Replay of ext-021

This was a 24 hour online game of werewolf / mafia started on 2016-05-05, where each player was given a new random identity from a selection of well known geeky characters

Play a game of online werewolf.

  • Day 1
  • Parappa Mon 12:50
    what's up, guys
  • MATT_DAMON Mon 12:51
    MATT DAMON!
  • Grumpy Mon 12:51
    why am i called grumpy
  •  
    this is so insulting
  • Sackboy Mon 13:38
    Hello there my friends. Nice that we've finally started this.
  • MATT_DAMON Mon 14:43
    Matt Damon?
  •  
    Ok, first day, nothing much to say. Just going to leave this, the wolves usually go for the active people, so I encourage the protector and huntsman to keep their heads down and protect someone who's said something today.
  • Sackboy Mon 19:08
    If they are active themselves
  • MATT_DAMON Mon 19:39
    We live in hope
  • Sackboy Mon 19:43
    There are a lot of posibilities, maybe even the wolves are not active, which we will see next day
  • Night 1
  • Moderator
    Night falls. As the village sleeps the werewolves begin to stir and decide who to eat tonight...
  • Death
    MATT_DAMON was killed during the night.
  • Day 2
  • Moderator
    The sun rises, the village is safe from the werewolves for now. Discuss who you think is a wolf, soon you will get a chance to lynch them
  • Skywalker Tue 09:17
    sorry, my first game, I don't know how it works @.@
  • Hamster Tue 10:12
    do you think EpicFetch is a wolf?
  • Sackboy Tue 10:33
    Hmm... wait guys, this is strange... considering the amount of active people, we could either have 3, 2 or just one wolf active... untill we are sure who they are, we shouldn't vote for someone to day at random...
  •  
    if you guys agree?
  •  
    Skywalker, during the day, we all have to discuss who the wolves are and then vote for those people together, and they will end up dead
  •  
    But the tricky part is, we don't know who we decidec to kill during the day, only a gravedigger can do that
  •  
    and if we make a mistake, we might and up killing one of us :/ Which is highly posible, since there are more 8 people in the villagers teamn and only 3 on the wolves team
  • Hamster Tue 11:23
    I say hang someone
  • Sackboy Tue 11:28
    That's something a wolf would say...
  •  
    I say hang someone, but first be sure he is a wolf
  • Hamster Tue 11:34
    we can never be sure
  • Sackboy Tue 11:55
    Oh, but that's where you're wrong... with a good deduction, we can be sure... the only thing is, it is to early to start any deduction
  • Pikachu Tue 12:06
    Hey im a gravedigger. So if you want me to check for you guys go ahead
  •  
    But i also think its a little early
  • Sackboy Tue 12:38
    Pikachu, you shouldn't have said that! Now the wolves are gonna kill you first since you told them who you are!
  • Yoda Tue 12:46
    Hi this is my first time playing this game but I have watched this game on a Chinese game show before.
  • Pikachu Tue 12:54
    Yeah i know its risky to reveal your role but its not like im a seer or a huntsman. A smart wolf would kill at random because he'd have greater odds of killing a seer
  • Yoda Tue 12:56
    Oh if everyone is here, we are actually supposed to "reveal" all of our roles. Sadly most people appears to be inactive so that does not work...
  •  
    Is the number of wolves fixed every game?
  • Pikachu Tue 13:03
    I know its usually 3. Its definetly 33 here
  •  
    3*
  • Yoda Tue 13:06
    Oh okay, on the game show I watched there could be 3 or 4. So 1 seer, 1 protector, 1 huntsman, 1 grave digger, 1 or 2 lycans, 3 or 4 villagers. For werewolves there are 1 bloodhound, 1 shapeshifter and 1 normal werewolf?
  •  
    How are we going to deduct who the werewolves are when most people are inactive? Anyways I will start revealing myself. I am no one special, just a villager who is trying to get a sense of what is going on.
  • EpicFetch Tue 13:35
    y vote for me?
  •  
    ??
  • Parappa Tue 13:38
    it's his first game, he doesn't know how it works
  • EpicFetch Tue 13:47
    yoda, beat some sense into this guy
  • Pikachu Tue 14:57
    I feel like skywalker is full of shit about this being his first game. He was too clumsy with the voting, even for someone playing their first game
  • EpicFetch Tue 16:29
    .....then winds up on me
  • Grumpy Tue 17:03
    yohoho
  •  
    merry christmas
  •  
    wow you guys are sooo iactive
  •  
    inactive
  • Yoda Tue 17:16
    Hello Grumpy
  • Grumpy Tue 17:16
    heyy
  •  
    games like this should be made in a lobby of <60 minutes
  • Yoda Tue 17:18
    Yeah pretty awkward...
  •  
    Do you guys have previous experiences? How did the game go in previous games?
  • Grumpy Tue 17:32
    you can check previous game easily
  •  
    because the game actually based on real time, it'll take place in a very long time
  •  
    so during the gap time ( where nothing happens - the waiting time ) people find it boring and leave and then forget and never coming back again
  • Yoda Tue 17:34
    Ah ty
  • Grumpy Tue 17:34
    some of them might forget to log in to check
  •  
    and they might never check again
  • EpicFetch Tue 17:38
    well i read it said 24 hour game when i signed up
  •  
    maybe discuss game?
  •  
    main suspicion: skywalker
  • Grumpy Tue 17:44
    it's only the first day man
  • EpicFetch Tue 17:44
    what else then?
  • Grumpy Tue 17:44
    sleep
  •  
    cuz we haven't got any clue
  •  
    of who got the roles
  • EpicFetch Tue 17:45
    we might not 2morrow
  • Pikachu Tue 17:45
    Well i revealed my role
  •  
    And someone else said they were a villager. I think yoda
  • Yoda Tue 17:46
    Yeah Pikachu claims to be Gravedigger, and I claim to be Villager
  • Grumpy Tue 17:46
    the moderator should get some information of the numbers
  • EpicFetch Tue 17:46
    gravedigger I trust more, because if he lies, someone can call him on it
  •  
    start email had role numbers
  • Grumpy Tue 17:47
    like we got 11 ( max is 12) and we don't know how many villagers,wolf,huntsmant,seer,etc in the game
  •  
    this should be updated
  • EpicFetch Tue 17:47
    3 wolf, 1 seer, 1 huntsman, 1 protector, 1 gravedigger
  •  
    email said so
  • Pikachu Tue 17:47
    Thats still not enough to go on i think. Im suspicious of skywalker but i wont act on it
  • Yoda Tue 17:48
    Same
  • Grumpy Tue 17:48
    so we got 4 villager
  •  
    :-?
  •  
    those inactive players are just buzzing me off
  •  
    :T
  •  
    wow i'm sure is grumpy
  • Pikachu Tue 17:49
    There's always alot of inactive
  •  
    I once played a game with only one other active
  • Grumpy Tue 17:50
    heck
  • EpicFetch Tue 17:50
    that sucks
  • Grumpy Tue 17:50
    like if they registered
  •  
    they should at least check
  • Pikachu Tue 17:51
    There's only 4 people who are 100% inactive. So im happy with this
  • Grumpy Tue 17:51
    so
  •  
    pikachu
  •  
    you dig anything yet?
  • Pikachu Tue 17:51
    Yeah?
  • Grumpy Tue 17:51
    or 2nd night
  •  
    matt was dead
  • Pikachu Tue 17:52
    Cant on the first night. No dead people yet
  •  
    I'll dig matt tonight
  • Grumpy Tue 17:52
    yeah i forgot
  •  
    so boringggggggggggggggggggg
  • EpicFetch Tue 17:53
    u r grumpy =)
  • Grumpy Tue 17:53
    anyone else activeeeeeeee
  • EpicFetch Tue 17:54
    Parappa, Hamster, Skywalker say very little
  • Grumpy Tue 17:54
    nah i'm just gonna lynched the inactive anyway :T
  • Pikachu Tue 17:54
    Skywalker and parappa were active tho
  • Grumpy Tue 17:55
    sabretooth? sackboy?
  • Skywalker Tue 17:55
    sorry
  • Pikachu Tue 17:55
    Sackboy was active
  • Skywalker Tue 17:55
    I just woke up
  • EpicFetch Tue 17:55
    late night eatign VILLAGERS????
  • Skywalker Tue 17:55
    It was night when the day starts here
  • Grumpy Tue 17:56
    so skywalker is new
  • Skywalker Tue 17:56
    I'm sorry for voting you epicfetch
  • EpicFetch Tue 17:56
    "@Skywalker and parappa were active tho" -- what u mean???
  • Pikachu Tue 17:56
    They were active earlier
  • Grumpy Tue 17:56
    yeah
  •  
    now we got more company
  •  
    yayyyyyyyy
  • Skywalker Tue 17:56
    I just don't know how this game works
  • Grumpy Tue 17:56
    me excited
  • Skywalker Tue 17:57
    do we have to vote, or we can make a choice by not voting any?
  • Grumpy Tue 17:57
    skywalker: if you're one of the villager or - on human team, use clue to vote ( to kill ) the werewolf
  • Pikachu Tue 17:57
    You dont have to vote
  • Grumpy Tue 17:57
    if you suspect anyone
  •  
    vote
  • Skywalker Tue 17:58
    ok tks
  • Grumpy Tue 17:58
    one who got the major votes, eliminated
  •  
    so you make take back your vote since it's the first day
  •  
    * may *
  • Pikachu Tue 17:58
    Right now we have a tie so nobody will die
  • Skywalker Tue 17:58
    oh tks god
  •  
    :(
  • Grumpy Tue 17:59
    so
  •  
    skywalker
  • Pikachu Tue 17:59
    I dont think you can undo a vote, only change it
  • Grumpy Tue 17:59
    what are you
  • Skywalker Tue 17:59
    what should we do now?
  •  
    I have no idea
  • Grumpy Tue 17:59
    fine then
  • Pikachu Tue 17:59
    You have no idea? Im not buying any of this
  • Grumpy Tue 18:00
    maybe he doesn't want to reveal his role
  • Pikachu Tue 18:00
    Then he would just say so
  • Skywalker Tue 18:00
    I'm villagers man
  • Grumpy Tue 18:00
    well there are ways to say that
  •  
    haha
  • Skywalker Tue 18:00
    I know
  •  
    everybody says that
  •  
    so the question u asked, seem to be hard to prove now
  •  
    I need to read, to catch up u guys
  • Pikachu Tue 18:02
    There's no way to prove anything. Unless you catch someone in a lie
  • Skywalker Tue 18:02
    wait for me
  • Grumpy Tue 18:03
    so i checked from the start
  •  
    yoda claim villeger
  •  
    pikachu claim grave digger
  •  
    sky claims villager
  •  
    oh that 3 villagers
  • Pikachu Tue 18:04
    Assuming we arent lying
  • Grumpy Tue 18:04
    temporarily
  • Skywalker Tue 18:05
    okay
  •  
    got all the info
  •  
    epic seemed to be mad at me
  •  
    @.@
  • Grumpy Tue 18:06
    don't worry
  •  
    that was just a misunderstanding
  •  
    newbies get it
  • Skywalker Tue 18:07
    that's upset because someone sign up for the game and haven't showed up in the game
  •  
    @.@
  •  
    I read ext 20 to understand more how to play
  •  
    there are also many inactive players
  • Grumpy Tue 18:08
    have you ever play this game face - to - face
  • Skywalker Tue 18:08
    sadly, the active player used to be kill first
  •  
    yes, 2 times
  •  
    3 days ago
  • Grumpy Tue 18:09
    yeah you may notice that
  • Skywalker Tue 18:09
    I played with my friends and I played the resistance, too
  •  
    this game is more interesting
  • Grumpy Tue 18:09
    people'll show their roles in the 2nd or 3rd night
  •  
    or when things has gone madness
  • Skywalker Tue 18:09
    oh
  • Grumpy Tue 18:09
    like 3 people dies in a row in one night x_x
  • Skywalker Tue 18:10
    how it possibles?
  •  
    one is killed by wolf, one is lynched and how's about one left?
  • Grumpy Tue 18:11
    wolf kills the witch, witch poisoned the huntsman, huntsman shot at a random villager
  •  
    nah that's just part of the real game
  •  
    it's different up here
  •  
    oh we don't have any witch
  •  
    so sad
  •  
    geez, it's late already
  •  
    imma sleep instead
  • Skywalker Tue 18:15
    oh
  •  
    it's 10 am here
  • Grumpy Tue 18:15
    so tired :T
  • Skywalker Tue 18:15
    okay
  •  
    good night
  • Grumpy Tue 18:15
    00:AM here
  • Skywalker Tue 18:15
    tks for helping me a lot
  •  
    hope tmr we all can talk
  •  
    I'm going to have breakfast
  • EpicFetch Tue 19:13
    i think we shud lynch
  •  
    if we do the gravedigger is more powerful
  •  
    and pikachu says his gravedigger - so we have one
  •  
    i dont see why u wud lie abt that
  • Skywalker Tue 19:15
    should we lynch one of inactive players?
  •  
    srr epic
  •  
    I should change my vote
  •  
    to some1 inactive , is that okay?
  • EpicFetch Tue 19:16
    who?
  • Skywalker Tue 19:17
    some1 inactive, like nazgul or hamster?
  • EpicFetch Tue 19:17
    i think someone active but quiet better
  •  
    they lying low
  • Skywalker Tue 19:17
    I couldn't re-do my action
  •  
    @.@
  •  
    my bad
  • Pikachu Tue 19:28
    If you guys are lynching i'll definetley check for you
  •  
    But im not gonna vote
  • EpicFetch Tue 19:28
    what wud u say better?
  •  
    active + quiet
  •  
    or inactive?
  • Skywalker Tue 19:29
    I would like to choose inactive
  •  
    let active + quiet players explain later
  •  
    in my case, it was 12 p.m. when the day started here
  •  
    GMT -8
  • EpicFetch Tue 19:30
    everyone had 12 hours tho
  •  
    so Parappa, Hamster or Sackboy?
  • Skywalker Tue 19:33
    I have a question
  •  
    the vote is one for me, one for Nazgul
  •  
    what happens next?
  •  
    the system choose randomly a person to lynch or nothing happens
  • EpicFetch Tue 19:36
    i dont no
  •  
    i still think lynching inactive better
  •  
    i mean quiet
  • Nazgul Tue 20:32
    Hi im sorry this is my 1st game
  •  
    Id like to say that active + quiet is more worth to lynch
  •  
    What time is it in gmt?
  • EpicFetch Tue 20:40
    Talk about 11th hour.
  •  
    Read up - tell me your thoughts
  •  
    Nazgul, I have spared you, but say something and/or vote for Tony, he is silent all day.
  • Night 2
  • Moderator
    Night falls. As the village sleeps the werewolves begin to stir and decide who to eat tonight...
  • Death
    Tony was lynched by the village.
  •  
    Grumpy was killed during the night.
  • Day 3
  • Moderator
    The sun rises, the village is safe from the werewolves for now. Discuss who you think is a wolf, soon you will get a chance to lynch them
  • Sackboy Wed 09:10
    Guys!!!! I am so sorry that I wasn't there yesterday in the later hours of the day phase... I really had some unexpected errands to fulfill so I wasn't thare in second half of the day phase
  •  
    Rest in Peace Grumpy.... He who was so eager to play... it is said that he died among the first few...
  •  
    But oh well... those wolf bastards decided to kill him because they saw he had a good deduction skill! We will miss him...
  • Pikachu Wed 09:16
    Shiy ok we lost grumpy. Im not happy about that. And tony, who we lynched, was a villager. Thats not good
  • Sackboy Wed 09:20
    That is why I didn't want to vote for anyone to lynch... why should we kill someone during the day if we are not sure that it's a wolf... if we do that, we only make things easier for them...
  •  
    Also, I have a question... I don't know if this is a bug or something, but I don't have the option to vote today O.o
  •  
    Oh, so I guess voting opens after one hour into a day phase, that's why my voting options were not there this morning
  • Pikachu Wed 10:26
    Sackboy i agree and thats why i withheld my vote
  •  
    But now we have to do something because we're down 3 villagers
  • EpicFetch Wed 10:34
    we were probably down Tony regardless, we have a little more information.
  •  
    i will read what grumpy said
  •  
    any suspcions etc
  • Skywalker Wed 11:27
    Guys, we have 9 active players
  •  
    and in 9 players, at least 1 wolf right?
  •  
    so Pikachu, did u know what's the role of matt_damon?
  •  
    I hope he was a villager, so we can be sure that a seer and a protector and a huntsman are alive
  •  
    it gives us more chances
  •  
    it's 4 a.m. in my place now. I catch up the information later.
  • Pikachu Wed 11:33
    No i checked tony. He was a villager
  •  
    Im not gonna check matt damon. It would be a waste of time
  • EpicFetch Wed 11:37
    we know he wasn't a wolf
  • Sackboy Wed 11:38
    Well, we know that among us there is at least one wolf, that's for sure... Matt_Damon and Grumpy were probabbly villagers, otherwise the wolves wouldn't kill them... also, it goes to their advantage if one of them was a seer, protector or huntsman (since they can't be gravedigger, that role is claimed by Pikachu)
  •  
    And since all of us are active, that means that wolf (or wolves) are with us righ now, but they sure are good at hiding, because for now, noone is suspicious to me
  •  
    But I will read the entire conversation once more, because there might be something that someone said but we didn't see it at first!
  •  
    And I suggest you guys to do the same
  • EpicFetch Wed 12:26
    I say Parappa, Hamster or Nazgul
  • Parappa Wed 14:08
    hey, i'm not a wolf, I'm a villager
  •  
    From my perspective, I'm not a wolf, Pikachu sure isn't a wolf, but I really don't know about anything else
  • EpicFetch Wed 14:17
    you must have suspicions
  • Sackboy Wed 14:19
    Pretty suspicious to me that Nazgul joined yesterday just by the end of day when you woted for him EpicFetch
  •  
    Voted *
  • EpicFetch Wed 14:20
    same could be said now for Parappa
  • Sackboy Wed 14:21
    I mean, isn't that a bit suspicious? He was quiet all the time, but right after you voted for him, he joined and voted for you as well
  •  
    Aye, that is true... But again, who knows, maybe I am wrong to suspect someone based on that
  • EpicFetch Wed 14:25
    i want 2 hear more frm Parappa
  • Sackboy Wed 14:52
    Yup, he should say more
  • Nazgul Wed 14:56
    Hello guys
  • Sackboy Wed 14:56
    Hello to you as well, and welcome
  • Nazgul Wed 14:57
    It was pretty suspicious that i just joined the conv right just before the night ended right?
  •  
    Hello sackboy
  • EpicFetch Wed 14:58
    very, both you and Parappa
  • Sackboy Wed 14:58
    Well, to me, it was, but don't take that as an accusation though, suspecting someone and accusing someone is not the same thing
  • Nazgul Wed 14:59
    Its getting more suspicious that i joined after getting voted the most
  • Sackboy Wed 14:59
    Yes, that it does, because as soon as EpicFetch voted for you, you appeared
  • Nazgul Wed 15:01
    But id like to say that we have 9 peeps active
  • Sackboy Wed 15:01
    And?
  • Nazgul Wed 15:01
    Some of them might be a wolf
  •  
    Maybe one, or more
  • Sackboy Wed 15:02
    Why did you say "might be" at least one of them must be a wolf
  •  
    Since people were killed two nights straight
  • Nazgul Wed 15:03
    What shud ive said then?
  •  
    Lol
  • Sackboy Wed 15:04
    Well, you should've said "must be", like I did. But still, I understand what you mean
  • Nazgul Wed 15:04
    And if i were to be revealed, i wouldnt come up all of a sudden and cover my ass by saying "hell no im a villager" or such tjng
  •  
    *thing
  • Sackboy Wed 15:06
    People who don't say much are not helpfull at all, whatever their role is, they don't help much (and that is for both sides)
  • Nazgul Wed 15:07
    Yap
  • Sackboy Wed 15:07
    I know that beinf a seer, protector or huntsman is an important thing, so those people tend to stay quiet because they fear of being killed
  •  
    But that usually puts those people as a target first, both to wolves and villagers, because villagers either think that they are wolves in hiding, or inactive
  •  
    And wolves on the orher hand just know that those persons might be one of the special roles
  •  
    And who knows, maybe I am one of those special roles, maybe I'm not
  •  
    Being *
  • EpicFetch Wed 15:12
    actually, the wolves seem 2 b going 4 any1 that speaks
  •  
    the most talkative
  • Sackboy Wed 15:15
    Which means that you or I will be their next target :D That ain't good maan! Let's lay low!
  •  
    Just kiding... if we don't talk, how can we ever discover who is who
  •  
    Anyways, I don't think they necessarilly go for the most talkative, because if they were smarter they would pick their targets better
  •  
    Because, if they keep killing those that talk to much, they will remain against those that don't say anything and will be overvoted durin the day and lynched
  • EpicFetch Wed 15:18
    that makes no sense
  • Sackboy Wed 15:19
    How?
  •  
    Just think of it... if you were a wolf, and active... and end up killing all the "talkers"... those "silent birds" would have an easier job of lynching a wolf, since they know who was active, and if they know the wolves killed all other people
  •  
    The choices for deduction are easier that way... also, a seer has low chance of running into a wolf during the night early on, since there are more players, and chances are lower
  •  
    But if they remain silent and not get killed, the choices for them will get narrow, therefore the chance for a person they check to be a wolf are higher
  • EpicFetch Wed 15:29
    so a village of silent ppl will suddenly get their shit 2gether when there r only noisy wolves left??
  • Sackboy Wed 15:36
    Well yes, if by any chance, the active players menage to kill one of the wolves and one of those silent players is a seer
  •  
    But that's only in an ideal situation, but chances for that are not high
  • Parappa Wed 15:41
    i think we should focus more on the silent ones
  •  
    I suspect wolves are just hiding and never said a word
  • EpicFetch Wed 15:44
    yh, so i want u 2 say more
  • Parappa Wed 15:46
    Suppose wolves just get out at night and do the killing, leaving us active good people suspecting each other, they would feel very pleased
  •  
    because they would never be within our consideration, no one would bother put them on trial
  •  
    It's just my hypothesis, though
  •  
    I suspect there's at least one silent wolf out there
  • EpicFetch Wed 15:55
    my only confusion is y they didnt go 4 Pikachu
  • Parappa Wed 15:57
    Maybe they don't bother read our conversations above and pick a random good guy
  •  
    Or a random active good guy
  •  
    I really want those silent ones to come back and join us, though
  •  
    I say hamster could be a silent wolf, he never talks but the moderator says he is active during the last day, I wonder why
  • Sackboy Wed 16:11
    I think thw wolves don't want to kill Pikachu even though he is a grave digger, because he can say if they kill a seer or other important role
  •  
    That is just a guess though, I don't know for sure
  •  
    Okay guys, I will have to go now, but I will be back in 2 and a half hours
  •  
    So I'll still have 2 more hours to catch up on the conversation and I am sure you will keep discussing this.
  • Yoda Wed 17:24
    Hello I am back, and this is terrible.
  •  
    Matt Damon is likely a good guy, Tony is a good guy, Grumpy is likely a good guy. That leaves 9 of us, 6 good and 3 bad
  •  
    Out of 9 of us, Sabretooth is inactive and Hamster is somewhat inactive.
  •  
    I am a villager, Pikachu is a gravedigger. No one else has claimed to be a gravedigger so Pikachu can be trusted.
  •  
    Epicfetch's role: Undeclared, Sackboy: undeclared Nazgul: undeclared Hamster: Undeclared Parappa: Undeclared Skywalker: Undeclared
  •  
    Okay just read top and Parappa claims to be a villager, and Pikachu claims that Tony is a villager so there is only 1 villager left?
  •  
    Also what is the use of a seer, protector, huntsman when none of them speaks up? There is no seer examining the villagers and inform the rest of the village.
  •  
    There is no protector who tells us who they protected last night.
  •  
    Epicfetch puts Parappa on trial, Parappa puts Hamster on trial
  •  
    Hamster yesterday said "Let's hang someone." Which was bizarre.
  •  
    Matt_Damon is still suspicious of being a wolf. He is the founder of this game after I did some research.
  •  
    He asked protectors and huntsman to protect the most active player in the game, and who was the most active player? Matt_Damon himself
  •  
    There is a chance that Matt_Damon is the wolf who tried to kill himself because he was expecting Protectors and Huntsman to protect himself
  •  
    Highly unlikely but as a villager I am just going to guess anything. Though Matt_Damon is still 80% good guy.
  •  
    Okay Skywalker also claimed to be a villager as I read Day 2 chat log
  •  
    Epicfetch and Skywalker were the two who lynched Tony.
  •  
    Grumpy said and did almost nothing except complaining about how boring the game is when most people are inactive.
  •  
    Skywalker, Pikachu, and me were the ones who talked to Grumpy
  • Skywalker Wed 18:16
    Hey man, because during the day 2, I vote accidentally, and I can't take it back
  •  
    so end of the day, I have to vote for some1
  •  
    I didn't mean that
  •  
    I think in this way guys
  • Yoda Wed 18:17
    Yeah I am just analyzing the situation right now.
  • Skywalker Wed 18:17
    If the wolf kill someone who was talked about, they want us to suspect people who talk about this guy
  •  
    so that, we doubt each other
  • Yoda Wed 18:19
    Things can be viewed in many different ways and I am not drawing conclusions here.
  • Skywalker Wed 18:19
    yes, let's put some analysis here
  •  
    sabretooth is inactive right?
  • Yoda Wed 18:20
    The killing of Grumpy can be viewed as "Skywalker didn't like how Grumpy asked him for his role so Skywalker wanted rest of the wolves to kill him" or "Killing Grumpy so that we will suspect Skywalker"
  •  
    Yeah Sabretooth is inactive
  • Skywalker Wed 18:21
    tony was a villager
  •  
    you claimed as a villager right
  •  
    parappa also claimed as a villager
  •  
    and I claimed as a villager
  •  
    I make one of 4 people here are a liar
  • Yoda Wed 18:23
    How many villagers are there though?
  •  
    It is so unclear in the instructions
  • Skywalker Wed 18:23
    oh
  •  
    I didn't get the email, or I deleted it accidentally
  •  
    my bad
  • Yoda Wed 18:24
    3 wolves, 4 specials
  •  
    Any lycans? Idk...
  •  
    So if there is 1 lycan, then 4 villagers
  •  
    2 lycans, 3 villagers
  • Skywalker Wed 18:24
    so I guess 3 werewolves, 1 seer, 1 huntsman, 1 protector, 1 grave digger --> 5 villagers?
  • Yoda Wed 18:24
    My class is about to start -_- This is all I can do.
  • Skywalker Wed 18:25
    did u get the email that inform us how many roles are
  •  
    ok man
  •  
    you did help a lot
  • Sackboy Wed 19:33
    Yup, someone has to be liar.... there can't be so many villagers.... (even if only Tony was a villager, and Matt_Damon and Grumpy were something else) that means one villager dead, Yoda, Skywalker, EpicFetch, Parappa and myself also claiming to be villagers, that means the math is not right...
  • Skywalker Wed 19:37
    There is some roles that it's better to not reveal such as the seer or the protector. So if one of us is a liar, but keeping the special role, it's not bad at all
  •  
    this game is so confusing
  • Sackboy Wed 19:38
    Okay, let us go for the worst posible scenario.... let's say that all 3 wolves are still alive, and posibly active... that would mean, 3 wolves, 1 gravedigger, and five more people, among which, there could be 4 villagers and one more special role, or any other combo... like 3 villagers and 2 roles, or 2 villagers and 3 roles
  • Pikachu Wed 19:38
    I dont think its 1 of you
  •  
    I think there may be multiple wolves active
  • Skywalker Wed 19:38
    I cannot imagine how the villagers can win @.@
  • Pikachu Wed 19:38
    Im thinking maybe the seer is hamster or sabretooth
  •  
    Dont you mean "how we can win"?
  • Sackboy Wed 19:39
    And if the last thing I said is somehow true, then the wolves just have to pick the right two persons and win.... but that makes it harder, because they have 2 in 6 chances to get it right
  • Skywalker Wed 19:39
    take it easy man
  • Pikachu Wed 19:40
    No way. I was suspicious of you for long enough
  • Skywalker Wed 19:40
    I mean that I cannot imagine in which situation we can win
  • Pikachu Wed 19:40
    And now you slipped up
  •  
    Somebody else vote skywalker. I want him dead
  • Skywalker Wed 19:40
    such as the game I play the resistance, at the last round
  •  
    just one 1 vote is enough to win
  •  
    not like the 4th round, it requires 2 votes to win
  • Sackboy Wed 19:41
    Okay guys! wait.... I am not jumping to his defense, but.... he may just have been objective about the situation, not speking as either of the teams, but looking from the neutral perspective?
  • Skywalker Wed 19:41
    I don't judge you
  • Pikachu Wed 19:41
    He was acting weird the first round too
  • Skywalker Wed 19:41
    I'm vietnamese, so maybe I don't use English fluently
  • Pikachu Wed 19:42
    Someone has to die
  • Skywalker Wed 19:42
    It causes some mistakes
  • Pikachu Wed 19:42
    Bad excuse. You know the difference between villagers and we
  • Skywalker Wed 19:42
    Think this way, if I were a wolf, why should I make such easy mistake like this
  • Pikachu Wed 19:42
    Now im definetly killing you
  •  
    Because you slipped up
  • Skywalker Wed 19:43
    well it's your assumption
  • Pikachu Wed 19:43
    And i'll prove myself right when i dig your grave after we lynch you
  • Skywalker Wed 19:44
    when I talked about this, I stand for the third view position, not me or anything else man
  • Pikachu Wed 19:45
    I know what you meant, im talking about how you said it
  • Sackboy Wed 19:45
    Pikachu, one question? You are not obligated to help me, but, I just want to see if my theory is correct... we know who Tony was, but can you also check Grumpy and Matt_Damon (one by one), just to make sure we didn't lose a seer or maybe some other role?
  • Pikachu Wed 19:45
    I can only check once per night
  • Sackboy Wed 19:45
    Because, to be honest, maybe they didn't speak up because they are allready dead?
  • Pikachu Wed 19:46
    And i'd rather check people we lynch so we can know if we made a mistake
  •  
    Now can you help me by voting for skywalker?
  •  
    We cant afford a night without lynching at this point
  • Skywalker Wed 19:47
    lol, what makes you suspect me more
  • Sackboy Wed 19:47
    Yes, I know it's one per night... Yeah, I know what you mean, but I am really curious about why special roles are quiet so far, because, I know shit! As a villager, I can just go around and make asumptions like you do
  • Skywalker Wed 19:47
    you can check that I haven't played any game here
  •  
    that makes some of my unknown actions
  •  
    my ID is chungpham
  •  
    first, the first day I voted, I don't know that
  • Pikachu Wed 19:48
    I cant find a way to search you
  • Sackboy Wed 19:48
    We have one more hour to decide, I hope others will join in, because I don't want us to act alone, we need to work as a team
  • Skywalker Wed 19:48
    because when I played face to face, I have to vote
  • Pikachu Wed 19:49
    Sackboy i need you to vote for him
  •  
    You're the only other one here, its up to you
  • Skywalker Wed 19:49
    but here, I can make a choice by giving a vote or not
  • Pikachu Wed 19:49
    Yeah go epicfetch!!!
  • EpicFetch Wed 19:50
    I think Pikachu is a good as verified
  • Skywalker Wed 19:50
    lol
  •  
    you are making mistake
  • EpicFetch Wed 19:50
    came out day1 as gravedigger
  •  
    no1 contested
  •  
    i prefer to follow his hunches/reasoning
  • Pikachu Wed 19:50
    I'll check skywalker tonight. Make sure we made the right choice
  • EpicFetch Wed 19:50
    than some1 i may not trust
  • Sackboy Wed 19:50
    Allright! The cavalry has arrived!
  • Pikachu Wed 19:50
    But im feeling confident
  • Skywalker Wed 19:51
    okay, now I have to reveal myself because of you
  •  
    I'm protector
  • EpicFetch Wed 19:51
    hahaha no you're not
  •  
    i never said my role
  •  
    we have found wolf
  • Sackboy Wed 19:51
    And did you protect anyone? And if you did, who?
  • Pikachu Wed 19:51
    Thats a last ditch attempt at saving yourself
  • EpicFetch Wed 19:51
    guaranteed
  • Pikachu Wed 19:52
    Wait epicfetch are you the protector?
  • EpicFetch Wed 19:52
    yes
  • Skywalker Wed 19:52
    lol, you are liar
  • Pikachu Wed 19:52
    Aww skywalker poor move
  • Skywalker Wed 19:52
    what did u protect the first day?
  •  
    who, i mean
  •  
    my bad english again
  • EpicFetch Wed 19:53
    i am not saying so wolves dont no who i can save 2nite
  • Pikachu Wed 19:53
    Epicfetch knows the risk of coming out as protector. Cause when i check you tonight i'll find out who's telling the truth
  • EpicFetch Wed 19:53
    i had no reason 2 lie about this, u were getting lynched
  •  
    better we go 2 sleep feeling good about it ^^
  • Sackboy Wed 19:54
    Okay, EpicFetch, as a protector, you can't protect yourself? In that case, I advise a huntsman to protect you this night, if wolves are stupid enough, they will try to kill you hence, killing a huntsman, but also one of them dies
  •  
    Skywalker dies today, and then only one wolf will remain and then we win! :)
  • EpicFetch Wed 19:54
    i am not saying who i will protect
  •  
    hope u understand
  • Pikachu Wed 19:54
    If only it were that simple. The wolves are smarter than that
  • Sackboy Wed 19:55
    Well, at least one of them is out now
  • EpicFetch Wed 19:55
    yes
  • Sackboy Wed 19:55
    others are still clever and manage to hide so far, but we will find out who they are
  • Pikachu Wed 19:56
    Best case scenario he was the only active wolf
  • Sackboy Wed 19:57
    also, I sure hope that Matt_Damon and Grumpy were just villagers (don't get this wrong, I am not happy of having 3 dead villagers) because if only villagers are dead, that means we still have all 4 roles
  • Pikachu Wed 19:57
    They were definetely innocents. But yeah i'd rather them just be villagers
  • Skywalker Wed 19:57
    I tried to vote me
  •  
    but it didn't work
  •  
    there are something I need to understand before tonight
  •  
    I die anw
  • Pikachu Wed 19:58
    What?
  • Sackboy Wed 19:58
    And if they were seer and huntsman, then I guess we have more chance to win, since more of us are alive (when I say we, I mean villagers, just to be clear) :D
  • Skywalker Wed 19:58
    oh, I want to learn how the voting system works
  •  
    I tried to vote myself
  • Sackboy Wed 19:59
    you can vote for anyone but yourself
  • Skywalker Wed 19:59
    but I changed to Yoda
  • Sackboy Wed 19:59
    that's all there is to it
  • Skywalker Wed 19:59
    it
  •  
    *it
  • Sackboy Wed 20:00
    Also, Yoda and Pikachu? If I understand it correctly, in the unlikely situation that 1 villager, 1 wolf and 1 special role are left alive, if the villager dies, the wolves win, if the wolf dies the villagers win?
  • Pikachu Wed 20:01
    Yeah thats right
  • Sackboy Wed 20:01
    I mean, for the wolves to win, they just need to kill villagers, they don't have to kill specials also?
  • Pikachu Wed 20:01
    No they have to kill everyone
  • Skywalker Wed 20:01
    hey I have a question
  • Pikachu Wed 20:01
    What?
  • Skywalker Wed 20:01
    If a seer pick someone to reveal
  •  
    for example, this guy is a protector, so a seer will reveal him as a human or protector
  • Pikachu Wed 20:02
    They see if they're a wolf or not. They dont learn if they're a special
  • Skywalker Wed 20:03
    just only grave digger can know the exact role right
  • Sackboy Wed 20:03
    Oh, I thought that they need to kill only villagers, that's why I was calculating what would happen if more of us (villagers) are in the graveyard, and what if specials are
  • Pikachu Wed 20:03
    Yes only gravediggers get the role
  • Sackboy Wed 20:03
    No, seer can only tell if someone is on werewolf team or villager team, they never know if someone is special role... I know that because I played as a seer in last game
  • Pikachu Wed 20:04
    Yeah thats what i said
  • Sackboy Wed 20:04
    Oh, you were faster Pikachu :D
  • Skywalker Wed 20:04
    oh
  •  
    did the huntsman active last game?
  • Pikachu Wed 20:04
    Idk
  • Skywalker Wed 20:05
    I asked Sackboy because he is the seer last game
  •  
    I read and there are many inactive player
  • Sackboy Wed 20:05
    No, only 3 or 4 players were active, including me, I revealed myself as a seer then cos there was no risk, only one wolf was active and when we lynched him it was all easy after that
  • Skywalker Wed 20:05
    *s
  • Sackboy Wed 20:05
    but let's not talk about other games here because we don't want to confuse others
  • Skywalker Wed 20:06
    oh okay
  •  
    the last one
  • Pikachu Wed 20:06
    Skywalker are you gonna admit to being a wolf since you're dying?
  • Sackboy Wed 20:06
    I mean, you can email me about that: [email protected]
  • Skywalker Wed 20:07
    Can the dead people see what role players are after their dead? (like the face-to-face game)
  • Sackboy Wed 20:07
    That I don't know, I haven't died in any game yet :)
  • Pikachu Wed 20:07
    No i dont think so
  • Skywalker Wed 20:08
    I die anyway, I don't know how to prove to you
  •  
    but epic is not protector
  •  
    I just want to be prepared for the next game
  • Pikachu Wed 20:08
    If he isnt then i'll learn that tonight and we'll lynch him tomorrow
  • Skywalker Wed 20:08
    yes
  •  
    so all I can do now is asking more to understand the game
  •  
    it's enough for today
  •  
    good luck guys
  • Pikachu Wed 20:10
    Thanks
  • Sackboy Wed 20:10
    being a villager is somewhat fun though :D Because now I have no idea who is who, and I have no way to check things for sure, I can only deduct things myself based on what others say
  •  
    Skywalker, email me if you want any more help about the game
  • Pikachu Wed 20:11
    Yeah the seer is usually the most important one
  • Skywalker Wed 20:11
    okay man tks
  • Pikachu Wed 20:11
    Im the guy who makes sure we didnt fuck up
  • Sackboy Wed 20:11
    Yes, and that's why he must be kept safe
  •  
    as for huntsman and protector, they should take turns in protecting the seer
  •  
    and while one is protecting the seer, the other is protecting that other one
  • Pikachu Wed 20:12
    I agree
  • Sackboy Wed 20:12
    in that case, wolves could never kill those three
  •  
    unless they get lucky to aim for someone when huntsman is protecting him, because then they get rid of the huntsman, but they will also lose one of their own
  •  
    So, I guess we are done for today, I mean, we found a wolf and everything is decided? Now we just wait and hope not to die during the night :D
  • EpicFetch Wed 20:15
    i think this is open/shut 4 today
  •  
    i am going 2 eat
  • Sackboy Wed 20:19
    We can all celebrate now guys! The fact that we killed one wolf is really a good news! Because now, it's either one active and one inactive wolf, or... if it's the worse case scenario, both of them are active
  •  
    Okay guys, since it's 21:23 in my time zone right now, I am going to sleep, I have to work tomorrow... also, if I do not survive the night, it was good playing with you guys and I will meet you in the next game
  •  
    But I doubt it... I think the wolves will go for the EpicFetch now that they know he is a protector... but I doubt it... they will posibly kill someone at random so to throw of further investigation
  • Yoda Wed 20:44
    Yeah sadly in a game like this, anyone who makes a mistake while speaking will be lynched.
  •  
    Also it is ridiculous to vote for me when Epicfetch claims to be a protector, Skywalker.
  • Pikachu Wed 20:58
    Dont guess who is gonna die. It might motivate the wolves to kill that person
  •  
    Also why sadly? We should be glad he made that mistake and i caught it
  • Night 3
  • Moderator
    Night falls. As the village sleeps the werewolves begin to stir and decide who to eat tonight...
  • Death
    Skywalker was lynched by the village.
  •  
    Hamster was killed during the night.
  •  
    Sackboy was killed during the night.
  • Day 4
  • Moderator
    The sun rises, the village is safe from the werewolves for now. Discuss who you think is a wolf, soon you will get a chance to lynch them
  • EpicFetch Thu 11:26
    does that mean sackboy was huntsman and hamster werewolf?
  •  
    only spoken when on trial
  • Pikachu Thu 12:04
    Skywalker was a werewolf
  •  
    And yes one of them was a huntsman. Which means we only have one wolf
  • Yoda Thu 14:59
    Yeah that explains the death of Grumpy. Hamster, Nazgul, and Skywalker are the wolves. Skywalker is the sole person who voted to kill Grumpy and other two are inactive and only said dumb things. Hopefully this will be GG
  • Nazgul Thu 16:33
    Really dude i aint one
  •  
    How come
  •  
    Parappa comes out when gets suspected
  • Yoda Thu 17:22
    It is fine. If you turns out to be a villager, we just all vote for Parappa day 5
  • Nazgul Thu 17:23
    Lolz
  •  
    We can make it fast by lynching parappa today
  •  
    It might be suspicious what im saying but trust me
  • Night 4
  • Moderator
    Night falls. As the village sleeps the werewolves begin to stir and decide who to eat tonight...
  • Death
    Nazgul was lynched by the village.
  •  
    EpicFetch was killed during the night.
  • Day 5
  • Moderator
    The sun rises, the village is safe from the werewolves for now. Discuss who you think is a wolf, soon you will get a chance to lynch them
  • Pikachu Fri 12:12
    Oh boy this is it. Either yoda or parappa are the werewolf. Alright i guess you guys need to convince me to kill the other person now
  • Yoda Fri 14:19
    I am the villager. There isn't much a villager can do to prove himself because I don't have special roles
  •  
    Skywalker voted for me on Day 3 and he turned out to be a wolf.
  •  
    We don't know each other
  •  
    Gravedigger did you check anyone's role last night?
  •  
    Oh yeah no need to because Skywalker and Hamster are the wolves
  • Night 5
  • Moderator
    Night falls. As the village sleeps the werewolves begin to stir and decide who to eat tonight...
  • Death
    Parappa was lynched by the village.