ext-118 Day 5 | Epic Mafia Online Hidden Roles

Replay

You are viewing day 5 of a game of werewolves started on the 17-Feb-25 Sat on a 24 hour cycle (12h day, 12h night).

This is a spoiler free version, use the user button (top menu) to see who was alive at the time, and the calendar button or links below the chat to navigate through to different days.

You can play a game of online Mafia by joining the game currently in sign up. New players are welcome, but try to be active!
Jaqueline Wed 09:14

OMG
Wed 09:14

I am so happy right now
Wed 09:14

Whoop whoop
Wed 09:14

I can confirm Krusty
Wed 09:15

Apu was lying
Wed 09:15

I did recuit him. But it seems Apu also got recruited by the vamp
Wed 09:15

And Ralph was PM
Wed 09:24

And duffman is indeed beholder
Willie Wed 09:51

Apu was indeed familiar
Hibbert Wed 10:03

Hey guys, Hibb's here
Wed 10:04

hmm, 2 deaths, strange
Wed 10:05

based on TR read, must be vamp + witch or vamp + WH
Wed 10:06

WH is not likely since Freddie agreed not to kill Bumble yesterday
Wed 10:07

Witch also not likely, since a witch would definitely choose to kill WH
Wed 10:07

I dont know what to make of this, need more intel
Wed 10:08

@Freddie: who did you check last night?
Wed 10:08

@Jacqueline: welcome back, we still need the revivor to confirm you tho, could be a witch revive + djinn swap
Wed 10:09

I believe we are in for a TOTAL ROLL CALL today
Jaqueline Wed 10:10

Yeah I understand :)
Wed 10:10

Well since BumblebeeMan is dead I think WH did kill him
Hibbert Wed 10:12

So far we have
Wed 10:12

Willie - GD
Jaqueline Wed 10:12

A role call could be beneficial for village
Hibbert Wed 10:12

Freddie - WH
Wed 10:12

Krusty - TR
Wed 10:12

Jaqueline - ML
Wed 10:12

Barney Monroe Jeremy Raphael Hibbert - ???
Wed 10:12

I dont really trust Willie and Freddie tho, need more intel
Jaqueline Wed 10:13

I'd like the "shady" people to claim a role first
Hibbert Wed 10:16

since you are here, what were beholder checks Jaq?
Wed 10:16

and who were the puppets?
Moderator Wed 10:18

Hibbert votes to lynch Jeremy
Moderator Wed 10:18

Hibbert votes to lynch Barney
Willie Wed 10:20

Hibbert, really?
Wed 10:20

you think I just guessed that Duff was Beholder?
Wed 10:21

oh btw, I had the option of checking the smitees last night
Hibbert Wed 10:21

Willie, sry mate, but you are not confirmed
Willie Wed 10:21

so idk why it didn't let me last night
Hibbert Wed 10:21

if you are coven, you could totally know that Duff was beholder
Willie Wed 10:24

how?
Wed 10:24

what
Wed 10:25

You realise that Bloodhound is a wolf role, not coven, right?
Hibbert Wed 10:26

come on mate, you know beholder's dead based on Krusty's read, but Ralph the PM still alive till Day3
Wed 10:26

easy to figure it out, if you are coven
Wed 10:26

I dont say you are, I just mean you aint confirmed, yet
Jeremy Wed 10:33

Hello, I'm back
Hibbert Wed 10:34

Hi Jer, we are in for a total roll call party
Wed 10:34

who are you?
Willie Wed 10:38

Hibbert, did you even read what I said yesterday
Jaqueline Wed 10:38

I'll check I dont know if He stated all his checks
Wed 10:38

Lemme see
Willie Wed 10:38

go read D2 where I ask about TR
Wed 10:38

then look at my first sentence yesterday, where I use the word "behold"
Wed 10:38

or is that just coincidence?!
Wed 10:39

D2 -> D3
Jaqueline Wed 10:39

He said; jacqueline was visited by abu n2
Wed 10:40

But he said I visited him N2, but I think he mixed them up so he corrected himself
Jeremy Wed 10:44

@Hibbert, I am the Reviver
Jaqueline Wed 10:44

MA HERO
Jeremy Wed 10:44

So I just reread
Wed 10:44

and I wonder, why is Freddie still alive???
Willie Wed 11:09

the succubus could have made him target BBM
Wed 11:09

if BBM was protector
Hibbert Wed 11:13

Make sense, if Jeremy is revivor then big chance Bumble was our Prot
Wed 11:13

Assuming we believe Freddie the WH
Wed 11:15

I still dont understand why 2 deaths
Jaqueline Wed 11:15

So why did you decide to revive me?
Wed 12:10

??
Freddie Wed 12:12

hey it didn't tell me if he used witched craft?
Wed 12:14

and I am surprised I'm alive
Jaqueline Wed 12:22

So Freddie you didn't kill BBM?
Monroe Wed 13:00

Im gonna ASV
Moderator Wed 13:00

Monroe votes to lynch Raphael
Monroe Wed 13:01

Will change later, sorry Raphael
Krusty Wed 13:23

J I can confirm you. What was the phrase we were gonna use to confirm Apu?
Wed 13:25

Just to make sure you weren't swapped+revived
Moderator Wed 13:27

Krusty votes to lynch Barney
Jaqueline Wed 13:47

It was about the weather
Wed 13:47

Either a positive one or a negative one
Wed 13:48

Am I allowed to copy and paste my own mason chat?
Krusty Wed 13:49

Probably not
Wed 13:49

But that's good enough
Jaqueline Wed 13:50

Hmm I was the last one to speak in the masons chat that night and I wrote 2 possiblities
Wed 13:50

You also let me guess your new role
Krusty Wed 13:50

Yeah, I trust you
Jaqueline Wed 13:51

Alrighty
Krusty Wed 13:51

:)
Jaqueline Wed 13:51

:D
Wed 13:52

I also heard something like, The GY is full of coven
Wed 13:52

But I'm not completely sure where. Cuz I can find it anymore
Wed 13:53

I found it
Wed 13:54

On day 4 SantasLittleHelper said
Wed 13:54

I'm TR and the rest is coven
Wed 13:54

After that I explained that you stole his role
Freddie Wed 14:38

nope I didn't kill him
Wed 14:39

I wanted to see if Barney uses witchcraft
Wed 14:39

And it didn't say anything at all this morning.
Wed 14:39

and, he isn't red
Krusty Wed 14:39

It doesn't tell you when you've been redirected
Wed 14:40

If it didn't give you a result, then you've probably killed BBM
Freddie Wed 14:40

I didn't vote to killhim
Wed 14:41

I voted to check magic
Wed 14:41

oh. would it make me kill too?
Jeremy Wed 14:43

Is it possible that Freddie is swapped?
Freddie Wed 14:43

geeez
Wed 14:43

really
Wed 14:44

I amnot
Krusty Wed 14:44

What makes you think he's been swapped?
Jeremy Wed 14:45

That he is alivw
Jaqueline Wed 14:46

Jeremy can you answer my question
Wed 14:47

"So why did you decide to revive me?"
Jeremy Wed 14:50

To clear the Apu/Krusty stuff
Jaqueline Wed 15:36

Alrighty.
Hibbert Wed 16:17

Hey guys, Hibb's here
Wed 16:18

Hmm Monroe gets on, say nothing about his role, just ASV
Wed 16:18

very sus in my book
Wed 16:19

Jeremy, so you revived Jaqueline last night?
Wed 16:20

why are you sure that Jaqueline wasn't swapped?
Willie Wed 16:21

because there was no night in between?
Wed 16:22

Seriously Hibbert, are you just acting dense on purpose?
Hibbert Wed 16:22

yes I did Willie
Willie Wed 16:25

also, why haven't you told us your role?
Wed 16:26

what if BBM was coven, and witch-kill-shapeshifted into Freddie?
Monroe Wed 16:27

So I needa tell my role?
Hibbert Wed 16:27

that's a possibility
Wed 16:27

yeah Monroe, pls reveal your role
Monroe Wed 16:28

Dont have any info and dont wanna be smited so ASV
Wed 16:28

Prot
Hibbert Wed 16:28

oh, your protection by night pls, bar last 2 nights
Willie Wed 16:29

just fyi, from a *very quick* scan back through yesterday, Freddie didn't capitalise names or use commas
Monroe Wed 16:29

Last night I protected Krusty
Willie Wed 16:29

*headstall*
Hibbert Wed 16:29

... I just said not 2 recent nights
Wed 16:29

all your check then pls
Willie Wed 16:29

*headdesk* even
Monroe Wed 16:30

So from the beginning till now?
Wed 16:30

Okay
Hibbert Wed 16:30

yeah
Moderator Wed 16:30

Willie votes to lynch Freddie
Willie Wed 16:30

until I get chance to read back properly
Monroe Wed 16:30

D1 Me
Wed 16:30

D2 Apu
Willie Wed 16:30

Jesus Apu was popular
Hibbert Wed 16:31

indeed he was lol, he talked alot
Willie Wed 16:31

"Jesus Apu" xD
Wed 16:31

a lot*
Monroe Wed 16:31

D3 Willie
Hibbert Wed 16:31

gnazi detected
Monroe Wed 16:31

D4 Krusty
Willie Wed 16:31

awwh <3 thanks
Hibbert Wed 16:32

come to think about it, anyone else got redirected by succubus, except Freddie?
Wed 16:33

why krusty monroe? he did his purpose, why not me or willie?
Jeremy Wed 16:33

Hello again!
Hibbert Wed 16:34

Hi Jeremy
Wed 16:34

what do you think of Monroe, Jeremy? I find him sus, do you?
Monroe Wed 16:35

Yes
Jeremy Wed 16:35

I agree Hilbert
Wed 16:35

If Monroe is Prot, what was BBM?
Monroe Wed 16:35

Im sus i know it
Hibbert Wed 16:36

why didnt you protect willie or me, Monroe?
Monroe Wed 16:36

Coven or vampire they wont kill you last night
Hibbert Wed 16:37

Krusty did his job, he reveals everything he knows, he's not a big target
Monroe Wed 16:37

Maybe they would change the target to Krus
Wed 16:37

Imo
Hibbert Wed 16:37

huh why didnt they want to kill me?
Monroe Wed 16:37

You said me to protect you and Willie
Wed 16:38

So to be safe, they dont kill you guys
Wed 16:38

Instead, they kill Krus
Wed 16:38

I think so
Hibbert Wed 16:39

ok, that's good thinking
Jeremy Wed 16:39

To repeat the TR: Vampire 1, GD 1, PM 0, WitchHunter 1, Succubus 1, Stalker 1, Familiar 1, Puppet 1, Protector 1, Beholder 0, Djinn 1, ML 1, TR 1, Reviver 1, Witch 1
Monroe Wed 16:39

Am I still sus?
Hibbert Wed 16:39

I think you are less sus now
Monroe Wed 16:39

:)
Hibbert Wed 16:39

btw do you ever get redirected? no one seems to, except Freddie
Monroe Wed 16:40

No
Jeremy Wed 16:40

Hibbert, do you think Freddie is swapped?
Hibbert Wed 16:41

he could be, coven could do a swap - poison kill
Wed 16:42

lemme think if it's possible
Wed 16:42

like shapeshifting
Wed 16:43

nowFreddie could be Database or BBM
Wed 16:43

I'm more concern about
Wed 16:43

why did you lie to be a revivor Jeremy?
Jeremy Wed 16:43

in what order are Nightactions executed?
Wed 16:44

@Hibbert what?
Hibbert Wed 16:44

I know you aint revivor, what role are you?
Jeremy Wed 16:44

I am revivor, Hibbert
Wed 16:45

*reviver
Hibbert Wed 16:45

no, we both know you are not mate, drop the act
Jeremy Wed 16:46

Hibbert, what are you?
Hibbert Wed 16:47

well, I think you figured it out, I'm revivor
Wed 16:47

the one and only
Jeremy Wed 16:47

Well, no you are not
Hibbert Wed 16:47

and I haven't used my ability yet
Willie Wed 16:47

Hibbert, why did you revive Jaqueline?
Hibbert Wed 16:47

or did I?
Willie Wed 16:48

why would coven revive a villager?
Jeremy Wed 16:48

WIllie, he didnt
Hibbert Wed 16:49

who do you think I am then?
Willie Wed 16:49

Djinn, maybe?
Hibbert Wed 16:49

I asked Jeremy
Jeremy Wed 16:50

idk. I guess coven
Hibbert Wed 16:50

ok, it's not fun playing with you when old Willie is here xD
Wed 16:51

Jeremy visited Monroe last night
Willie Wed 16:51

Hibbert, why would coven revive a villager?
Hibbert Wed 16:51

not Jaqueline
Willie Wed 16:51

but Krusty confirmed Jaqueline??
Hibbert Wed 16:51

hence Jeremy can't be reviver
Moderator Wed 16:52

Hibbert votes to lynch Jeremy
Moderator Wed 16:52

Jeremy votes to lynch Hibbert
Willie Wed 16:52

oh, Monroe is dead
Wed 16:52

isn't*
Jeremy Wed 16:52

or you are lying
Hibbert Wed 16:52

I still dont know what he's, I thought he's Succubus
Wed 16:52

but Monroe claimed that he didn't get redirected
Willie Wed 16:52

so you're stalker? but you didn't believe I was GD and didn't think to check me?
Hibbert Wed 16:53

I dont fully trust you Willie, but trust you more than others
Monroe Wed 16:53

Gotta change my vote
Hibbert Wed 16:53

thought about checking you, but I think it's more important to find the vamp
Moderator Wed 16:53

Monroe votes to lynch Jeremy
Willie Wed 16:53

he can't be vampire, he can't be witch unless they swapped into Monroe which is stupid... was there a shaman?
Hibbert Wed 16:53

that's why I urged Freddie the WH to check you willie
Wed 16:54

if we believe Krusty, then no shaman
Wed 16:54

out of all coven roles, only witch and succ have visiting roles
Wed 16:55

*are
Willie Wed 16:55

Monroe should know if he was redirected, since he should get a "You will not be able to protect X tomorrow" at the start of the day
Hibbert Wed 16:56

yeah
Willie Wed 16:56

Freddie seems like he would be the best candidate for a redirect, but Jeremy went to Monroe...
Monroe Wed 16:56

I didnt see it
Willie Wed 16:56

didn't see what?
Monroe Wed 16:57

You will not be able blablabla
Willie Wed 16:58

hmm, interesting
Hibbert Wed 16:58

there's no ''you will not be able to protect Krusty tmr''?
Monroe Wed 16:58

Yeah
Willie Wed 16:58

did you get that any other night?
Monroe Wed 16:58

No
Willie Wed 16:59

seems suspicious to me :/
Jeremy Wed 16:59

sry, I have to go for now
Hibbert Wed 16:59

Jeremy
Wed 16:59

you will be lynched for sure
Wed 17:00

if you know who's the vamp is
Monroe Wed 17:00

I have said many times that I know Im sus
Hibbert Wed 17:00

pls help us
Wed 17:00

I think you coven know who the vamp is already
Wed 17:00

maybe tell us?
Willie Wed 17:01

how could they know?
Hibbert Wed 17:02

they know who are coven, and us outted roles
Wed 17:02

they can kinda figure it out
Wed 17:02

or limit to 1 or 2
Willie Wed 17:02

well, assuming you and Monroe aren't coven
Hibbert Wed 17:02

yeah, assuming I and Monroe aint coven
Wed 17:03

still, I cant figure it out, what role is Jeremy?
Willie Wed 17:03

OH
Hibbert Wed 17:03

if he's witch, Monroe should be dead by now
Wed 17:03

if he's Succ, Monroe should be redirected
Willie Wed 17:04

what if Monroe is the vampire
Wed 17:04

he can't be redirected
Hibbert Wed 17:04

oh
Wed 17:04

now that's a good possibility
Moderator Wed 17:04

Willie votes to lynch Monroe
Monroe Wed 17:04

Again: Im the prot
Willie Wed 17:04

although I'm still not sure I trust you, Hibbert...
Monroe Wed 17:05

PROT IS HERE
Hibbert Wed 17:05

you should be skeptical Willie, but re read everything I said
Monroe Wed 17:05

Dont know what happened
Hibbert Wed 17:05

you will know I'm lit
Wed 17:05

Jeremy, help us out mate, if you are Succubus, tell us
Wed 17:05

we will lynch Monroe the vamp and not you tonight
Monroe Wed 17:05

Why me?
Wed 17:06

PROT AGAIN
Hibbert Wed 17:06

ah, ok
Monroe Wed 17:06

Damn vote me if you guys wanna lose, villager :((
Hibbert Wed 17:06

I think I know a method
Willie Wed 17:06

why did you protect me N3?
Hibbert Wed 17:06

we lynch Jeremy tonight
Wed 17:06

Monroe protect me tonight
Wed 17:07

I will check him
Monroe Wed 17:07

Seems like you have a role, Willie
Hibbert Wed 17:07

if I live and he visited me, he's lit
Monroe Wed 17:07

Thats why I protected you
Hibbert Wed 17:07

If I die, you know who the vamp is
Monroe Wed 17:07

Okay will protect you
Willie Wed 17:08

Hibbert, hmm
Hibbert Wed 17:08

is that a foolproof plan?
Willie Wed 17:08

is any plan foolproof?
Wed 17:08

Do you think Freddie has been witch-shifted?
Hibbert Wed 17:09

I'm not sure, but his story sounds odd
Wed 17:09

let's settle this first
Wed 17:10

Monroe, protect me tonight, ok?
Wed 17:11

Willie what do you think?
Monroe Wed 17:12

Okay Hibbert
Willie Wed 17:13

I don't know, I have a headache and I think this is just making it worse
Wed 17:14

we have two claims and, theoretically, one should be counterable?
Wed 17:14

sorry, three claims
Wed 17:15

stalker, protector and reviver... I'd assume that at least one of those is a alive to counterclaim
Wed 17:15

now, whether they should or not...
Hibbert Wed 17:15

I'm, ofc, lit
Willie Wed 17:15

I want to reread Freddie before I give a final opinion
Hibbert Wed 17:16

I think Freddie was lit till last night
Wed 17:16

at least
Willie Wed 17:16

I'm Town, SRSLY
Hibbert Wed 17:16

I find it kinda strange no one counter the Prot and Reviver claims
Wed 17:17

hah, why reveal? xD
Jaqueline Wed 17:17

Honestly I feel like i've missed some things.
Wed 17:17

I've been trying to keep up with the chat while I was in GY
Wed 17:17

But I missed quite a lot
Hibbert Wed 17:19

what do you think, should we lynch Jeremy or Monroe tonight?
Wed 17:20

btw Apu did visit you N2
Jaqueline Wed 17:20

As in I haven't really been keeping up with the "who do I think is sus" thing
Wed 17:20

I find both to be sus
Wed 17:21

I had some suspicion about Jeremy from the beginning
Hibbert Wed 17:21

yeah, but I saw Jeremy visited Monroe
Wed 17:21

Jer claimed revivor, surely that's a lie, so he must be coven
Jaqueline Wed 17:21

Sorry, your role again?
Hibbert Wed 17:22

but Monroe claimed that he didn't get redirected
Jaqueline Wed 17:22

What's your role?
Hibbert Wed 17:22

stalker, dear
Jaqueline Wed 17:22

Alrighty
Wed 17:23

Ehm, so you saw him visit Monroe hmm
Wed 17:23

So what could he be>
Hibbert Wed 17:23

Actually I kinda thought Jeremy lied about being revivor because he wanted to lay low, as a Prot or WH
Wed 17:24

but his reaction said otherwise
Wed 17:24

he can't be village, then coven
Jaqueline Wed 17:24

Yeah, as in which coven role
Hibbert Wed 17:24

only witch, or succ
Wed 17:25

but his action did nothing to Monroe, then Monroe could be the vamp
Jaqueline Wed 17:25

But he didn't get killed nor redirected..
Wed 17:25

Ohh right
Hibbert Wed 17:25

is that only possible explanation?
Jaqueline Wed 17:26

Well if you're telling the truth, I dont know what else he could be
Hibbert Wed 17:27

I do, the question is, should we lynch Jeremy the coven, or Monroe the possible vamp?
Jaqueline Wed 17:29

hmmmm
Hibbert Wed 17:29

there's a tiny chance that Jeremy is a dumb, suicidal WH that checked on Monroe the Prot but for some reason lies and denies it
Jaqueline Wed 17:29

Has there been any swap lately
Hibbert Wed 17:29

I saw Phil did unreasonable play similar to that, once xD
Wed 17:30

in the Witcher game, as a prot
Krusty Wed 17:30

pfff
Jaqueline Wed 17:30

But he claimed reviver?
Wed 17:31

ohh right
Wed 17:31

Well I dont think he is tbh
Wed 17:31

Krusty what do you think?
Wed 17:31

I trust you opinion
Krusty Wed 17:32

I don't know, I have to reread some of this
Hibbert Wed 17:35

ok, tell us what you think
Wed 17:35

I will be back in half an hour
Jaqueline Wed 17:36

Alrighty
Moderator Wed 17:44

Krusty votes to lynch Monroe
Krusty Wed 17:45

Can you list your stalks, Hibbert?
Hibbert Wed 17:48

sure
Wed 17:49

N1 Nelson > noone. N2 Apu > Jaqueline. N3 Murdoch > noone. N4 Jeremy > Monroe
Jaqueline Wed 17:50

hmm
Hibbert Wed 17:50

kinda bad luck, I checked on 2 puppets
Jaqueline Wed 17:50

There are a few things I dont like about this check list
Hibbert Wed 17:51

btw if you re read yesterday you will see that I think Apu was a stalker before being converted into fam, before he claimed so
Jaqueline Wed 17:51

One is 2 of your checks are already dead. And I told you Apu checked me..
Hibbert Wed 17:51

that's why I find it hard to believe when Krusty said that there's only 1 stalker
Wed 17:52

actually I was about to check on Krusty N3, because he voted me for no reason, but switch to Murdoch in last minute, fuck me xD
Willie Wed 17:54

Hibbert you checked two puppets?
Hibbert Wed 17:55

yep
Jaqueline Wed 17:55

Why did you decide on stalking me?
Hibbert Wed 17:55

I didnt stalk you Jaque, I stalked Apu
Jaqueline Wed 17:55

I mean apu sorry
Hibbert Wed 17:56

he said a lot, I thought he could have a role
Willie Wed 17:56

Hibbert, who are the puppets?
Hibbert Wed 17:56

Nelson and Murdoc, if we believe that Ralph is PM, which I do
Wed 17:57

ofc I didnt know they were puppets at first lol
Willie Wed 17:57

Why do we think Ralph was PM?
Jaqueline Wed 17:57

I know he is
Wed 17:57

He told me in GY
Willie Wed 17:58

ah, cool
Jaqueline Wed 17:58

Ofcourse he could be lying
Willie Wed 17:58

well, no
Hibbert Wed 17:58

Seriously Willie, are you just acting dense on purpose?
Willie Wed 17:58

it's one of those three
Wed 17:58

and dead puppets can't talk
Wed 17:59

Hibbert, nope
Wed 17:59

just being IRL dense.
Wed 18:00

I missed Jaq say Ralph was PM earlier ^^
Hibbert Wed 18:00

it's good to pay back that line on you tho :p
Willie Wed 18:00

;)
Wed 18:03

so anyway, I don't know if I trust Hibbert yet but I'm convincing myself that Freddie has been shifted :/ I really need to go back and take a closer look... that means Database could be Reviver or Stalker maybe
Wed 18:04

Monroe just feels off to me
Wed 18:04

his checks are, hmm, idk
Wed 18:05

that sounds like they were made given the current information, rather than being natural checks that would have been made at that time
Wed 18:05

but then, I didn't trust Freddie who was probably WH and I don't trust Hibbs who might be stalker
Wed 18:05

so fuck my judgement
Hibbert Wed 18:07

Think Meth, think. Did I do anything bad for village for you not to trust me?
Wed 18:09

Here's the deal, if you dont trust me, we can lynch Jeremy today, then I will stalk Monroe tonight ( he agreed to ''protect'' me)
Wed 18:10

If I live and Monroe did visit me, we know he's lit
Wed 18:10

If I die, you know who's the vamp
Krusty Wed 18:11

You don't thi k the vamp will try to frame Monroe by killing you anyway?
Hibbert Wed 18:12

Krusty mate, Monroe claimed Prot and will ''protect'' me
Krusty Wed 18:12

Oh right
Jaqueline Wed 18:12

I'll go with jeremy then
Moderator Wed 18:12

Jaqueline votes to lynch Jeremy
Hibbert Wed 18:14

the only problem I can think of is: Jeremy is a witch, not succ, and the succ could redirect Monroe (in case he's lit)
Jaqueline Wed 18:15

But the chance of Jeremy being the only coven left is quite high right?
Hibbert Wed 18:15

no, I meant, if I live and Monroe live but succ redirect my stalk to someone else, then I can't verify him
Jaqueline Wed 18:15

We know GY is full of coven
Wed 18:16

Yes, but how do we know succubus is even alive?
Jeremy Wed 18:17

Hi again
Jaqueline Wed 18:17

Supp
Hibbert Wed 18:17

we dont, but we should assume the worst
Jeremy Wed 18:17

3 votes on me :(
Jaqueline Wed 18:17

any defense jeremy
Moderator Wed 18:17

Krusty votes to lynch Jeremy
Jeremy Wed 18:17

4
Krusty Wed 18:17

Better?
Jeremy Wed 18:17

no, worse
Jaqueline Wed 18:17

any defense?\
Hibbert Wed 18:17

we are likely to be 6vs2vs1 right now, or 5vs3vs1 if witch indeed kill shift into Freddie
Jeremy Wed 18:18

no, worse
Wed 18:18

Hibbert is fake, thats all I can say
Jaqueline Wed 18:18

thats all you can say?
Jeremy Wed 18:18

yep.
Jaqueline Wed 18:18

Like common give some real defense
Hibbert Wed 18:18

Jeremy, if you are Succ, admit it so we can lynch Monroe the vamp and get this game over with
Jeremy Wed 18:19

Well, I claimed reviver quite early, b4 Hibbert, and someone must have revived you, Jaqueline
Jaqueline Wed 18:19

Yes someone must have.
Wed 18:20

Altough the question is, if you were the one to revive me
Hibbert Wed 18:20

I think it was bumble who was reviver, or database
Jeremy Wed 18:20

So, who did it?
Jaqueline Wed 18:20

And your def is pretty lame
Hibbert Wed 18:20

it's still strange that no counterclaim on protector
Jeremy Wed 18:20

Hibbert, but then Freddie is lying
Wed 18:20

bc bumble used magic
Krusty Wed 18:21

Recivers are witchcraft users
Wed 18:21

revivers*
Hibbert Wed 18:21

I think Freddie was lit, until last night
Jeremy Wed 18:21

but i thought only when they use their power?
Hibbert Wed 18:21

so it's true that bumble was a magic user
Krusty Wed 18:21

Revivers are always WC users
Jeremy Wed 18:21

Why would you lynch me if you dont have another reviver claim???
Wed 18:22

oh, ok Krusty
Jaqueline Wed 18:22

Ehm a dead person could be reviver? duh
Krusty Wed 18:22

Becauae he saw you visit someone else
Hibbert Wed 18:22

then can you suggest someone to be lynch Jeremy? instead of you?
Jaqueline Wed 18:22

You have been accused of visiting Monroe
Jeremy Wed 18:23

I know, and I didnt
Jaqueline Wed 18:23

You really think we will believe you if you only say you didnt
Wed 18:24

If you are telling the truth think of something to contradict Hibbert.. At least try
Jeremy Wed 18:24

@Hibbert I'd say Hibbert or Freddie, although Barney and Raphael haven't shown up
Wed 18:25

Hibbert, please tell me what you think I am and why i would visit Monroe
Wed 18:25

I am trying, Jaqueline
Hibbert Wed 18:25

speaking of that, Barney and Raphael could be smited soon if they dont come up and ASV
Wed 18:26

assuming they are both village, we village could lose the game because of them
Wed 18:26

damn
Jeremy Wed 18:26

...
Krusty Wed 18:26

I think one of them is coven
Hibbert Wed 18:26

@Jeremy I think you are either witch, or Succ
Wed 18:27

I thought you were a WH that tried to fake claim and to lay low ealier, but your reaction suggest otherwise
Jeremy Wed 18:27

and why?
Hibbert Wed 18:27

so you are witch/succ and Monroe is vamp, is the only explanation
Wed 18:28

still, why no Prot counterclaim? it does bug me
Jeremy Wed 18:28

also, what do you think is Database?
Jaqueline Wed 18:28

prot could be dead
Jeremy Wed 18:28

or Stalker could be dead
Jaqueline Wed 18:28

Could be, yes
Jeremy Wed 18:28

Hibbert contradicts me and Monroe
Wed 18:29

and I have proof that I am alive
Jaqueline Wed 18:29

ehm alive?..
Hibbert Wed 18:29

lol, nice proof mate
Jaqueline Wed 18:29

obv you are
Jeremy Wed 18:30

that the reviver is alive
Jaqueline Wed 18:30

That is no proof
Jeremy Wed 18:30

????
Jaqueline Wed 18:30

I was revived N4 which means BBM or database could have been the reviver
Jeremy Wed 18:31

sigh
Hibbert Wed 18:31

worst case scenario, BBM was revivor and database was prot
Wed 18:31

Jeremy, I like you mate, fighting till the end
Jeremy Wed 18:31

what is more likely, Hibbert
Hibbert Wed 18:32

but if you just drop the act and tell me if Monroe is indeed a vamp, we could end this game faster
Jeremy Wed 18:32

...
Jaqueline Wed 18:32

Hibbert if you are vamp or coven, GG mate, GG
Jeremy Wed 18:32

I am not, Jaqueline
Hibbert Wed 18:32

I dont think there's much chance for coven, unless if Krusty and Jaqueline and Willie all were coven all along
Jaqueline Wed 18:32

I said Hibbert
Jeremy Wed 18:33

k
Jaqueline Wed 18:33

Lol xD
Wed 18:33

That would have been hilarious
Wed 18:33

Wish I was now :p
Jeremy Wed 18:33

I thought you finally listened
Hibbert Wed 18:33

yeah, that would be excellent play xD
Wed 18:33

especially the TR read
Jeremy Wed 18:33

why do you believe Hibbert?
Hibbert Wed 18:34

err, because I have been trying to help the town from Day1?
Jeremy Wed 18:34

not asking you
Jaqueline Wed 18:34

His reasoning makes a lot more sense
Jeremy Wed 18:35

what reasoning?
Jaqueline Wed 18:35

Or well ehm explanation
Wed 18:35

Just sound more believable
Jeremy Wed 18:36

Does it? :/
Wed 18:39

3/4 of his targets are dead
Jaqueline Wed 18:39

Jeremey, I just read some chat of yours
Jeremy Wed 18:40

and?
Jaqueline Wed 18:40

You didn't think along with the village. Most of the time said random things like: hi guys. and overall you haven't brought any information to this town
Wed 18:41

Also, Hibbert. You didn't really talk much until day 4
Hibbert Wed 18:41

Jeremy, do you want us to lynch Monroe, instead of you?
Jeremy Wed 18:42

Idk whether he is Prot
Wed 18:42

need to reread
Wed 18:42

i would also like to see Freddie
Wed 18:44

my lynch list right now is: Hibbert > Freddie > Monroe
Hibbert Wed 18:45

Remember that, If we lynch you, coven still has a chance to win, due to all those soon-to-be-smited
Wed 18:45

If we lynch Monroe and he's vamp, village win, coven loses, you are outnumbered
Wed 18:45

what say you?
Wed 18:46

should we lynch monroe?
Krusty Wed 18:46

That's bot how it works, village have to lynch all the coven before the game ends
Jeremy Wed 18:46

Hibbert, stop that bs
Hibbert Wed 18:46

huh, really?
Krusty Wed 18:46

Yeah
Hibbert Wed 18:47

I thought if all killing roles die and we outnumber the coven, we win
Wed 18:47

ok then
Krusty Wed 18:47

No, but coven don't have much chance once the killing roles are gone
Jeremy Wed 18:47

coven only has witch as killing power
Wed 18:48

and succ
Krusty Wed 18:48

Witch is a one-time kill and succ doesn't add to killing power, it just changes the target
Jeremy Wed 18:48

oh wait, no only witch, so only lynching will be left
Wed 18:48

I thought Succ&WH
Krusty Wed 18:49

That only works every other day on witchcraft users
Wed 18:49

and can be easily prevented by WH just not checking anyone
Jeremy Wed 18:50

yeah, realised that
Hibbert Wed 18:53

hmm, that's troublesome, out of Krusty and Jacqueline, I'm not sure if others are coven or not, even Willie SRSLY
Jeremy Wed 18:53

Hibbert, what do you think about Freddie?
Hibbert Wed 18:53

I hope that Freddie the WH wasn't kill-shifted
Wed 18:54

I find he sus
Wed 18:54

I asked him to check Willie yesterday, but he didn't
Jeremy Wed 18:54

that could be succ
Hibbert Wed 18:55

but I think you are succ and you visited Monroe
Jeremy Wed 18:55

Monroe was not redirected
Wed 18:55

your story makes no sense
Krusty Wed 18:56

Vamps can't be redirected
Hibbert Wed 18:56

he could not be redirected, if he's the vamp
Jeremy Wed 18:56

Any more conditions, Hibbert?
Hibbert Wed 18:56

I dont know, that's why I was confused
Jeremy Wed 18:57

"confused"
Hibbert Wed 18:57

You could be witch jeremy, but I cant think of any reason for witch to poison Monroe, instead of Freddie the WH or BBM
Wed 18:57

so you could only be Succ
Wed 18:58

and Monroe is vamp
Wed 18:58

we will see tonight
Wed 18:58

I think I will be killed, ''sacrifice myself for science'' xD
Jeremy Wed 18:58

OR, you could be vamp/coven
Hibbert Wed 18:59

yeah, I could be
Jeremy Wed 18:59

Also, thats why i think Freddie has been dealt with
Wed 19:00

In your story, Hibbert, coven would have let Freddie be
Hibbert Wed 19:01

no, he could have been dealt with, you succ control Monroe, while the witch and djinn worked on Freddie
Jeremy Wed 19:01

your world has too many conditions
Hibbert Wed 19:03

ohhh
Wed 19:03

I get why you are so resilient
Wed 19:04

if the witch is alive, she can revive you sooner or later
Jeremy Wed 19:06

I am so resilient, bc I doubt witch is going to bring back a villager; and village follows the evil guy
Wed 19:06

also, why is Monroe voting me?
Wed 19:08

I have to go for now - @everyone please reconsider Hibbert
Hibbert Wed 19:13

Ok I get to go
Wed 19:13

Big chance I will be killed tonight
Wed 19:14

Monroe, remember to protect me
Wed 19:14

Barney and Raphael, if any of you are the real protector, pls protect me too
Wed 19:15

I could also be subjective for a kill swap by coven if they haven't done that already, so check my writing if I'm alive
Wed 19:15

Good luck village
Willie Wed 19:23

I still think Hibbert is coven just because he proposed a 3-way vote split :(
Wed 19:23

I wish I could just unhear that and I'd probably believe him
Wed 19:25

Neither Barney nor Raph have said a word, and I had good feelings about Raph earlier in the game :/
Wed 19:28

btw, I'm not Meth xD
Jaqueline Wed 19:55

I know who meth is. I recognized him earlier
Freddie Wed 20:10

lots to read up on
Wed 20:20

waiiit
Jaqueline Wed 20:21

?
Freddie Wed 20:22

I swear His said to check barney yesterday???
Wed 20:22

And, I don't trust Jeremy either.
Jaqueline Wed 20:22

So you agree on lynching Jeremy?
Freddie Wed 20:23

I didn't get swapped/
Wed 20:23

yes
Wed 20:23

He said he was sick which could be true but never got online until right before night fall
Wed 20:23

how come then and not any other day. and then today he has been very active
Moderator Wed 20:24

Freddie votes to lynch Jeremy
Freddie Wed 20:24

I mean when I didn't have much time to play and I was evil I'd wait until the end of the day so I could do both actions
Jeremy Wed 20:25

Freddie, I was very active today???
Freddie Wed 20:25

Hib did say to check willie or barney at 1900
Wed 20:26

more than you have been you said you were sick and that's about it one or two other statements and then you leave before night fall.
Jeremy Wed 20:26

so ?
Freddie Wed 20:27

which part?
Jeremy Wed 20:27

why do you think that it isnt true?
Wed 20:27

You are voting me for the wrong reasons
Wed 20:27

(Not that it matters)
Freddie Wed 20:28

I didn't say anything wasn't true.
Jeremy Wed 20:28

I thought you were implying it
Wed 20:29

Also, in what way is that alignment indicative?
Moderator Wed 20:33

Jeremy votes to lynch Freddie
Moderator Wed 20:33

Jeremy votes to lynch Hibbert
Freddie Wed 20:35

its not really I guess
Wed 20:36

just thought It was odd.
Jeremy Wed 20:36

I still find it incredible that Hibberts claim is believable and doesnt stink with all of his targets dead
Wed 20:37

He couldn't have chosen an easier fake claim
Freddie Wed 20:37

I don't know if he is evil or not.
Wed 20:38

I have believe him Krusty and Jaq
Wed 20:38

I think its odd he said I didn't do what he said to do
Wed 20:38

Because I did.
Jaqueline Wed 20:38

I'll be so sad if Jeremy is actually telling the truth
Moderator Wed 20:39

Freddie votes to lynch Barney
Freddie Wed 20:39

Here I am changing I have no idea.
Wed 20:40

he has stated he wanted protected more than once
Jaqueline Wed 20:41

As in before his claim of being a reviver?
Freddie Wed 20:43

okay
Jaqueline Wed 20:43

?
Freddie Wed 20:43

His has asked to be protected more than once.
Jaqueline Wed 20:44

again, As in before his claim of being a reviver?
Freddie Wed 20:44

yesh
Wed 20:44

yes**
Jaqueline Wed 20:44

hmm
Freddie Wed 20:44

today yesteday
Wed 20:44

id have to look into the other days
Jaqueline Wed 20:45

Well I dont know.. I dont feel entirely convident with either of them.
Wed 20:45

Jeremy seems the most sus to me
Moderator Wed 20:45

Freddie votes to lynch Hibbert
Willie Wed 20:45

why would Jeremy fake claim reviver?
Wed 20:46

how could he knows the reviver was dead? (assuming he is, and that's the reason we have no counter claim?)
Freddie Wed 20:46

I'm goingot vote HIB.
Jaqueline Wed 20:46

Because of obvious reasons lol
Willie Wed 20:46

(did he just get lucky?)
Jaqueline Wed 20:47

Sorry but your reasoning is a bit weird
Wed 20:47

As in he could of course be a reviver
Freddie Wed 20:47

So I just figured out I was redirected...
Wed 20:47

Like I said I haven't been witch hunter before.
Jaqueline Wed 20:47

...
Wed 20:48

So that means Jeremy cant be Succubus
Freddie Wed 20:48

SO, last night it was Hib and then it got more to Barney
Jaqueline Wed 20:48

if you're telling the truth
Freddie Wed 20:48

then nothing shows up today
Wed 20:48

yes which make MUCH more sense
Jaqueline Wed 20:48

ugggh
Wed 20:48

what to do
Wed 20:48

I really dont know
Wed 20:49

COULD MORE PEOPLE COME PLZ
Freddie Wed 20:49

Ialso have never been redirected
Krusty Wed 21:00

Did a bunch of stuff just get deleted?
Jaqueline Wed 21:01

I think so
Moderator Wed 21:01

*mod snips meta*
Jaqueline Wed 21:01

Meta from who?
Wed 21:01

From freddie?
Freddie Wed 21:01

what does meta mean
Wed 21:01

why do people keep saying
Moderator Wed 21:01

(it was snipped for a reason?)
Freddie Wed 21:01

that
Moderator Wed 21:01

(be quiet about it!)
Jaqueline Wed 21:01

:p
Moderator Wed 21:02

nothing exists OUTSIDE of this game!
Lynched Wed 21:06

Jeremy was lynched by the village
Killed Thu 09:24

Krusty was killed during the night

Your role: Observer

The Village

Graveyard

Spoiler free day archives