

I don't think lynching her is a good move
Tue 15:09

if we wanna pressure and lynch someone, try the inactives
Derpy Tue 15:10

that's too easy an out
Tue 15:11

I don't want to play a game where wolves can make shit up, and roll with it if there's no counter claim, or just say "nah, I'm vanilla and was testing you".
Discord Tue 15:11

hmm...
BigMac Tue 15:11

that's called baiting
Tue 15:11

we have plenty of that in 127
Tue 15:12

why suddently a discrimination here?
Discord Tue 15:12

everything is vague right now
Derpy Tue 15:12

it's consistent logic for me, at least
Discord Tue 15:12

Derpy, how about postpone it a day?
Derpy Tue 15:12

don't listen to me
Tue 15:12

make your own mind up
Tue 15:12

move your vote
Tue 15:12

if enough people agree
Tue 15:13

my vote won't matter
Tue 15:13

you don't need my permission
Moderator Tue 15:13

BigMac votes to lynch RainbowDash
Derpy Tue 15:13

this is not a "let's all vote the same person" game
BigMac Tue 15:13

lol, any vote matters
Derpy Tue 15:13

it's a "who has the most votes" game
Tue 15:13

you've presented your point, I disagree
BigMac Tue 15:13

I would rather vote on someone who hasn't talked at all, like Rainbow
Discord Tue 15:13

I'm good for now
Derpy Tue 15:14

by all means, feel free to try and convince me, but ultimately make your mind up and do it, you know?
Discord Tue 15:14

yes, and yes
Tue 15:14

I've tried to convince you
Tue 15:15

like I said, we need clear evidence
Derpy Tue 15:15

so when the lynch happens, whoever dies, if we get more GD data, maybe use my stubbornness as evidence
Tue 15:15

or maybe use BigMac flying into to rescue Mayor as evidence
Discord Tue 15:16

sure, i note that
Derpy Tue 15:16

this is why voting who YOU want to lynch is essential, because it creates data
TwilightSparkle Tue 15:17

Derpy, it's not "newest claim wins" it's "vaguest claim loses"
Derpy Tue 15:17

well great news
Tue 15:17

I'm seer and Apple is a wolf
TwilightSparkle Tue 15:18

We (well, at least I) want Mayor to explain his statement yesterday that led to the lynch
Derpy Tue 15:18

2 things, one, there's no vaguery, two, maybe this is just a test
Tue 15:18

as a vanilla, that's a good play, right?
TwilightSparkle Tue 15:18

Derpy, are you going to vote for her?
Derpy Tue 15:19

I'm not being serious
Discord Tue 15:19

example
TwilightSparkle Tue 15:19

*shrugs* Why not
Derpy Tue 15:19

my vote is on Mayor because I think he made a bad play - if Apple is to be believed
BigMac Tue 15:19

no it's not, it called fake claiming and creates confusion
TwilightSparkle Tue 15:19

You could be
BigMac Tue 15:19

it's totally different from asking who did someone do at night
Tue 15:20

that's not hard evidence or fake claiming
Tue 15:20

*what
Derpy Tue 15:20

right, so what's hard evidence in what Apple said?
BigMac Tue 15:20

I don't fly in to rescue anyone here, but I see every active player who contributes to the game as an asset
Discord Tue 15:21

Mayor, pls say something, don't let BigMac here do your work
TwilightSparkle Tue 15:21

BigMac, my impression is that Mayor phrases the question in such a way that implied he had information - I would set that to some degree that is fake claiming
BigMac Tue 15:21

we could pressure and lynch inactives or ppl we sus, but lynching assets is a lost for the town
Derpy Tue 15:21

Twilight is right
TwilightSparkle Tue 15:21

say*
Derpy Tue 15:21

he definitely indicated he knew something
TwilightSparkle Tue 15:22

And if he didn't, he should have clarified before night fall
Tue 15:22

not just let the village continue with a lynch based on a false inference
Derpy Tue 15:23

^
BigMac Tue 15:23

yeah that's bad play, I agree, just not worth of a lynch
Discord Tue 15:23

yes, that's the point I agree with you
BigMac Tue 15:23

we would have pressured Sombra anyway
Tue 15:23

that's my view
Discord Tue 15:23

bad move
TwilightSparkle Tue 15:23

— I'm not trying to suggest that the lynch was incorrect or his fault, by the way
BigMac Tue 15:23

and he wouldn't come up to defense himself anyway
TwilightSparkle Tue 15:23

just that he *contributed* to it
Derpy Tue 15:23

my lack of investment in this game is kinda leading me to use it as "let's set an example and lynch for the bad play"
Tue 15:23

which is probably poor form on my part
Discord Tue 15:24

I get your point, Derpy
Derpy Tue 15:24

otherwise, what's to stop it happening again
Tue 15:24

OR becoming "acceptable" for wolves to pull off
TwilightSparkle Tue 15:25

I'm just following yesterday's pattern - Mayor's actions lead me to believe that he is off the opinion that if you don't turn up to defend yourself then you're eligible for being lynched ... so odd like him to defend himself
Tue 15:25

is of*
Tue 15:25

I'd*
BigMac Tue 15:26

Derpy, to state it clear, I don't see anything wrong with that play, it's the ppl who believe someone out of thin air, despite any hard evidence or clear role claim
Derpy Tue 15:26

are you using speech to text, Twilight?
Tue 15:26

I'd -> odd is an odd typo otherwise
TwilightSparkle Tue 15:26

no, just swyping quickly
MayorMare Tue 15:26

I just asked KingSombra what he did at night, I didn't say he actualyl did something.
BigMac Tue 15:27

they are the problems, not the one who tries that move
Derpy Tue 15:27

Mayor, you definitely worded it in a way that made it seem like you knew something
Tue 15:27

off the top of my head, it was something like "why don't you explain your actions last night"
Tue 15:27

indicating you knew there WERE actions
MayorMare Tue 15:28

Well yeah, I phrased it in such a way that if he was doing something he'd feel he had to say
TwilightSparkle Tue 15:28

"KingSombra - care to explain what you were up to last night? :)"
Tue 15:28

FWIW
Derpy Tue 15:28

ugh, I see both angles
Tue 15:28

I definitely read it one way
Tue 15:29

I now see the other
TwilightSparkle Tue 15:29

I'm not concerned that you didn't come back towards the end of the day to clarify that you were bluffing
MayorMare Tue 15:29

The phrasing was intentionally acusatory to try and elicit a response if in deed he was doing something
Tue 15:30

I should have come back, yes, I intended to. Unfortunately sometimes real life gets in the way
Moderator Tue 15:30

TwilightSparkle votes to lynch PrincessCelestia
TwilightSparkle Tue 15:30

Anyway, I got what I wanted
Tue 15:31

which was an explanation
Tue 15:31

although, I would like it made explicitly clear as to if it really was a bluff
Tue 15:32

just so we don't have a situation in a few days where Mayor claims stalker then we have to go back and decide between Mayor and Apple
MayorMare Tue 15:32

TwilightSparkle: It was a bluff, I am vanilla.
TwilightSparkle Tue 15:32

... or where Mayor dies and we lose a chance to expose Apple as a wolf
Tue 15:32

thanks!
Tue 15:33

so many vanilla :/
Tue 15:33

guess that's why we got a "Good Luck!"
Discord Tue 15:33

a lots -_-'
MayorMare Tue 15:33

I wanted to spark some discussion in an otherwise quiet village. I figured as a vanilla I can do it "safely" as if it backfired then it wasn't a loss of intel for the village if I got lynched in retaliation
Derpy Tue 15:34

instead a random role got lynched
Tue 15:34

which wolves would love
Tue 15:34

if we believe Apple, it was vanilla
Tue 15:34

shit, you AND Apple could be wolves
Zecora Tue 15:35

Hmm. Tbh i believe mayor a little bit. A wolf or coven wont likely to claim like that.
Derpy Tue 15:35

wait
BigMac Tue 15:35

well, I feel Mayor's play make sense
Tue 15:35

'cause I'm a vanilla too
Derpy Tue 15:35

he only come out as "fake" SINCE being disproven
Tue 15:36

so wolf could fake claim, knowing he was "safe" because BigMac here's gonna say it's a legit play
Tue 15:36

then GD disproves him
Tue 15:36

and he's then got that escape if he needs it
Discord Tue 15:37

or apple can be a BH
Derpy Tue 15:37

or just any wolf
Tue 15:37

only needs to be BH if we stalk him
Tue 15:37

any wolf could say "those guys who we killed, ahem, who died are both vanilla"
TwilightSparkle Tue 15:37

And then she's busted antsy
Tue 15:37

anyway*
Derpy Tue 15:38

that's an easy claim
TwilightSparkle Tue 15:38

because BH can't visit the dead
Derpy Tue 15:38

the only risk there is coven knowing they're a wolf, if a coven partner died
Tue 15:38

but coven can't tell us that without outing themselves
Tue 15:39

inb4 someone says Apple shouldn't have disproven Mayor because it was an obvious test
TwilightSparkle Tue 15:40

I just think we should move on
Discord Tue 15:40

at first, I kinda agree with Mayor, there's a possibility in his explanation
TwilightSparkle Tue 15:40

This line of enquiry seems like its leading nowhere
Derpy Tue 15:40

so Twilight, you think all involved are villagers?
Discord Tue 15:40

but BigMac put a great effort to defense him
Derpy Tue 15:40

aaaaand from it all, we got no data
Tue 15:40

except a lynched villager
TwilightSparkle Tue 15:42

Derpy, I don't know really but the way I see it we have two options currently: either we continue this discussion and decide that Mayor is a wolf, lynch him and hope that Apple can check him out we move on until something more concrete cones out
Derpy Tue 15:42

I don't even trust Apple
Tue 15:42

but I guess
BigMac Tue 15:42

@Discord I said it, as a fellow vanilla, Mayor's play makes sense to me
Tue 15:43

hell, if I have more time and care more for this game, I would try to bait some wolves too
TwilightSparkle Tue 15:43

and I don't think with the given information we can *prove* anything either way, so we are possibly going to end up another villager
Derpy Tue 15:43

BigMac feels so wolfy
TwilightSparkle Tue 15:43

lynching*
Tue 15:44

Derpy, imho you seem just as "wolfy" as BigMac
Derpy Tue 15:44

great
Discord Tue 15:44

even if I agree with him, I still have some doubt and didn't defensed Mayor that hard
Derpy Tue 15:44

I'm glad you've expressed that Twilight
Tue 15:44

maybe a vote would cement it
Tue 15:45

and certainly create data for future days
TwilightSparkle Tue 15:45

I'm not saying I think you're a wolf, just that you both display traits that I associate less with Ponies and more with Wolfies
Tue 15:46

let's discuss Apple - did she give another check?
Zecora Tue 15:46

So, up to now we have Twilight, Derpy, Belle, Discord and Mayor and me claimed vanilla
Derpy Tue 15:47

2 nights, 2 reveals from Apple
MayorMare Tue 15:47

Apple said Trixie and KingSombra
SweetieBelle Tue 15:47

So I just speed read. & We are lyching Mayor because of the bait?
Derpy Tue 15:48

WE aren't lynching anyone
Tue 15:48

holy shit
TwilightSparkle Tue 15:48

yes, I just read back ... also I noticed that Mayor already defended himself once, somehow I missed that (sorry!)
Derpy Tue 15:48

do you think he should be lynched? vote him. Don't think he should be lynched? vote someone else
Tue 15:48

the majority will win
TwilightSparkle Tue 15:49

we're only "lynching Mayor" in the same way that yesterday we were "lynching Sombra"
SweetieBelle Tue 15:49

I took it as a bait but since King didnt really appear to defend himself means we could have hit a faulty pony or simply just inactive pony who couldnt be arse
TwilightSparkle Tue 15:49

which is that the majority didn't get challenged
Tue 15:50

there's no formal agreement that we should lynch him, so if you disagree you should attempt to balance
SweetieBelle Tue 15:50

I dont see a need to lynch him imho. On the other hand, Apple a seer? You know what let me read carefully about Apple
Tue 15:50

Alrighty, I will balance
TwilightSparkle Tue 15:50

Gravedigger
MayorMare Tue 15:51

Apple said he was GD
Derpy Tue 15:51

oh man
SweetieBelle Tue 15:51

Oh wait but what balance when there's 4 on Mayor and the rest all one vote
TwilightSparkle Tue 15:51

Be the change you want to see
Moderator Tue 15:51

SweetieBelle votes to lynch RainbowDash
MayorMare Tue 15:51

or heavily implied I guess ([AppleBloom] Does that not come up? On gd check?)
Moderator Tue 15:51

TwilightSparkle votes to lynch RainbowDash
Moderator Tue 15:52

MayorMare votes to lynch RainbowDash
Derpy Tue 15:52

actively saying "I'm gonna balance" is effectively saying "I don't know who I want to lynch, but I'm not gonna let those who do have their say". It's pretty much anti democracy to balance. Which is fine, but you might be a wolf for doing it.
MayorMare Tue 15:52

I'm balancing for obvious "I don't want to die" reasons.
SweetieBelle Tue 15:52

GD
Tue 15:52

Wait, let me read her checks
TwilightSparkle Tue 15:52

So - question for y'all: do we think a wolf (or multiple) will have contributed to the lynch yesterday?
Derpy Tue 15:53

hard to say
Zecora Tue 15:53

I started the push actually
Derpy Tue 15:53

it very much seemed a "consensus" lynch
Zecora Tue 15:53

and didnt really comeback
Discord Tue 15:54

I think there are wolves
TwilightSparkle Tue 15:54

Derpy, what if it's "I don't know who I want to lynch but it's definitely not that person"?
Zecora Tue 15:55

Sounds wolfy :p
Tue 15:55

And Mayor is not even that trustworthy
Discord Tue 15:55

this is the chance they can vote without raise sus too much
Tue 15:55

and if Mayor is wolf, they need to defense him
Zecora Tue 15:57

Funny that ppl dont need that much justice when it came to King :>
SweetieBelle Tue 15:57

See this is where it gets tangle and hard for vanillager. When one starts to group votes as birds of same feather flock together
Tue 15:57

I dont see GD check.
TwilightSparkle Tue 15:57

Discord, I disagree: "I think he's a wolf for his behaviour" / "I don't think we can draw a solid conclusion from his behaviour, so we should turn our attention elsewhere for now" ... why should the former win without a majority?
Tue 15:59

maybe we don't come up with a better alternative, maybe in that case we should acquiesce to those with more conviction...
Discord Tue 15:59

they're not sure they can win, but they can try make the lynch reasonable
Tue 16:00

not raise too much sus
TwilightSparkle Tue 16:00

but yesterday we went with a lazy majority and we were wrong, why risk the same mistake?
SweetieBelle Tue 16:00

We were wrong/
Tue 16:00

?*
Tue 16:00

Sombra is someone special?
TwilightSparkle Tue 16:00

If we believe Apple; which I do currently
Tue 16:01

Sombra is vanilla
SweetieBelle Tue 16:01

Eh, am I missing out or I cant see GD checks
Tue 16:01

Oh, wait what is her checks?
Discord Tue 16:01

I don't know, like I said I think they can try and not make them seem suspected
Zecora Tue 16:01

AppleBloom Tue 12:06 Well may as well drops some info down, before it becomes another empty day. Tue 12:06 Trixie and sombra were villagers Derpy Tue 12:08 that's their faction? AppleBloom Tue 12:08 And role Derpy Tue 12:08 so vanilla? AppleBloom Tue 12:08 Aye
TwilightSparkle Tue 16:02

AppleBloom [Tue 12:06] Well may as well drops some info down, before it becomes another empty day. [Tue 12:06] Trixie and sombra were villagers
SweetieBelle Tue 16:02

That's feeding info
Tue 16:02

One way to know if she is really GD, dont even answer own question posed to her
TwilightSparkle Tue 16:02

"feeding info"?
Zecora Tue 16:03

We should know tomorrow, since she is the only intel that came out
Tue 16:03

sooner or later someone will verify or disprove her
SweetieBelle Tue 16:03

That's factions btw, not role. So I hope someone could verify her
Tue 16:04

Also, Trixie was caught D1. Either she is holding really powerful role as she stated she was or she was just playing a fool
Zecora Tue 16:04

Usually i believe the first one who comes out, except vanilla
SweetieBelle Tue 16:04

The next day, she died.
Tue 16:04

I usually give such claim a benefit of doubt
Zecora Tue 16:05

Why?
Tue 16:05

Trixie was like a good target
SweetieBelle Tue 16:05

So yeah but I will keep in mind that Apple gave only factions so perhaps she might have something at play for the benefit of village
VinylScratch Tue 16:05

villager is the name of the role
SweetieBelle Tue 16:05

Trixie was a good target because of the line she stated
Tue 16:06

@Vinyl ah my bad, I vaguely remember how to play GD
Zecora Tue 16:06

Apple can hide the info, i dont see problem with that. Villager is enough for us.
SweetieBelle Tue 16:07

Thus why I said prolly she has something at play for the benefit of village
Zecora Tue 16:07

So do you believe her or not?
SweetieBelle Tue 16:08

Benefit of doubt so yeah I have to believe her for now
Tue 16:08

Usually, this number of players might have 2nd GD
Tue 16:09

Which prolly be good to verify the claim GD as well as stay low
Tue 16:09

If there is another GD
Zecora Tue 16:09

stalker and harlot can also confirm
SweetieBelle Tue 16:09

Otherwise, Im sure we have other intel to prove her
Tue 16:09

Yup
VinylScratch Tue 16:10

Stalker can, harlot can't visit the dead
SweetieBelle Tue 16:10

Then again, if we do have a good intel, pretty sure that person would have check Mayor last night
Zecora Tue 16:10

Mb, i mean beholder
SweetieBelle Tue 16:11

I would check Mayor to see this person is lit or not based on the hoo-haaa yesterday
Tue 16:12

would have*
Tue 16:13

Silence means Mayor is good or silence could also means our intel is 6ft under. We running blind here anyway...
Derpy Tue 16:16

gonna be away again this evening
Tue 16:16

but you have my thoughts on things
Tue 16:16

and my vote stands
SweetieBelle Tue 16:17

At least we can cross few roles: No zealot, prolly no succu since no one reports of being redirected even if they have no ability, no djinn(or djinn prolly mess around in gy), no messiah (no 2 deaths so far), no vamp no fam. If this is solely wolves vs villagers, prolly all 5 wolves at play.
Tue 16:17

Good numbers of vanillas = 2 stalkers at play perhaps
Tue 16:18

Well, Im just assuming setup
Tue 16:18

I could be wrong
Zecora Tue 16:26

Note that this game started at April Fools XD
Tue 16:26

Ok got to sleep, g9 all
SweetieBelle Tue 16:27

XD
AppleBloom Tue 16:59

If this game consists of just villagers and a gd, ahhhh. It is an april fools game after all
Tue 17:00

N2-Trixie-villager (the role)
Tue 17:01

N3-KingSombra-villager
Tue 17:02

Yes I'm GD, just be clear
Tue 17:05

The only info we can get it seems, atm, is from lynches.
Tue 17:05

Balancing really doesn't seem the way to go
MayorMare Tue 17:07

There must be a killing faction as well
Tue 17:07

I don't think mod would be doign the killing themselves at night
AppleBloom Tue 17:08

Also Trixie baiting then dieing says a lot
Tue 17:11

Sleepwalker but instead sleep werewolf
Tue 17:12

Think you are villager but randomly kill at night, (superLycan)
Fluttershy Tue 17:13

I see some developments happened while I was away
Tue 17:14

Lemme read :D
Tue 17:14

Okay that's WAYYY to long for the time I got
Tue 17:15

Someone mind giving me a TLDR
Tue 18:05

MM might a puppet you know
Tue 18:06

Just trying to get someone lynched. I personally think the not coming back move was on purpose
Tue 18:06

So no new information showed up and we only had his information.
Tue 18:07

But don't pin it down on me. It's just a thought
Tue 18:08

I think he's either a puppet or a normal villager
AppleBloom Tue 18:12

Repeatedly balancing and not voting for people you suspect, will just lead to a straight loss.
Tue 18:15

With such a large amount of villagers don't expect much more info. Especially if people are so reluctant to lynch
TwilightSparkle Tue 18:31

Apples must be the name of his cat...
Tue 18:31

Sorry, I got distracted: Apples, do you support that we lynch Mayor?
Moderator Tue 18:39

VinylScratch votes to lynch MayorMare
MayorMare Tue 19:29

Fluttershy, there are no puppets
Tue 19:30

Vinyl: got anything to add other than the silent vote?
Fluttershy Tue 19:30

You kept track of the amount of people that joined this game?
MayorMare Tue 19:30

Yes
Moderator Tue 19:30

Fluttershy votes to lynch Rarity
Fluttershy Tue 19:31

Oh I didnt realize I voted for you
MayorMare Tue 19:31

(The API also makes it obvious)
Fluttershy Tue 19:32

So guys let's discuss. Do we want MM dead?
Tue 19:32

I personally don't know
Tue 19:32

I kinda want him lynched
Rarity Tue 19:32

Ok. A few things to add quickly
Fluttershy Tue 19:32

Like his move was weird
Tue 19:32

Ah, you're here
Rarity Tue 19:33

Mare made a bad play.
Tue 19:33

Lots of people followed and either voted or stood by and let the lynch happen.
Tue 19:34

If you dropped a vote and didn't come back.... bad play
Tue 19:34

If you were there at the days end and didn't help balance.... bad play
Fluttershy Tue 19:35

So do you distrust MM or do you just think it was a bad play as a villager
Moderator Tue 19:37

Fluttershy votes to lynch MayorMare
Rarity Tue 19:40

I think MM. is a bad lynch for winning this game as village. But the right lynch for sending the right message.
Tue 19:40

This vote is for better play at we.es
Moderator Tue 19:41

Rarity votes to lynch MayorMare
Fluttershy Tue 19:41

The thing is. I'm kinda thinking we're just lynching villagers here and the wolves are just staying low and are just laughing at us
Tue 19:42

As a reminder: MM, Cecora, Applebloom and Sweetiebelle voted KS yesterday
Tue 19:42

Who did claimed a role today?
AppleBloom Tue 19:47

Honestly I think we are getting caught up on balancing, when we should just be voting for who we suspect the most
Tue 19:49

MM is active enough to defend herself, but not to say yesterday that it was just an accusation
Tue 19:51

Look back yesterday for people that knew the lynch was a villager, and acted oddly to not put too much suspicion on themselves
Tue 19:53

The amount of people who I had as suspicious now voting on MM is worrying
Tue 19:54

I hope I will be around long enough to say the result tomorrow
MayorMare Tue 19:55

Some final words then to those who actually want to win as a village, look at the people who are lynching "to send a message" or because they didn't like the play, rather than those lynching because they actually want to win by lynching wolves.
AppleBloom Tue 19:55

AppleBloom, PP, Derpy,VinylScratch,Fluttershy and RArity are on MM at the moment
MayorMare Tue 19:55

To make it easier for people looking back, at the moment, the following people are voting for me: AppleBloom, Derpy, Fluttershy, PinkiePie, Rarity, VinylScratch
AppleBloom Tue 19:55

oh
Fluttershy Tue 19:56

I really dont know what to do
Tue 19:56

MM sounds like a villager though ...
Moderator Tue 19:57

AppleBloom votes to lynch RainbowDash
MayorMare Tue 19:57

I've admitted that it turned out to be a bad play, last minute RL stuff can do that to you sometimes, but if that's what people want then good luck.
Fluttershy Tue 19:57

Well it's balanced now
Tue 19:57

UGH
AppleBloom Tue 19:57

I have others to dig
Fluttershy Tue 19:57

I hate these decisions
Tue 19:58

Are we really doing this?
Tue 19:58

Like I cant do anything atm
Tue 19:58

My vote is already on MM
AppleBloom Tue 19:58

Urg
Tue 19:58

Smites are going through as well
Fluttershy Tue 19:59

Is somebody else here???
TwilightSparkle Tue 19:59

I can tip the balance, if you guys convince me in 1 minute
Fluttershy Tue 19:59

Who's getting smited?
Tue 19:59

urrr
Tue 19:59

donno
AppleBloom Tue 19:59

Idon't like balance
TwilightSparkle Tue 19:59

I would still prefer not to lynch Mayor though
AppleBloom Tue 19:59

but my gut says village
TwilightSparkle Tue 19:59

but I agree, too
Fluttershy Tue 19:59

YES OR NO
Tue 19:59

O_O
Tue 20:00

Too late
AppleBloom Tue 20:00

Hope it's not wrong
Tue 20:00

but would be good info
MayorMare Tue 20:00

I have no desire to lynch RainbowDash, he was just the only other person I could vote for that wasn't be to stop me dying.
Tue 20:00

So I'd rather there was balance for today, for purely selfish reasons right now.
Fluttershy Tue 20:00

Well at least this was a more interesting day
TwilightSparkle Tue 20:00

to be fair, I think Rainbow is going to get smited anyway?
AppleBloom Tue 20:00

Hope I'm here tomorrow
Tue 20:01

Otherwise enjoy villager fest 2017
MayorMare Tue 20:01

Yeah RainbowDash looks to be getting smited anyway, ok
Killed Wed 08:02

Rarity was killed during the night

Your role: Observer

The Village

Graveyard

Spoiler free day archives