ext-128 Day 9 | Forum Werewolf Game

Replay

The game is over, this is post game log when real identites and roles are revealed

This is a spoiler free version, use the user button (top menu) to see who was alive at the time, and the calendar button or links below the chat to navigate through to different days.

You can play a game of online Mafia by joining the game currently in sign up. New players are welcome, but try to be active!
clockworkg Wed 08:20

clockworkg has joined the game
nconeymmi Wed 08:38

nconeymmi has joined the game
Philosophile Wed 09:59

Philosophile has joined the game
Usernamer Wed 12:01

Usernamer has joined the game
Kingsombra Wed 19:40

Kingsombra has joined the game
Kingsombra Wed 19:47

Kingsombra has joined the game
Kingsombra Wed 19:49

Kingsombra has joined the game
Scav Wed 20:28

Scav has joined the game
ShaneMcC Wed 20:57

ShaneMcC has joined the game
WindowsBob Wed 21:23

WindowsBob has joined the game
hershey Thu 03:51

hershey has joined the game
ImTownSRSLY Thu 09:06

ImTownSRSLY has joined the game
Sigrifia Thu 09:07

Sigrifia has joined the game
enna Thu 17:59

enna has joined the game
Kingsombra Thu 19:22

Kingsombra has joined the game
XII Thu 22:10

XII has joined the game
SoFasttt Fri 04:37

SoFasttt has joined the game
ctsk Fri 04:41

ctsk has joined the game
Player3103 Fri 04:43

Player3103 has joined the game
Rubin_1998 Fri 06:33

Rubin_1998 has joined the game
JohanDoe Fri 09:16

JohanDoe has joined the game
Hanumanman Fri 10:45

Hanumanman has joined the game
Fri 11:19

has joined the game
Fri 11:19

has joined the game
aheadofyourtime Fri 12:49

aheadofyourtime has joined the game
Agent4nderson Fri 13:05

Agent4nderson has joined the game
borissssss Fri 14:38

borissssss has joined the game
Mvto Fri 22:16

Mvto has joined the game
ctsk Fri 22:39

ctsk has joined the game
Pandyrockz Fri 23:11

Pandyrockz has joined the game
ShaneMcC Sat 01:54

ShaneMcC has joined the game
DRskeleton654 Sat 05:54

DRskeleton654 has joined the game
DRskeleton654 Sat 05:54

DRskeleton654 has joined the game
legomanzelda Sat 08:38

legomanzelda has joined the game
nconeymmi Sat 10:13

nconeymmi has joined the game
nconeymmi Sat 10:13

nconeymmi has joined the game
ShaneMcC Sat 11:11

ShaneMcC has joined the game
Hanumanman Sat 11:12

Hanumanman has joined the game
Hanumanman Sat 11:12

Hanumanman has joined the game
legomanzelda Sat 15:27

legomanzelda has joined the game
Lomoinc Sat 16:29

Lomoinc has joined the game
KingSombra Sat 19:12

KingSombra has joined the game
Lyra Sat 19:12

Lyra has joined the game
MayorMare Sat 19:12

MayorMare has joined the game
Fluttershy Sat 19:12

Fluttershy has joined the game
Zecora Sat 19:12

Zecora has joined the game
PrincessCelestia Sat 19:12

PrincessCelestia has joined the game
AppleBloom Sat 19:12

AppleBloom has joined the game
Discord Sat 19:12

Discord has joined the game
RainbowDash Sat 19:12

RainbowDash has joined the game
BigMac Sat 19:12

BigMac has joined the game
PinkiePie Sat 19:12

PinkiePie has joined the game
SweetieBelle Sat 19:12

SweetieBelle has joined the game
Rarity Sat 19:12

Rarity has joined the game
Derpy Sat 19:12

Derpy has joined the game
TwilightSparkle Sat 19:12

TwilightSparkle has joined the game
VinylScratch Sat 19:12

VinylScratch has joined the game
Trixie Sat 19:12

Trixie has joined the game
DaringDo Sat 19:12

DaringDo has joined the game
Moderator Sat 19:13

Good luck!
Derpy Sat 19:14

Oh mods
Fluttershy Sat 19:14

a closed setup O_o
Derpy Sat 19:14

Really?
Fluttershy Sat 19:14

also this theme, lol
Derpy Sat 19:14

I'm not derpy, I'm drunky
Zecora Sat 19:14

Wut
Sat 19:14

Kill me
Fluttershy Sat 19:14

Derpy our picture are so much alike
Sat 19:14

O_o/
Derpy Sat 19:15

I'm also gonna go on strike because of this awful theme
Zecora Sat 19:15

I demand a theme change NOW
Derpy Sat 19:15

Err, I'm blonde on purple. Your pink on yellow. Get on my level, you basic mare
Fluttershy Sat 19:16

;-;
AppleBloom Sat 19:16

:s
Sat 19:16

we all look the same ahhhhhh
Zecora Sat 19:17

Im Seer, kill me :"o
VinylScratch Sat 19:17

lol
Sat 19:17

april fools theme
Zecora Sat 19:19

How about all role claim and end this in 2 days=￣ω￣=
Trixie Sat 19:22

omg.........
VinylScratch Sat 19:22

all behold the great and powerful Trixie!
AppleBloom Sat 19:22

Everyone else is a puppet anyways
Trixie Sat 19:22

huh?! you can see my role????
VinylScratch Sat 19:25

That's her line from the show
Sat 19:25

"The great and powerdul Trixie!"
Sat 19:26

*powerful
Trixie Sat 19:31

hahaa well it is true here
Sat 19:31

you watch this? how old are u
Sat 19:34

can wolves bite me i want to join
MayorMare Sat 19:35

Looks like I am the mayor, so i will lead us to great justice!
Killed Sun 08:06

Trixie was killed during the night
Discord Sun 09:23

WoW, it's quite here
Sun 09:27

*quiet :p
KingSombra Sun 09:31

woot woot
Sun 09:32

i cant believe this goes for a week, whats up w that
Moderator Sun 09:34

KingSombra votes to lynch Discord
SweetieBelle Sun 09:38

Whadaheck is this theme? My lil pony?
Sun 09:39

Imma sweetieeeee
Lyra Sun 09:52

Morning
Fluttershy Sun 10:27

Greeting yall
Derpy Sun 10:28

hey
Moderator Sun 10:34

KingSombra votes to lynch RainbowDash
Moderator Sun 10:34

KingSombra votes to lynch Discord
Discord Sun 11:00

hey, guess that it's ASV time
Moderator Sun 11:01

Discord votes to lynch KingSombra
Discord Sun 11:01

revenge is sweet :)
Moderator Sun 11:08

MayorMare votes to lynch TwilightSparkle
MayorMare Sun 11:09

ASV for now
Moderator Sun 11:22

SweetieBelle votes to lynch BigMac
SweetieBelle Sun 11:22

coz Im having a big mac for dinner
Derpy Sun 11:24

jealous
Moderator Sun 11:26

Lyra votes to lynch PrincessCelestia
Lyra Sun 11:26

ASV
Sun 11:27

Coz you have the longest name with 16 letters
DaringDo Sun 11:45

zirieF lwieiroeue. Haiarnennew
Sun 11:45

FFgiiünDfzifn
Sun 11:45

Hi
Moderator Sun 11:45

DaringDo votes to lynch PrincessCelestia
TwilightSparkle Sun 12:04

Morning all
Sun 12:05

DaringDo, any reason for tipping the balance?
PinkiePie Sun 12:07

yo yo yooooooooooo
Sun 12:08

daringdo strikes me as a troll or smth which I rly do not wanna deal with
Sun 12:08

I have my lifeguard training all day so I may be able to pop in in a couple hours on my lunch, but probably not
TwilightSparkle Sun 12:09

Lifeguard training?
Sun 12:09

that sounds amazing
Sun 12:09

but...
PinkiePie Sun 12:09

it's crazy hard
TwilightSparkle Sun 12:09

surely rescuing peke is really hard with only hooves?
Moderator Sun 12:09

PinkiePie votes to lynch RainbowDash
TwilightSparkle Sun 12:09

people*
PinkiePie Sun 12:10

hahahahaha
Sun 12:10

I make it work
TwilightSparkle Sun 12:10

:D
PrincessCelestia Sun 12:54

Hi
Sun 12:55

I hope you are not too upset that I won't rp...
Sun 12:57

just wanted to asv and saw "BigMac"
Sun 12:57

:DDD
Moderator Sun 12:57

PrincessCelestia votes to lynch Rarity
TwilightSparkle Sun 12:59

Hi Celestia - you're not slightly worried that you have 2 votes on you?
PrincessCelestia Sun 13:01

I didnt even notice
Sun 13:06

They should fear their Princess' wrath
Moderator Sun 13:19

Zecora votes to lynch BigMac
Zecora Sun 13:19

I hate fast food
TwilightSparkle Sun 13:20

Has anyone taken the trouble to check for puppets in this game yet?
SweetieBelle Sun 13:22

I dont think we have puppets.
Discord Sun 13:22

if I remember it right, we had 16 ppl (12h before the game start)
SweetieBelle Sun 13:23

It became 17th right?
VinylScratch Sun 13:23

I think it was 18 people
SweetieBelle Sun 13:23

Okay honestly I cant remember
Discord Sun 13:23

I dunno, I didn't check again after that
Sun 13:24

since I was sleeping when the game started
VinylScratch Sun 13:24

But in a game this size, coven are likely
Discord Sun 13:24

absolutely
TwilightSparkle Sun 13:31

I'm specifically concerned about puppets, since we need to organise a (minumum) 4-way balance if we intend to not lynch today
Derpy Sun 13:32

huh? puppet votes don't count, so if we intend not to lynch, we all just vote on someone so everyone has 1 vote on them. 2 votes don't count. 2 people don't have a vote on them. 15 people have 1 vote on them. Votes tie. No lynch.
TwilightSparkle Sun 13:33

uh?
Sun 13:33

Are you roleplaying your name?
Derpy Sun 13:33

well please explain, since I'm derping
TwilightSparkle Sun 13:34

Well I think you might have said exactly what I was implying...
Sun 13:34

we currently have two ponies with 2 votes each
Derpy Sun 13:34

but that can change
TwilightSparkle Sun 13:34

so *IF* there are puppets in this game, which seems to be the case, then we need to ensure we have a minium of a 4-way tie
Derpy Sun 13:34

right
Sun 13:34

but simplify it by saying "put 1 vote on everyone"
Sun 13:35

whoever voted BigMac, one of them needs to come change
Sun 13:35

that's far less complex than anything else
TwilightSparkle Sun 13:35

I want to hear back from DaringDo
Sun 13:35

as to why he/she/it put a second vote on the Princess
Moderator Sun 13:36

TwilightSparkle votes to lynch KingSombra
Moderator Sun 13:36

VinylScratch votes to lynch TwilightSparkle
VinylScratch Sun 13:36

There's your four-way tie
TwilightSparkle Sun 13:36

Brilliant
Sun 13:37

That said... I do think we should lynch today!
SweetieBelle Sun 13:37

Okay this too meta but I remember I was 2nd last person to join so yeah we had 18th
Sun 13:37

But just to be sure you guys can have your 4way
RainbowDash Sun 14:47

ASV for now :")
Moderator Sun 14:47

RainbowDash votes to lynch AppleBloom
Moderator Sun 14:50

Fluttershy votes to lynch Lyra
Fluttershy Sun 14:50

For Rob
Moderator Sun 14:52

Derpy votes to lynch VinylScratch
Derpy Sun 14:52

*freeze frame* Yep, that's me...
MayorMare Sun 16:03

As the mayor, I am declaring this village a puppet-free zone.
Sun 16:04

All of our fellow ponies are unique individuals!
PinkiePie Sun 16:25

I coulda sworn we had 16 when it started but aight
Sun 16:26

see nothing's happened
Sun 16:26

all gucci
Sun 16:26

going back to fake saving ppl lives cya
Sun 16:26

ALSO THE BRICK IS THE WORST THING AAAAAAA
DaringDo Sun 17:07

Brick?
Moderator Sun 17:36

AppleBloom votes to lynch PinkiePie
BigMac Sun 17:47

Hey guys, BigMac's here
Sun 17:48

why everyone hates me but eat me up when they are/were students anyway?
Moderator Sun 17:48

BigMac votes to lynch Zecora
BigMac Sun 17:48

ASV
PinkiePie Sun 19:17

EVERY DAY WE STRAY FURTHER FROM GOD'S LIGHT
Sun 19:17

NEVER BE A LIFEGUARD
Sun 19:22

also yes the brick it's the Worst!!!!!! you swim 15m and then dive down 10m to get a 20 pound brick (equivalent to carrying a 200pound man in the water) and you have to bring the brick up to surface while keeping your mouth above the water for 5m
Sun 19:22

it's Sufferinf
Sun 19:23

Suffering*
VinylScratch Sun 19:32

D:
PinkiePie Sun 19:37

not even the worst of it
Killed Mon 08:02

DaringDo was killed during the night
AppleBloom Mon 08:11

Waddup
TwilightSparkle Mon 08:43

hmm
Derpy Mon 08:44

hmm?
TwilightSparkle Mon 08:44

*theory crafting*
SweetieBelle Mon 09:06

So no zealot presence?
Mon 09:06

Good sweetie morneng
Mon 09:07

And Vamp faction as well seeing a singular kill each night?
Mon 09:07

So ever presence of Wolves and Covens?
Mon 09:07

Ah well
MayorMare Mon 10:01

No zealot, no puppets, and probably only a single killing faction. I'd guess probably wolves rather than vampire.
VinylScratch Mon 10:06

It could still be a vamp and a zealot, if the vamp recruited tonight, or wolves that hit protection and a zealot
Rarity Mon 10:35

But the odds are lower for that. still worth keeping in mind
Mon 10:35

Howdy yall
Mon 10:35

I love you all
Mon 10:35

*rainbows*
Mon 10:35

Rarity is such a pretty name
Mon 10:35

and Twilight Sparkle
MayorMare Mon 10:39

Well, lets get this party started then. KingSombra - care to explain what you were up to last night? :)
Moderator Mon 10:39

MayorMare votes to lynch KingSombra
PinkiePie Mon 11:02

ooooooooh
Mon 11:02

im tempted to say like don't do the usual dance cause that takes like 89 years, like cmon just say what you found, but I also wanna hear what king says that he was up to last night yknow
Moderator Mon 13:05

Lyra votes to lynch BigMac
Lyra Mon 13:05

ASV
Moderator Mon 13:19

Zecora votes to lynch KingSombra
Zecora Mon 13:20

Push a little bit
Moderator Mon 13:22

Derpy votes to lynch KingSombra
Derpy Mon 13:23

Because who doesn't love a bandwagon?
Moderator Mon 14:17

Discord votes to lynch Derpy
Discord Mon 14:18

@Derpy Me, cuz' I'm a Discord
Mon 14:18

:p
Derpy Mon 14:20

very good
Discord Mon 14:21

thank you
BigMac Mon 15:08

Hey guys, BigMac's here
Mon 15:08

what a quiet day 3
Mon 15:13

3 votes already, let's hear from Sombra
SweetieBelle Mon 15:28

Really quiet
Zecora Mon 15:37

I think you should speak first King
Mon 15:38

Oh nvm, got mixed up
Mon 15:38

Thought BigMac is King smh
Fluttershy Mon 15:46

Oh yeah wtf this game exists
Mon 15:46

Greetings
Mon 15:48

So nothing is happening x)
Mon 15:48

We need some Intel to work with
Mon 15:49

Is there someone here who could share some useful information which can help us in order to maybe have a good lynch
Moderator Mon 15:56

PinkiePie votes to lynch KingSombra
PinkiePie Mon 15:56

SOMBRA CMON
PrincessCelestia Mon 16:31

Your Celestial Princess here
Fluttershy Mon 16:32

Greetings
PrincessCelestia Mon 16:34

Is King Sombra my father?
Fluttershy Mon 16:35

Donni
PrincessCelestia Mon 16:37

http://mlp.wikia.com/wiki/Princess_Celestia
Mon 16:38

incredible that there is a MLP wiki
Mon 16:39

Kind Sombra I demand to hear from you
Fluttershy Mon 16:44

What's up with the sombra?
Mon 16:44

Has he not spoken yet?
VinylScratch Mon 16:51

Sombra isn't your father. He's an evil king from another land
Fluttershy Mon 17:15

O_o/
Moderator Mon 17:29

AppleBloom votes to lynch KingSombra
AppleBloom Mon 17:30

So sombra isn't goingt to defend himself?
VinylScratch Mon 17:31

It could just be an awkward timezone
AppleBloom Mon 17:31

hmm maybe
Mon 17:31

I'll keep an eye open, to see if he comes back at all
Moderator Mon 17:38

SweetieBelle votes to lynch KingSombra
SweetieBelle Mon 17:38

I need to sleep. cant stay and watch
Moderator Mon 17:39

Derpy votes to lynch SweetieBelle
Derpy Mon 17:39

moving my vote off Sombra
Mon 17:40

as I'm gonna be away now and they may well come back and defend themselves
TwilightSparkle Mon 18:46

This is boring, let's throw around baseless accusations and see what sticks: DaringDo was SS... discuss.
Mon 18:48

"That's crazy, TwikightSparkle, why would an SS shift so early?"
Mon 18:49

That's a good question, FaceAndBodyAndVoicelessPony! I don't know, why wouldn't an SS shift so early?
Mon 18:50

(anyone else can join in at any point)
Mon 18:50

(don't be shy!)
Mon 18:51

"The only reasons an evil Pony would shift are that their original Ponyform is heavily suspicious and in danger of being lynched OR that they've found a target that's more trusted them their original form... do you think either of these are likely?"
Fluttershy Mon 18:53

WAIT
Mon 18:54

A potential SS happened?
Mon 18:54

When was this discussed?
TwilightSparkle Mon 18:54

Right now
Fluttershy Mon 18:54

This game is really boring so far
TwilightSparkle Mon 18:54

it's happening as we speak!
Fluttershy Mon 18:54

O right x)
TwilightSparkle Mon 18:55

no-one was talking so I decided to throw out some random speculation
Fluttershy Mon 18:55

I like it
Mon 18:55

The speculation part
TwilightSparkle Mon 18:57

We could do a role call...
Mon 18:57

but I fear it's too late on the day now
Fluttershy Mon 19:00

I'm down for a rolecall
Mon 19:00

But I agree it's too late
TwilightSparkle Mon 19:01

Rariry spoke but didn't vote...
Mon 19:01

She might get taken out behind the barn and shot at this rate
Moderator Mon 19:01

Fluttershy votes to lynch Lyra
Fluttershy Mon 19:01

I didnt vote as well, thanks for the reminder
TwilightSparkle Mon 19:02

No problem
Mon 19:02

You voted yesterday so it's fine
Fluttershy Mon 19:03

I know, but just to be sure ;0
Mon 19:03

;)*
TwilightSparkle Mon 19:03

Unless...
Fluttershy Mon 19:06

What?
Mon 19:23

?
VinylScratch Mon 19:30

I think Sombra's had long enough to say something. If he does defend himself, it'd have to be good to change the lynch in the last 30 minutes.
Moderator Mon 19:30

Rarity votes to lynch Lyra
VinylScratch Mon 19:30

No smites tonight :)
Rarity Mon 19:30

What's going on
PrincessCelestia Mon 19:32

I would like for Mayor to get more concrete
VinylScratch Mon 19:32

Mayor should tell us what dirt she has on sombra
Rarity Mon 19:32

What the hell is happening here
VinylScratch Mon 19:32

So we're not just lynching him for being inactive
Rarity Mon 19:32

a five vote stack on somebody
PrincessCelestia Mon 19:32

Not that much ro read, Rarity
Rarity Mon 19:33

based on not responding to a very vague accusation
Mon 19:33

ive read it all
Fluttershy Mon 19:33

Accusions what did I miss O_o
Rarity Mon 19:33

I should have said 'what are you all thinking'
Fluttershy Mon 19:33

I'll re-read real quick
PrincessCelestia Mon 19:34

I am thinking: Where is Sombra
Fluttershy Mon 19:36

A lot of people are thinking the same ;)
Rarity Mon 19:37

So Sombra has been accused of visiting somebody
Mon 19:37

and five poeple have pressured to lynch
Fluttershy Mon 19:37

He deserves this lynch
Rarity Mon 19:37

Im ok with lynching a lurker.
Fluttershy Mon 19:38

Same here
Rarity Mon 19:38

or somebody who is afk
Mon 19:38

but I dont think sombra is a lurker
Mon 19:38

maybe AFK
VinylScratch Mon 19:38

Nope, Mayor just asked him what he did last night
Fluttershy Mon 19:38

He is prob afk
Moderator Mon 19:38

Rarity votes to lynch MayorMare
Fluttershy Mon 19:38

If he is a lurker that he's just stupid
Mon 19:38

He could have spoken already
Rarity Mon 19:39

Could be a victim of timezone
PrincessCelestia Mon 19:39

Yesterday he was online in the morning
Fluttershy Mon 19:39

^^
VinylScratch Mon 19:39

If you can't speak at all in day, you shouldn't really be playing imo
PrincessCelestia Mon 19:39

so no, it is not timezone
Mon 19:39

Probably just life
Rarity Mon 19:40

Sombra was on for an hour in the morning
Mon 19:40

I think they may be a new player
Fluttershy Mon 19:40

I dont really like this lynch though come to think about it
Rarity Mon 19:40

Said something about 'can't believe this goes on for a whole week'
Fluttershy Mon 19:41

He is like prob a villager, no on is defending him
Rarity Mon 19:41

perhaps implying the game goes on for that long, then dropped a vote an hour later.
Mon 19:41

... hmmm.
Fluttershy Mon 19:41

If he was a wolf or coven they would have tried to defend him
Rarity Mon 19:42

Unless people think he is a lost cause
Fluttershy Mon 19:42

Hmm as an evil it would be pretty easy to defend him
Rarity Mon 19:42

I think its too late to swing it.
Fluttershy Mon 19:42

But idk
PrincessCelestia Mon 19:42

@Fluttershy aren't you defending him?
Rarity Mon 19:43

So I think we lynch, then interrogate those that voted for him
Fluttershy Mon 19:43

I knew you would say that x)
Rarity Mon 19:43

AND take them to task
Mon 19:43

Especially our MayorMare
Fluttershy Mon 19:43

I'm not, I'm merely telling you guys we are prob lynching a villager
PrincessCelestia Mon 19:43

That would make MM definitly evil
Rarity Mon 19:44

Without anymore evidence I agree with FLuttershy
Fluttershy Mon 19:44

I think if KS is villager there are at least 2 evils voting him
VinylScratch Mon 19:44

It could have been a bluff to get someone she thought was suspicious to slip up, Celestia
Rarity Mon 19:44

Thought it can be hard to fake a stalker or harlot.... as wolf.
VinylScratch Mon 19:44

She never claimed anything
PrincessCelestia Mon 19:45

Nope
Mon 19:45

they would be here then
Mon 19:45

or in some way react to KS not reacting
Rarity Mon 19:45

I've seen a 'good play' which involves faking a role as a villager and then attempting to 'read' how people react.
Mon 19:46

She did not claim anything - but implied it through accusing KS of visiting
PrincessCelestia Mon 19:47

I shall be quite displeased if that turns out to be the case
Rarity Mon 19:47

Well - I will grant its very indirect....MM asked KS to explain what they were doing last night. Which could just be a bluff or stab in the dark.
Mon 19:48

MM was not explicit about a role or about KS visiting... but did imply.
PrincessCelestia Mon 19:48

We are ahead of ourselves - we should discuss MM tomorrow
Fluttershy Mon 19:49

Yes I agree, but the fact MM is not responding at all makes it a bit weird
PrincessCelestia Mon 19:49

What bad can come out of lynching Sombra?
Fluttershy Mon 19:49

If it was bait he would have told us by now and lot let this come so far
Rarity Mon 19:49

Celestia - do you weigh in on this at all. I notice you have not voted for KS or otherwise
PinkiePie Mon 19:49

ok y'all I'm not complicit in this
Moderator Mon 19:49

PinkiePie votes to lynch Fluttershy
PinkiePie Mon 19:49

y'all lynch him, go on, idc he's a lurker anyways
Mon 19:50

but y'all aren't pinning anything on me
PrincessCelestia Mon 19:50

4 votes were quite enough for the cause of getting them to talk
Rarity Mon 19:50

Pinkie - are you against it?
Mon 19:50

If so, help balance on MM
PinkiePie Mon 19:50

anyways, if sombra is wolf/coven, we agree that rarity is the same, yeah ??
Mon 19:50

not against or for it
Mon 19:50

letting y'all do you
Mon 19:51

sombra is a lurker, most likely a new player given that "can't believe this lasts a week" comment
Mon 19:51

mayor was vague and never came back confirming bait or not
Mon 19:51

so I'm stepping out so I can't be blamed for taking action
Mon 19:51

for inaction, yeah, but same with many others yknow
Fluttershy Mon 19:51

I find it sus that MM didnt come back to tell us more
Mon 19:52

And ofcourse I also find it sus Sombra isnt talking
Rarity Mon 19:52

Taking no action to balance Pinkie - is still being part of it
Mon 19:52

if you stand by and watch a lynch you don't agree with - you are part of it
Fluttershy Mon 19:53

Okay so I think we could balance. What do we want?
Rarity Mon 19:53

If you want to try and distance yourself - wolf or otherwise, a 4 vote or 5 vote lynch makes no difference
PrincessCelestia Mon 19:53

If we lynch sombra : worst case: KS is powerful role / best case: coven / wolf
Mon 19:53

if we dont lynch Sombra: worst case: SS / Alpha /Witch best case: powerful role
Mon 19:54

Evidence against Sombra: MM saw him visiting x
Rarity Mon 19:54

Agree with PC
Mon 19:54

Thats really weak evidence
PrincessCelestia Mon 19:54

Yup
Mon 19:54

no roleclaim from Sombra either
Rarity Mon 19:54

But the worst case best case thing makes sense
PrincessCelestia Mon 19:54

* MM
Rarity Mon 19:55

Maybe Role vs. Maybe wolf.
PinkiePie Mon 19:55

rt
Rarity Mon 19:55

Its all meaningless.
Mon 19:55

Take the lynch. and learn from the five that voted on them
Mon 19:55

PS. I like that Pinkie has already started to throw shade on me
Mon 19:56

Because I *must* be the same team as KS
Mon 19:56

But PP - you are not free from this.
Fluttershy Mon 19:56

I dont see why you would be on the same team?
Rarity Mon 19:57

PP thinks I'm defending KS. Which I am to a degree. But I'd say I'm just trying to make a more meaningful decision
Mon 19:57

and think its weak reasoning
Mon 19:57

anyway, I'll be on later.
Fluttershy Mon 19:57

Be on later?
Mon 19:57

It's almost night
VinylScratch Mon 19:58

Game end in like 2 min
Fluttershy Mon 19:58

Like 2 mib
Rarity Mon 19:58

Maybe I wont
Mon 19:58

....
VinylScratch Mon 19:58

:P
PrincessCelestia Mon 19:58

oh
Rarity Mon 19:58

End of summertime has changed day start and end
Mon 19:58

Theres been a 2-hour swing for me...
PrincessCelestia Mon 19:58

they don't go by UTC?
Rarity Mon 19:59

There has been a change in my TZ, and a change in BST vs UTC
VinylScratch Mon 19:59

9am-9pm BST
Rarity Mon 19:59

1 hour each way over the last week or so
Mon 19:59

wreaking havoc!
Moderator Mon 19:59

PrincessCelestia votes to lynch MayorMare
Rarity Mon 19:59

Token effor?
Mon 19:59

Have fun in wolf chat wolves.
Fluttershy Mon 20:00

MM, Cecora, Applebloom and Sweetiebelly voted KS
VinylScratch Mon 20:00

Good night everpony
Rarity Mon 20:00

and PP
VinylScratch Mon 20:00

everypony*
Rarity Mon 20:00

never forget PP
PinkiePie Mon 20:00

smh
Fluttershy Mon 20:00

Mischief Managed
PinkiePie Mon 20:00

not on him anymore
Mon 20:00

was for pressure
PrincessCelestia Mon 20:00

Wrong theme, Fluttershy
Rarity Mon 20:00

Then balance
Mon 20:00

.....
PinkiePie Mon 20:00

not enough
Rarity Mon 20:01

sighs
PinkiePie Mon 20:01

won't do any good
Fluttershy Mon 20:01

Mischief Managed O_o/
PinkiePie Mon 20:01

besides, why should I balance??
Rarity Mon 20:01

Weak excuse PP
PinkiePie Mon 20:01

rarity, you're defending him far too much
Rarity Mon 20:01

NO no no.
Mon 20:01

Im attacking you now
PinkiePie Mon 20:01

you've been playing defence for KS because he's not on
PrincessCelestia Mon 20:01

@PP so you agree with the lynch?
Lynched Mon 20:04

KingSombra was lynched by the village
Killed Tue 08:33

Lyra was killed during the night
Derpy Tue 08:34

Lots of smite risk from yesterday
PrincessCelestia Tue 08:34

Why did the night take so long?
Tue 08:35

Whatever
Tue 08:36

I think it's time for the GD to come out
Fluttershy Tue 08:38

Might be useful
PrincessCelestia Tue 08:41

Actually, lets hear from MM first
Derpy Tue 08:43

these are known roles?
Fluttershy Tue 08:58

Are we doing a role reveal?
Zecora Tue 09:02

Hmm
Tue 09:02

So we actually lynched King
Fluttershy Tue 09:03

Yes and you were a part of it
Derpy Tue 09:21

duhh, I was reading MM as ML (Mason Leader) so that was confusing me
Fluttershy Tue 09:52

Should we do a full reveal?
Derpy Tue 09:52

seems as valid to me as anything at this point
Fluttershy Tue 09:53

We got like no info, so we need to create into
Tue 09:53

Info
Tue 09:53

So I'm down
Tue 09:53

*waiting for someone to tell me I'm high*
Tue 10:06

Is someone here to discuss things?
Tue 10:06

I'm bored
Derpy Tue 10:06

sure
Tue 10:11

or not, whatever :D
Fluttershy Tue 10:11

:D
Tue 10:11

Soo any suspicious so far?
Tue 10:12

Did you read the MM and KS thing?
Tue 10:12

I want MM to speak up ASAP
Derpy Tue 10:12

I did
Fluttershy Tue 10:13

And what did you think?
Derpy Tue 10:13

I agree with Pinky that Rarity was defending King quite heavily
Tue 10:13

I think we need more info
Fluttershy Tue 10:13

We indeed do need more info
Derpy Tue 10:14

more info from them, that is
Fluttershy Tue 10:14

Which is why I would be down for a full reveal
Derpy Tue 10:14

not just generally
Tue 10:14

King needs to either tell us what Mayor is talking about
Fluttershy Tue 10:14

Yes especially from MM
Derpy Tue 10:14

or Mayor needs to expand
Fluttershy Tue 10:14

Err, King is dead..
Derpy Tue 10:15

King is dead
Tue 10:15

I just realised that
Fluttershy Tue 10:15

:/
Tue 10:15

So we will only have info from MM
Derpy Tue 10:15

as I looked up to see who was going to be smited today
Fluttershy Tue 10:15

Which is something I don't like
Derpy Tue 10:15

yes, we need that info from Mayor
Fluttershy Tue 10:15

MM where are yaaaa
Moderator Tue 10:38

Fluttershy votes to lynch MayorMare
SweetieBelle Tue 10:41

What's the story morning glory ponies
Discord Tue 10:43

I didn't expect King was lynch with just an vague sentence like that :(
TwilightSparkle Tue 10:44

Hello my equine friends
Discord Tue 10:44

Hello
TwilightSparkle Tue 10:44

Discord, I would not have expected it either, but I do not believe he turned up to defend himself?
Tue 10:45

I have yet to catch up on the end of the day though, so I might be mistaken
Discord Tue 10:45

Yup
Tue 10:46

King didn't show up
TwilightSparkle Tue 10:47

I think at the very least, we should hear from the accuser (was it Mare?) to provide their full information
Discord Tue 10:47

It's Mayor
Tue 10:47

Right
TwilightSparkle Tue 10:47

MayorMare, how punny
Derpy Tue 10:48

in certain accents, yes
TwilightSparkle Tue 10:48

I suggested a role reveal yesterday, I stand by that today if others agree
Discord Tue 10:48

Seem like everyone want that too
TwilightSparkle Tue 11:02

great ^_^
Zecora Tue 11:07

I will start. Im vanilla :(
Tue 11:08

Like super vanilla
Tue 11:08

Im a zebra too
Fluttershy Tue 11:21

If we do this I like EVERYONE to claim
PrincessCelestia Tue 11:37

That leaves the powerful as targets ...
Tue 11:37

I think it is better for the Intel roles to come out once they find something
TwilightSparkle Tue 11:43

I am also vanilla
Tue 11:43

hmm
Tue 11:45

Princess, I think they should come out anyway, we've seen in the past that early role reveals leave the evils off balance and vulnerable
Tue 11:45

also they generally don't claim it claim late, so that gives any power roles better targets
Derpy Tue 12:02

I'm also vanilla
Tue 12:02

let's just get this out there
AppleBloom Tue 12:06

Well may as well drops some info down, before it becomes another empty day.
Tue 12:06

Trixie and sombra were villagers
Derpy Tue 12:08

that's their faction?
AppleBloom Tue 12:08

And role
Derpy Tue 12:08

so vanilla?
AppleBloom Tue 12:08

Aye
Derpy Tue 12:08

ok
Tue 12:09

but you are claiming GD
Tue 12:09

so at least we're not all vanilla
Tue 12:09

I could have seen mods doing that for a joke
AppleBloom Tue 12:10

So there is no way sombra could have visited, right?
Derpy Tue 12:11

ahh
Tue 12:11

unless they were a sleepwalker
Tue 12:11

was that implemented yet?
Tue 12:11

/guides/roles/Sleepwalker yes it was
AppleBloom Tue 12:11

Does that not come up? On gd check?
Derpy Tue 12:11

I don't think so
AppleBloom Tue 12:11

Lycan did right?
Fluttershy Tue 12:15

So who claimed vanilla so far?
Tue 12:15

Let's get a summary going
Moderator Tue 12:20

AppleBloom votes to lynch MayorMare
SweetieBelle Tue 12:24

Me. Im a vanillager
Tue 12:24

Just read
AppleBloom Tue 12:24

I see a trend coming on...
TwilightSparkle Tue 12:29

You'd see Sleepwalker
Discord Tue 12:29

count me in vanilla group
TwilightSparkle Tue 12:29

You find out their exact role, plus pretty sure a GD had confirmed a sleepwalker in the past
Moderator Tue 12:29

TwilightSparkle votes to lynch MayorMare
Discord Tue 12:30

uh oh
Tue 12:31

this feel familiar
Tue 12:31

Mayor, pls don't be the second KingSombra
AppleBloom Tue 12:59

At this point wolves will just all claim villager, and we'll just end up outing the specials -_-
Fluttershy Tue 13:04

I agree with AppleBloom
PinkiePie Tue 13:23

yo yo yooooooooooo
Tue 13:23

I third that
Moderator Tue 13:23

PinkiePie votes to lynch MayorMare
PinkiePie Tue 13:23

also, wtf mayor
Derpy Tue 13:43

hold on now
Tue 13:43

this is mayor vs apple
Tue 13:43

let's not just play "trust the newest info"
MayorMare Tue 13:52

HI all, so yesterday was interesting. I was trying to spark some discussion, it was really just an ASV, wasn't expecting that to turn into a lynch. But well, if he wasn't active enough to defend himself then seems like a fair lynch to me.
Derpy Tue 13:53

so you didn't actually see anything?
MayorMare Tue 13:56

I did not - I picked him because of the title (I'm Mayor, he is King. Mayor > King) - Was expecting more than just bandwagon voting and no defense.
Derpy Tue 13:57

pfff
Tue 13:58

I mean, doing that and then not coming back... that's the bit that's gonna hurt you
Moderator Tue 13:58

Derpy votes to lynch MayorMare
Derpy Tue 13:58

because we really needed to know that yesterday
MayorMare Tue 13:59

I intended to come back, but things got in the way. Lynching me will just remove another vanilla, so other than changing the ratio of evil:villagers, no loss.
Derpy Tue 14:01

that might be true
Tue 14:01

but the chance of you being anti-town is higher than it was previously, IMO
MayorMare Tue 14:04

Understandable.
Derpy Tue 14:04

if you'd come back and said this yesterday, it's something
MayorMare Tue 14:04

We should still try and use the rest of teh day to get some useful info from people rather than just another day focussed on lynchign a single person (which was not my intention yesterday)
Fluttershy Tue 14:07

That was a really silly move MM
Tue 14:08

I mean the bait was okay I guess. But not coming back is the bad part
MayorMare Tue 14:10

Well, had to try something. Yesterday was pretty dead, conversation wise.
Derpy Tue 14:11

so if you are a villager, it's even worse
Tue 14:11

since today's now the same
Tue 14:11

AND we're lynching you as a result
MayorMare Tue 14:15

Could always not lynch me and do something useful...
Derpy Tue 14:15

yep
Tue 14:15

could
Tue 14:16

gonna be tough to make that happen now though
Fluttershy Tue 14:16

It would all have been solved if you came back yesterday
Tue 14:16

;-;
MayorMare Tue 14:22

I realise I hurt my play a bit with that, it was unintended. And fine, if people are still going to lynch me today then I guess that's my fault - but at the very least there should be some other discussion, at least make the day useful.
Moderator Tue 14:22

MayorMare votes to lynch VinylScratch
MayorMare Tue 14:22

ASV on the off-chance I don't die. Hasn't spoken today yet.
Discord Tue 14:23

yo
Tue 14:24

worse scenario: 5 villager in gy tonight -_-'
Tue 14:25

*worst
Tue 14:25

I guess we have conven in this setting
MayorMare Tue 14:26

Have we seen any evidence of Coven? Anyone been redirected/swappped?
Discord Tue 14:26

nah, haven't heard anything
Derpy Tue 14:27

not many roles claimed, that could be redirected so far
Discord Tue 14:27

dozen of vanilla though
Derpy Tue 14:27

claimed vanilla
Tue 14:28

wouldn't surprise me if we had coven in that mix
Discord Tue 14:28

or, maybe there are lycans and sleepwalkers
MayorMare Tue 14:36

Started on April Fools, so probably a bunch of sleepwalkers/lycans
Discord Tue 14:39

if it's so, we might have a seer
Tue 14:40

or stalker
Tue 14:40

harlot
Tue 14:41

but no one has spoken anything
Tue 14:41

yet
Tue 14:47

so let's lean on the theory that we have fake claim here
BigMac Tue 15:06

Hey guys, BigMac's here
Tue 15:06

hmm, why do we lynch MayorMare
Tue 15:07

I think it was a good move yesterday to make Sombra talk and generate some info out of thin air
Discord Tue 15:07

that's right
Tue 15:07

but
Tue 15:08

she didn't come back after that
BigMac Tue 15:08

The way he didn't come up is bit sus, but so did Sombra
Discord Tue 15:08

bad move
BigMac Tue 15:09

I don't know, MM feels vanilla who tried to do something for a boring town to me
Tue 15:09

I don't think lynching her is a good move
Tue 15:09

if we wanna pressure and lynch someone, try the inactives
Derpy Tue 15:10

that's too easy an out
Tue 15:11

I don't want to play a game where wolves can make shit up, and roll with it if there's no counter claim, or just say "nah, I'm vanilla and was testing you".
Discord Tue 15:11

hmm...
BigMac Tue 15:11

that's called baiting
Tue 15:11

we have plenty of that in 127
Tue 15:12

why suddently a discrimination here?
Discord Tue 15:12

everything is vague right now
Derpy Tue 15:12

it's consistent logic for me, at least
Discord Tue 15:12

Derpy, how about postpone it a day?
Derpy Tue 15:12

don't listen to me
Tue 15:12

make your own mind up
Tue 15:12

move your vote
Tue 15:12

if enough people agree
Tue 15:13

my vote won't matter
Tue 15:13

you don't need my permission
Moderator Tue 15:13

BigMac votes to lynch RainbowDash
Derpy Tue 15:13

this is not a "let's all vote the same person" game
BigMac Tue 15:13

lol, any vote matters
Derpy Tue 15:13

it's a "who has the most votes" game
Tue 15:13

you've presented your point, I disagree
BigMac Tue 15:13

I would rather vote on someone who hasn't talked at all, like Rainbow
Discord Tue 15:13

I'm good for now
Derpy Tue 15:14

by all means, feel free to try and convince me, but ultimately make your mind up and do it, you know?
Discord Tue 15:14

yes, and yes
Tue 15:14

I've tried to convince you
Tue 15:15

like I said, we need clear evidence
Derpy Tue 15:15

so when the lynch happens, whoever dies, if we get more GD data, maybe use my stubbornness as evidence
Tue 15:15

or maybe use BigMac flying into to rescue Mayor as evidence
Discord Tue 15:16

sure, i note that
Derpy Tue 15:16

this is why voting who YOU want to lynch is essential, because it creates data
TwilightSparkle Tue 15:17

Derpy, it's not "newest claim wins" it's "vaguest claim loses"
Derpy Tue 15:17

well great news
Tue 15:17

I'm seer and Apple is a wolf
TwilightSparkle Tue 15:18

We (well, at least I) want Mayor to explain his statement yesterday that led to the lynch
Derpy Tue 15:18

2 things, one, there's no vaguery, two, maybe this is just a test
Tue 15:18

as a vanilla, that's a good play, right?
TwilightSparkle Tue 15:18

Derpy, are you going to vote for her?
Derpy Tue 15:19

I'm not being serious
Discord Tue 15:19

example
TwilightSparkle Tue 15:19

*shrugs* Why not
Derpy Tue 15:19

my vote is on Mayor because I think he made a bad play - if Apple is to be believed
BigMac Tue 15:19

no it's not, it called fake claiming and creates confusion
TwilightSparkle Tue 15:19

You could be
BigMac Tue 15:19

it's totally different from asking who did someone do at night
Tue 15:20

that's not hard evidence or fake claiming
Tue 15:20

*what
Derpy Tue 15:20

right, so what's hard evidence in what Apple said?
BigMac Tue 15:20

I don't fly in to rescue anyone here, but I see every active player who contributes to the game as an asset
Discord Tue 15:21

Mayor, pls say something, don't let BigMac here do your work
TwilightSparkle Tue 15:21

BigMac, my impression is that Mayor phrases the question in such a way that implied he had information - I would set that to some degree that is fake claiming
BigMac Tue 15:21

we could pressure and lynch inactives or ppl we sus, but lynching assets is a lost for the town
Derpy Tue 15:21

Twilight is right
TwilightSparkle Tue 15:21

say*
Derpy Tue 15:21

he definitely indicated he knew something
TwilightSparkle Tue 15:22

And if he didn't, he should have clarified before night fall
Tue 15:22

not just let the village continue with a lynch based on a false inference
Derpy Tue 15:23

^
BigMac Tue 15:23

yeah that's bad play, I agree, just not worth of a lynch
Discord Tue 15:23

yes, that's the point I agree with you
BigMac Tue 15:23

we would have pressured Sombra anyway
Tue 15:23

that's my view
Discord Tue 15:23

bad move
TwilightSparkle Tue 15:23

— I'm not trying to suggest that the lynch was incorrect or his fault, by the way
BigMac Tue 15:23

and he wouldn't come up to defense himself anyway
TwilightSparkle Tue 15:23

just that he *contributed* to it
Derpy Tue 15:23

my lack of investment in this game is kinda leading me to use it as "let's set an example and lynch for the bad play"
Tue 15:23

which is probably poor form on my part
Discord Tue 15:24

I get your point, Derpy
Derpy Tue 15:24

otherwise, what's to stop it happening again
Tue 15:24

OR becoming "acceptable" for wolves to pull off
TwilightSparkle Tue 15:25

I'm just following yesterday's pattern - Mayor's actions lead me to believe that he is off the opinion that if you don't turn up to defend yourself then you're eligible for being lynched ... so odd like him to defend himself
Tue 15:25

is of*
Tue 15:25

I'd*
BigMac Tue 15:26

Derpy, to state it clear, I don't see anything wrong with that play, it's the ppl who believe someone out of thin air, despite any hard evidence or clear role claim
Derpy Tue 15:26

are you using speech to text, Twilight?
Tue 15:26

I'd -> odd is an odd typo otherwise
TwilightSparkle Tue 15:26

no, just swyping quickly
MayorMare Tue 15:26

I just asked KingSombra what he did at night, I didn't say he actualyl did something.
BigMac Tue 15:27

they are the problems, not the one who tries that move
Derpy Tue 15:27

Mayor, you definitely worded it in a way that made it seem like you knew something
Tue 15:27

off the top of my head, it was something like "why don't you explain your actions last night"
Tue 15:27

indicating you knew there WERE actions
MayorMare Tue 15:28

Well yeah, I phrased it in such a way that if he was doing something he'd feel he had to say
TwilightSparkle Tue 15:28

"KingSombra - care to explain what you were up to last night? :)"
Tue 15:28

FWIW
Derpy Tue 15:28

ugh, I see both angles
Tue 15:28

I definitely read it one way
Tue 15:29

I now see the other
TwilightSparkle Tue 15:29

I'm not concerned that you didn't come back towards the end of the day to clarify that you were bluffing
MayorMare Tue 15:29

The phrasing was intentionally acusatory to try and elicit a response if in deed he was doing something
Tue 15:30

I should have come back, yes, I intended to. Unfortunately sometimes real life gets in the way
Moderator Tue 15:30

TwilightSparkle votes to lynch PrincessCelestia
TwilightSparkle Tue 15:30

Anyway, I got what I wanted
Tue 15:31

which was an explanation
Tue 15:31

although, I would like it made explicitly clear as to if it really was a bluff
Tue 15:32

just so we don't have a situation in a few days where Mayor claims stalker then we have to go back and decide between Mayor and Apple
MayorMare Tue 15:32

TwilightSparkle: It was a bluff, I am vanilla.
TwilightSparkle Tue 15:32

... or where Mayor dies and we lose a chance to expose Apple as a wolf
Tue 15:32

thanks!
Tue 15:33

so many vanilla :/
Tue 15:33

guess that's why we got a "Good Luck!"
Discord Tue 15:33

a lots -_-'
MayorMare Tue 15:33

I wanted to spark some discussion in an otherwise quiet village. I figured as a vanilla I can do it "safely" as if it backfired then it wasn't a loss of intel for the village if I got lynched in retaliation
Derpy Tue 15:34

instead a random role got lynched
Tue 15:34

which wolves would love
Tue 15:34

if we believe Apple, it was vanilla
Tue 15:34

shit, you AND Apple could be wolves
Zecora Tue 15:35

Hmm. Tbh i believe mayor a little bit. A wolf or coven wont likely to claim like that.
Derpy Tue 15:35

wait
BigMac Tue 15:35

well, I feel Mayor's play make sense
Tue 15:35

'cause I'm a vanilla too
Derpy Tue 15:35

he only come out as "fake" SINCE being disproven
Tue 15:36

so wolf could fake claim, knowing he was "safe" because BigMac here's gonna say it's a legit play
Tue 15:36

then GD disproves him
Tue 15:36

and he's then got that escape if he needs it
Discord Tue 15:37

or apple can be a BH
Derpy Tue 15:37

or just any wolf
Tue 15:37

only needs to be BH if we stalk him
Tue 15:37

any wolf could say "those guys who we killed, ahem, who died are both vanilla"
TwilightSparkle Tue 15:37

And then she's busted antsy
Tue 15:37

anyway*
Derpy Tue 15:38

that's an easy claim
TwilightSparkle Tue 15:38

because BH can't visit the dead
Derpy Tue 15:38

the only risk there is coven knowing they're a wolf, if a coven partner died
Tue 15:38

but coven can't tell us that without outing themselves
Tue 15:39

inb4 someone says Apple shouldn't have disproven Mayor because it was an obvious test
TwilightSparkle Tue 15:40

I just think we should move on
Discord Tue 15:40

at first, I kinda agree with Mayor, there's a possibility in his explanation
TwilightSparkle Tue 15:40

This line of enquiry seems like its leading nowhere
Derpy Tue 15:40

so Twilight, you think all involved are villagers?
Discord Tue 15:40

but BigMac put a great effort to defense him
Derpy Tue 15:40

aaaaand from it all, we got no data
Tue 15:40

except a lynched villager
TwilightSparkle Tue 15:42

Derpy, I don't know really but the way I see it we have two options currently: either we continue this discussion and decide that Mayor is a wolf, lynch him and hope that Apple can check him out we move on until something more concrete cones out
Derpy Tue 15:42

I don't even trust Apple
Tue 15:42

but I guess
BigMac Tue 15:42

@Discord I said it, as a fellow vanilla, Mayor's play makes sense to me
Tue 15:43

hell, if I have more time and care more for this game, I would try to bait some wolves too
TwilightSparkle Tue 15:43

and I don't think with the given information we can *prove* anything either way, so we are possibly going to end up another villager
Derpy Tue 15:43

BigMac feels so wolfy
TwilightSparkle Tue 15:43

lynching*
Tue 15:44

Derpy, imho you seem just as "wolfy" as BigMac
Derpy Tue 15:44

great
Discord Tue 15:44

even if I agree with him, I still have some doubt and didn't defensed Mayor that hard
Derpy Tue 15:44

I'm glad you've expressed that Twilight
Tue 15:44

maybe a vote would cement it
Tue 15:45

and certainly create data for future days
TwilightSparkle Tue 15:45

I'm not saying I think you're a wolf, just that you both display traits that I associate less with Ponies and more with Wolfies
Tue 15:46

let's discuss Apple - did she give another check?
Zecora Tue 15:46

So, up to now we have Twilight, Derpy, Belle, Discord and Mayor and me claimed vanilla
Derpy Tue 15:47

2 nights, 2 reveals from Apple
MayorMare Tue 15:47

Apple said Trixie and KingSombra
SweetieBelle Tue 15:47

So I just speed read. & We are lyching Mayor because of the bait?
Derpy Tue 15:48

WE aren't lynching anyone
Tue 15:48

holy shit
TwilightSparkle Tue 15:48

yes, I just read back ... also I noticed that Mayor already defended himself once, somehow I missed that (sorry!)
Derpy Tue 15:48

do you think he should be lynched? vote him. Don't think he should be lynched? vote someone else
Tue 15:48

the majority will win
TwilightSparkle Tue 15:49

we're only "lynching Mayor" in the same way that yesterday we were "lynching Sombra"
SweetieBelle Tue 15:49

I took it as a bait but since King didnt really appear to defend himself means we could have hit a faulty pony or simply just inactive pony who couldnt be arse
TwilightSparkle Tue 15:49

which is that the majority didn't get challenged
Tue 15:50

there's no formal agreement that we should lynch him, so if you disagree you should attempt to balance
SweetieBelle Tue 15:50

I dont see a need to lynch him imho. On the other hand, Apple a seer? You know what let me read carefully about Apple
Tue 15:50

Alrighty, I will balance
TwilightSparkle Tue 15:50

Gravedigger
MayorMare Tue 15:51

Apple said he was GD
Derpy Tue 15:51

oh man
SweetieBelle Tue 15:51

Oh wait but what balance when there's 4 on Mayor and the rest all one vote
TwilightSparkle Tue 15:51

Be the change you want to see
Moderator Tue 15:51

SweetieBelle votes to lynch RainbowDash
MayorMare Tue 15:51

or heavily implied I guess ([AppleBloom] Does that not come up? On gd check?)
Moderator Tue 15:51

TwilightSparkle votes to lynch RainbowDash
Moderator Tue 15:52

MayorMare votes to lynch RainbowDash
Derpy Tue 15:52

actively saying "I'm gonna balance" is effectively saying "I don't know who I want to lynch, but I'm not gonna let those who do have their say". It's pretty much anti democracy to balance. Which is fine, but you might be a wolf for doing it.
MayorMare Tue 15:52

I'm balancing for obvious "I don't want to die" reasons.
SweetieBelle Tue 15:52

GD
Tue 15:52

Wait, let me read her checks
TwilightSparkle Tue 15:52

So - question for y'all: do we think a wolf (or multiple) will have contributed to the lynch yesterday?
Derpy Tue 15:53

hard to say
Zecora Tue 15:53

I started the push actually
Derpy Tue 15:53

it very much seemed a "consensus" lynch
Zecora Tue 15:53

and didnt really comeback
Discord Tue 15:54

I think there are wolves
TwilightSparkle Tue 15:54

Derpy, what if it's "I don't know who I want to lynch but it's definitely not that person"?
Zecora Tue 15:55

Sounds wolfy :p
Tue 15:55

And Mayor is not even that trustworthy
Discord Tue 15:55

this is the chance they can vote without raise sus too much
Tue 15:55

and if Mayor is wolf, they need to defense him
Zecora Tue 15:57

Funny that ppl dont need that much justice when it came to King :>
SweetieBelle Tue 15:57

See this is where it gets tangle and hard for vanillager. When one starts to group votes as birds of same feather flock together
Tue 15:57

I dont see GD check.
TwilightSparkle Tue 15:57

Discord, I disagree: "I think he's a wolf for his behaviour" / "I don't think we can draw a solid conclusion from his behaviour, so we should turn our attention elsewhere for now" ... why should the former win without a majority?
Tue 15:59

maybe we don't come up with a better alternative, maybe in that case we should acquiesce to those with more conviction...
Discord Tue 15:59

they're not sure they can win, but they can try make the lynch reasonable
Tue 16:00

not raise too much sus
TwilightSparkle Tue 16:00

but yesterday we went with a lazy majority and we were wrong, why risk the same mistake?
SweetieBelle Tue 16:00

We were wrong/
Tue 16:00

?*
Tue 16:00

Sombra is someone special?
TwilightSparkle Tue 16:00

If we believe Apple; which I do currently
Tue 16:01

Sombra is vanilla
SweetieBelle Tue 16:01

Eh, am I missing out or I cant see GD checks
Tue 16:01

Oh, wait what is her checks?
Discord Tue 16:01

I don't know, like I said I think they can try and not make them seem suspected
Zecora Tue 16:01

AppleBloom Tue 12:06 Well may as well drops some info down, before it becomes another empty day. Tue 12:06 Trixie and sombra were villagers Derpy Tue 12:08 that's their faction? AppleBloom Tue 12:08 And role Derpy Tue 12:08 so vanilla? AppleBloom Tue 12:08 Aye
TwilightSparkle Tue 16:02

AppleBloom [Tue 12:06] Well may as well drops some info down, before it becomes another empty day. [Tue 12:06] Trixie and sombra were villagers
SweetieBelle Tue 16:02

That's feeding info
Tue 16:02

One way to know if she is really GD, dont even answer own question posed to her
TwilightSparkle Tue 16:02

"feeding info"?
Zecora Tue 16:03

We should know tomorrow, since she is the only intel that came out
Tue 16:03

sooner or later someone will verify or disprove her
SweetieBelle Tue 16:03

That's factions btw, not role. So I hope someone could verify her
Tue 16:04

Also, Trixie was caught D1. Either she is holding really powerful role as she stated she was or she was just playing a fool
Zecora Tue 16:04

Usually i believe the first one who comes out, except vanilla
SweetieBelle Tue 16:04

The next day, she died.
Tue 16:04

I usually give such claim a benefit of doubt
Zecora Tue 16:05

Why?
Tue 16:05

Trixie was like a good target
SweetieBelle Tue 16:05

So yeah but I will keep in mind that Apple gave only factions so perhaps she might have something at play for the benefit of village
VinylScratch Tue 16:05

villager is the name of the role
SweetieBelle Tue 16:05

Trixie was a good target because of the line she stated
Tue 16:06

@Vinyl ah my bad, I vaguely remember how to play GD
Zecora Tue 16:06

Apple can hide the info, i dont see problem with that. Villager is enough for us.
SweetieBelle Tue 16:07

Thus why I said prolly she has something at play for the benefit of village
Zecora Tue 16:07

So do you believe her or not?
SweetieBelle Tue 16:08

Benefit of doubt so yeah I have to believe her for now
Tue 16:08

Usually, this number of players might have 2nd GD
Tue 16:09

Which prolly be good to verify the claim GD as well as stay low
Tue 16:09

If there is another GD
Zecora Tue 16:09

stalker and harlot can also confirm
SweetieBelle Tue 16:09

Otherwise, Im sure we have other intel to prove her
Tue 16:09

Yup
VinylScratch Tue 16:10

Stalker can, harlot can't visit the dead
SweetieBelle Tue 16:10

Then again, if we do have a good intel, pretty sure that person would have check Mayor last night
Zecora Tue 16:10

Mb, i mean beholder
SweetieBelle Tue 16:11

I would check Mayor to see this person is lit or not based on the hoo-haaa yesterday
Tue 16:12

would have*
Tue 16:13

Silence means Mayor is good or silence could also means our intel is 6ft under. We running blind here anyway...
Derpy Tue 16:16

gonna be away again this evening
Tue 16:16

but you have my thoughts on things
Tue 16:16

and my vote stands
SweetieBelle Tue 16:17

At least we can cross few roles: No zealot, prolly no succu since no one reports of being redirected even if they have no ability, no djinn(or djinn prolly mess around in gy), no messiah (no 2 deaths so far), no vamp no fam. If this is solely wolves vs villagers, prolly all 5 wolves at play.
Tue 16:17

Good numbers of vanillas = 2 stalkers at play perhaps
Tue 16:18

Well, Im just assuming setup
Tue 16:18

I could be wrong
Zecora Tue 16:26

Note that this game started at April Fools XD
Tue 16:26

Ok got to sleep, g9 all
SweetieBelle Tue 16:27

XD
AppleBloom Tue 16:59

If this game consists of just villagers and a gd, ahhhh. It is an april fools game after all
Tue 17:00

N2-Trixie-villager (the role)
Tue 17:01

N3-KingSombra-villager
Tue 17:02

Yes I'm GD, just be clear
Tue 17:05

The only info we can get it seems, atm, is from lynches.
Tue 17:05

Balancing really doesn't seem the way to go
MayorMare Tue 17:07

There must be a killing faction as well
Tue 17:07

I don't think mod would be doign the killing themselves at night
AppleBloom Tue 17:08

Also Trixie baiting then dieing says a lot
Tue 17:11

Sleepwalker but instead sleep werewolf
Tue 17:12

Think you are villager but randomly kill at night, (superLycan)
Fluttershy Tue 17:13

I see some developments happened while I was away
Tue 17:14

Lemme read :D
Tue 17:14

Okay that's WAYYY to long for the time I got
Tue 17:15

Someone mind giving me a TLDR
Tue 18:05

MM might a puppet you know
Tue 18:06

Just trying to get someone lynched. I personally think the not coming back move was on purpose
Tue 18:06

So no new information showed up and we only had his information.
Tue 18:07

But don't pin it down on me. It's just a thought
Tue 18:08

I think he's either a puppet or a normal villager
AppleBloom Tue 18:12

Repeatedly balancing and not voting for people you suspect, will just lead to a straight loss.
Tue 18:15

With such a large amount of villagers don't expect much more info. Especially if people are so reluctant to lynch
TwilightSparkle Tue 18:31

Apples must be the name of his cat...
Tue 18:31

Sorry, I got distracted: Apples, do you support that we lynch Mayor?
Moderator Tue 18:39

VinylScratch votes to lynch MayorMare
MayorMare Tue 19:29

Fluttershy, there are no puppets
Tue 19:30

Vinyl: got anything to add other than the silent vote?
Fluttershy Tue 19:30

You kept track of the amount of people that joined this game?
MayorMare Tue 19:30

Yes
Moderator Tue 19:30

Fluttershy votes to lynch Rarity
Fluttershy Tue 19:31

Oh I didnt realize I voted for you
MayorMare Tue 19:31

(The API also makes it obvious)
Fluttershy Tue 19:32

So guys let's discuss. Do we want MM dead?
Tue 19:32

I personally don't know
Tue 19:32

I kinda want him lynched
Rarity Tue 19:32

Ok. A few things to add quickly
Fluttershy Tue 19:32

Like his move was weird
Tue 19:32

Ah, you're here
Rarity Tue 19:33

Mare made a bad play.
Tue 19:33

Lots of people followed and either voted or stood by and let the lynch happen.
Tue 19:34

If you dropped a vote and didn't come back.... bad play
Tue 19:34

If you were there at the days end and didn't help balance.... bad play
Fluttershy Tue 19:35

So do you distrust MM or do you just think it was a bad play as a villager
Moderator Tue 19:37

Fluttershy votes to lynch MayorMare
Rarity Tue 19:40

I think MM. is a bad lynch for winning this game as village. But the right lynch for sending the right message.
Tue 19:40

This vote is for better play at we.es
Moderator Tue 19:41

Rarity votes to lynch MayorMare
Fluttershy Tue 19:41

The thing is. I'm kinda thinking we're just lynching villagers here and the wolves are just staying low and are just laughing at us
Tue 19:42

As a reminder: MM, Cecora, Applebloom and Sweetiebelle voted KS yesterday
Tue 19:42

Who did claimed a role today?
AppleBloom Tue 19:47

Honestly I think we are getting caught up on balancing, when we should just be voting for who we suspect the most
Tue 19:49

MM is active enough to defend herself, but not to say yesterday that it was just an accusation
Tue 19:51

Look back yesterday for people that knew the lynch was a villager, and acted oddly to not put too much suspicion on themselves
Tue 19:53

The amount of people who I had as suspicious now voting on MM is worrying
Tue 19:54

I hope I will be around long enough to say the result tomorrow
MayorMare Tue 19:55

Some final words then to those who actually want to win as a village, look at the people who are lynching "to send a message" or because they didn't like the play, rather than those lynching because they actually want to win by lynching wolves.
AppleBloom Tue 19:55

AppleBloom, PP, Derpy,VinylScratch,Fluttershy and RArity are on MM at the moment
MayorMare Tue 19:55

To make it easier for people looking back, at the moment, the following people are voting for me: AppleBloom, Derpy, Fluttershy, PinkiePie, Rarity, VinylScratch
AppleBloom Tue 19:55

oh
Fluttershy Tue 19:56

I really dont know what to do
Tue 19:56

MM sounds like a villager though ...
Moderator Tue 19:57

AppleBloom votes to lynch RainbowDash
MayorMare Tue 19:57

I've admitted that it turned out to be a bad play, last minute RL stuff can do that to you sometimes, but if that's what people want then good luck.
Fluttershy Tue 19:57

Well it's balanced now
Tue 19:57

UGH
AppleBloom Tue 19:57

I have others to dig
Fluttershy Tue 19:57

I hate these decisions
Tue 19:58

Are we really doing this?
Tue 19:58

Like I cant do anything atm
Tue 19:58

My vote is already on MM
AppleBloom Tue 19:58

Urg
Tue 19:58

Smites are going through as well
Fluttershy Tue 19:59

Is somebody else here???
TwilightSparkle Tue 19:59

I can tip the balance, if you guys convince me in 1 minute
Fluttershy Tue 19:59

Who's getting smited?
Tue 19:59

urrr
Tue 19:59

donno
AppleBloom Tue 19:59

Idon't like balance
TwilightSparkle Tue 19:59

I would still prefer not to lynch Mayor though
AppleBloom Tue 19:59

but my gut says village
TwilightSparkle Tue 19:59

but I agree, too
Fluttershy Tue 19:59

YES OR NO
Tue 19:59

O_O
Tue 20:00

Too late
AppleBloom Tue 20:00

Hope it's not wrong
Tue 20:00

but would be good info
MayorMare Tue 20:00

I have no desire to lynch RainbowDash, he was just the only other person I could vote for that wasn't be to stop me dying.
Tue 20:00

So I'd rather there was balance for today, for purely selfish reasons right now.
Fluttershy Tue 20:00

Well at least this was a more interesting day
TwilightSparkle Tue 20:00

to be fair, I think Rainbow is going to get smited anyway?
AppleBloom Tue 20:00

Hope I'm here tomorrow
Tue 20:01

Otherwise enjoy villager fest 2017
MayorMare Tue 20:01

Yeah RainbowDash looks to be getting smited anyway, ok
Killed Wed 08:02

Rarity was killed during the night
AppleBloom Wed 08:12

I thought for certain I'd be dead today
Wed 08:13

Anyone want to guess DaringDo's role?
Derpy Wed 08:13

I certainly wish I was dead
Wed 08:13

there's a player called DaringDo in this game
Wed 08:13

?
VinylScratch Wed 08:16

yeah, she's like Indiana Jones, ponified
TwilightSparkle Wed 08:17

Apples, was it villager?
Fluttershy Wed 08:18

Morning
Wed 08:18

Just tell us
AppleBloom Wed 08:19

Ding ding plain villager
Fluttershy Wed 08:19

We need a TR
TwilightSparkle Wed 08:21

You know, it really wouldn't surprise me if Mod brought demons back, just for April Fools
Fluttershy Wed 08:21

O god
VinylScratch Wed 08:22

*overnight half of ponyville dies*
TwilightSparkle Wed 08:25

I mean, this was a fairly big game, it doesn't look like we have a vampire and there's no evidence of any alpha wolves either... so unless there are 5 wolves (in which case this have could be over as quickly as tomorrow) a pure werewolf vs village game could drag on quite a bit
Wed 08:27

and if there are coven o.o ... This could last even longer
Wed 08:28

hmm... the other option is that this is a coven vs vampire vs village game
Wed 08:29

but no evidence of coven makes me think that's unlikely
Wed 08:29

*should stop speculating*
AppleBloom Wed 08:29

At the moment it seems like the most cannon fodder village ever. No info role by day 5?
Wed 08:30

Villager killed N1 & 2
Wed 08:31

Am I the only 1 ;_;
Derpy Wed 08:32

or you're a wolf, as I speculated earlier
Wed 08:32

part of me thinks it's worth lynching you, since you're not really giving us any info we wouldn't have a good chance of guessing - at this point
Wed 08:32

so far, our knowledge of the setup makes your claim very easy to fake
Wed 08:33

plus wolves haven't seen fit to kill you yet
Wed 08:33

or even try to (no failed night kill)
AppleBloom Wed 08:34

Yes perfect, lynch the only person providing a slow dribble of info
Derpy Wed 08:34

but what info have you given us?
Wed 08:34

everyone who is dead is vanilla
Wed 08:34

like everyone who has claimed
Wed 08:34

like everyone in the game, probably
AppleBloom Wed 08:35

3 of the people I checked are vanilla, no sleepwalks no lycans. Plain vanilla
Wed 08:37

So what info have you given us? Following the same logic. The easiest claim right now is oh I'm also a villager
Wed 08:39

There seems to be no confirmation either, so either trust the one info role, or have nothing but villagers and wolves
VinylScratch Wed 08:51

I think it best to assume there will be no more info, lest we live out the rest of our days doing nothing but waiting for it
Wed 08:53

With no info, we must vote on suspicions alone.
Moderator Wed 08:55

Derpy votes to lynch BigMac
VinylScratch Wed 08:56

My suspects are SweetieBelle, MayorMare and BigMac, in that order. Sweetie and BigMac for defending MayorMare (which actually made me trust her less). They didn't seem suspicious at all of her.
Moderator Wed 08:56

VinylScratch votes to lynch SweetieBelle
Derpy Wed 08:57

I agree on Sweetie and BigMac
Fluttershy Wed 08:58

I'm mostly sus of BigMac
VinylScratch Wed 09:00

Then you should vote for BigMac. Everypony should vote for who they personally find most suspicious
Wed 09:01

So that we may generate our own info
Derpy Wed 09:13

this is part of the problem with people being around for a set amount of time, but not all of the day. Towards the end of the day, it's okay (even good) to make compromises with your vote to ensure a lynch. But at the start of the day, you should vote who you suspect the most. This also encourages activity from those being voted.
BigMac Wed 09:20

Hey guys, BigMac's here
Wed 09:21

on the run, so only few minutes
Wed 09:21

finally I catch a wolf xD
Moderator Wed 09:21

BigMac votes to lynch PinkiePie
BigMac Wed 09:22

my N1 N2 N3 checks are all village
Wed 09:22

you guys can easily guess who I checked N3 by now
Wed 09:23

I will be back in few hours for more info
Fluttershy Wed 09:24

Hmm
Wed 09:24

Okay, interesting
Wed 09:25

Why is it always when BH claim seer they go away after the claim
Wed 09:26

I'm not claiming seer or anything. It's just a thing I noticed before
TwilightSparkle Wed 10:13

Fluttershy, I'm not sure that's true; how many games have you observed that over?
Wed 10:13

BigMac: is it worth sharing the rest of your checks with us? What made you check PinkiePie?
MayorMare Wed 12:00

Hello one and all, what a glorious day to be alive. Your mayor is happier today.
Moderator Wed 12:00

MayorMare votes to lynch PinkiePie
MayorMare Wed 12:00

Lets see what PinkiePie has to say
Wed 12:01

This village is way too quiet :(
Moderator Wed 12:26

Discord votes to lynch BigMac
Discord Wed 12:27

Hello
Wed 12:28

So, one of the sus yesterday turned out to be seer, too convenient
PinkiePie Wed 12:46

yo yo yooooooooooo
Wed 12:47

man I kinda wish I was vanillager bc then I could be lycan and we could actually have a seer
Wed 12:47

too bad tho
Wed 12:47

hmmmmm
Fluttershy Wed 12:53

What are you claiming?
PinkiePie Wed 12:58

h m m m m m m m m
Moderator Wed 12:58

PinkiePie votes to lynch BigMac
Discord Wed 13:00

Pinkie, did you claim vanilla?
Wed 13:01

BigMac, pls list your check 3n before
BigMac Wed 13:01

Hey guys, I'm back
Wed 13:01

have about 10 min, still working
Wed 13:02

seems like PP claim HM, which is BS, if she claims lycan maybe I would have a thought
Wed 13:02

My checks?
Wed 13:03

N1 - ?
Wed 13:03

N2 - DaringDo village
Wed 13:03

N3 - MayorMare village
Wed 13:03

N4 - PinkiePie member of wolfpack
Wed 13:03

N1 check is still alive and village so I will reveal later
Wed 13:04

N2 I checked DaringDo because she made some kinds of strange characters, could be BH code
Wed 13:05

N3 I considered between Rarity, PinkiePie and MayorMare, in the end I checked Mayor because in case she claims some intel role D4, I will know if she's believable or not
Wed 13:06

that's also why I tried to defense her yesterday
Wed 13:07

N4 I considered between Rarity, PinkiePie and Fluttershy
Wed 13:07

and Derpy, but Derpy could be lit imo
Fluttershy Wed 13:08

Well at least your explanation seems lit
BigMac Wed 13:08

I saw that playstyle as a village before, a bit aggressive and odd, but acceptable
Fluttershy Wed 13:09

May I know why you considered checking me?
BigMac Wed 13:09

The reason I checked PinkiePie is because she voted both Sombre and Mayor and eager to lynch
Wed 13:09

very wolfy
Fluttershy Wed 13:09

I am very wolfy?
Wed 13:10

Or is this stil for Pinkie?
BigMac Wed 13:10

you guys could read back D3 for her sus behavior
Fluttershy Wed 13:10

right
Wed 13:10

I asked you something
BigMac Wed 13:11

Fluttershy, sry but you are on my list too, imo you are 80% wolf
Wed 13:11

your behavior yesterday is very sus
Fluttershy Wed 13:11

Well fine, but I asked for the reason
Wed 13:11

Mind telling me why?
BigMac Wed 13:12

the way you tell us that ''you don't know if MM is lit or not'' but still try to lynch him is inconsistent and wolfy
Wed 13:12

maybe I will check you tonight
Wed 13:12

I'm confident with 3 vanilla in GY, we must have some kind of protection left
Fluttershy Wed 13:12

I explainded why
Wed 13:13

Buutt sure. check me tonight
Wed 13:14

I explained I didnt like his bait and not coming back
Wed 13:14

He deserved to be lynched because of it. Yet I was not sure if he was lit or not
BigMac Wed 13:14

just maybe Flutter, I have another 2 suspects in my list
Fluttershy Wed 13:15

I mean you can check me. But the only thing you'll see me being part of the village
Wed 13:16

I find Derpy a bit sus
BigMac Wed 13:18

actually, I kinda find Mayor sus for her behavior D3 too, if I didn't check her, I could totally vote on her xD
Wed 13:20

yesterday when I saw Twilight and Sweeties quickly jumped in try to balance, I even thought she could be a Dire
Fluttershy Wed 13:20

What makes you think MM isn't Dire?
BigMac Wed 13:21

The fact that PP is wolf and voted on Mayor suggests the contrary
PinkiePie Wed 13:21

I am HM. nice job, kiddo
Fluttershy Wed 13:21

It could explain the weird move
BigMac Wed 13:21

wolves won't contradict others, at least at the first few votes
Derpy Wed 13:21

why claim Pinkie?
BigMac Wed 13:21

so Twilight and Sweeties are likely lit
PinkiePie Wed 13:21

because I'm under fire
Fluttershy Wed 13:22

This girl is ON FIJAAAAAHHHHHH
BigMac Wed 13:23

lol humor us then PP, your ''HM'' checks pls
Derpy Wed 13:23

HM checks?
PinkiePie Wed 13:24

bigmac, a word of advice: the more condescending you are, the less likely people are to trust you
BigMac Wed 13:24

sure lol
Derpy Wed 13:24

lol pinkie
Wed 13:24

"kiddo"
PinkiePie Wed 13:24

I learned that the hard way
Wed 13:25

n1 - fluttershy, random, she talked a bit. n2 - twilightsparkle, random again, talked to me for like 2 seconds. n3 - fluttershy, fairly logical and I wasn't sold on mayor being lit at that point. n4, [redacted], fairly obvious and also [redacted]
Wed 13:25

do y'all know how humiliating it is to have MLP up on ur screen in class
BigMac Wed 13:26

nice try PP, keep it up
PinkiePie Wed 13:26

once again-- the more condescending you are, the less likely people are to even humour you
BigMac Wed 13:26

I stated all my checks and reasons above
Derpy Wed 13:27

oh I missed BigMac saying Pinkie is a wolf
BigMac Wed 13:27

I will let the others decide who to lynch
PinkiePie Wed 13:27

you do that
Fluttershy Wed 13:53

@Derpy I almost did too, but BicMac but him on trail
BigMac Wed 14:39

Home finally
Wed 14:40

any question?
Discord Wed 14:46

say
Wed 14:46

n1 check, have they claimed a role?
BigMac Wed 15:05

yeah they did
Wed 15:05

vanilla
SweetieBelle Wed 15:12

Oh Mardy Bum. What's the story ponies?
Wed 15:13

Frak... what a long read
Wed 15:18

I get why ya'll suspicious of me because of my vote but I can swear that Im just vanillager
Wed 15:20

Seeing GD's checks pretty much all vanillas
Wed 15:20

Big mac claimed seer?
TwilightSparkle Wed 15:21

he did indeed
SweetieBelle Wed 15:22

PP claimed HM
Wed 15:22

BUt seen as wolf
TwilightSparkle Wed 15:25

So I'll add a few cents: I find the timing of BigMac's announcement awfully convenient - he was being discussed as suspicious and then turns up with a wolf; at first this made me doubt him, but after reading more and some reflection I think that it actually makes me trust him more rather than less
Wed 15:26

However, when I was looking back to see if Pinkie claimed anything yesterday (she didn't, by the way... I'll come on to that shortly) I noticed this:
SweetieBelle Wed 15:26

What am I gonna say: If I vote for PP or Bigmac, some of ya'll will see me as partnering with wolves.
TwilightSparkle Wed 15:27

BigMac [Tue 15:42] @Discord I said it, as a fellow vanilla, Mayor's play makes sense to me
SweetieBelle Wed 15:27

Ahh
TwilightSparkle Wed 15:30

So those are some thoughts on the burger, as for the pie: she didn't claim anything yesterday; she arrived (at least joined in the conversation) just after it was pointed out that if all the vanillas revealed it would just our specials, and she agreed... could be a wolf who wanted an excuse not to claim or a power role who wanted an excuse not to claim... doesn't help much in my opinion, but others might want to read into it
BigMac Wed 15:33

Twilight, you guys should all see that I was sus yesterday because I DEFENSE Mayor
Wed 15:34

I didn't reveal my role yet because she's just a vanilla, not an intel role, so I didn't think it's worthy to reveal mine
Wed 15:35

however I thought wolves could have picked up my defense on her and worked out that I have an intel role (hence I knew she's not wolf and not to lynch)
TwilightSparkle Wed 15:35

I suppose my concern with that is that you didn't *not reveal your role* rather you *claimed a different role*
BigMac Wed 15:35

that's why I purposely claimed vanilla yesterday, so they wouldn't kill me in the night
Wed 15:35

I didn't have to claim anything
Wed 15:35

no one asked me to claim
Wed 15:35

I did it purposely
TwilightSparkle Wed 15:35

You didn't say "as a villager", you said "as a vanilla"
BigMac Wed 15:35

ofc
Wed 15:36

if I claim vanilla, wolves wouldn't kill me, it's a wasted kill
Wed 15:36

if I just claim villager or nothing, wolves would know that I knew something, and kill me off in the night
Wed 15:36

it's a bluff for the wolves
Wed 15:38

like I often claim militia if I'm the WH, so coven wouldn't kill me off
TwilightSparkle Wed 15:38

on the other hand, wolves might have gone for you anyway just for being vocal, or they might have already had a bloodhound check you and found you are seer, and if they had killed you last night then your claim might have cause enough doubt to get the GD lynched
BigMac Wed 15:39

well, that's a risk we have to take
TwilightSparkle Wed 15:39

so *shrugs*
BigMac Wed 15:39

in that case, you guys should work out that I bluff anyway
TwilightSparkle Wed 15:40

We nearly tipped the balance just before night fall, which you couldn't have stopped
BigMac Wed 15:40

if you lynch GD for what I claimed alone, village deserves to lose
TwilightSparkle Wed 15:40

would you have let us lynch a villager to keep your role hidden one more night?
BigMac Wed 15:40

ofc
Wed 15:40

Mayor is just a vanilla
Wed 15:40

if she's harlot or stalker or some role, I would go out
TwilightSparkle Wed 15:41

How do you know she's not?
BigMac Wed 15:41

she claimed that
Wed 15:41

under pressure
TwilightSparkle Wed 15:41

So did you...
BigMac Wed 15:41

Twilight you are starting to nitpick
Wed 15:41

no one asked me to claim anything
TwilightSparkle Wed 15:41

(to the claim)
BigMac Wed 15:41

if I was to be lynched yesterday, I would obviously reveal my role too
Wed 15:42

it's funny
Wed 15:42

I checked Mayor and found that she's village
Wed 15:43

I defense her yesterday => now you guys think I'm sus
TwilightSparkle Wed 15:43

I don't think I'm nitpicking; you believe that your behaviour was justified, I'm just arguing for an alternative view point
BigMac Wed 15:43

IF I DIDNT defense her yesterday and reveal today => you guys gonna ask why didn't I try to save her
Wed 15:44

I believe my behavior is just and normal
Wed 15:44

try to put yourself in my shoes
Wed 15:44

and you would do exactly like that too
Wed 15:45

there's no other way
TwilightSparkle Wed 15:45

Maybe that's why we disagree
Wed 15:45

I would have revealed
BigMac Wed 15:45

sure, then?
Wed 15:46

you risk get killing off in the night, without finding any wolf
TwilightSparkle Wed 15:46

we don't know if there are any protection roles - if I knew there was a seer then I would assume there was a protector; if I assume there's a protector, the wolves also probably assume that... therefore maybe they won't attack me immediately
BigMac Wed 15:46

not to mention, you would still look sus in everyone's eyes, they will think that you are wolf and try to fly in rescue your teammate
TwilightSparkle Wed 15:46

maybe they will, maybe I'll get unlucky
BigMac Wed 15:47

so prot might not protect you
TwilightSparkle Wed 15:47

but saving a villager - even vanilla - from the gallows is beneficial imho
BigMac Wed 15:47

lol, so 50/50
Wed 15:47

lol
Wed 15:47

Twilight
Wed 15:47

pls go back and read D4 again
Wed 15:48

I WENT OUT OF MY WAY TO DEFENSE HER
Wed 15:48

that made me a target for the wolves
Wed 15:48

I think I did enough
TwilightSparkle Wed 15:48

so, I'm not saying your behaviour was wrong, just like I didn't say Mayor's behaviour was wrong... just that I can see why not everyone would agree with it
BigMac Wed 15:48

for a vanilla
Wed 15:48

dont you dare tell me to do more, for a vanilla
Wed 15:49

if I didn't check her and defense her, she would be another vanilla who gets lynched because we need to lynch someone
TwilightSparkle Wed 15:49

maybe I just don't like you're attitude that you seem to think you're superior to a vanilla
BigMac Wed 15:49

oh sure, as a seer, I'm way more important than any vanilla
TwilightSparkle Wed 15:49

because what you're saying is that you're superior to me
BigMac Wed 15:49

I don't think so, I know so, it's the mechanic
TwilightSparkle Wed 15:49

and that's insulting
BigMac Wed 15:49

Twilight, I don't say that I'm superior than you
Wed 15:50

you are imagining thing
Wed 15:50

I say that I'm way more important than you
Wed 15:50

if we want the village to win
TwilightSparkle Wed 15:50

are you more useful than a vanilla if you only see village and don't speak up when you know they're innocent?
BigMac Wed 15:50

don't speak up when you know they are innocent?
Wed 15:50

I didn't?
Wed 15:50

are you high?
TwilightSparkle Wed 15:51

you argued, yes, but you admitted you'd have let Mayor get lynched if it came to that
BigMac Wed 15:51

anway
Wed 15:51

everyone has their own playstyle
Wed 15:52

you don't get to judge me for anything
Wed 15:52

back to the topic
Wed 15:52

I'm seer and I find a wolf
Wed 15:52

do you want to lynch him or not?
TwilightSparkle Wed 15:52

so, after this little discussion, let me make one thing clear: I believe you're seer, I just don't agree with you
Moderator Wed 15:52

TwilightSparkle votes to lynch PinkiePie
BigMac Wed 15:52

sure, I respect that, like I said, everyone has their own playstyle
Wed 15:53

I don't tell you how to play as a vanilla
Wed 15:54

and I expect that no one tells me how to play as a seer
Wed 15:54

unless I make a big mistake, which I haven't
Derpy Wed 16:22

I have no read on anyone
Wed 16:22

it's a 50/50
Wed 16:22

I already didn't trust BigMac
Wed 16:22

slightly
Wed 16:23

so my vote stays there
SweetieBelle Wed 16:23

Im not sure who to believe
BigMac Wed 16:30

Sweetie if you believe Mayor is village-aligned yesterday, you should believe me
Derpy Wed 16:31

why
Wed 16:31

because you seer'd him?
Wed 16:32

because you defended him?
Wed 16:32

all easy things to do as a wolf
BigMac Wed 16:32

why? if I'm a wolf and she's a village, why the hell would I went out of my way and defense her?
Wed 16:32

everything is easy to do as a wolf, accusing ppl wolf included
Wed 16:33

that's exactly what are you doing right now, you choose to believe PP blindly
Derpy Wed 16:34

lol
Wed 16:34

I can believe PP blindly, or I can believe you blindly
BigMac Wed 16:34

lol
Wed 16:35

sure, voting pattern today will be a good data on who's wolf too
Wed 16:35

just vote as you want
Derpy Wed 16:35

only if GD survives
Wed 16:35

and is lefit
BigMac Wed 16:35

even if I get lynched, we will learn something from this, I'm sure
Derpy Wed 16:35

*legit
Wed 16:36

because the voting pattern won't mean dick if we can't get confirmation on who was what role
Wed 16:36

AND it be trustworthy
BigMac Wed 16:36

lol, we will
Wed 16:36

I believe we have more intel role than only 1 seer and 1 GD
Wed 16:36

they just haven't found any thing useful
Wed 16:36

to come out yet
Wed 16:38

3 vanilla in GY right now is actually a good thing
Wed 16:38

it means some intel roles are still alive
Derpy Wed 16:40

if we believe the GD
Wed 16:40

which is not guaranteed legit
BigMac Wed 16:40

true
Wed 16:40

he could be fake
Derpy Wed 16:40

I wish I cared more, but I don't really, sorry
Wed 16:40

I still want to be right, I'm not throwing the game, but this has been a real tough one
BigMac Wed 16:41

lol, typical wolf excuse
Wed 16:41

sure, vote as you want
Derpy Wed 16:41

typical wolf excuse? ok man
Wed 16:41

stick to one target at a time, yeah?
BigMac Wed 16:41

if you are a village and you don't really know who to trust, you would vote neither
Derpy Wed 16:42

nah, I like lynches
BigMac Wed 16:42

often wolves say that to misdirect village, and vote with their pack
Derpy Wed 16:42

you get info either way
BigMac Wed 16:42

lol, big talk, so you want to kill of a potential seer, in exchange for a potential HM?
Wed 16:42

great logic, if you are lit
Wed 16:43

and that's a BIG IF
Derpy Wed 16:43

lynching no-one does fuck all to help us, just gives wolves a free kill
Wed 16:43

lynching seer, GD says they're legit, we lynch the wolf
BigMac Wed 16:43

sure, lynch the wolf then, PP
Derpy Wed 16:43

it's not a fun trade off, but there's a 50% chance of us getting it right
BigMac Wed 16:43

lol
Wed 16:43

fuck up logic
Derpy Wed 16:44

let's balance
Wed 16:44

every day
Wed 16:44

how many games do village win?
TwilightSparkle Wed 16:44

depends if there's a zealot in the game
SweetieBelle Wed 16:45

There's no zealot
Wed 16:45

We have established that b4
TwilightSparkle Wed 16:45

but the answer to Derp's question depends
BigMac Wed 16:45

I don't say we balance, I say we lynch the wolf
Derpy Wed 16:45

no shit Sherlock
BigMac Wed 16:46

all thing equals, if you choose to sacrifice a potential seer, instead of a potential HM
TwilightSparkle Wed 16:46

village wins 0% of their games without a lynch UNLESS there's a zealot in play
BigMac Wed 16:46

either you are wolves, or your logic really has some problem
TwilightSparkle Wed 16:46

I was taking a cheap shot at a time I don't like ;)
Wed 16:46

at a role*
BigMac Wed 16:47

seer can find wolves and verify village, HM can't, that's simple
Moderator Wed 16:47

Discord votes to lynch PinkiePie
Discord Wed 16:47

cuz' your answers are logic
BigMac Wed 16:47

thx, Discord, you won't regret this
Wed 16:48

I think I already find another wolf, either Derpy, or Flutter
Wed 16:48

will check one tonight
Wed 16:49

Sweetie's hesitation doesn't sound good to me, but she's the first one that try to balance to save Mayor yesterday
Wed 16:49

so I think she's lit
SweetieBelle Wed 16:51

Of course wont sounds good
Wed 16:51

I have to place my vote either on you or PP
Wed 16:51

But I did stated yest that I gave apple
Wed 16:52

Benefit of doubt
Wed 16:52

And benefit of doubt I am giving now to both of you
Moderator Wed 16:53

SweetieBelle votes to lynch PinkiePie
BigMac Wed 16:53

Well, I think all my arguments, checks and logic sound much more lit than PP
Wed 16:53

but maybe it's just to me xD
Wed 16:53

if you need more proof
Wed 16:54

come back D3 and D4
Wed 16:54

PP voted to lynch on both Sombra and Mayor, both villages
Wed 16:54

she even insisted in lynching Sombra
Wed 16:54

that's why I decided to check her
Wed 16:55

I, mean while, didn't vote any of the 2, because I wasn't sure it's a good lynch
Discord Wed 16:56

hmm...except the claim and the visit list, PP didn't explain much
Derpy Wed 16:57

according to an UNCONFIRMED GD
Discord Wed 16:57

so you sounds more persuasive to me
SweetieBelle Wed 16:57

Usually those who has been accused and dont bother to defend themselves always turn out evil
Discord Wed 16:58

maybe I need to heard from PP more
BigMac Wed 16:58

sure, Derpy, you wanna choose to believe an UNCONFIRMED HM WHO GOT ACCUSSED WOLF
Wed 16:58

and disbelieve an unconfirmed GD + Seer
Wed 16:59

I can't figure why
Discord Wed 16:59

I don't think so, Derpy didn't trust you in the first place
BigMac Wed 16:59

god, I hope you are wolf, otherwise I might waste a check on a village with dense play
Wed 17:00

Discord, I dont need her to trust me, I just find it odd
Wed 17:00

that she distrust both me and the GD
Wed 17:00

but trust the HM who is sus AF
Derpy Wed 17:01

you claimed seer, who found wolf, after a couple of votes and more suspicion on you
Wed 17:01

classic wolf move
Wed 17:01

I'd already voted you at that point
Wed 17:01

I just didn't unvote you after
BigMac Wed 17:02

lol, the first thing I do when I get on here, is claiming and announce my checks
Wed 17:02

it didn't like I was on, chit chat for a while, then reveal and accusse some wolf after got voted on
Wed 17:03

sure, you can sus me for that, a bit
Wed 17:03

but it seems like you ignored all my arguments and logic
Derpy Wed 17:03

well sorry for suspecting you too early int he day
BigMac Wed 17:29

ok, got to go
Wed 17:29

things doesn't look too good for us, Princess and Zecora will be smited soon
Wed 17:30

hopefully we only have 4 wolves, if 5 then 1 alpha tonight and we lose the game
Wed 17:32

Prot pls protect me tonight, I have wolves to check
Wed 17:32

since we have no HM counterclaim, I believe we don't have HM at all, or he's dead already
PrincessCelestia Wed 17:43

Your Princess has forgotten herself
Wed 17:43

Let me read whay has happened since
PinkiePie Wed 17:52

you know what I think?
Wed 17:53

I think mac, tryna claim seer, decided to say I was wolf so I would be aggressive and aggravated and no one would take my side
Wed 17:53

it's a smart move but it's a shitty one
Wed 17:54

unless prot is alive/there's more hm, you're lynching your only protection
Wed 17:54

so good luck y'all, I'm not pressed
Wed 17:55

have fun losing
PrincessCelestia Wed 17:55

We have a GD, so no problem
Wed 17:58

BigMac seems legit and has some good checks .... might be our rescue
Moderator Wed 18:00

PrincessCelestia votes to lynch PinkiePie
PrincessCelestia Wed 18:03

Pinkie, who did you Protect?
TwilightSparkle Wed 18:29

I think she's gone...
PrincessCelestia Wed 18:46

I hoped to get some information out of her
Moderator Wed 19:08

Fluttershy votes to lynch PinkiePie
Fluttershy Wed 19:09

Well I think I trust the seer at this moment. I won't be on later so this will be my vote
PinkiePie Wed 19:54

I said all my protects
Wed 19:54

fluttershy, twilight, fluttershy, and unfortunately for y'all, applebloom
Wed 19:55

now y'all can lynch me and ill go back to this delicious mac and cheese
Lynched Wed 20:08

PinkiePie was lynched by the village
Killed Thu 08:02

AppleBloom was killed during the night
Derpy Thu 08:02

ugh I thought last night would be my night
TwilightSparkle Thu 08:02

Your night?
Derpy Thu 08:04

to be killed
TwilightSparkle Thu 08:05

hmm
Derpy Thu 08:06

one positive is that overnight I came round on BigMac a little
Thu 08:06

I'd overlooked a facet of his claim
TwilightSparkle Thu 08:07

I'm getting more and more concerned that we haven't had a double kill yet
Derpy Thu 08:07

concerned? alpha isn't a guarantee
Thu 08:07

and it might even have been blocked
TwilightSparkle Thu 08:07

could be that Pinkie was an alpha and we dodged a bullet lynching her, but I've not seen an alpha hold onto their kill so long before
Derpy Thu 08:08

or there is no alpha
TwilightSparkle Thu 08:08

hmm, true about the block
Derpy Thu 08:08

not worth worrying about tbh
TwilightSparkle Thu 08:08

yes, but no alpha is what worries me
Derpy Thu 08:08

even if the seer said "here's all 5 wolves", we can't lynch the alpha for certain
Thu 08:08

so don't worry about it
TwilightSparkle Thu 08:08

what are the chances that this is a 18 strong game with no vampire and no alpha?
Derpy Thu 08:09

with 5 wolves, fairly high
TwilightSparkle Thu 08:09

5 wolves, all vanilla?
Derpy Thu 08:09

since village seem pretty basically powered, if claims/results are to be believed
TwilightSparkle Thu 08:09

blood hound?
Thu 08:09

dire?
Derpy Thu 08:09

maybe not all, but it's impossible to know
TwilightSparkle Thu 08:09

shape shifters?
Derpy Thu 08:09

no-one's reported being blocked
Thu 08:09

SS is possible
Thu 08:09

and most likely, I'd say
TwilightSparkle Thu 08:10

mmh, I'm just paranoid that we're missing something
Derpy Thu 08:10

I'm certain we're missing a lot
Fluttershy Thu 08:11

So should we do a full role reveal or not because it's a bit late
Derpy Thu 08:12

I've claimed already, so I'm down for that
TwilightSparkle Thu 08:12

we already started t'other day
Fluttershy Thu 08:13

Started, but we didn't finish it or anything. Thus my question
TwilightSparkle Thu 08:20

well, my answer is the same as Derp's
Thu 08:21

"I've started so I'll finish..."
BigMac Thu 08:36

Hey guys, BigMac's here
Thu 08:37

on the run again
Thu 08:37

I have bad news
Thu 08:37

or maybe good, well
Derpy Thu 08:37

let's hear it
BigMac Thu 08:37

Flutter is village
Thu 08:38

or maybe Dire, but let's give her benefit of the doubt for now
Thu 08:40

I really need to work on my seer play, 4 out of 5 checks of mine were villages
Thu 08:40

zzz
Thu 08:41

Anyway, GD is likely lit, since she got killed off last night
Derpy Thu 08:41

yep
BigMac Thu 08:41

Tonight would be my turn I guess
Derpy Thu 08:42

maybe there's still some protection out there
BigMac Thu 08:42

Really hope we havr a beholder at this point
Derpy Thu 08:42

wolves haven't killed any power roles til last night
BigMac Thu 08:44

Also, another bad news is my N1 check got smited last night
Thu 08:44

Zecora
Fluttershy Thu 08:55

Well at least you're right on me being village. This makes me trust you somewhat more
Thu 08:55

Hmm, a bit convienent but sure
TwilightSparkle Thu 10:32

So Apples is probably our GD and I'd say her death means we don't have any protection roles
Thu 10:48

Anyone alive?
Derpy Thu 10:52

in body, yes
Thu 10:52

in mind, eh
TwilightSparkle Thu 10:55

:)
Thu 10:55

one of those days?
Thu 10:55

or one of those games...?
Derpy Thu 10:55

both
Thu 10:56

one of those weeks, at the minute
Fluttershy Thu 11:05

So who hasnt revealed yet?
Thu 11:06

If we finish this reveal I'd say everyone claims.
Thu 11:06

I dont know why but this is going like crap
Moderator Thu 11:07

Fluttershy votes to lynch PrincessCelestia
TwilightSparkle Thu 11:09

Pressureee
Moderator Thu 11:09

TwilightSparkle votes to lynch PrincessCelestia
Fluttershy Thu 11:09

Sparkle have you claimed yet?
TwilightSparkle Thu 11:09

yes
Fluttershy Thu 11:10

Vanilla I guess since I havent noticed your claim
TwilightSparkle Thu 11:10

vanilla, once day 4 and several times yesterday
Fluttershy Thu 11:10

right
Discord Thu 11:12

I'm too lazy to reread
Thu 11:13

If I remember it right
Thu 11:14

Only BigMac, Apple and PP claimed special role
Thu 11:15

The rest, plain villager
Fluttershy Thu 11:16

As in the rest has all claimed vanillager?
Thu 11:16

So that would mean everyone except for me has claimed?
Discord Thu 11:21

It seems so, or maybe the workload still mess up my mind
Fluttershy Thu 11:29

Hmm alrighty
BigMac Thu 13:40

Hey guys, BigMac's here
Thu 13:40

home sweet home
Thu 13:40

hmm so we are on a dead lead currently
Derpy Thu 13:40

you might as well lead BigMac
BigMac Thu 13:40

lead?
Derpy Thu 13:40

in voting
Thu 13:41

despite my normal methods
BigMac Thu 13:41

why?
Derpy Thu 13:41

you know what you know
Thu 13:41

you seem more legit to me now than you did yesterday
BigMac Thu 13:41

well, you all know what I know
Derpy Thu 13:41

true, but if we all start voting, there's some wolves in there trying to influence people
Thu 13:41

if you pick someone, at least we know that's fairly true
Discord Thu 13:42

hmm...
Thu 13:42

why's the change?
Derpy Thu 13:42

in my views on voting, or my opinion on BigMac?
Thu 13:42

(probably both, right?)
Discord Thu 13:43

yes
Derpy Thu 13:43

opinion on BigMac. Yesterday I overlooked that he was defending Mayor because he'd checked him and knew he was a villager. That explains his intense defence, but he hadn't yet claimed Seer. That did not occur to me yesterday, I realised it overnight.
BigMac Thu 13:44

hmm
Thu 13:44

I wonder how anyone who was active on here can miss that
Derpy Thu 13:44

my view on voting. Pretty much as I've said above. In this scenario, wolves are gonna be trying to lynch villagers. Villagers won't know who is who. BigMac can at least make an educated guess on the lynch, which I'd rather we all followed than letting the wolves try to influence us.
Thu 13:45

honestly, BigMac, I can only put it down to being wishy washy with the game. Not paying as much attention as I should, due to not being motivated by this game.
BigMac Thu 13:47

the sudden change of attitude is bit odd to me, but thx anyway
Thu 13:47

Like I said, you guys know everything I know
Derpy Thu 13:47

on voting, or on you?
Thu 13:47

*you voting
Thu 13:48

I was always 50/50 on you, barely leaning towards voting you
BigMac Thu 13:48

also, we are right about there are 4 wolves left, then 1 wrong lynch, even no lynch today would lose the game for us
Derpy Thu 13:48

we clashed afterwards because you insisted on talking like you were confirmed, but that didn't influence me wanting to vote
TwilightSparkle Thu 13:48

Derpy, did you not consider that Mayor could still be a wolf?
Derpy Thu 13:49

only if BigMac is
Thu 13:49

there's no way BigMac is a villager if Mayor is a wolf
Thu 13:49

uhg
Thu 13:49

wrong way roun
Thu 13:49

d
TwilightSparkle Thu 13:49

yes, and you thought BigMac was yesterday - now you say you think he's seer because he defended Mayor
BigMac Thu 13:50

I and Mayor both could be wolves, theoritically xD
Derpy Thu 13:50

true
TwilightSparkle Thu 13:50

but if neither is confirmed, I don't see how these influences your opinion
Thu 13:50

that*
BigMac Thu 13:51

so do I
Thu 13:51

that's an odd play after your extremely aggressive attitude against me yesterday
Thu 13:52

but I haven't seen any harm from your support, so whatever
Thu 13:53

unless you are trying to make me look sus, like you and I are 2 wolves that support each other xD
Thu 13:53

back to the topic
Thu 13:53

if there are 4 wolves left
Thu 13:53

1 wrong lynch, or even no lynch today = gg for us
Thu 13:54

and bad news is we have no concrete lead at the moment
TwilightSparkle Thu 13:55

Good news is that we have a high chance of lynching a wolf
BigMac Thu 13:55

voting pattern and role claims are our only weapon right now
TwilightSparkle Thu 13:56

Assuming you're not lying to us ;)
BigMac Thu 13:56

high chance, Twilight?
TwilightSparkle Thu 13:56

9 players, 4 wolves, 3 "confirmed" villages
BigMac Thu 13:56

50% isn't too high in my book, considering that Mayor or Flutter could be Dire
TwilightSparkle Thu 13:56

that means we've got a 4/6 chance of hitting a wolf
Derpy Thu 13:57

2/3
Thu 13:57

yeah, it's not 50/50
Thu 13:57

assuming we trust you
BigMac Thu 13:57

esply Flutter, I still find her very sus, based on her behavior D4 and D5
Derpy Thu 13:57

and in fact, better than that, for those of us who haven't been checked - if we trust you
TwilightSparkle Thu 13:57

yes, true about Dire
Derpy Thu 13:57

because it's 4/5 in that case
BigMac Thu 13:57

and I believe we can totally have Dire in a blind game like this
TwilightSparkle Thu 13:58

I think it's way too OP in a blind game :(
Derpy Thu 13:58

this is true
BigMac Thu 13:58

not to mention, with 4 wolves left, they could even force a vote, 1 inactive and we lose
Derpy Thu 13:58

pfff
Thu 13:58

hadn't thought about that
BigMac Thu 13:58

the odd is really stacked against us xD
Derpy Thu 13:58

they can force a balance, at least
Thu 13:59

which is no lynch, which is probably a loss
Thu 13:59

if not now, then tomorrow
BigMac Thu 13:59

no, they can't, if we are all be active enought, so make sure to check back when you guys have time, until the end
Thu 14:00

so, I believe voting pattern and role claims are our best weapon right now
Thu 14:00

correct me if I'm wrong
Thu 14:00

so far we have
Thu 14:00

BigMac - seer
Thu 14:00

MayorMare - vanilla
Thu 14:00

Discord - vanilla
Thu 14:00

SweetieBelle - vanilla
Thu 14:01

Derpy - vanilla
Thu 14:01

TwilightSparkle - vanilla
Thu 14:01

Fluttershy - ?
Thu 14:01

VinylScratch - ?
Thu 14:01

PrincessCelestia - ?
VinylScratch Thu 14:01

Villager
BigMac Thu 14:01

meant vanilla?
VinylScratch Thu 14:01

Villager the role
BigMac Thu 14:01

that's convenient, but sure
Thu 14:02

so VinylScratch - vanilla
Derpy Thu 14:02

only as convenient as any others you haven't checked
Thu 14:02

like me
BigMac Thu 14:03

I can't believe a game like this, with 4-5 wolves and only 1 seer + 1 GD???
Thu 14:03

are you fking kidding me mod?
Derpy Thu 14:03

some dead people didn't get GD'd, right?
VinylScratch Thu 14:03

Yeah
BigMac Thu 14:03

yeah, Imo Lyra could be something
Thu 14:04

her dead felt odd
Derpy Thu 14:04

plus those you've "seen" could have been SS'd
Thu 14:04

which actually fucks the whole thing up
BigMac Thu 14:04

she wasn't active or contributing, looks like a checked-killed dead
Derpy Thu 14:04

but, eh, not much to be done for that
PrincessCelestia Thu 14:05

The time has come for me to reveal
BigMac Thu 14:05

I don't really think we have a SS that shifted, yet
Thu 14:05

AppleBoom didn't have any reason to shift
Thu 14:05

and Rarity died before I came out
PrincessCelestia Thu 14:06

to reveal my reads
BigMac Thu 14:06

nice, PC, what read?
PrincessCelestia Thu 14:06

my tarot read!
VinylScratch Thu 14:06

When did you use the power? Last night?
PrincessCelestia Thu 14:06

yep
Thu 14:07

thats why i didnt claim earlier
Derpy Thu 14:07

awesome, my cynicism had dropped on BigMac, now it gets to be huge again on you....
BigMac Thu 14:07

pls state your read first
PrincessCelestia Thu 14:07

ok
Thu 14:07

There is protection left in this village
Derpy Thu 14:08

or WAS
Thu 14:08

since your result goes before the kill, right?
PrincessCelestia Thu 14:08

Werewolves [2] and SS [1]
VinylScratch Thu 14:08

If you think applebloom was protector or HM?
TwilightSparkle Thu 14:08

but the kill was GD, surely?
BigMac Thu 14:08

...
Thu 14:08

guys
Thu 14:08

let her finish her read
PrincessCelestia Thu 14:08

calm down
Derpy Thu 14:08

oh of course
Thu 14:08

haha
TwilightSparkle Thu 14:08

unless Apples was shifter
PrincessCelestia Thu 14:09

GD [0] and Seer [1]
BigMac Thu 14:09

or I will have to think that you are giving her hintes, as wolves
TwilightSparkle Thu 14:09

0 GD?
VinylScratch Thu 14:10

Means apples wasn't a GD when she died
BigMac Thu 14:10

PLS LET HER FUCKING FINISH HER READ
TwilightSparkle Thu 14:11

I assumed she's finished...?
BigMac Thu 14:11

you assumed? we have 10 ppl last night
Moderator Thu 14:11

VinylScratch votes to lynch PrincessCelestia
BigMac Thu 14:12

PC, how about hurry up, it can't take that long to read and type your read out
PrincessCelestia Thu 14:12

Lycan [1] and Militia [1] Villagers [3]
Thu 14:12

sorry
VinylScratch Thu 14:12

finished now?
PrincessCelestia Thu 14:12

my connection dropped (tunnel)
Thu 14:12

yes, finishe
Thu 14:12

d
BigMac Thu 14:12

huh
Thu 14:12

are you sure?
TwilightSparkle Thu 14:12

...
VinylScratch Thu 14:13

Your check means that applebloom was village aligned but not a GD which doesn't make much sense
Thu 14:13

If she had already shifted, how did she die?
PrincessCelestia Thu 14:13

I updated the number
Thu 14:13

bc she died ....
BigMac Thu 14:13

you dont get to update anything
Thu 14:13

just show us all your read
Thu 14:14

without copy pasting
PrincessCelestia Thu 14:14

sigh
Thu 14:14

ok
BigMac Thu 14:14

you are looking quite sus now, you know that?
Derpy Thu 14:14

chill BigMac
TwilightSparkle Thu 14:15

what happened to the protection?
BigMac Thu 14:15

ok, pls PC
PrincessCelestia Thu 14:15

Werwolf [2], SS [1], Lycan [1], Militia [1], Villager [3], GD [1], Seer [1], Protector [1]
Derpy Thu 14:16

so at least one villager is lying, but there's also a lycan
Thu 14:16

meaning the seer results are no good
BigMac Thu 14:16

PP is no lycan, she claimed HM
PrincessCelestia Thu 14:17

^
Derpy Thu 14:17

and she got lynched
TwilightSparkle Thu 14:17

You did that check last night, right?
PrincessCelestia Thu 14:17

yes
BigMac Thu 14:17

good news is, if we believe PC's read, there're only 3 wolves left
Derpy Thu 14:17

oh shit wait, I got it wrong
BigMac Thu 14:17

which buy us some space to breath
Derpy Thu 14:17

your reads ARE good
Fluttershy Thu 14:17

Also no dire?
Derpy Thu 14:17

because a lycan appears as a wolf
Fluttershy Thu 14:17

Great
Derpy Thu 14:17

durr
BigMac Thu 14:18

however
VinylScratch Thu 14:18

How do you have 11 people in the check?
BigMac Thu 14:18

how come we have 11 in the read?
Fluttershy Thu 14:18

Why durr -_-
Derpy Thu 14:18

durr at me, flutter
Fluttershy Thu 14:18

You weren't sure either
Derpy Thu 14:18

there's 11 because it's before the night kill guys
TwilightSparkle Thu 14:18

also
Thu 14:18

where the TR?
Fluttershy Thu 14:18

Oh right
Derpy Thu 14:18

hence the 1 GD
BigMac Thu 14:18

there's only 1 kill
Thu 14:18

last night
Derpy Thu 14:18

LOL
VinylScratch Thu 14:18

should be 10
Derpy Thu 14:18

where IS the TR?
BigMac Thu 14:18

true, where's the TR xD
TwilightSparkle Thu 14:19

Where. Is. The. Tarot. Reader?
PrincessCelestia Thu 14:19

ok, let me retry without c/p
Fluttershy Thu 14:19

Wait what?
Derpy Thu 14:19

ok, I got way confused there, I thought we were at 10, maybe cos I was thinking "it needs to be 10 to account for the kill" then I recounted and was like "it needs to be 11, cos we're at 10". Sorry for confusion
PrincessCelestia Thu 14:20

w/e I failed
Thu 14:20

the truth is
BigMac Thu 14:21

..you are wolf?
Fluttershy Thu 14:21

You're vanilla.. :/
PrincessCelestia Thu 14:21

Werwolf [2], SS [1], Lycan [1], Militia [1], Villager [2], GD [1], Seer [1], Protector [0], TR [1]
BigMac Thu 14:21

interesting
Derpy Thu 14:21

why 0 on protector?
Fluttershy Thu 14:21

What is this
BigMac Thu 14:22

what are you trying to do PC?
PrincessCelestia Thu 14:22

I tried to pretend that there is a protector, but i was to stupid
BigMac Thu 14:22

preten that there's prot to do what?
Fluttershy Thu 14:23

So no protector left Princess? :(
PrincessCelestia Thu 14:23

Isn't it obvious?
BigMac Thu 14:23

no it doesn't to me
Derpy Thu 14:23

to draw the kill off you, BigMac
PrincessCelestia Thu 14:23

^
BigMac Thu 14:23

lol
Thu 14:23

I don't think so
Fluttershy Thu 14:23

Princess there is no protectore left? :(
BigMac Thu 14:23

even if we have prot
PrincessCelestia Thu 14:24

*had
BigMac Thu 14:24

he's likely to prot GD N4 and me last night
Thu 14:24

so I'm totally could be killed tonight
Fluttershy Thu 14:24

Okay fuck it, I'm protector. ugh why did for make me come out
PrincessCelestia Thu 14:24

ok
Fluttershy Thu 14:24

So princess, youre lying
BigMac Thu 14:24

even more interesting
PrincessCelestia Thu 14:25

nope, I am not
Fluttershy Thu 14:25

Dont you remember BigMac checked me?
PrincessCelestia Thu 14:25

I do
Thu 14:25

but you arent protector
BigMac Thu 14:25

your check pls, Flutt
Fluttershy Thu 14:25

So, even in your case you're lying
Derpy Thu 14:25

inb4 Mayor, BigMac and Flutter are wolves
Fluttershy Thu 14:26

Derpy -_-
Derpy Thu 14:26

hey, it's not the worst play ever
Fluttershy Thu 14:26

Sure let me check
Thu 14:26

I can already say I forgot to prot n1
BigMac Thu 14:27

all in one, pls, except N5
Fluttershy Thu 14:27

N2 myself - N3 Rarity - N4 myself - N5 SECRET
BigMac Thu 14:27

Derpy, so you think I'm wolf again?
Derpy Thu 14:27

you shouldn't have claimed
Thu 14:28

BigMac, I'm saying it's possible
PrincessCelestia Thu 14:28

You protected yourself n4?
Derpy Thu 14:28

you're all linked now
Fluttershy Thu 14:28

And why not
Thu 14:28

Princess is lying here, so ofcourse I claimed
BigMac Thu 14:28

why did you prot yourself N4, but not GD?
Fluttershy Thu 14:28

Yes I prot myself N4
Derpy Thu 14:28

problem with claiming is that it's very obvious who you protected last night. So it's obvious who you can't protect tonight. So claiming outright was a little silly, since it's not gonna gain us anything. You could have said "I'm a role not in that list".
Fluttershy Thu 14:29

Because I was surte they wouldnt kill him that night
Derpy Thu 14:29

we'd still know she was lying
Thu 14:29

without having it easy for the wolves to kill BigMac tonight
BigMac Thu 14:29

how can you sure that they wouldn't kill the GD?
Fluttershy Thu 14:30

I was almost sure they would after she claimed.
PrincessCelestia Thu 14:30

the thing is, that Fluttershy is still lying, and her checks make no sense
Fluttershy Thu 14:30

Also, I wasnt completly sure if he was lit
PrincessCelestia Thu 14:30

I think she got shifted ...
Fluttershy Thu 14:30

Ask me ANYTHING you want and I'll answer
Thu 14:30

Now fuck off Princess will you
Derpy Thu 14:30

pineapple on pizza, yes or no?
Thu 14:30

woah
Discord Thu 14:31

tbh, I feel everything is too convenient for BigMac
Derpy Thu 14:31

chillll
Fluttershy Thu 14:31

Big NO
Thu 14:31

Pinapples dont go in pizza
VinylScratch Thu 14:31

You mean Yay or Neigh?
BigMac Thu 14:31

Derpy, what's youre opinion on Flutter and Princess
Thu 14:31

I want to know your opinion
Derpy Thu 14:31

Discord, whilst this is true, it's not impossible
BigMac Thu 14:31

who do you trust?
Derpy Thu 14:31

that's what I'm wrestling with
Thu 14:31

right now, I'm trusting Flutter over Princess
Discord Thu 14:32

wait, what, darn my connection
Derpy Thu 14:32

but if you're all wolves, I hate you
Fluttershy Thu 14:32

I assure you, I'm not
PrincessCelestia Thu 14:32

BigMac is legit
BigMac Thu 14:32

why do you trust Flutter over Princess?
PrincessCelestia Thu 14:32

Flutter is not
Moderator Thu 14:32

PrincessCelestia votes to lynch Fluttershy
Fluttershy Thu 14:32

Princess he checked me -____-
Thu 14:32

And no I dont get shifted
PrincessCelestia Thu 14:32

Of course
Fluttershy Thu 14:32

Some people should be ablke to tell that
BigMac Thu 14:32

Derpy, why do you trust FLutter over Princess?
Fluttershy Thu 14:33

Check my writing, EXACTLY the same
BigMac Thu 14:33

and if you do, why do you think I'm a wolf if flutter is lit?
Derpy Thu 14:33

IF Princess is legit, there is a Seer. There's no counter, so it's BigMac. BigMac checked Flutter, so that's a link. Flutter being legit means Princess isn't.
Thu 14:33

that's my logic
Thu 14:34

and I think (hope) it's tight
BigMac Thu 14:34

but you said that I could be wolf above?
Derpy Thu 14:34

I've changed my mind
Thu 14:34

I mean, you could be, but it's a lot smaller chance now
TwilightSparkle Thu 14:34

Fluttershy, why didn't you protect Apples last night? o.o
BigMac Thu 14:34

lol, your mind changes like weather xD
Derpy Thu 14:34

I see new info, I change my mind
Thu 14:34

or, I realise new info
Fluttershy Thu 14:35

Neew info?
BigMac Thu 14:36

ok, so first thing, we have a conflict today, which means Flutter or Princess must be wolf
Derpy Thu 14:37

Flutter - more a reinterpretation of the info I already had
BigMac Thu 14:38

which is much more better than what we started the day with, like, no lead at all
Thu 14:38

the question here is, who is lit, Flutter or Princess
Fluttershy Thu 14:39

Bigmac, you must know I'm lit, you checked me. and if yuou think I got shifted, then check the previous days
Derpy Thu 14:39

you've checked one of them BigMac
Thu 14:39

shifts are possible
Thu 14:39

but shit, that's tough for us to call
Fluttershy Thu 14:39

They indeed are, but you'll immediately see its still me
Thu 14:39

Nahh, you can see its me
TwilightSparkle Thu 14:40

I want to know why Flutter didn't protect the most important Intel role for last night
Fluttershy Thu 14:42

Last night?
BigMac Thu 14:42

#Flutter: I checked her, she's village-aligned but we can't rule out the possible of a Dire that exploited my check on her. I still think Flutter's behavior on D4 and D5 look sus, also her prots weren't really good prot.
Fluttershy Thu 14:42

I didnt state my prot from last night
BigMac Thu 14:42

#Princess: Her reveal after being pressured looks bit sus, TR uses power N5 is also unusual, and she messed up her checks 2 first times in attempt for a ''prot bluff'', which doesn't have any clear intention imo.
Fluttershy Thu 14:43

So how could you know
TwilightSparkle Thu 14:43

because they died
Moderator Thu 14:43

Derpy votes to lynch PrincessCelestia
TwilightSparkle Thu 14:43

-_-
Fluttershy Thu 14:43

@BigMac how can you say I'm Dire? The 'TR'rread said NO dire
BigMac Thu 14:44

oh, goddamn, true
Derpy Thu 14:44

haha
BigMac Thu 14:44

haha, thx Flutter
Moderator Thu 14:44

BigMac votes to lynch PrincessCelestia
Derpy Thu 14:44

Princess's claim just gets worse and worse for her, as far as I can tell
Fluttershy Thu 14:45

Well if she would have kept her 1 list and if she didnt change the prot then I might have believed her
BigMac Thu 14:45

I must go take a shower, feel tired after a long day and starting to confuse myself at the moment
Thu 14:45

but right now we can pretty much say that Princess is a wolf
Thu 14:45

be back in 15 mins
Fluttershy Thu 14:46

Alrightyy
BigMac Thu 14:46

and thx for the TR attempt, princess xD
Discord Thu 14:46

sorry, I've just caught up with you guys
Moderator Thu 14:46

Discord votes to lynch PrincessCelestia
PrincessCelestia Thu 14:47

ok, I am really confused
Fluttershy Thu 14:47

Because your claim didnt work out like you wanted?
PrincessCelestia Thu 14:48

THe only explaination is that Fluttershy got shifted into
Thu 14:48

ok
Fluttershy Thu 14:48

The explantion is: you're lying
PrincessCelestia Thu 14:48

So, I know there is a militia
Derpy Thu 14:48

militia, if you're here, claim
Thu 14:48

it can't hurt, at this point
PrincessCelestia Thu 14:48

may I politely ask that person to shoot Fluttershy?
Derpy Thu 14:49

ask them to claim and confirm you
BigMac Thu 14:49

let me guess, Discord is militia?
Fluttershy Thu 14:49

Yes, militia if youre here, pleace do claim
Discord Thu 14:49

no
Thu 14:49

i'm just vanilla
Fluttershy Thu 14:50

A militia would really help us though
BigMac Thu 14:50

however we can't rule out the possiblity of a SS that know I'm gonna check Flutter and shifted into her last night
Thu 14:50

GD wasn't verified by anyone anyway
Discord Thu 14:50

how so?
BigMac Thu 14:50

unlikely tho, since SS often doesn't speak much
PrincessCelestia Thu 14:50

GD is legit
Discord Thu 14:50

you gave 2 options
Fluttershy Thu 14:50

Please do check
BigMac Thu 14:51

but to be safe, could anyone check Flutter's writting pls
Fluttershy Thu 15:01

Also saying I was SSed into would mean AppleBloom wasnt lit
Thu 15:02

So applying the logic: "Why didnt you prot AppleBloom N4" is invalid if you say I got shifted into
BigMac Thu 15:16

nevermind, there's a GD in PC's ''read'' too
SweetieBelle Thu 15:16

Hmmmmm, this is a big revelation. intel comes b4 kill
BigMac Thu 15:16

so Applebloom must be lit
Thu 15:16

2 wolves down, 2 (or 3) to go
Fluttershy Thu 15:17

I think there are still 4 wolves atm
Thu 15:17

Why would she tell us the amount of wolves
SweetieBelle Thu 15:17

Intel always come first b4 kill. Therefore SS happens last so which mean whoever Seer checked b4 has the possibility of getting ss i to
Fluttershy Thu 15:17

We know
SweetieBelle Thu 15:18

Im late for the pony partt
Thu 15:18

party*
Fluttershy Thu 15:18

But Princess ios contradicting herself
Thu 15:18

android*
BigMac Thu 15:18

Sweetie, however PC said GD is lit, so in order for Apple to be SS, PC must lie
SweetieBelle Thu 15:19

Im sos slow as ever
Thu 15:19

I was speed reading
Thu 15:20

Okay let me have my food b4 i crack my brain in this
BigMac Thu 15:20

Well, Princess said GD is lit, so Apple must be lit (no counter-claim) => he couldn't SS into Flutter last night
SweetieBelle Thu 15:20

I dont need to crack my brain
Thu 15:21

all votes of her
Thu 15:21

I shall ride like a pony
Thu 15:21

Yeah you are tighy
Thu 15:21

right*
Moderator Thu 15:21

SweetieBelle votes to lynch PrincessCelestia
Derpy Thu 15:26

so right now, wolves either realise Princess fucked up
Thu 15:26

so they have to vote her
Thu 15:27

or they're joining the misvote
Fluttershy Thu 15:27

I think they'll realize Princess fucked so they'll vote for her
Thu 15:28

They'll be dumb if they dont
Thu 15:28

Or they'll come up with something to contradict me. But I'm not sure what that would be
Discord Thu 15:29

apparently the first one
Thu 15:29

we all have voted for Princess
Fluttershy Thu 15:31

1 person hasnt
Thu 15:31

Our dear Mayor
Discord Thu 15:33

inactive again?
Thu 15:34

but BigMac already checked him
Fluttershy Thu 15:48

He did
Thu 15:49

But for all we know he's a direwolf
TwilightSparkle Thu 16:02

Fluttershy, did you use my question of why you didn't protect Apples against Princess?
Fluttershy Thu 16:03

use?
TwilightSparkle Thu 16:03

Princess: why did you want to pretend there was still protection if there wasn't?
PrincessCelestia Thu 16:03

Because
Thu 16:03

wolves
Thu 16:03

would
Thu 16:03

not
Thu 16:03

dare
Thu 16:04

hit
Thu 16:04

BigMac
Fluttershy Thu 16:04

Anyways, as I said I thought wolves wouldnt kill the GD after he claimed
TwilightSparkle Thu 16:05

I see :/
Fluttershy Thu 16:05

But I guess I should have protected him after that :(
PrincessCelestia Thu 16:05

>clap clap
Fluttershy Thu 16:05

I was really temped to do so. I almost did
TwilightSparkle Thu 16:08

Princess, it didn't occur to you that that (a) they might assume BigMac was protected last night (b) BigMac could still be a wolf?
PrincessCelestia Thu 16:10

No, it didnt occur to me that BigMac could still a wolf
Thu 16:10

no one else claimed seer
TwilightSparkle Thu 16:11

No one else claimed Tarot Reader... ;)
BigMac Thu 16:22

because finding a TR in a blind game who only used her power N5 is as hard as finding an all vanilla game
TwilightSparkle Thu 16:23

um?
BigMac Thu 16:23

if I was TR in this game, I would use my power N4 at the latest, maybe 3
TwilightSparkle Thu 16:24

Yeah, but you'd also let a villager get lynched so let's not discuss your play style ^_^
BigMac Thu 16:24

sure
Thu 16:25

anyway, MayorMare could be a Dire
Thu 16:25

however, she's the first one who voted with me on PP and has never changed her vote
TwilightSparkle Thu 16:25

we've not seen any evidence of there being Dire, but yeah we shouldn't rule out our
BigMac Thu 16:25

so I think she's likely lit, till now
TwilightSparkle Thu 16:25

out*
Thu 16:26

it*
MayorMare Thu 16:26

Evening all, your major is here!
TwilightSparkle Thu 16:26

MajorMayor
Thu 16:27

Major Major Major Major?
MayorMare Thu 16:27

I've not read back yet, will do that now - any TL;DR?
TwilightSparkle Thu 16:27

a wolf exposed themselves
MayorMare Thu 16:27

AppleBloom :(
PrincessCelestia Thu 16:27

MAYOR
BigMac Thu 16:27

Twilight, since you are agree on we shouldn't rule out Dire, I'm curious, would you reveal and risk dying without finding any wolf (aka useful intel) just to save a possible Dire/vanilla?
TwilightSparkle Thu 16:27

we're going to arrest them for public indecency
PrincessCelestia Thu 16:27

Mayor =/= major
TwilightSparkle Thu 16:27

the punishment is to be hung...
Thu 16:28

... WELL HUNG
Thu 16:28

get it? it's a pens joke...
Derpy Thu 16:28

( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°)
TwilightSparkle Thu 16:28

WTF
PrincessCelestia Thu 16:28

HANGED
TwilightSparkle Thu 16:28

MY PHONE WON'T ACCEPT PENIS AS A WORD
PrincessCelestia Thu 16:28

they are not a tapestry
MayorMare Thu 16:29

oh, lol @ PrincessCelestia's terrible TarotReading!
Moderator Thu 16:29

MayorMare votes to lynch PrincessCelestia
PrincessCelestia Thu 16:29

#asoiaf
TwilightSparkle Thu 16:29

Depends, if you put a noose around their neck they're hanged — if you nail them to the wall then they're hung
Thu 16:30

/me gets the nails
PrincessCelestia Thu 16:30

or to the cross?
TwilightSparkle Thu 16:30

Which would you prefer?
PrincessCelestia Thu 16:30

Hanged
VinylScratch Thu 16:31

Why sent her to the moon for 1000 years like she did her own sister
Thu 16:31

Why not*
TwilightSparkle Thu 16:31

is that an actual MLP reference?
PrincessCelestia Thu 16:31

I can do that?
VinylScratch Thu 16:31

Yeah
PrincessCelestia Thu 16:32

ok 3 2 1 .....
Thu 16:32

wooosh
Thu 16:32

Fluttershy is still here :/
VinylScratch Thu 16:33

http://villains.wikia.com/wiki/Nightmare_Moon
TwilightSparkle Thu 16:34

She mocked me, apparently :(
Thu 16:35

Who's the main character?
Thu 16:36

is it RainbowDash?
VinylScratch Thu 16:36

You are the most main character
TwilightSparkle Thu 16:36

That's the only one I've heard of previously
VinylScratch Thu 16:36

out of the mane 6
Thu 16:37

Twilight, Rarity, Fluttershy, Rainbow Dash, Applejack and Pinkie Pie
TwilightSparkle Thu 16:37

oh!
Thu 16:37

I'm a mainer!
VinylScratch Thu 16:38

You all have your own episodes dedicated to solving your friendship problems
TwilightSparkle Thu 16:38

a main-sixer
Thu 16:38

not quite a phase sixer, but never mind
VinylScratch Thu 16:38

You're not in all the episodes though
TwilightSparkle Thu 16:39

oh well
Thu 16:39

everyone needs a holiday
BigMac Thu 16:48

ok, got to go
Thu 16:49

I will likely get killed tonight
Thu 16:49

after I die, you guys will have no more intel and have to rely on your guts and voting pattern
Thu 16:49

So here's my sus list atm, really consider it:
Thu 16:49

Discord - Twilight - Derpy - Vinyl - Sweetie
Thu 16:50

#Discord: he tried to cast shade on me right after Flut and I sus Princess's ''read''
Thu 16:50

Discord Thu 14:31 tbh, I feel everything is too convenient for BigMac
Thu 16:50

also he's one of the last to cast votes on both PP and Princess despite always being there from beginning
Thu 16:50

looks like a wolf that bandwagon to me
Thu 16:51

If you guys have absolute no lead tmr, PLS LYNCH HIM FIRST.
Thu 16:51

#Derpy: she is inconsistent AF, I can't read her at all
Thu 16:51

also conveniently she aggressive suspected to me both times we find wolves, then switch her attitude back when the wolves were done for.
Thu 16:51

#Twilight: I have mixed feeling on him, sometimes he feels lit, sometimes he looks sus with his utmost skeptical
Thu 16:52

#Vinyl: he's too casual and laid back this game, always fly under the radar, either a true vanilla, or a wolf
Thu 16:52

#Sweetie: I don't know about her, she feels off recently, just not sure why.
VinylScratch Thu 16:53

DJ Pon3 is always laid back :)
BigMac Thu 16:54

I think we must have SS this game, maybe haven't shifted yet
Thu 16:54

you guys should be careful and compare writting of MayorMare/Fluttershy/Me if some of above ppl get killed for no real reason
Thu 16:55

we likely have 2 wolves down to lynch, 3 in worst case scenario
Thu 16:56

ok then, good luck
Derpy Thu 16:57

I would say that I feel like Discord tried to buddy with me a little in the early game
Thu 16:57

when I was talking about voting reasons etc.
Thu 16:57

it could just be he agrees with my views, but not many people seem to :P
Fluttershy Thu 17:12

I find Twilight a bit random, not contributing much and he only really makes jokes. I feels a bit like be when I'm a wolf. I also distrust Discord seems like a wolf to me
TwilightSparkle Thu 17:41

Not really sure what you expect from me? I've cross examined every power role claimant that's come out so far and provided speculation during quiet periods to attempt to get the game moving...
Fluttershy Thu 17:42

Maybe I'm wrong. I dont know
TwilightSparkle Thu 17:48

¯\_(ツ)_/ ¯
Lynched Thu 20:02

PrincessCelestia was lynched by the village
Killed Fri 08:02

BigMac was killed during the night
Derpy Fri 08:02

Predictable kill is predictable
Fluttershy Fri 08:11

:(((
Fri 08:12

I wish I didn't Prot her N5
Derpy Fri 08:13

I wish you didn't outright claim
Fri 08:13

but it's not the end of the world
Fri 08:13

I mean, it's not your fault you claimed, it was the obvious thing to do
Fluttershy Fri 08:15

I didn't want to but I kinda had to
Fri 08:15

At least we know we have 1 wolf in GY
TwilightSparkle Fri 08:20

probably 2
Fri 08:21

I mean, there's still a chance BigMac has played a blinder of a game as a wolf, but at this point it seems unlikely
Derpy Fri 08:21

they'd night kill one of their own to sell it?
Fri 08:21

I don't even know if that's possible
TwilightSparkle Fri 08:21

SS?
Fri 08:22

clear a villager as seer, then SS into them a few days later
Fri 08:22

would be next level play
Derpy Fri 08:22

true
TwilightSparkle Fri 08:22

but I didn't get that impression from BigMac
Fri 08:23

he seemed the more... straightforward type
Fluttershy Fri 08:24

I don't think BM was wolf. He felt really lit to me
Fri 08:25

If he was a wolf and he shifted. Ma man. That's some next level play
Discord Fri 09:04

Hey
TwilightSparkle Fri 09:07

Heya
Discord Fri 09:10

I saw BigMac sus me
Fri 09:11

I blame that on the internet connection
Fri 09:12

After I answer Derpy "yes"
Fri 09:12

My connection was down
Fri 09:13

I waited a few min but didn't see anything so I gave my opinion
Fri 09:14

Then refreshed the page
Fri 09:14

By then, you guys had already moved on
Fri 09:15

And the conflict had happended
Moderator Fri 10:53

Derpy votes to lynch Discord
Derpy Fri 10:53

As I said yesterday, I'm willing to let BigMac lead
Fri 10:54

therefore, I'll treat his list of suspects as a good base
TwilightSparkle Fri 11:12

Did BigMac give any reasons for suspecting Discord?
Moderator Fri 11:12

TwilightSparkle votes to lynch SweetieBelle
TwilightSparkle Fri 11:13

I'm going to go with Sweet, mainly for balance, but also because I think she's been less active than more of us who are left
Fri 11:18

Also just to clarify: although I balanced I think we need to lynch; I just don't want it to be off a single vote
Discord Fri 11:51

hey there
Fri 11:51

#Discord: he tried to cast shade on me right after Flut and I sus Princess's ''read''
Fri 11:52

Discord Thu 14:31 tbh, I feel everything is too convenient for BigMac
Fri 11:52

also he's one of the last to cast votes on both PP and Princess despite always being there from beginning
Fri 11:52

looks like a wolf that bandwagon to me
Fri 11:52

quote from BigMac
Fri 11:53

well, I've explained it already
TwilightSparkle Fri 12:28

Discord, what did you mean by "too convenient"?
Discord Fri 12:32

oh, maybe I need to explain it more clearly
Fri 12:34

after the day BigMac reveal and win the argument with PP
Fri 12:35

our GD died so we couldn't comfirmed what was PP's role
Fri 12:36

and all ppl he had check (except Flutter) were in GY
Fri 12:36

at that time, Flutter haven't reveal yet
Fri 12:37

so sorry if I found it was sus
Fri 12:38

my connection had gone down about 30 min, so my words were delayed
Fri 12:39

when I came back, Princess had made a big fuss
Fri 12:40

I had to reread 2 times because of her bluff checks
Fri 12:42

that's it
Fluttershy Fri 13:54

I have to work. I'll give some input when I'm done
Moderator Fri 15:18

Discord votes to lynch Derpy
Discord Fri 15:18

you srsl have some issue about mood swing
Derpy Fri 15:19

not sure what you want me to say
Fri 15:20

I'm not allowed to change my mind?
Discord Fri 15:26

it's not like that, no offense
Fri 15:27

but you can't deny that it seems sus
Derpy Fri 15:28

I guess
VinylScratch Fri 15:53

How about we all list everyone in order of our suspicions
Fri 15:54

Mine would be: Discord, SweetieBelle, MayorMare, Fluttershy, Derpy, TwilightSparkle
Moderator Fri 15:54

VinylScratch votes to lynch Discord
Discord Fri 16:03

from high to low
Fri 16:03

Derpy, Sweetie, Vinyl, Twilight, Mayor, Flutter
TwilightSparkle Fri 16:07

I prefer this type of thing to be done where everyone reveals at the same time, otherwise it's easy to bias the results... but since we started like this I'll add mine:
Fri 16:09

T1: Sweetie; T2: Discord, Vinyl, Derpy; T3: Mayor, Flutter
Derpy Fri 16:10

I put my trust in BigMac, like I said (excluding myself, of course): Discord - Twilight - Vinyl - Sweetie
TwilightSparkle Fri 16:14

I'll like to ask that no-one comments on anyone else's list until everyone has replied - anyone object to that?
Derpy Fri 16:14

works for me
Discord Fri 16:18

sounds good
Fri 16:20

but Mayor often show up late, I afraid I can't join in the discuss
Fri 16:21

I guess that you guys should start without me then
Derpy Fri 16:21

I'm only gonna be here for another hour or so
TwilightSparkle Fri 16:23

hmm, that's a good point, I might not be around much this evening either ://
Derpy Fri 16:24

Fridays
SweetieBelle Fri 17:25

Im still outside having a drink or two with my mates
Fri 17:26

@vinyl @twilight No point sus-ing me coz Im a vanilla through and through and you will only be disappointed post game
Fri 17:27

hmmm list of sus
Fri 17:27

Let me go through later. not staying out late tho
Fri 17:27

See u guys in abit
Fluttershy Fri 18:13

I think Discord is a good lynch. I trusted BM so I will follow his lead
Moderator Fri 18:13

Fluttershy votes to lynch Discord
TwilightSparkle Fri 19:51

There's 10 minutes to go until night fall... I wonder if Sweetie will make it back in time
SweetieBelle Fri 19:52

Back
Fri 19:53

I was reading last night
Fri 19:53

Coz I saw Flutter wanted to lynch discord according to BM
Fri 19:54

I didnt read BM's will last night
Fri 19:54

He suspected discord
Fri 19:54

Even today Discord still feel that BM is wolf
Fri 19:56

The worst that I could think of is wolves playing us out. Because they knew village too pussied out and will believe any outright lie. But the past few days, both apple's and Bm checks seems to click.
Fri 19:58

Is Mayor out to get smited?
Moderator Fri 19:58

SweetieBelle votes to lynch Discord
VinylScratch Fri 20:01

No, mayor voted yesterday
Lynched Fri 20:25

Discord was lynched by the village
Killed Sat 08:06

MayorMare was killed during the night
Fluttershy Sat 09:01

Why him
Sat 09:06

This is hard
Derpy Sat 09:12

I still trust BigMac, since I think we're kinda forced to
Sat 09:12

the fact the game isn't over is a good thing
Moderator Sat 09:12

Derpy votes to lynch TwilightSparkle
Fluttershy Sat 09:13

You distrust Sparkle?
Derpy Sat 09:13

she was second on BigMac's list, after Discord
Fluttershy Sat 09:14

I know, but I don't think we should just blindly follow BigMac
Derpy Sat 09:14

he was all but confirmed legit
Fluttershy Sat 09:14

We should at least think who we distrust the most ourselves
Sat 09:14

I know
Derpy Sat 09:14

in a situation where others can lead us (small groups with close to half wolves), I feel it's best to not go off your own interests, really
Sat 09:15

interests is the wrong word, I'm hungover
Fluttershy Sat 09:15

That feel so unlike you. But right
Derpy Sat 09:15

I know
Sat 09:15

I don't see end-game often, so this part of me doesn't often come out
Sat 09:15

but in a normal situation, we'd all present our thoughts
Sat 09:16

your thoughts might change mine - which would be fair enough when you're one person out of 20
Sat 09:16

but when you're one person out of 5, 2 of whom are wolves, I don't want ANY of you to influence me
Sat 09:16

the best way to do that, IMO, is to follow the directions of a legit villager - even if they are dead
Fluttershy Sat 09:16

Why not me? I'm only pretty much conformed
Sat 09:17

Confirmed*
Derpy Sat 09:17

because I already said I was gonna go by BigMac
Fluttershy Sat 09:17

Hmm okay
Derpy Sat 09:17

also I just want the game to be over without much more thought required, sad but true
Fluttershy Sat 09:18

Right
Sat 09:18

But don't you think MM is a weird kill?
Derpy Sat 09:20

a little, I guess
Sat 09:20

but also no
Sat 09:20

as I've said, BigMac was pretty much confirmed by now
Sat 09:21

killing his "confirmed villagers" makes sense
Sat 09:21

I wasn't checked by him - you don't have any info on my role, "confirmed" or not
Sat 09:21

hence why I'm still here
Fluttershy Sat 09:22

But why not kill me
Derpy Sat 09:22

I guess it just doesn't make any difference
Sat 09:22

you, MM, whoever
Sat 09:22

perhaps you're next
Fluttershy Sat 09:22

I'm Prot, so I don't see why he didn't go for me first
Sat 09:22

Or they I don't know how many are left
Derpy Sat 09:23

oh I forgot about that
Sat 09:23

maybe they're concerned about a secret harlot or something
Sat 09:23

if we had one, it would be on you, for sure
Fluttershy Sat 09:24

That would be great. But I'm pretty sure we don't have one
Derpy Sat 09:25

could be me
Sat 09:25

unless they have a BH, they don't know
Fluttershy Sat 11:14

Where are the others?
Sat 11:15

Honestly I find everyone sus lol
Derpy Sat 11:20

yeah I know
TwilightSparkle Sat 11:34

Afternoon
Fluttershy Sat 11:34

hi
Moderator Sat 11:34

TwilightSparkle votes to lynch SweetieBelle
TwilightSparkle Sat 11:35

I'm still not convinced by Sweetie's behaviour, and she seems high on everyone's suspicions list
Fluttershy Sat 11:35

What do you think of Viny?
TwilightSparkle Sat 11:37

I like the theory behind Derpy's reasoning for going with BigMac, but it seems to me that that's only a good strategy if we have reasons to believe his instincts are good
Sat 11:38

Flutter, Vinyl is interesting... I'd like to know why he put Derpy and myself lower down his suspicion list than you or Mayor
Fluttershy Sat 11:39

Same here.
Sat 11:39

I personally trust you the most out of everyone atm
Sat 11:39

But I could be horribly wrong
TwilightSparkle Sat 11:43

The problem with blind games is that we have no idea what we're up against; we don't even know how many wolves are left ... if we assume two then we have to lynch (correctly) or the game ends — but actually there might only be one left and in that case lynching is actually detrimental to our cause
Fluttershy Sat 11:45

So how many wolves do you think there are left?
TwilightSparkle Sat 11:47

hmm - well let's start with facts: there can't be three wolves still alive (... unless there's a coven lurking, but let's ignore that possibility for now)
Sat 11:50

so then, we lynched two confirmed (presumably?) wolves already - Pumpkin and Princess - so it partly depends how many we started with
Sat 11:51

It's possible that Discord was also a wolf, but we've also had a couple of smites who also could have been wolves and that complicates things
Sat 11:52

although I think Mac cleared Zecora
Sat 11:53

so, moving into speculation - I'd say we started with five wolves, three must definitely be dead, so imho we have two left
Sat 11:54

but maybe we got lucky and one was smited
Sat 11:55

and three were lynched
Fluttershy Sat 12:02

So coming to my question, how many do you think are still left?
Derpy Sat 12:03

huh?
Sat 12:03

2 confirmed dead, as you said
Sat 12:03

but possibly Discord
Sat 12:03

how does that equal "three must definitely be dead"?
Fluttershy Sat 12:04

Nevermind I misread. 2 left you think. Okay
Sat 12:05

Derpy, what do you think? How many are left and who dod you think are the wolves
Derpy Sat 12:06

It's hard to say
Sat 12:07

I'd kinda love for me to be the last villager, and there be 2 coven and 2 wolves
Sat 12:07

but I doubt that, unless the Seer was EXTREMELY unlucky
Fluttershy Sat 12:07

How would that be possible?
Derpy Sat 12:07

nah, it wouldn't, if BigMac was legit
Sat 12:07

ignore me, I'm all over the place
Sat 12:08

but if it was just wolves vs village, starting with 5 makes sense
Sat 12:08

I suppose there can't be 3 left, or mod would end the game?
Sat 12:08

so it must be 2
Fluttershy Sat 12:08

Not its 2 or 1
Sat 12:08

noep*
Sat 12:08

NOPE=*
Derpy Sat 12:09

so in that case, ignore my questioning of Twilight above. I see now she was speculating
Fluttershy Sat 12:09

Derpy you are all over the place
Derpy Sat 12:09

I know
Sat 12:09

hungover, unmotivated
Fluttershy Sat 12:10

Yeah but like the whole game
Sat 12:10

It's day 8
Derpy Sat 12:10

oh, just unmotivated for the whole game
Fluttershy Sat 12:10

Again?
Derpy Sat 12:10

not 100% sure why
Fluttershy Sat 12:10

right
Derpy Sat 12:10

early game was a drain on me
Sat 12:10

I got pissed off again
Fluttershy Sat 12:11

Okay, so coming to my question who do you think are the last 2 wolves
Derpy Sat 12:16

internet died, sorry
Sat 12:16

that's the big question, isn't it?
Fluttershy Sat 12:16

It is, that's why i'm asking
Derpy Sat 12:17

sorry, my net seems to be dropping in and out now
Sat 12:17

not all messages appearing
Sat 12:17

for the third time... vinyl has been rather quiet, as far as I remembere
Sat 12:18

so my 2 are Twilight and Vinyl/Sweetie
Sat 12:18

but I'm really not sure between the last two
Sat 12:18

maybe today's voting will help me work it out
SweetieBelle Sat 15:24

@twilight Nah m8, Im only high on both discord and your list. the rest was bottom for me. so here I am. Either, we still trust BM through and through or like some of you mentioned Vinyl
Sat 15:25

I have to agree on feeling unmotivated.. Fun fact: when you get vanillager, at times I could go braindead on trying to reach a logical rational sounding decision or theory
Sat 15:27

Expect the worse, prolly 2 wolves left

Your role: Observer

The Village

Graveyard

Spoiler free day archives