ext-118 Day 3 | Epic Mafia Online Hidden Roles

Replay

You are viewing day 3 of a game of werewolves started on the 17-Feb-25 Sat on a 24 hour cycle (12h day, 12h night).

This is a spoiler free version, use the user button (top menu) to see who was alive at the time, and the calendar button or links below the chat to navigate through to different days.

You can play a game of online Mafia by joining the game currently in sign up. New players are welcome, but try to be active!
BumblebeeMan Mon 09:14

AYAYAYAAAAAYYYYYAAAA
Mon 09:14

muuucho muuucho anti smite
Jaqueline Mon 09:35

Morning
Apu Mon 09:42

Good morning! :)
Mon 09:42

A lot of people should vote today indeed.
Jaqueline Mon 09:45

Yeah I will
Willie Mon 10:06

oh I died
Mon 10:06

except I didn't die
Mon 10:07

I died and got djinn swapped
Mon 10:07

how quaint
Jaqueline Mon 10:07

wuut
Apu Mon 10:08

So you are Duffman, now-Willie?
Willie Mon 10:08

indeed
Jeremy Mon 10:10

"Voting is now open to lynch the next werewolf"
Moderator Mon 10:11

Jaqueline votes to lynch Murdoch
Moderator Mon 10:11

Willie votes to lynch Raphael
Moderator Mon 10:21

Apu votes to lynch BumblebeeMan
Apu Mon 10:21

We have 2 coven roles confirmed then; PM + Djinn (if we are to believe Willie, but it seems a safe assumption).
Mon 10:22

There having been a kill again confirms that vamp has killed probably. The night a recruit takes place we should expect no kill, I guess - unless there are other events such as messiah, witch kill, ML recruiting wolf, etc...
Mon 10:22

Ml recruiting vamp*, obviously
Ralph Mon 10:35

Hi bros
Mon 10:36

I just realized we have no wolf...?
Apu Mon 10:41

It's day 3, and you've finally read the role list. Cheers, Ralph, glad that you're on board... Somehow this suits your avatar ;)
Jeremy Mon 10:52

@apu considering so many people havent even talked yet, not surprising
Jaqueline Mon 10:54

Nice one Ralph
BumblebeeMan Mon 10:59

ÀYAAYAYY Carriba! Ralphe beste Sherlock
Moderator Mon 11:01

BumblebeeMan votes to lynch Raphael
Apu Mon 11:09

@Bumblebee: I'm not sure what 'beste' means, and (so) I'm not sure what you intended with your vote, but FYI: Raphael != Ralph.
Mon 11:10

Raphael now has 2 votes. Why?
Mon 11:10

Is there a reason to kill Raphael?
Mon 11:10

If anything, I would like to suggest that we lynch Ralph today. Because of his ignorance; either he's really not paying attention, or he's just a puppet playing dumb or something like that. Your opinions, please :)
BumblebeeMan Mon 11:14

Mucho pressure
Jeremy Mon 11:17

idk if he is joking (bc it fits his character) or serious
BumblebeeMan Mon 11:18

Ralpho or mio?
Jeremy Mon 11:19

ralph
Jaqueline Mon 11:21

I think Apu has a point
Mon 11:22

Although he could have an Intel role for village
Mon 11:23

So if we decide to lynch him. I'd say we ask for his role.
Mon 11:23

Although this could also have side effects
Mon 11:23

But I won't get into them to give him any ideas :p
Moderator Mon 11:27

Apu votes to lynch Ralph
Apu Mon 11:27

Lets poke him to see what happens
Mon 11:27

I think you're thinking in the right direction, Jaqueline
Moderator Mon 11:30

Jaqueline votes to lynch Ralph
Moderator Mon 11:46

Jeremy votes to lynch Ralph
Moderator Mon 11:58

Monroe votes to lynch Ralph
Apu Mon 12:07

Alright, with Jeremy and Monroe following silently on the vote, we already have 4 votes. Lets keep it at that for now, it's enough for pressure.
Mon 12:13

Nelson and Database haven't spoken yet at all, I also invite them to at least drop one message today.
Willie Mon 12:19

four votes could really be two puppets, we should keep that in mind if we want to balance
Moderator Mon 12:19

Willie votes to lynch Monroe
Monroe Mon 12:33

I thought you guys have found a non-villager
Mon 12:33

So votung Ralph is a joke?
Mon 12:34

*voting
Moderator Mon 12:46

Jeremy votes to lynch Monroe
BumblebeeMan Mon 13:01

I'll defend Ralph until 13:00
Moderator Mon 13:01

Monroe votes to lynch Raphael
BumblebeeMan Mon 13:01

ok it's over...
Monroe Mon 13:01

BALANCED
BumblebeeMan Mon 13:01

shit... roleplay
Mon 13:01

AYAAAAYAYAYAYYYYAAAAAAAYYYYY
Jeremy Mon 13:26

I don't like Monroes lines at [t=12:33]
Monroe Mon 13:32

I dont like myself at this part too lol
Mon 13:33

A non villager is coven or vampire I meant
BumblebeeMan Mon 13:37

:)
Mon 13:37

fuck this BumblebeeMan roleplay
Mon 13:37

-_-
Jeremy Mon 13:37

What i dont like is that you say you "thought" instead of reading
Mon 13:37

and then blindly follow
Monroe Mon 13:42

I read, then I thought!
Apu Mon 13:42

Agreed, Jeremy - it's not that much effort to catch up on chat at this stage! ;)
Monroe Mon 13:42

It was not "blindly follow"
Apu Mon 13:43

Although the purpose of the vote was to simply pressure somebody who was making a strange remark; there's no indication of evil alignment yet
BumblebeeMan Mon 13:43

not?
Moderator Mon 13:43

BumblebeeMan votes to lynch Monroe
Apu Mon 13:44

Well, chat behavior is an indication; I meant that there's no evidence like a seer check or something like that yet
Monroe Mon 13:45

Dont vote me just because Im ugly :((
BumblebeeMan Mon 13:45

ok
Moderator Mon 13:45

BumblebeeMan votes to lynch Ralph
Monroe Mon 13:45

Dont randomly vote...
BumblebeeMan Mon 13:45

It's not random
Mon 13:45

I try to get someone lynched
Apu Mon 13:46

We're going all over the place
Mon 13:46

We = mostly BumblebeeMan here
BumblebeeMan Mon 13:46

Thanks bro, we foreigners need to stick together
Mon 13:47

So you don't wanna lynch?
Apu Mon 13:47

Lets focus on Ralph first today, see what he has to say. We also keep tabs on Monroe. And if something more important (= based on night ability's evidence) turns up in the meantime, we switch.
Mon 13:47

^
Monroe Mon 13:47

:(( Why thats me?
Mon 13:48

Because Im ugly?
BumblebeeMan Mon 13:48

Switching before midnight is for pussies, real mean like me go through with their votes!
Apu Mon 13:48

I say we lynch Ralph unless he comes up with a good story. Although my primary concern is that we get this game going and start talking, so: yes - I'll say we should lynch Ralph, so that we can then start discussing and (dis)agreeing
Jeremy Mon 13:48

And lets hope the other two thirds of the village show up
BumblebeeMan Mon 13:48

I don't wanna lynch Ralph
Apu Mon 13:48

Why not, BBM?
Mon 13:48

@Jeremy: agreed
BumblebeeMan Mon 13:48

The remark was too uhm
Mon 13:48

bad
Mon 13:49

Like when I'm evil I write way more diplomatic
Mon 13:49

I think the remark was kinda innocent. Not sure though
Mon 13:50

I think Database looks suspicious
Moderator Mon 13:50

BumblebeeMan votes to lynch Database
Apu Mon 13:50

@Monroe: it's not about your ugliness, although it may be a factor. The comment you made (pointed out by Jeremy) seemed a bit strange.
Mon 13:50

@BBM: what the hell are you doing!?
Mon 13:50

You're throwing votes like crazy
BumblebeeMan Mon 13:50

?????????????????????????????
Apu Mon 13:50

Why is Database suspicious?
BumblebeeMan Mon 13:50

voting obviously
Mon 13:50

I don't know I don't like the glasses
Monroe Mon 13:51

My comment was strange
Mon 13:51

Okay
Mon 13:51

So just vote me
BumblebeeMan Mon 13:51

nah
Mon 13:51

nobody agreeing with Database?
Apu Mon 13:53

He hasn't spoken at all, which doesn't vouch for him, but that does mean he hasn't had the opportunity to make suspicious comments yet
Mon 13:53

It seems like you're being protective of Ralph now, BBM, to me
Monroe Mon 13:54

Just read back and I think my comment was so suspicious lol
Mon 13:54

My bad English...
Apu Mon 13:57

You're excused, Monroe. At least, for now: my attention's on Ralph and BBM at the moment...
Moderator Mon 14:25

Barney votes to lynch Ralph
Jeremy Mon 15:32

Hi Barney
Apu Mon 15:36

It's always interesting when somebody votes without speaking, right Jeremy? ;)
Ralph Mon 16:26

Eh? Why me?
Mon 16:26

Ah i have to admit things are really rough recently
Jaqueline Mon 16:27

Read the chat
Mon 16:27

Like really
Ralph Mon 16:27

Yeah like wtf XD
Jaqueline Mon 16:28

Well I agree with them
Mon 16:28

It's day 3, and only now you notice the setup?
Mon 16:28

What have you been doing the rest of the time?
Ralph Mon 16:29

Yeah i have another game in progress
Jaqueline Mon 16:29

So?
Ralph Mon 16:29

And im busy, i have a life too
Jaqueline Mon 16:29

So do we mate
Mon 16:30

But reading aint that hard
BumblebeeMan Mon 16:30

Jaq don't be too harsh.
Jaqueline Mon 16:30

It might sound harsh, I don't mean it like that. Just trying to understand him
Ralph Mon 16:31

I got mixed up XD whats so hard to understand about it
BumblebeeMan Mon 16:31

I can kinda understand why you take wolves for granted
Ralph Mon 16:31

^
Mon 16:31

Finally
Jaqueline Mon 16:32

I get that, but please get a bit more involved. It makes the game much more fun for everyone
BumblebeeMan Mon 16:32

AYAYAYAAAAAAAYAAAAAY
Mon 16:32

Roleplay not -_-
Jaqueline Mon 16:32

XD
Moderator Mon 16:33

BumblebeeMan votes to lynch Monroe
BumblebeeMan Mon 16:33

I'll balance on monroe for the moment
Ralph Mon 16:34

Seer is gonna check me anw
Mon 16:35

The fact that bumblebee protected me even makes me more suspicious XD
BumblebeeMan Mon 16:35

-_-
Mon 16:35

Why, I'm your trustworthy bumble
Mon 16:35

bee
Mon 16:35

Man
Mon 16:35

thingy..
Mon 16:36

I don't know why I'm even slightly suspicious
Murdoch Mon 16:37

So are we lynching or not?
Ralph Mon 16:38

I mean how do you even know who i am smth like that XD why you are being so protective of me
BumblebeeMan Mon 16:40

Expirience
Ralph Mon 16:42

Thanks then :D
Hibbert Mon 16:43

Hey guys, Hib's here
Mon 16:44

Look like we have a pretty confident vamp, D3 and still no Fam recruitment
Jeremy Mon 16:44

read the chat and tell us what you think
Hibbert Mon 16:45

also if we believe that Willie is telling the truth about the swap, then Vamp chose to kill Willie yesterday
Mon 16:46

I wonder is it random choice or what
Mon 16:46

however the fact that Willie got swapped with Duff look odd
Mon 16:47

Djinn didn't swap anyone on N2, but N3 decide to swap between 2 INACTIVE ppl
Jeremy Mon 16:47

Why?
Ralph Mon 16:47

That and you guys still want to lynch me -_-
Hibbert Mon 16:48

if I was Djinn, I would have swap 2 ppl that is active, would make more confusion, like Apu and Jaque
Ralph Mon 16:48

i mean why in the world would the coven just swapped randomly 2 villager
Hibbert Mon 16:48

My hunch is, Willie and Duff both could be coven, or at least 1
Ralph Mon 16:49

And willie got killed right after that by the vamp?
Hibbert Mon 16:49

no, swap happened last, willie got killed, then swapped
Mon 16:49

now it shows that Duff got killed, and now-Willie is in fact Duff
Database Mon 16:50

hey guys,
Hibbert Mon 16:50

btw my point is there's a chance Willie is coven, seer or WH pls check him
Mon 16:50

Now about lynching
Mon 16:51

It's easy to see that with 1 vamp and maybe 1 witch at most, evils dont have many killing power
Database Mon 16:51

i had a busy monday af
Hibbert Mon 16:51

I dont think start lynching D3 based on air, is wise
Database Mon 16:51

will reread and brb
Hibbert Mon 16:52

I say we balance today, buy some more time for our special roles to get info, and start pressuring tmr
Mon 16:52

I think only coven and vamp would try to get ppl lynch ''on a hunch'' at this point
BumblebeeMan Mon 16:53

HE HE
Hibbert Mon 16:54

bottom line is, we should have a 3 ways balance today
Moderator Mon 16:54

Hibbert votes to lynch Raphael
Ralph Mon 16:54

Anw dont want to be a bitch but why did bumblebee vote me and protect me right away XD
Mon 16:54

And good idea Hibb :D
Hibbert Mon 16:59

need 1 more vote on Raphael for 3v3v3
Mon 16:59

Freddie Krusty Nelson Database Raphael Murdoch Ralph if you dont vote soon you will be smited
Mon 17:00

just ASV and create a 3v3v3v3 if you cant decide
Mon 17:01

btw I notice that Jeremy voted without saying anything twice, looks like a puppet
Murdoch Mon 17:02

My avatar is so suspicious i dont even want to live anymore
Mon 17:02

Damn
Moderator Mon 17:02

Murdoch votes to lynch Raphael
Jeremy Mon 17:10

@Hibbert, I think I have explained my votes
Willie Mon 17:25

This might be a bit off topic. but what do we think the chances of there being a TR in this set up are?
Mon 17:26

and the follow-up question: should they use their ability asap?
Mon 17:27

Hibbet, why a 3-way balance?
Freddie Mon 17:27

I agree with Hib
Mon 17:28

I have to vote
Mon 17:28

Maybe we have an inactive vamp
Mon 17:28

but I think our coven is active
Willie Mon 17:28

"I agree with Hib" - about what+
Mon 17:29

why do you think we gave an inactive vampire??
Mon 17:29

have*
Freddie Mon 17:30

that willie or duff was coven andsould be checked
Mon 17:30

If they haven't killed
Mon 17:30

or could they have killed or picked duff or willie and you be lying?
Mon 17:30

I haven't played vampire yet
Willie Mon 17:31

words are coming out of your mouth but I'm failing to find any meaning
Freddie Mon 17:31

ok
Mon 17:32

Could you be a vampire or the familiar
Mon 17:32

since you said you died and didt
Mon 17:32

didn't and are lying
Mon 17:32

Just a question
Willie Mon 17:32

wat
Mon 17:33

what am I lying about?
Freddie Mon 17:33

about being dead duff and now not dead duff in willie
Willie Mon 17:34

I would have thought given our radical differences in speaking that it would be quite obvious we were swapped last night
Freddie Mon 17:36

I don't think it is
Mon 17:37

you don't use periods and you don't use caps at the start of your sentence and you stated statement with hitting enter after you said a thought
Willie Mon 17:37

oh well
Freddie Mon 17:38

really?
Willie Mon 17:39

I don't really care what you think, I assume anyone with a brain can work it out for themselves
Freddie Mon 17:39

I have to vote and I'm picking you. town can decide if we want to hang someone
Moderator Mon 17:39

Freddie votes to lynch Willie
Freddie Mon 17:42

ill be back l8r
Willie Mon 17:43

I wouldn't bother, tbh
Jeremy Mon 17:45

I have some questions: 1. Should we do some codes so we can prove that we were swapped/not swapped? 2. Is that ok by the rules? and 3. Is cryptography forbidden?
Krusty Mon 17:50

Well if you say the code here, anyone can see it and use it later, unless it uses knowledge from outside the game which would be meta.
Mon 17:51

I'm afraid all we can do (beside confirming swaps with night actions) is study and compare how the swap suspects speak and behave.
Database Mon 17:54

Finished!
Mon 17:56

So Willie died, and Duff now live under Willie identity
Mon 17:56

*lives
Krusty Mon 17:57

@Willie, I think that a TR should use their power sooner rather than later because this is a hidden roles game and with a role list, we could do a role call if we decided to
Jeremy Mon 17:58

@Krusty We can also have a code like [-x-mp---od-] and the solver needs to fill in the gaos
Database Mon 17:58

Why do we need a code ?
Jeremy Mon 17:58

To confirm identities
Database Mon 17:59

i did not get that, Jer
Krusty Mon 17:59

But there's no one else that can confirm that the code is correct
Database Mon 17:59

If we got swapped, we gonna say it out
Krusty Mon 17:59

Anyone that wanted to masquerade as you could guess and make up the codeword
Database Mon 18:00

Unless they swap themselves
Mon 18:00

Like swapping PM with a pet
Krusty Mon 18:01

Since we don't have any swap claims for yesterday, I expect that coven swapped within their faction
Database Mon 18:02

Maybe and maybe not
Moderator Mon 18:03

Krusty votes to lynch Hibbert
Database Mon 18:03

I think they only swapp themselves when they decide to sacrify a pet to distract us from the real 1
Mon 18:03

As i read back, not too much pp talked yesterday
Mon 18:05

Btw, because the real-Willie died already, so we don't know if Duff-or-the-real-Duff is telling the truth or not
Mon 18:06

Is this an ASV Krusty?
Willie Mon 18:06

so I'll just put this question out there... why would anyone lie about being swapped in this manner o.o
Mon 18:06

like, what would the gain be?
Database Mon 18:08

i'm thinking about it as well lol
Krusty Mon 18:09

Yeah, smite prevention
Database Mon 18:10

I also need to ASV now
Moderator Mon 18:10

Database votes to lynch Nelson
Database Mon 18:11

nelson did not say anything, right?
Mon 18:12

Dont be smited, guys
Jeremy Mon 18:19

Krusty, we could make the code difficult, or use hashes
Raphael Mon 18:19

Hey guys, can we do a 4-way tie?
Moderator Mon 18:19

Raphael votes to lynch Nelson
Willie Mon 18:51

I like you, Raphael
Mon 18:51

You seem smart
Raphael Mon 19:02

Thanks :)
Apu Mon 20:02

I don't think Willie's necessarily suspicious for being swapped. I'm not sure I understand the anti-Djinn coding, so if we're onto that please explain it more :)
Mon 20:03

Considering the limited killing power, I do agree (I think it was Hibbert who said that) that lynching is not the best way to go. Although some people are a bit 'meh' in my view, nothing's powerful enough for a lynch yet.
Mon 20:04

A 4-way tie is the way to go indeed.
Mon 20:05

Although some people are on the brink of being smited - Nelson is, at least, he still hasn't checked in.
Mon 20:05

I'd rather risk getting Nelson lynched than Ralph in this context, so I'll change to Nelson atm.
Moderator Mon 20:06

Apu votes to lynch Nelson
Apu Mon 20:06

(Nelson can only die if Monroe and Raphael both have a puppet on them, but since Nelson is bound to be smited it might not make a difference after all)
Mon 20:07

Alright, I'm off again. See you tomorrow. Let's hope we can get this party started then! ;)
Killed Tue 09:02

Jaqueline was killed during the night
Killed Tue 09:02

Murdoch was killed during the night

Your role: Observer

The Village

Graveyard

Spoiler free day archives