ext-041 | online werewolf game replay

Replay

This is a log of a game of werewolves started on the 13th July 2016 on a 24 hour cycle (12h day, 12h night).
This is a spoiler free version, use the user button (top menu) to see who was alive at the time, and the calendar button or links below the chat to navigate through to different days.
Day 3
Moderator

The sun rises, the village is safe from the werewolves for now. Discuss who you think is a wolf, soon you will get a chance to lynch them
Jaime

Active during the last day
Littlefinger

Active during the last day
Cersei

Active during the last day
Raven

Active during the last day
Tywin

Active during the last day
Oberyn

Active during the last day
Hound

Active during the last day
JonSnow

Active during the last day
Melisandre

Active during the last day
Arya

Active during the last day
Mountain

Active during the last day
Moderator

Voting is now open to lynch the next werewolf
Oberyn Thu 10:22

we lost mountain, hmmm
Thu 10:24

and Jon was lynched without any clue
Thu 10:25

i wonder if GD checked Jon yet
Melisandre Thu 11:22

Hmmmm indeed
Thu 11:23

Lots of activity over the last day, but very few people taking
Jaime Thu 11:35

There's not been much to go on, other than Jon coming out as a wolf as a joke,
Thu 11:36

And we need to be a wary, as the wolves have a shapeshiter and a bloodhound, each night we don't lynch, and reach day we don't discuss, we end hand as bit more of the game to the wolves
Littlefinger Thu 11:58

Any suspicions?
Cersei Thu 12:09

I was about to say it's been pretty quiet except for yesterday's banter
Thu 12:09

So there's not exactly much to go off
Thu 12:10

So was Jon joking? Or was he a wolf?
Littlefinger Thu 12:14

If he was joking, he should have defended himself better
Cersei Thu 12:41

So seems a good possibility he was a wolf?
Littlefinger Thu 12:43

maybe, I think
Thu 12:44

we should play it like it's the worst scenario though, that we lost an innocent
Oberyn Thu 12:46

i see tywin is active but don't a word
Thu 12:48

i think the longer the game goes, the stronger the seer, so need not to be worry as long as the seer's alive
Jaime Thu 13:07

It fair enough to say that we're ok as long as the seer id alive, but they may already be dead, they could have been targeted randomly already, the bloodhound could have foubd them on the first night, for all we know mountain was the shapeshiter he's shifted into thr seer already.
Thu 13:11

Having said that I think in that instance it would make sense had the seer come out today, it would allow a shift seer to try to gain trust early
Cersei Thu 13:20

But then supposing the seer has only seen innocents, which is really unlucky, then there not much point coming out
Thu 13:40

From what Oberyn says, Raven has also been quiet, and I suppose so too has Hound
Thu 13:40

Not that that really means much
Jaime Thu 14:53

That's true to be honest, I don't think the village has much chance of winning, especially if people aren't speaking, we will most likely have to rely on lynching quiet people. But catch 22, at that point we risk lynching specials who don't want to speak so that they don't make themselves targets
Cersei Thu 16:10

Well we've got just under 6 hours to decide, right?
Melisandre Thu 16:34

I think if a special doesn't speak to defend themselves then they're as good as useless
Thu 16:36

However, I'd say it's more likely that the wolves will be quiet but not silent players... they'll probably chip in here and there and maybe try to sway things, but will avoid drawing too much attention
Thu 16:36

The caveat to that is, of course, fake role claims
Cersei Thu 16:41

As far as that goes we've only had one, which was foolish since he ended up dead
Thu 16:42

So I can't see anyone else doing the same, though possibly claiming to just be a villager when they aren't is probably more likely
Thu 16:44

...Basically stating the obvious
Oberyn Thu 17:20

Damm i wish i was something
Thu 17:24

in my opinion, 1 harlot can come out if something special, or gd come out to tell if lynching Jon was worth it
Jaime Thu 17:30

If meliandre's point is to be taken into use, I felt that yesterday when Jon snow came out as a wolf. Arya kind of spoke up soon after but then went silent again afterwards, and zeeingbas how we have little else to go on I feel that's as good a place to start.. just because my suspicions were peaked by that...
Oberyn Thu 17:37

actually cersei, the mission of the seer is to gather information, not try to see who's the werewolf. He's the one who lead the village to victory
Thu 17:40

Arya only spoke one word "Yikes!" and then voted :v
Thu 17:44

Actually, it's kinda strange when she voted after littlefinger initiated
Thu 17:47

So we have "the silent" list: Arya, Raven, Hound, Tywin
Thu 18:20

maybe we should let it be until day 4 (if enforced lynch is not implemented)
Thu 18:20

i need to go to bed right now, sorry guys
Thu 18:26

if it's not implemented, maybe someone can balance the vote if she can defend herself
Moderator

Oberyn votes to put Arya on trial
Cersei Thu 18:27

Piqued*
Thu 18:27

But yes, I see where you're coming from
Thu 18:28

I didn't even realise Arya had spoken
Thu 18:29

Just looking back I see she put Jon on trial
Thu 18:33

The only other who put Jon on trial was Littlefinger
Thu 18:42

Both seemed pretty spontaneous, but I wouldn't necessarily say that puts them as wolves, especially if Jon was one
Jaime Thu 18:53

No it didn't necessarily make them wolves, but with no information and a need to win the game, sought suspicions are better than no suspicion and we have to file any information that we have otherwise we've lost anyway
Cersei Thu 18:58

Yeah that's true, I was going to suggest Littlefinger for trial, but Oberyn beat me to Arya
Thu 18:59

Based on just about the same pretences
Tywin Thu 19:42

sorry guys, been busy last couple of days
Thu 19:43

i think jonsnow was probably just being stupid and it backfired on him, but he had no role to defend himself (or didnt think he would be lynched)
Thu 19:43

or he just wanted to leave the game, which would suck if he was a special role
Thu 19:44

it was a little suspicious that people suddenly jumped on him when it looked like it was probably a joke
Thu 19:44

i think at this early stage it makes sense to start to question some of the quieter players
Thu 19:46

i notice that viserys hadnt said a word and mountain had only said a single sentence before he was killed too
Thu 19:47

id guess the wolves are targeting quiet players to try and get the village to lynch more active ones
Thu 19:47

though thats just a guess
Thu 19:49

looking through yesterday again, both arya and littlefinger only spoke up when they voted for jonsnow
Thu 19:49

could be a ploy to get the village to trust them ('we killed that wolf!') but could just be coincidence
Thu 19:50

i think hearing from either of them would be good at this stage
Thu 19:51

also, this isnt a forced lynch game, its not been implemented yet
Cersei Thu 20:17

Welcome father, it's good to hear your counsel
Arya Thu 20:18

Hello! Sorry I haven't been on much. I was using limited data yesterday and didn't have much time, so I quickly scrolled through what had happened with JonSnow, and voted him and said "Yikes!" because I figured he was probably a new player who didn't understand why. I didn't see anything else until now.
Thu 20:19

I have wifi now, so I'll be more active!
Cersei Thu 20:19

That leaves Littlefinger to speak up
Thu 20:20

Nice to have you join us again Arya
Tywin Thu 20:25

how come you didnt change your vote once he said it was a joke?
Arya Thu 21:14

I said, I had limited data and was checking in once. I commented on the situation, voted, and then logged off. I thought I might have been able to come back online, but I wasn't.
Tywin Thu 21:16

ok
Moderator

Tywin votes to put Littlefinger on trial
Tywin Thu 21:17

to balance it out
Moderator

Cersei votes to put Littlefinger on trial
Cersei Thu 21:24

I will match you, since he voted to oust Jon without much reason
Melisandre Thu 21:31

that's not how balancing works
Moderator

Melisandre votes to put Arya on trial
Cersei Thu 21:33

Well I was thinking of doing that since 19:00 or so, so I'm not balancing, in casting what I think is right
Thu 21:34

Okay we're balanced again
Thu 21:34

Anyone else want to chip in?
Thu 21:34

There's only 25 minutes to go...
Melisandre Thu 21:52

fwiw, I think we made the wrong decision lynching Jon last night
Tywin Thu 21:57

im hoping he didnt have a special role, think he would have told us if he did to avoid being lynched
Thu 21:57

unless we were unlucky and he couldnt come back in time
Thu 21:58

think we have to assume he was a normal villager for now though
Thu 21:58

need littlefinger to speak up tomorrow
Melisandre Thu 21:59

Unless he was both new and misunderstood his role and somehow thought he was actually a wolf
Thu 21:59

idk
Thu 21:59

:S
Tywin Thu 21:59

maybe, or he was a wolf and just messed up, but i think thats unlikely
Night 3
Moderator

Night falls. As the village sleeps the werewolves begin to stir and decide who to eat tonight...
Killed

Melisandre was killed during the night

Your role: Observer

The Village

Graveyard

Spoiler free day archives