wlf-063 Day 4 | Why Villager Contribution in Werewolf is so Important

Replay

You are viewing day 4 of a game of werewolv.es started on the 19-Jun-17 Mon on a 24 hour cycle (12h day, 12h night).

This is a spoiler free version, use the user button (top menu) to see who was alive at the time, and the calendar button or links below the chat to navigate through to different days.

You can play a game of online Mafia by joining the game currently in sign up. New players are welcome, but try to be active!
Regatti Thu 08:16

Liz is a wolfie
Moderator Thu 08:16

Regatti votes to lynch Elizabeth
Regatti Thu 08:16

I thought so. Right Mr. Sparrowwwww
Thu 08:24

I guess me not dying is some bluff by wolves
Thu 08:24

Making me suspicious
Salazar Thu 08:53

hmm, lets see what Elizabeth has to say
Thu 08:53

It's weird you didn't die
Moderator Thu 08:53

Salazar votes to lynch Elizabeth
Salazar Thu 08:54

Or are you shifted?
Regatti Thu 08:54

Noooot rly
Thu 08:54

*checks body*
Thu 08:54

I mean I think I get the plan
Thu 08:54

Blackbear paid most attention and me convincing him of not being shfited like yesterday may spell doom for the wolves
Thu 08:55

also I think black and me would pick up on liz odd late ovte and the general shadyness of her
Thu 08:55

if she lets Blacky live, I don't think this guy would have been fooled by liz
Thu 08:55

so I think wolves did the best play in trying to frame me, and thus shift attention away from liz herself
Thu 08:56

So basically the best shot for wolves is to let me life and then say "how are you still alive"
Thu 08:56

while if I was dead, Blacky would rip Liz a new one.
Elizabeth Thu 08:58

Ok
Thu 08:58

I see how it makes sense to vote me
Thu 08:59

But I think that regatti is shifter
Thu 08:59

It makes sense, shift into regatti wait a bit and frame someone
Thu 09:00

Though I don’t know why you did it now
Thu 09:00

And I know I’m pretty sus
Thu 09:00

So it makes sense that you ‘checked’ me
Moderator Thu 09:00

Elizabeth votes to lynch Regatti
Regatti Thu 09:01

I like your play liz, nice try, but uhm I wont be shifted that easily
Elizabeth Thu 09:01

But you already are shifted
Thu 09:01

That’s the point lol
Thu 09:01

And it’s not you I’m trying to shift
Thu 09:02

I don’t think I can convince you that you’re wolf
Thu 09:02

But hopefully the others believe me
Thu 09:02

Otherwise the wolves could win this game
Thu 09:02

But I do think that’s unlikely
Thu 09:03

Me and you were both good shift targets
Thu 09:04

But I think the wolves realised prot was dead and that shifting to you would be the best plsy
Thu 09:04

Play
Salazar Thu 09:05

Who do you think shifted into Regatti Elizabeth?
Regatti Thu 09:06

Blackbeard LOL
Thu 09:07

43253245234523452354234,2345,3245,3245,32452345,2345243123123,,12 this is my new shiftcode, I'm blackbeard!
Salazar Thu 09:07

Hi Blackbeard
Regatti Thu 09:07

waiit...
Elizabeth Thu 09:09

Probably either mullroy or scrum
Thu 09:09

Actually no definitely one of those two
Thu 09:10

Wait?
Salazar Thu 09:10

If thats the case either prot died n1 or prot didnt protect the seer n2 and gambled.
Thu 09:10

But wouldnt be the firsat time a protective role gambles and loses
Thu 09:11

*first
Elizabeth Thu 09:11

I think the village got unlucky and prot died N1
Thu 09:11

We don’t have a gd to confirm though
Thu 09:12

Or to confirm that calypso was wolf
Thu 09:12

This could be game over if we vote wrong
Thu 09:14

The wolves have been smart
Thu 09:14

With their killing
Murtogg Thu 09:18

The way I see it there are 3 options
Thu 09:19

1. Regatti has been a wolf all along, claimed seer d2 and it just so happened seer had been killed n1. Would have been a big gamble so I think unlikely
Elizabeth Thu 09:20

Yeah I really doubt that
Murtogg Thu 09:21

2. Regatti was shifted into. IF Calypso was a wolf (which I think they were), the fact that Reg didn't like that lynch is a bit sus
Thu 09:22

But to be fair, being against lynching the only prot claim when you're a seer is perhaps understandable
Regatti Thu 09:23

I mean even if she was wolf, it could have given me one more check, due to the wolves trying to establish that the seer is still there
Thu 09:24

If you fake prot and you normally don't kill of the most obvious power role next night
Thu 09:24

this undermines the litness of your prot claim and may get you lynched
Thu 09:24

this is why I wasn't a huge fan of lynching Calypso
Murtogg Thu 09:24

That's fair Reg 3. Liz was shifted into. Liz was the most sus person yesterday after Calypso, so if the obvious thing (Reg dying) happened then lynching Liz was basically inevitable
Moderator Thu 09:25

Murtogg votes to lynch Elizabeth
Regatti Thu 09:26

Also for me to be wolf we would kinda have to agree that Blacky was shifted
Thu 09:26

or blacky was terrible at detecting players and didn't notice the shift yesterday
Thu 09:26

since I'dbe wolf for 2 days in a row now
Salazar Thu 09:28

*puts on tinfoil hat* Regatti is really Blacky who shifted, we lynched the prot and now he is framing Liz.
Regatti Thu 09:29

I wonder if a shifting blacky would have problems to restrain himself at going full maths mode in a new avatar :D
Thu 09:29

*mussssst resist the maaathhhhhsss*
Elizabeth Thu 09:29

Lmao
Thu 09:30

So there’s 3 votes for me
Thu 09:30

I’m gonna need to convince you all that I’m not shifted
Thu 09:31

I’m not saying regatti is 100% definitely shifter
Thu 09:31

Almost any of us could be
Thu 09:31

My best guess is regatti though
Thu 09:32

But he does seem quite convincing so maybe not
Thu 09:32

We probably only have 1 wolf left
Thu 09:32

The shofter
Thu 09:32

Shifter
Thu 09:33

Unless we killed the shifter and we still have an alpha
Thu 09:33

But that’s really unlikely
Murtogg Thu 09:35

"Almost any of us could be" That doesnt make sense - If you're not a wolf, then Regatti has to be shifter or else why would he be lying?
Regatti Thu 09:36

^^
Thu 09:36

Let the roasting commence, I'm enjoying this^^
Elizabeth Thu 09:41

Like i said, we have no way to prove that calypso was alpha
Thu 09:41

Even though she probably was
Thu 09:42

But on the odd chance she wasnt
Thu 09:42

Then we have 2 wolves
Thu 09:42

Regatti being one and someone being the other
Thu 09:42

This could be right
Thu 09:42

But it’s probably bot
Thu 09:42

Not
Murtogg Thu 09:42

Okay, so for sake of argument say Calypso was legit prot
Elizabeth Thu 09:43

Ok
Murtogg Thu 09:43

4 ppl voted for her: me, Blackbeard (now dead), Liz and Sal
Elizabeth Thu 09:44

Yeah?
Murtogg Thu 09:44

I think it's extremely unlikely if she was lit that neither wolf voted for her
Thu 09:44

So from my perspective, you or Sal are still a wolf (or both)
Elizabeth Thu 09:45

Ok that’s fair
Thu 09:45

But one of them could’ve beeb voting differently
Murtogg Thu 09:45

I suppose Sal and Reg being two remaining wolves is possible (or me and Reg from your perspective)
Thu 09:45

But I don't think it's likely
Elizabeth Thu 09:46

Exactly
Thu 09:46

We have to be careful trusting the seer
Thu 09:47

It’s not like we have another seer to prove the
Thu 09:47

Them
Thu 09:47

Like I was saying before
Thu 09:47

One of the wolves was voting calypso while the other was voting someone else
Thu 09:47

Maybe
Thu 09:48

If they did this then if we find voting calypso sus then one still lives
Thu 09:48

But if we find not voting her sus then the other lives
Murtogg Thu 09:54

Sparrow where you at?
Thu 09:55

What do you think about the possibility that Reg and Sal are the wolves?
Thu 09:59

Try to lynch Mullroy d2, when it fails kill him in the night to make it look like a shift, then one helps lynch Calypso while the other says it's a bad idea so either way one is covered
Thu 10:00

It would require either a very lucky seer claim d2, or a very good shift from Scrum - I haven't seen anything that has suggested to me that Reg is shifted
Thu 10:02

It would also mean that Blackbeard has been basically wrong about all their suspicions the whole way through
Regatti Thu 10:22

yeah and didn't spot the shift of me
Thu 10:22

although blacky and I had some deep talks about the purpose of life, the galaxy and wolves
Murtogg Thu 10:57

My vote shows where I stand on this
Thu 10:57

But would like to hear from Sparrow
Sparrow Thu 11:51

Hi guys. Lunch break. Will go through properly later.
Thu 11:52

Not sure what to think now.
Moderator Thu 11:52

Sparrow votes to lynch Elizabeth
Sparrow Thu 11:53

Of course we could lose today if This is wrong
Thu 11:53

Yarr
Thu 11:55

Or Elizabeth is last wolf and we win
Thu 11:55

Arr
Regatti Thu 11:59

Well I don't think there are many that plausible theories at the moment when I would have been shifted, and the "he was wolf all along" kinda breaks down with my early claim. I may act bold from time to time, but suicide is not my jam
Salazar Thu 14:47

hmmst
Regatti Thu 14:48

hm?
Sparrow Thu 15:14

Yarr?
Thu 15:37

Are we all happy that If we lynch Elizabeth tonight and Regatti is still alive tomorrow we lynch them? (Assuming we haven't won/lost)
Thu 15:38

No wait
Thu 15:38

Thinking
Thu 15:39

Not sure whether we would be better lynching the other way around
Thu 15:46

I really don't like how you are still alive.
Salazar Thu 16:08

You think Regatti and someone else is wolf?
Thu 16:09

If you go the way that Regatti is wolf then you cant lynch Elisbeth tomorrow, cause then you would loose if that assumption is true. Would have to lynch someone else.
Murtogg Thu 16:18

I think on balance Liz is the right choice today. If it's not over then tomorrow we'll have to work out whether Calypso or Liz was the right one
Salazar Thu 18:57

Regatti, please promise me that you are not a wolf, I will be sad if you are a wolf.
Regatti Thu 19:23

I do :)
Murtogg Thu 19:23

Ugh second guessing myself right now and I don't like it
Thu 19:23

The current lynch makes the most sense
Regatti Thu 19:23

Don't, I lost so many games doing it. I mean only theory is that Blackbeard shifted me, or someone did an incredible job in being me yesterday
Thu 19:25

and today
Thu 19:25

altho I have to say I was a bit more quiet today, there wasn't much to be said with an actual wolf check
Murtogg Thu 19:26

Everyone has been quieter today
Regatti Thu 19:26

well there are only two choices today
Thu 19:26

I hope this ends, altho I'm not positive
Thu 19:26

there's a chance that calypso was prot
Thu 19:26

on the other hand liz voted for cali very late
Thu 19:27

so maybe it was a wolf on wolf due to there being no chance to sway the vootes
Thu 19:27

-o
Murtogg Thu 19:56

I'm not sure it will end today, but whatever happens thank you all for making this an actually interesting wlf game
Sparrow Thu 19:58

I'm a wolf...
Thu 19:58

Joke
Thu 19:58

Yarr
Thu 19:59

What's a pirate's favourite letter?
Moderator Thu 19:59

It will soon be night...
Sparrow Thu 19:59

You think'd be R but it's actually the C
Regatti Thu 20:00

aha
Lynched Thu 20:00

Elizabeth was lynched by the village
Moderator Thu 20:00

Village Victory!
Regatti Thu 20:00

fuck yes
Thu 20:00

STEVE YOU'RE A HEROOOOO
Thu 20:00

what a mission that guy
Thu 20:01

gg
Salazar Thu 20:01

gg, prot died n1 xD
Blackbeard Thu 20:02

Hooray
Regatti Thu 20:02

fuck
Thu 20:02

I mixed up mark and Steeve
Thu 20:02

GG Mark :D
Thu 20:02

what a mission
Thu 20:02

MAKE WLF GREAT AGAIN
Blackbeard Thu 20:02

GJ everyone
Elizabeth Thu 20:02

Welp
Thu 20:02

Gg
Regatti Thu 20:03

Sorry liz, this was a hard task for ya
Blackbeard Thu 20:03

Good have been an easy victory for wolves of we just sat back
Murtogg Thu 20:03

Noice! Well done Mark
Thu 20:03

(And everyone else)
Blackbeard Thu 20:03

So we had to be very proactive from d2
Regatti Thu 20:03

this was a lot of fun to play
Blackbeard Thu 20:03

GJ everyone, WP wolves also
Regatti Thu 20:04

if you got someone like Mark on your neck, being wolf is hard
Blackbeard Thu 20:04

Town and I have a good history of working together as well which didn't help them :p
Regatti Thu 20:04

well you know me
Blackbeard Thu 20:04

<3
Regatti Thu 20:04

so it's hard to get a shift through
BootstrapBill Thu 20:04

Well, gg everyone
Regatti Thu 20:05

or well make it seem like one
Blackbeard Thu 20:05

Yeah
Thu 20:05

Sadly can't play for a week or so after this as I'm too busy but we'll play in wlf 065 probably
Thu 20:05

And yes let's make wlf great again :D
Regatti Thu 20:06

thanks to everyone for actually trying to see if I shifted instead of just blindly go for the "he's alive he must be evil"
Yup Fri 06:58

I've been observing. Gotta say. That was a really fun game to observe.

Your role: Observer

The Village

Graveyard

Spoiler free day archives