ext-324 Day 10 | Werewolf Game Replay

Replay

You are viewing day 10 of a game of werewolv.es started on the 19-May-14 Tue on a 24 hour cycle (12h day, 12h night).

This is a spoiler free version, use the user button (top menu) to see who was alive at the time, and the calendar button or links below the chat to navigate through to different days.

You can play a game of online Mafia by joining the game currently in sign up. New players are welcome, but try to be active!
Sandslash Thu 08:23

Wakey wakey people!
Thu 08:24

So it either wasn't Weezing , or there is another evil here besides Weezing
Thu 08:24

Likely - the first option...
Thu 08:25

I want more participation than a single sentence per day from our stalker (may be too late by now anyway)
Thu 08:27

Also Dug has dug up (HA HA) some quotes from Meta, I want some answers on what he reeealy knows about those UD, I didn't consider the quotes and points brought up by Dug lynch worthy though yesterday
Venomoth Thu 08:29

So again
Thu 08:29

nobody died
Thu 08:29

That means no zombie?
Thu 08:29

Am I correct?
Thu 08:30

oh wait no
Thu 08:30

it would die tonight
Thu 08:32

So if metapod is to be believed a VD died already - do we think there is another VD still alive making zombies or not? if not then we are looking at an undead which has been there all along or we are looking at a revenant swap
Thu 08:32

either of the last two options means they don't have night killing power
Thu 08:32

as nobody has died two nights in a row
Thu 08:33

We will know tonight
Rhyhorn Thu 08:53

*sigh* it still isn’t over?
Metapod Thu 08:53

Good morning
Rhyhorn Thu 08:53

Hey Meta
Metapod Thu 08:53

I dug poli last night
Rhyhorn Thu 08:53

And?
Metapod Thu 08:53

They were a medium
Rhyhorn Thu 08:53

Hmm
Thu 08:53

...weren’t you accused of possibly being a Medium yesterday?
Metapod Thu 08:54

That puts the known UD as Raticate - original zombie, Poliwrath - Medium, Starmie - Wight, Nidoking - Ghoul, Magnemite - Voodoo Doctor.
Thu 08:54

I was accused of everything under the sun yesterday
Rhyhorn Thu 08:55

Oh well, I didn’t like Spearow’s play yesterday, they said like 2 sentences and then later voted without saying anything
Thu 08:56

So I’m voting them (for now)
Thu 08:56

At least until they explain themselves
Moderator Thu 08:56

Rhyhorn votes to lynch Spearow
Metapod Thu 08:57

If a ghoul consumed an UD role such as VD would the ghoul permanently become the VD?
Rhyhorn Thu 09:04

Yes
Metapod Thu 09:04

Then I'm fairly certain spearow's the zombie and a wasted vote
Thu 09:06

Spearow will die tonight and we will have a new zombie tomorrow
Thu 09:06

There is really only 5 people left today
Thu 09:06

If there is 2 UD, then 4 people total tomorrow
Thu 09:07

We could lose
Thu 09:13

Not really sure how you want me to answer those "quotes" from dug. There's nothing suspect about them at all... I used the H2P to get an idea of the mechanics but I'm not so used to them that I know the roles inside out
Moderator Thu 09:14

Metapod votes to lynch Dugtrio
Metapod Thu 09:17

Dug is my vote as they spend all yesterday switching their vote depending on who was drawing attention to them
Venomoth Thu 09:18

Meta why did you not dig the seer?
Metapod Thu 09:19

What would that achieve?
Sandslash Thu 09:19

it's about the zombie theory
Venomoth Thu 09:19

We would know if they had been zombified
Metapod Thu 09:20

Should of told me.
Thu 09:20

I should of dug mag though
Venomoth Thu 09:20

thus their check on me - that whole thing you talked about yesterday
Metapod Thu 09:20

I literally said yesterday I would dig poli
Thu 09:20

No one told me not to
Sandslash Thu 09:22

Actually - I don't think this was a realy bad lynch, but Ven is not wrong either
Thu 09:22

dig not lynch
Thu 09:24

my cold is going strong, sorry :(
Metapod Thu 09:24

I should of dug mag. They would of shown as Wight if we were dealing with a VD :/
Venomoth Thu 09:24

I mean I think it's weird they went all the way back to D2 rather than the lynch from yesterday or the seer - and then conveniently found another undead
Thu 09:24

but not impossible
Metapod Thu 09:25

Why is it weird trying to find out what the UD pool is? Poli was a seer checked UD
Venomoth Thu 09:25

Yeah true
Sandslash Thu 09:26

Meta - you're consistently ignoring my questions about your UD knowledge
Metapod Thu 09:26

Ask a question
Sandslash Thu 09:27

see what Dug said yesterday before nightfall
Metapod Thu 09:27

I've answered that
Sandslash Thu 09:27

did you? let me check
Metapod Thu 09:27

Not that there was a question to answer
Venomoth Thu 09:28

I do want to just put it out there that Sandslash has had nobody question them. They are not top of my sus list or anything but it's common that the person making lists and spreadsheets and being very helpful dies for that reason, so it's weird they haven't died. I've seen evils take on the role of the town spreadsheet and summary person and live a long time because of it.
Thu 09:28

Just dont want that to go unsaid
Metapod Thu 09:28

I don't trust anyone anymore including sand
Venomoth Thu 09:28

i mean yeah, same
Thu 09:28

but there are probably people i'd lynch before him
Thu 09:29

I want to hear from spearow today
Thu 09:30

If we are in this same position tomorrow I think you should hold your dig metapod and we get spearow to stalk you
Metapod Thu 09:30

Sure but spearows gone
Venomoth Thu 09:30

gone like, not participating?
Metapod Thu 09:31

zombifies
Venomoth Thu 09:31

OH you think?
Thu 09:31

Well I guess we'll find out tonight
Thu 09:31

So you think there is still a VD?
Sandslash Thu 09:31

Nobody has to trust me, still will try and do my best to keep this game going in the right direction :)
Metapod Thu 09:32

Yeah I said earlier that I thought a ghoul devoured the VD
Sandslash Thu 09:32

I'm probably still alive since I was BH checked as vanilla and thus there were other targets to kill
Metapod Thu 09:32

Or that's my main theory
Sandslash Thu 09:33

or at least that's what the Ivysaur confession brought to light
Thu 09:34

Spearow could a necro'd UD, a Ghoul or just a lurky stalker
Metapod Thu 09:34

With regards to what we know about the UD pool. What do you guys think the most likely other roles are?
Venomoth Thu 10:12

So to me it seems likely there is probably a necromancer if there is VD, medium, ghoul
Thu 10:12

I dont really know
Thu 10:12

I dont think there is a banshee
Thu 10:13

and i think we know there isn't a revenant
Metapod Thu 10:13

On earlier days some mentions its common to have multiple ghouls
Venomoth Thu 10:13

yeah a second ghoul is also possible
Sandslash Thu 11:33

I agree with Venomoth about the possible setup, GHOUL is quite a versatile role and can become any other UD role.
Thu 11:42

I'll wait for Spearow, my spread sheet hasn't been as useful the last few days :/
Venomoth Thu 12:37

This game is dragging on a bit tbh
Sandslash Thu 12:38

Yes - and it get's less exciting from day to day :(
Venomoth Thu 13:00

okay whats the plan if spearow doesn't turn up or is not very convincing?
Thu 13:01

I think it's a waste to lynch them as if they die in the night it tells us something
Thu 13:01

for me today we lynch dugtrio or rhyhorn
Moderator Thu 13:01

Venomoth votes to lynch Dugtrio
Venomoth Thu 13:02

vOv
Thu 13:02

happy to change my mind
Spearow Thu 13:12

Metapod is still Metapod
Thu 13:12

They went to dig Poliwrath
Sandslash Thu 13:12

who is top of your list?
Spearow Thu 13:13

Now thinking about it, I've never checked you.
Metapod Thu 13:22

Right well there goes my spearow's a zombie theory
Moderator Thu 13:22

Metapod votes to lynch Venomoth
Sandslash Thu 13:23

You gave your check before though, but I can't blame Spearow for this, it's a good check
Metapod Thu 13:23

Does the order matteR?
Sandslash Thu 13:25

everyone already knows what you did, since you gave your dig first :)
Metapod Thu 13:26

Obviously but I don't see how spearow saying where I went first would benefit
Sandslash Thu 13:26

It would verify him, since it would be info nobody else could get
Metapod Thu 13:27

You think people would of trusted my info?
Sandslash Thu 13:31

well - you're rather low on my list, only thing bothering me is that your knowledge about UD seems to fluctuate (what Dug pointed out yesterday)
Dugtrio Thu 13:31

harrow
Thu 13:31

no death means if there is a VD, we lynched the zombie
Metapod Thu 13:33

I don't think you read what dug said yesterday very well then sand
Thu 13:34

08:25:41 Metapod I'm not super familiar with UD setups, but people were saying only a couple of PRs and ghouls/wights? Wed 19:30 from d5 Wed 19:30 ::bangs head on desk::
Sandslash Thu 13:36

I see, I'll check again
Thu 13:36

(please stand by)
Rhyhorn Thu 13:39

Well I’ve been pretty vocal on my sus on Dugtrio (which tbh has increased because they have been a lot more active these past 2 days out of nowhere) so I could believe that they’re (one of) the UD
Moderator Thu 13:40

Rhyhorn votes to lynch Dugtrio
Rhyhorn Thu 13:40

So unless you can convince me not to lynch you
Thu 13:40

...my vote stays
Dugtrio Thu 13:40

i have nothing to provide
Thu 13:41

i tried digging through chat logs, but nothing other than last night's ramblings seemed to jump out
Metapod Thu 13:41

I'm more suspect of veno now that spearow has cleared me
Thu 13:41

As spearow said dug went nowhere night before
Dugtrio Thu 13:42

All i can say for my case is that I have always for the best interst of the village. if that's not good enough then I have nothing else to tell you
Thu 13:42

@Rhyhorn
Thu 13:42

:(
Moderator Thu 13:42

Dugtrio votes to lynch Venomoth
Rhyhorn Thu 13:43

But why have you suddenly been so much more active these past few days? I find that a little strange, and reason to believe you were necroed
Dugtrio Thu 13:43

i am WAY more active mon-fri
Thu 13:43

i work a crappy desk job
Thu 13:44

typical weekends i'm out doing things. this weekend I happened to be moving apartments
Thu 13:44

took friday off for the move
Thu 13:45

so thursday is when i agve you the warnign about my lapse in activity
Thu 13:45

(*w/e game day that was)
Thu 13:45

go check the game days vs a calendar and tell me i'm wrong
Rhyhorn Thu 13:50

You did give the warning for Friday and the Weekend, but you didn’t become active again until Wednesday iirc, but fair enough I guess
Thu 13:50

Real life shit happens
Dugtrio Thu 13:52

Like I have already stated repeatedly: I have no intel to provide and Vanillas are a great place to start lynching when there is no other information to act on. I spent a good chunk of time yesterday trying to find something for us to work with since I am convinced a VD is still in play but I came up empty after working myself in circles.
Thu 13:53

if i was really trying to deflect, why would I have ruined my own "metapod is bad" theory?
Thu 13:54

I am the one who found the message that derailed my own theory and announced it which would bring the focus back to myself.
Thu 13:54

So I am the final evil with suicidal tendencies this close to a victory?
Thu 13:57

I agree that my level of activity has increased; that is irrefutable. Like I said yesterday, being vanilla is pretty lame and with the move I wasn't really paying that close of attention. Then suddenly being in the final pool of survivors and evils looked like they may actually win, I started putting in a lot more effort. If you don't belive that, then lynch me b/c that's the truth and I have nothing else to give you.
Rhyhorn Thu 14:06

Okay, you actually make an excellent point there
Thu 14:06

Who would you suggest we lynch then? Veno?
Moderator Thu 14:06

Rhyhorn votes to lynch Venomoth
Dugtrio Thu 14:06

after yesterday, i have no damned idea
Rhyhorn Thu 14:07

Same tbh, it’s hard to find an evil right now
Sandslash Thu 14:07

Back.
Thu 14:07

If I had an obvious suspicion I'd vote earlier, but this has become very much a guessing game :(
Moderator Thu 14:08

Sandslash votes to lynch Venomoth
Rhyhorn Thu 14:08

If it doesn’t end tonight and Spearow is still alive tomorrow, they’re next imo
Thu 14:08

Yeah @Sandslash
Sandslash Thu 14:08

i have some trust in Dug due to him not wanting to vote Weezing
Thu 14:08

it would only make sense if they're both in one team
Thu 14:09

(which is worth a consideration though)
Venomoth Thu 14:44

okay well this id dumb
Thu 14:45

I'm starting to lose enthusiasm for this game
Thu 14:48

Spearow is just like "oh yeah the GD is legit"
Thu 14:49

and he is like "oh well I guess spearow is fine then!"
Thu 14:49

he had already given his check
Thu 14:49

all spearow has to do is say "yeah he did do that!"
Dugtrio Thu 14:53

tbh i'd be okay with switching to Spear
Thu 14:54

after d6 their activity fell off a cliff
Sandslash Thu 14:57

i can stare at me spread sheet at hours, from this point on, without finding anything. :/
Thu 14:58

Spearow is so quiet, we can't even judge if ever was a necro shift on him. It's a total gamble at this point
Thu 14:58

there*
Dugtrio Thu 14:59

we're voting veno b/c a zombie said he was village. we would be voting Spear b/c he went into 'lay low' mode without warning
Thu 14:59

(or is there something else about veno?)
Sandslash Thu 15:00

No - I think that's it
Dugtrio Thu 15:30

In the same way that i was super sus b/c of a sudden change in activity; Spear should be held to the same standard
Moderator Thu 15:30

Dugtrio votes to lynch Spearow
Rhyhorn Thu 16:06

Someone brought up the possibility of Spearow being Zombie, which I why I moved off
Venomoth Thu 16:07

I think we need to see if spearow dies tonight
Thu 16:07

and that wa sme
Thu 16:07

who brought that up, then y'all voted for me
Thu 16:07

for some reason
Thu 16:07

Dugtrio Thu 13:52 Like I have already stated repeatedly: I have no intel to provide and Vanillas are a great place to start lynching when there is no other information to act on
Thu 16:07

I disagree
Thu 16:08

With UD in the game could be anyone
Thu 16:10

So I dont think we vote for spearow
Thu 16:11

because we need to see if they die in the night
Thu 16:11

if they dont then we know we have VD and someone will have changed tomorrow
Thu 16:11

ignore that person and choose among the rest
Rhyhorn Thu 16:15

hu 16:10 So I dont think we vote for spearow Thu 16:11 because we need to see if they die in the night Thu 16:11 if they dont then we know we have VD and someone will have changed tomorrow | How would we know we have a VD if he doesn’t die?
Venomoth Thu 16:17

sorry i mean if they do die
Thu 16:18

if spearow dies we probably have a VD
Thu 16:20

but we need to not lynch them if we think they are a zombie
Thu 16:20

as it's pointless
Thu 18:28

So is this what we're doing? Killing me?
Thu 18:28

Cool
Thu 18:29

Good luck - I think it's probably Metapod or maybe Rhyn since nobody seems to be questioning him that much
Moderator Thu 18:32

Venomoth votes to lynch Metapod
Sandslash Thu 19:06

Ven - what makes you think it's meta?
Thu 19:12

of all the people we got left, Meta is the one to participate and give checks. what makes you distrust him?
Moderator Thu 19:59

Coldness creeps in as the daylight fades...
Lynched Thu 20:00

Venomoth was lynched by the village
Moderator Fri 07:59

The cockerel stirs...

Your role: Observer

The Village

Graveyard

Spoiler free day archives