ext-041 | online werewolf game replay

Replay

This is a log of a game of werewolves started on the 13th July 2016 on a 24 hour cycle (12h day, 12h night).
This is a spoiler free version, use the user button (top menu) to see who was alive at the time, and the calendar button or links below the chat to navigate through to different days.
Day 5
Moderator

The sun rises, the village is safe from the werewolves for now. Discuss who you think is a wolf, soon you will get a chance to lynch them
Jaime

Active during the last day
Hound

Active during the last day
Oberyn

Active during the last day
Tywin

Active during the last day
Littlefinger

Active during the last day
Cersei

Active during the last day
Arya

Active during the last day
Raven

Active during the last day
Moderator

Voting is now open to lynch the next werewolf
Oberyn Sat 10:21

what the hell
Cersei Sat 11:01

I have a theory to last night
Sat 11:03

I think the Hound really was the Shapeshifter. He was up for trial yesterday so clearly getting nervous about being lynched, and do decided it was time to change
Sat 11:05

I'm also certain Arya was innocent, even though she was up for trial too
Sat 11:07

Which means that the Protector was targeted and he managed to save himself
Sat 11:07

Because otherwise there would have been 2 deaths
Sat 11:08

Alternatively the Hound wasn't a wolf and got killed anyway...
Sat 11:13

I see both Tywin and Raven voted to lynch Hound but it didn't carry, which to me makes them suspicious
Littlefinger Sat 11:26

Cersei Sat 00:36 I'm going to stick with Littlefinger as my gut feeling, saying only the numbers of information that should exist, plus, suggesting i'm suspicious i guess is just another thing to dislike,
Sat 11:26

I never suspected you Cersei
Sat 11:26

not until now
Sat 11:30

Hound visited Arya last night
Sat 11:30

either we lost a special or Arya has been shifted into
Sat 11:31

I'm putting Arya on trial
Sat 11:32

just to see how she speaks now ;)
Moderator

Littlefinger votes to put Arya on trial
Littlefinger Sat 11:33

and please, if any of you have information please come out... we have little to lose now
Sat 11:35

I lost a game or two because the specials just kept info to themselves
Sat 11:35

until they died
Sat 11:35

until we all died :(
Tywin Sat 12:05

i voted for hound to get him to speak, as i said yesterday i left the vote on him to balance the votes. also, if your theory is correct, why would that make us suspicious? that makes no sense
Cersei Sat 12:06

it just seems to me that you might have wanted to get rid of Hound no matter what
Sat 12:06

so it's possible one of you could be a werewolf
Sat 12:07

but that being said, i know it's not you Tywin
Tywin Sat 12:07

cant speak for raven, but like i said, i wanted to keep the votes balanced and it was 2-2
Sat 12:10

also, there wouldnt be two deaths, the shapeshifter shifts into the wolves target
Cersei Sat 12:13

But the wolves would have targeted someone, and if the Shapeshifter become someone (and died) there would have been another death, unless it was prevented
Tywin Sat 12:14

thats not how the shapeshifter works, they become whoever the wolves targeted and they die, so you still only get one death
Oberyn Sat 12:30

wait, you're harlot littlefinger?
Cersei Sat 12:33

Oh is it? I didn't know that :x
Oberyn Sat 12:33

Hound visited Arya last night either we lost a special or Arya has been shifted into I'm putting Arya on trial
Sat 12:34

why don''t you speak from day 4 littlefinger
Tywin Sat 12:36

i dont believe you, i think you did know that and are trying to confuse the village. youve been acting suspiciously (as jaime pointed out) and you were really keen to protect arya this morning, before anyone else had mentioned her - then you proceeded to try and put suspicion on me and raven. that and that you following it up with a hint about knowing i am a villager makes me think you are the bloodhound
Moderator

Tywin votes to put Cersei on trial
Tywin Sat 12:36

if arya has indeed been shifted into, she is just a normal wolf - it is better for us to lynch the bloodhound now and prevent them from seeing any other roles
Sat 12:37

we can deal with the shifted wolf later, since they cant shift again
Sat 12:38

im also a little suspicious of oberyn, who is pretty lynch-happy - one vote on arya is enough for now until we hear from her
Sat 12:39

littlefinger, have you seen any other activity during the nights previous? you are likely to die tonight, so if you did it would be good to hear if you saw anything else (and it will help us determine if you are telling the truth)
Oberyn Sat 12:41

i don''t get the part where you say that i'm lynch-happy
Sat 12:42

i haven't voted for anyone yet
Tywin Sat 12:43

"Hound visited Arya last night either we lost a special or Arya has been shifted into I'm putting Arya on trial"
Sat 12:43

i think my messages stopped you
Oberyn Sat 12:43

sorry, i recited that from littlefinger
Tywin Sat 12:44

oh, then i take that back about today. however you do tend to vote early in the day and then not come back to change it or just go with the flow and change your vote to whatever seems most likely to be successful
Sat 12:45

its not a strong suspicion at this point, but if im right about cersei i expect to die in a day or two
Sat 12:45

so im airing them all now
Oberyn Sat 12:46

because i'm in a different timezone from you guys
Sat 12:46

i can't stay up to 4:00AM in the morning just to change my vote for arya (if you mean that vote)
Sat 12:47

i fell asleep last night, sorry btw, so i just wait until next day too see what happens
Tywin Sat 12:49

it just feels a little reckless to vote so early in the day and leave it there - the wolves could take advantage of that extra vote to lynch someone we dont want to die, especially at this later stage of the game
Oberyn Sat 12:49

yes cersei seems to know woofie stuff
Tywin Sat 12:49

again, its not a strong suspicion, just putting it out there
Sat 12:50

i also feel like cersei is trying to frame raven, which would make it unlikely he is a wolf
Sat 12:51

cersei has also completely ignored littlefinger's coming out as the harlot and pointing the finger at arya, yet replied to my messages about me
Sat 12:51

i want to hear from littlefinger about his other checks during the night and for cersei to defend herself at this point, i think its more important to get a likely bloodhound then a now-normal wolf
Oberyn Sat 12:52

i got a feeling that i can't trust anyone
Littlefinger Sat 12:53

as a matter of fact, you did ignore my coming out too Tywin
Tywin Sat 12:53

i didnt, i mentioned it several times and then asked you to tell us more
Sat 12:54

i wanted to tackle the accusation on me first, but i definitely wanted to talk about your check
Sat 12:55

can you tell us who else you have checked and if you saw any activity?
Littlefinger Sat 12:55

well then, too bad it's the only check with visits I have
Tywin Sat 12:55

that is a shame, can you tell us who you checked in what order?
Littlefinger Sat 12:55

first night I checked Mountain, not visited
Sat 12:56

the night later he was killed
Sat 12:56

I mean, night 2 Mountain was killed, I checked Oberyn, again not visited
Sat 12:56

night 3 it was Raven, not visited
Sat 12:57

I didn't want to come out day 4 because I had almost no useful info for you guys
Sat 12:58

but last night was worrying
Tywin Sat 12:59

it does sound like you saw a shapeshift, as the role action doesnt happen if the special is killed, so i dont think you would have seen a visit unless it was a shift
Oberyn Sat 13:02

hmmm, since no one admit anything else, i must temporarily agree with littlefinger
Littlefinger Sat 13:02

no, the role action still happens
Sat 13:02

if I was seer, I checked you last night and I was killed
Sat 13:03

I would still find out if you're a werewolf
Tywin Sat 13:03

the actions are done after the wolf kill, so you wouldnt
Sat 13:04

at least, with the special roles ive played and died as the action hasnt happened, could be some are done slightly differently
Littlefinger Sat 13:05

okay, I'm so confused now
Tywin Sat 13:05

if you are right, then it means there is a chance that there wasnt a shapeshift last night
Sat 13:06

and that it was a special role on the villager side that died
Littlefinger Sat 13:06

when I play it live, role action can still be done even if the special is killed, it's just that they will carry that secret with them to the graveyard
Tywin Sat 13:07

yeah, thats because the moderator has to do it in a certain order for the game to flow, this version doesnt have that constraint
Sat 13:07

i think its just the way the night phases are structured
Oberyn Sat 13:07

should i believe......
Moderator

Oberyn votes to put Cersei on trial
Littlefinger Sat 13:09

I... would not if I were you Oberyn
Tywin Sat 13:18

ok, checked with moderator, wolf kills happen last, which means there is a chance that hound was a special role on the villages side
Littlefinger Sat 13:19

I gotta go, I'll make this quick
Sat 13:20

order of suspicion: Arya (formerly Hound), Tywin
Sat 13:20

and Jaime
Tywin Sat 13:20

reasons?
Littlefinger Sat 13:21

Jaime is more like a hunch. he asked for people to speak up the first few days but then he didn't talk much himself, just enough to get by
Sat 13:23

Tywin for leveling my vote on Arya, who at that point he believed was clearly shifted into
Sat 13:24

any suggestion on who I should visit tonight?
Tywin Sat 13:24

ive already explained why, i think going after a potential bloodhound is more beneficial to the village, i will happily vote for arya tomorrow
Sat 13:24

unless someone else comes out i would say you decide
Sat 13:24

if someone else comes out as a role we can target them to give them some protection from the wolves, since you will know who visited them if they are killed
Sat 13:25

otherwise i think its best if the wolves dont know who you are targeting
Littlefinger Sat 13:27

okay then. til tomorrow, if I'm incredibly lucky enough to get through tonight
Tywin Sat 13:27

i would suggest the other harlot check littlefinger tonight if they are still alive
Sat 13:28

there is also a chance the protector may protect you, but we will see, i dont want them to give away who they are protecting
Sat 13:28

hopefully we shall see you tomorrow
Sat 13:28

hopefully arya and cersei will show up again at some point today too
Raven Sat 13:35

In case I die tonight or I don't get chance to carry on: surprise, I'm seer
Sat 13:36

I checked Hound and he was wolf, then he dies. So I'm guessing Arya is now a wolf
Sat 13:36

Cersei seems to be really accurate in what happened last night and is super suspicious so I guess she is also a wolf
Sat 13:36

Littlefinger, I checked Jaime and he is regular villager
Sat 13:36

I also checked Melisandre but she died the same night
Sat 13:37

If I could get some protection tonight I'll try and find another wolf, any recommendations?
Tywin Sat 13:48

what order did you check them in?
Raven Sat 13:51

Checked melisandre on the first night
Sat 13:51

checked hound on 2nd night - confirmed wolf
Sat 13:51

night 3 I forgot to check... woops, might have been at RL werewolf
Sat 13:51

night 4 checked jaime and he's villager
Sat 13:52

sad I can't provide any other info but I can at least confirm what littlefinger has said, and confirm his role as harlot
Sat 13:52

and it pretty much damns arya and cersei
Tywin Sat 13:53

ok, i would suggest arya or littlefinger - arya to see if she has been a shift target, or littlefinger to see if he is telling the truth about what he saw (mountain could have shifted into someone else and littlefinger is attempting to mislead us)
Sat 13:56

to me, it damns cersei, there is still some doubt about arya
Moderator

Jaime votes to put Cersei on trial
Jaime Sat 13:58

Cersei was exempt from Tywins suspicions until this mornings events. I would suggest checking him tonight. I am hoping both role claims are true, and not two wolves working together, as the wolves do have a bloodhound amongst them and the seer could have been found and replaced by now. I would say that Cersei is more than likely a wolf given her actions throughout the entire game though.
Cersei Sat 13:59

Littlefinger I'm diet I didn't notice you came out as harlot, I missed that, that puts to rest what suspicions io initially had of you
Tywin Sat 13:59

as i said yesterday, cersei has never been exempt from my suspicions, i voted to get hound to talk, which he did
Cersei Sat 13:59

I'm sorry* even
Tywin Sat 14:01

if you want to check me tonight you can, but i think it would be better to confirm whether arya is a shapeshift target, either by checking arya or littlefinger
Sat 14:01

its completely up to you which course of action you think is best
Sat 14:02

and i suggest you dont tell us what you choose
Cersei Sat 14:02

I think with all this damning going on of me I should come out
Sat 14:03

But I just saw that Raven saw Hound was a wolf
Sat 14:04

Why didn't you mention that before? (Unless you did and I missed that)
Tywin Sat 14:11

my guess is because of the shapeshifter, since raven isnt replying. what are you claiming to be, cersei?
Cersei Sat 14:14

I didn't want to do this earlier for obvious reasons, but I'm stating I'm the seer
Tywin Sat 14:15

who are you claiming to have seen in order?
Moderator

Raven votes to put Cersei on trial
Cersei Sat 14:19

Okay, from earliest to now:
Sat 14:19

Viserys - villager
Sat 14:20

Arya - villager
Sat 14:20

Jaime - villager
Sat 14:20

Tywin - villager
Tywin Sat 14:23

so you were suspicious of littlefinger but never bothered to check him?
Raven Sat 14:24

I am inclined to believe Littlefinger, so Arya is possibly a shifted wolf now, and cersei counter-claiming seer means she is definitely wolf. Since I checked Jaime and he is clear, this leaves Oberyn and Tywin
Cersei Sat 14:24

I felt I wanted to check others that the village was either suspicious of, or others that I was
Raven Sat 14:24

If Tywin is a wolf he is playing it well but I believe him, so I will check Oberyn tonight, if I can get some protection to confirm
Cersei Sat 14:25

Littlefinger was likely going to be there next check
Raven Sat 14:25

If not, you have the information you need
Tywin Sat 14:27

rubbish, cersei, you would have checked littlefinger the amount of times you pushed for the village to lynch him. oberyn, that makes sense to me, if littlefinger is telling the truth (if he isnt, we have to reevaluate everyone you have seen)
Sat 14:28

you dont even seem that bothered that raven claimed seer, you have said you wanted to come out because you were under suspicion, not because someone else came out as seer
Raven Sat 14:30

Since Cersei mentioned her Hound->Arya "hypothesis", Littlefinger questioned her about it, which gives him some credibility to me with the information I got, so I really hope he is telling the truth
Moderator

I've been asked for clarification on turn ordering. Village visits happen (checks, protects etc), wolf kills, SS shifts, harlots get final report
Cersei Sat 14:30

You're claiming I did not see Jaime on third night?
Tywin Sat 14:31

i also hope littlefinger isnt lying, but we will see, i guess
Cersei Sat 14:32

When did Raven come out as seer? I'm pretty sure I've read everything
Sat 14:32

I would have called him on it otherwise...
Raven Sat 14:32

we really don't need to question cersei anymore, we should focus on the others to find any faults in what has been said
Tywin Sat 14:33

it was the first thing he said today, immediately followed by his claims, which you mentioned already...
Sat 14:35

jaime, since you are the only one alive from ravens checks, id like to hear your opinions on who might be wolves - youve already mentioned me, who else do you suspect?
Sat 14:39

for me its cersei, arya/littlefinger (depending on whether littlefinger is telling the truth, i think he probably is) and then oberyn (much for the same reasons littlefinger suspects jaime, but raven has confirmed jaime as a villager, he would have been #4 on my list since he seems stuck on me for some reason)
Sat 14:45

we still need to hear from arya too
Cersei Sat 14:53

I'm interested Raven. You checked Melisandre, what was she, villager or wolf? And you didn't check anyone third night... That's not really a great help
Raven Sat 14:54

Melisandre was villager
Sat 14:54

and yeah sorry, life caught up on me
Sat 14:54

you're still a wolf tho, wolfie wolferson
Cersei Sat 14:55

Wolfie McWolfface you mean?
Sat 14:56

It does look like I'm going today doesn't it, 4 against me
Raven Sat 14:56

my apologies
Sat 14:56

and yee probably, good effort though!
Sat 14:57

now for the remainders
Cersei Sat 14:59

I feel I should have come out sooner
Sat 14:59

Since now you're in the way :(
Raven Sat 15:04

shhh shhh it's ok, it's over
Sat 15:04

see you in the next game
Sat 15:04

(I love you)
Cersei Sat 15:06

It's like in I Am Legend where Will Smith is cradling Sam as he slowly chokes him
Sat 15:06

:(
Raven Sat 15:08

oh god no that scene, stop :'C
Sat 15:08

my crys
Sat 15:08

</3
Arya Sat 15:27

Hello, I'm here.
Sat 15:28

Just read through everything. I have not been shapeshifted into, but I have no idea how to prove I wasn't, so?
Sat 15:28

(Also, sorry, I think I just interrupted an emotional moment.)
Jaime Sat 15:42

Little finger has peaked my suspicions, as I can't see why a harlot would choose to watch one of our suspects rather than someone who would be far more likely to be targetted by wolves in the night. I feel like he himself could be the shapeshifter. It may be good to check either Arya or him, since even if I am wrong, then Arya is the wolf of the two. Little finger could we hear reasons for your choices?
Littlefinger Sat 15:56

Shameful truth: because it's my first time being a harlot, I was confused how to put my ability to best use
Sat 15:57

first night I checked Mountain simply because he appeared to be the first one on my "the village" list
Sat 15:58

second night I checked Oberyn because he seemed like a logic player
Sat 15:58

wolves don't like logic players, I figure
Sat 15:59

then it didn't work out. also night 2 wolves killed Mountain who did talk much
Sat 16:00

so I thought maybe Raven
Sat 16:00

did not work out either
Sat 16:01

then I kind of suspected Cersei for the way she pushed for me and Arya
Sat 16:02

Arya defended herself well, so I thought maybe the wolves will go for a relatively quiet but strong player who has gained herself some trust
Sat 16:02

ding ding
Sat 16:04

oops, *Mountain who DIDN'T talk much
Sat 16:04

my bad
Arya Sat 16:52

Okay, let me get this straight. We have two claims for seer and one claim for harlot?
Cersei Sat 17:02

Seems like it
Sat 18:02

And preferably there are 4 hours for me to not die...
Sat 20:29

1.5 hours and it's pretty much inevitable...ah well
Sat 20:30

It was a good life
Moderator

Cersei votes to put Arya on trial
Cersei Sat 21:15

Vote with attempt to balance... Like it's going to help
Tywin Sat 21:18

you said arya definitely wasnt a wolf earlier, yet you just voted for her 'in an attempt to balance'
Cersei Sat 21:34

Yes, because it's currently 4 against me and the best chance to balance is to try to cancel it out by increasing on Arya
Sat 21:34

I have nothing against her
Sat 21:35

Atm someone could cancel vote on me by voting her and neither of us would go
Sat 21:35

Is what I'm suggesting
Sat 21:36

However saying that Littlefinger said she was shifted into, which is something to consider
Sat 21:47

13 minutes to go... Have a good night guys
Night 5
Moderator

Night falls. As the village sleeps the werewolves begin to stir and decide who to eat tonight...
Lynched

Cersei was lynched by the village
Killed

Raven was killed during the night

Your role: Observer

The Village

Graveyard

Spoiler free day archives